Rahul Gandhi backs Trump's ‘dead' Indian economy remark, his colleagues disagree: Who said what
After announcing the 25 per cent tariff and an unspecified penalty on New Delhi, Trump had said that India and Russia "can take their dead economies down together".
Rahul Gandhi was asked about the remark in the Parliament complex, to which he replied, "Yes, he is right. Everybody knows this except the Prime Minister and the Finance Minister. Everybody knows that the Indian economy is a dead economy. I am glad that President Trump has stated a fact... The