
Aid cuts mean Haiti will need to do more to shoulder humanitarian response, UN says
As United Nations agencies and other humanitarian aid groups in Haiti continue to feel the effects of global aids cuts, Haiti will need to take a more significant role in its humanitarian response, a top U.N. official says.
'Part of the humanitarian response needs to be shouldered by the government,' Ted Chaiban, the deputy director of the U.N.'s leading child welfare agency, UNICEF, told the Miami Herald.
Chaiban, whose connection to Haiti dates back to the early 1990s, spent several days in the country recently. He wanted to see first-hand the effects of the ongoing gang violence that has already led to more than 1,500 deaths this year and the destruction of at least 47 schools. He also wanted to see what was being done to help children, who are increasingly caught in the crossfire.
'The situation in Port-au-Prince in particular is heartbreaking, what's happening to people who have been displaced many times, who have lost everything,' he said.
Chaiban's visit first took him to the city of Gonaives in the Artibonite region, where schools and hospitals are still functioning despite the incursion of armed gangs in its lower valley just north of Port-au-Prince. Among his stops was a busy primary-care health center that treats about 500 people a day, including new mothers and babies, pregnant women, malnourished children and victims of sexual violence.
As he toured the UNICEF-funded facility, Chaiban said, the medical director told him that without the agency's continued support the facility would be forced to shut down.
'Funding cuts have consequences,' Chaiban added.
This was driven home during the visit in Port-au-Prince. He met with government ministers, toured displacement camps and met with victims of the violence. One of them was a 14-year-old girl who had been raped and shot in the face in December when gangs targeted her Lower Delmas neighborhood.
'She was just so strong and courageous in telling us how she's afraid, she's not happy about what is going on in her country but the one thing that gives her hope is that she's still in school; she wants to be a doctor someday,' Chaiban said.
More than half of Haiti's internally displaced people are children, according to UNICEF's figures, and they also account for half of the estimated 6 million Haitians who are in need of humanitarian assistance.
In the camps, Chaiban met children and parents who had been forced to run for their lives, leaving everything behind. Families spoke of fleeing through gunfire and of their homes being burned down.
One site he visited, a school that has been turned into a displacement camp, is sheltering more than 7,000 people. Half of them were were children. There were just four latrines for the entire site.
'Initially the authorities did not want any investments in some of these sites because they wanted people to go back' to their homes, he said. 'But the reality is they're not going back anytime soon and so you need to make some investments like more bathrooms. You need more latrines, you need more sanitation kits, you need more shelter; people are living under plastic sheeting.'
There were a few bright spots, he said. One of them was a private school with 300 students that has taken in an additional 900 students from a nearby public school.
'It's just remarkable to see a private school hosting a public school with the students from all very different backgrounds studying together,' he said.
Like other U.N. agencies, UNICEF is trying to adjust to funding cuts, he said, that are the result of the United States' aid freeze and cuts from other donors. In Haiti alone the agency is in need of $272 million for this year, and as of March had only raised $15 million.
'We need to get more resources to be able to continue the work that we do,' Chaiban said.
This includes money to deal with malnutrition. There are 128,000 Haitian children suffering from severe malnutrition who need ready-to-use food and other treatment.
'If you don't reach a child with treatment,' he said, 'they have a tenfold increase in their chance of dying, so it's a really serious situation when we see funding cuts.'
Because of the overall cuts in development assistance, the Haitian government needs to take a more leading role in the humanitarian response, he said.
Chaiban said that in his meetings with government officials, including the prime minister and the head of the Transitional Presidential Council, he focused on the impact of the aids cuts as well as the challenges the health and education systems face.
'We need a different way to cooperate, where the government needs to have a clear direction... be clear about what it's putting on the table and say to its partners, 'How can you complement what I am doing?'' he said.
That collaboration needs to extend beyond the capital, now endangered of falling completely to gang control.
'The situation in Port-au-Prince is dramatic; but Port-au-Prince is not Haiti,' said Chaiban. 'There are still services in the north and the south that need to be sustained; there are services that are working, whether its health or education, and we need to keep working... to sustain those.'
Haiti was recently named 'a situation of concern' in the U.N. Secretary-General's annual report on children and armed conflict. Among the report's alarming trends, which included more than 1,000 percent increase in verified cases of rape and others forms of sexual violence against children, was the recruitment of children by gangs.
The U.N. estimates that as much as 50% of Haiti's armed gangs consist of children.
Chaiban said he raised the issue with the government, which is required under an agreement with UNICEF to turn over children police find so they can be rehabilitated and reintegrated into society.
'We need to do everything to try and get them out and to keep children in school and try to find economic opportunities.'

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Miami Herald
7 hours ago
- Miami Herald
DHS acknowledges Haiti's humanitarian crisis — in its own notice on why to end TPS
As it turns out, the Trump administration isn't revoking revoking Temporary Protected Status for Haitians because 'it is safe for Haitian citizens to return home,' as a spokesperson said Friday. It's quite the opposite: The U.S. wants to send hundreds of thousands of people back to the Caribbean country exactly because the situation there has deteriorated so much. Sound contradictory? Hold on. In President Trump's world, this makes sense — the only way he can justify deporting about half-million people back to a country where Haitians are being slaughtered in the streets and in churches is by treating them as a threat to the U.S. In documents to be published in the Federal Registry Tuesday, Department of Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem wrote that allowing Haitian TPS holders to remain in the country is 'contrary to the national interest.' She highlighted 'widespread gang violence' happening in the country as one of the reasons for rescinding temporary deportation protections, the Herald reported. Gangs control 90% of the capital of Port-au-Prince. Weirdly, Noem quoted Amnesty International in her report, writing that ''Haiti is in the grip of severe humanitarian and human rights crisis. Armed gangs are striking the Port-au-Prince metropolitan area and its surroundings with terror and violence, including rape and other forms of sexual violence.'' In fact, the acute situation described above is the reason that the Biden administration expanded the TPS designation for Haitians following the assassination of President Jovenel Moïse in July 2021. But Noem argues that the widespread violence and the 'lack of functional government authority' make it hard for the U.S. to properly vet migrants at the border because 'Haiti lacks a functioning central authority capable of maintaining or sharing such critical information.' She added: 'Haitian gang members have already been identified among those who have entered the United States.' Noem has made a similar argument for terminating TPS for 350,000 Venezuelans because she said some of them belong to the notorious Tren de Aragua gang. Her contention about vetting migrants coming from a country enveloped in chaos isn't far-fetched. We don't doubt that there are bad actors willing to take advantage of America's immigration system and exploit the chaos in their own country that makes it hard to check their background. The American public has made it clear that people with gang ties and who have committed serious crimes should be deported. You won't find many people defending their right to immigrate here. But the 'bad apple' argument only goes so far to sell immigration policy to the public. What about the TPS holders who are already living in the country, who have been here for years, built lives, found jobs and, more importantly, have committed no crime? The U.S. government has plenty of resources to assess whether they have been a blight to their communities or not. These are people like Nadine Mallebranche, who was only 5 years old when she came from Haiti — in the 1980s. She's had TPS for 15 years, which has allowed her to work legally as a store supervisor, the Herald reported. 'The only home that I know is the United States,' she told Herald reporters. Will Noem tell us that the U.S. has no way to know what people in similar situations have been up to for the past 40 years? With over 300,000 Haitians living in the Miami metro area, what will happen to the employers who rely on TPS workers? We never expected Trump to have humanitarian concerns for migrants escaping violence and political instability — the reason that Congress created the TPS program — much less for Haitians, whom he accused on the campaign trail of eating people's pets in Ohio. But others should, in particular members of South Florida's delegation in Congress, regardless of party affiliation. Miami Republicans have pleaded with Noem to look at Venezuelan TPS holders at risk of deportation on a case-by-case basis. Haitians deserve better than this as well. Blanket policies that treat criminals and people just trying to live a better life the same are inherently unfair and bad for this country. Click here to send the letter.


Miami Herald
12 hours ago
- Miami Herald
Gang violence in Haiti is reason to end TPS, deport Haitians, Trump administration says
The Trump administration is using Haiti's 'widespread' gang violence, along with the State Department's recent decision to designate several of the country's most powerful armed groups as 'foreign terrorists,' to justify ending temporary deportation protections for hundreds of thousands of Haitians living and working in the United States. On Friday, a Homeland Security spokesperson justified the decision to end Temporary Protected Status by saying 'the environmental situation in Haiti has improved enough that it is safe for Haitian citizens to return home.' But in Federal Register documents to be published Tuesday, Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem highlights Haiti's 'widespread gang violence,' lawlessness and lack of a functioning government in the agency's argument to end TPS for Haitians — the same reasons for which the Biden Administration granted the deportation protections. In the official determination letter ending TPS, the Trump administration does not assess whether the country is safe enough for Haitian's to return. Instead, DHS cites several reports on the deteriorating conditions in Haiti describing the reality Haitians face, living in an overcrowded capital largely controlled under gang control. TPS is a designation given to countries with conditions so dangerous that their nationals in the U.S. cannot return. The Obama administration granted work permits and deportation protections under TPS for Haiti after the devastating 2010 earthquake near Port-au-Prince that killed over 300,000 people. The Biden administration then expanded the designation following the assassination of President Jovenel Moïse in July 2021 and again amid deteriorating conditions in February 2023 and July 2024. DHS determined that it is not in U.S. interests to maintain the designation because of the 'serious threat' Haitians gangs pose, coupled with the Haitian government's inability to provide reliable information about their nationals. 'Gang violence in Haiti persists as armed groups operate with impunity, enabled by a weak or effectively absent central government,' DHS said, citing a Congressional Research Service report as well as Amnesty International on how gangs are 'striking the Port-au-Prince metropolitan area and its surroundings with terror and violence, including rape and other forms of sexual violence.' The Trump administration's rationale is a significant departure from previous U.S. policies regarding Haiti. In the past, U.S. national interests were used to justify both American involvement in Haiti's internal political affairs and in its designation of TPS, as U.S. officials cited mounting fears of Haitians taking to the sea in rickety, unsafe boats to try to reach Florida. The agency notes that on May 2, Secretary of State Marco Rubio announced the State Department's designation of the gangs Viv Ansanm and Gran Grif as Foreign Terrorist Organizations and Specially Designated Global Terrorists. 'In his announcement, the secretary noted 'Haitian gangs, including the Viv Ansanm coalition and Gran Grif, are the primary source of instability and violence in Haiti,' DHS said. 'They are a direct threat to U.S. national security interests in our region.... Their ultimate goal is creating a gang-controlled state where illicit trafficking and other criminal activities operate freely and terrorize Haitian citizens.' Putting the blame on Haiti transitional government, DHS said the breakdown in governance that has allowed widespread gang violence in Haiti to be sustained 'directly impacts U.S. national security interests, particularly in the context of uncontrolled migration.' While previous goverment estimates have said that 521,000 Haitians were benefiting from immigration protections, the letter said DHS estimates there are approximately 348,187 nationals of Haiti or people with no nationality who last habitually resided in Haiti and hold TPS under Haiti's designation. Immigration advocates decrying the TPS decision say a wave of migration to Florida remains a high probability as the situation increasingly becomes unbearable for Haitians and as armed gangs continue to spread to other regions. They note that Haitians residing in the U.S. have been a lifeline for those still inside the country, contributing over $3 billion annually in remittances to the country. 'We believe that ending TPS for Haitians is not in the U.S. national interest,' the Miami-based Haitian-American Foundation for Democracy, an advocacy group made up of Americans of Haitian descent, said. 'We urge the administration to reconsider its decision and to continue providing safe haven while increasing its support of Haitian and international efforts to vanquish the criminal gangs that are transforming Haiti into a wasteland.' Immigration experts say the administration's reliance on 'national interests' makes little sense in the context of Haiti, and argue against the notion that granting temporary protections against deportation encourages illegal migration. 'The current situation in Haiti is concerning,' DHS said 'However, the United States must prioritize its national interests, which includes assessing foreign policy, public safety, national security, migration factors, immigration policy, and economic considerations. In considering these factors individually and cumulatively, the Secretary has determined that permitting Haitian nationals to remain temporarily in the United States is contrary to the U.S. national interest.' Miami Herald staff writer Syra Ortiz Blanes contributed to this story.


Miami Herald
20 hours ago
- Miami Herald
Trump says Haiti is safe enough for people to return. UN chief says otherwise
A new briefing by United Nations chief António Guterres on the worsening gang violence in Haiti is challenging the Trump administration's view that conditions inside the volatile Caribbean nation have 'improved enough' for more than a half million Haitians temporarily residing in the United States to safely return home. Guterres' report, obtained by the Miami Herald before it was made public, is part of his regular update on the situation in Haiti to the U.N. Security Council. An advanced copy was sent to the council, which has scheduled a closed-door meeting on Monday and a public discussion on Wednesday about the situation in Haiti. Written before the announcement on Friday by the Department of Homeland Security terminating Temporary Protected Status for Haitians, the report provides an independent assessment of the reality in the country, where criminal gangs have triggered a complex humanitarian crisis. Along with causing the displacement of people from their homes, hunger and a collapse of the education system, armed gangs have shuttered hospitals and schools, forced both rich and poor to flee their homes — sometimes with nothing more than the clothes on their backs — and have 5.7 million people, nearly half of the country's population, facing acute hunger. 'Haiti continues to face considerable challenges, particularly arising from the deterioration of the security situation and the expanding foothold of the gangs,' the U.N. secretary-general said in the report, highlighting the rising levels of violence particularly targeting women. There have been more than 4,000 gang-related homicides in the first five months of this year, an increase of 24% compared to the same time frame last year, he said. The rise, coupled with growing public frustrations over the government's inability to protect them, is pushing many Haitians to run vigilantism, Guterres warned. 'In sustaining their territorial expansion, armed gangs have seized strategic locations across the West, Central and Artibonite, spreading violence and committing serious human rights abuses against the population,' he said. 'All access routes to the capital are now under gang control.' DHS Secretary Kristi Noem on Friday announced the end of Haiti's TPS designation. TPS allowed an estimated 521,000 Haitians to legally live and work in the U.S. until conditions at home improved. Justifying the reason for ending the protection on Sept. 2, a DHS spokesperson said 'the environmental situation in Haiti has improved enough that it is safe for Haitian citizens to return home.' Absent a change of heart by President Donald Trump or an injunction by the courts, the decision means Haitians — some of whom had been living in the United States for decades due to Haiti's perpetual instability — face returning to a nation in turmoil. Gangs tighten grip The attacks are being carried out by members of a powerful gang coalition, Viv Ansanm, which has been tightening its grip since January. Gang members have forced government offices and agencies to relocate, affecting access to essential services and accelerating the country's economic collapse. Nearly 1.3 million people have been forced out of their homes and are living in makeshift shelters, according to the U.N.'s International Organization for Migration. The number is just below the 1.5 million left homeless in 2010 after a massive earthquake prompted President Barack Obama to suspend deportations to Haiti and designate the country for TPS. In the years since, hundreds of thousand of others have benefited from the designation and extensions, including ones that followed the 2021 assassination of President Jovenel Moïse. 'The main international airport is closed, and gangs have taken over the capital. Nothing is working,' said Pierre Esperance, a human rights activist in Port-au-Prince. 'If you send all of these people to Haiti, where are they going to go?' Faced with the worsening violence and political instability after Moïse's still unsolved killing plunged the country into further chaos, many Haitians left because they had no choice, he added. 'It's a situation that is grave, chaotic and sad for Haitians,' Esperance said. The Miami-based Haitian-American Foundation for Democracy agrees. Forcibly returning Haitian nationals 'is a recipe for greater chaos in Haiti and throughout the region,' the advocacy group said in a statement Guterres' report highlighted several recent events. Port-au-Prince-based gangs, he wrote, now partially control the town of Mirebalais — where the country's most modern and best equipped hospital has been forced to close — and the town of Saut-d'Eau. Both are home to key roads that link the capital to northern regions of the country and the neighboring Dominican Republic. This month gangs set fire to Mirebalais' central public market, while fed up residents broke into the Péligre hydroelectric plant and sabotaged equipment in a show of frustration with the lack of response from Haitian authorities. The twice plunged Port-au-Prince into darkness. In response to the violence, the government has implemented a series of security measures, including the renewal of the nationwide state of emergency until July 31. The country's Transitional Presidential Council also adopted a resolution authorizing the involvement of a controversial force, the Protected Areas Security Brigade, to fight gangs despite the agency's strained relationships with the Haiti National Police. Guterres' report steers clears of some U.N. officials' concerns about the deadly use of force to root out gangs and instead says that between March and May, the operations resulted in the deaths of at least 262 gang members. Security Council meets In February, Guterres recommended several measures. He nixed the deployment of a formal U.N. peacekeeping mission to Haiti instead offering for the Security Council to take on some of the financial burden for the multinational security mission being led by Kenya. But so far, the proposal has stalled at the U.N. where council members have been waiting on a clear directive from Washington. The Trump administration has not yet said whether it intends to support Guterres' recommendation. Secretary of State Marco Rubio recently called on the Organization of American States to play a more active role in Haiti. But rather than agree to lead a security intervention, as Rubio has suggested, the OAS last week adopted a resolution calling for concrete solutions to resolve the crisis. On Monday, members of the Security Council are scheduled to meet in a closed briefing to begin deliberations on Guterres' proposal. The Security Council has several reports on Haiti, including one showing that the number of child victims of the armed conflict has skyrocketed since last year by almost 500%, and another detailing the effects of the intensification of gang violence and the rise in human rights violations. That report was put together by the Security Council's panel of experts on Haiti who have been tasked with investigating the violence to help members decide who to target with global sanctions. The panel of experts' report is equally grim and also details the country's failed transition, which was stood up over a year ago with the help of the United States, the Caribbean Community and others. 'Gangs have been increasingly aggressive,' a report prepared by a Security Council panel of experts said, noting that armed groups have targeted the last 'free bastions' of Port-au-Prince. 'Alongside murder, kidnapping and rape, gangs have perpetrated at least four massacres' since mid-October, killing than 200 people in one case. The report warns that the number of mob lynchings is growing, as are the instances of extrajudicial killings by the Haitian national police. Mission members slain In a letter to the Security Council, Kenya President Willliam Ruto said the security mission his country is spearheading up in Haiti nees more equipment and operational support. The mission currently has 991 security personnel in Haiti, including 731 Kenyan police officers who arrived in three separate contingents starting June 25, 2024. That number is far below the planned 2,500 officers the mission originally planned to send to Haiti, said Ruto. Two members of the multinational force were killed this year by gangs. Ruto also notes that of 12 envisioned forward operating bases, only three have been established. In addition, the mission lacks air and sea capabilities, both of which he said are critical to deal with gang attacks from the mountains and at sea. 'The Haitian people require greater engagement and support from the international community for the restoration of sustainable peace and security,' Ruto said.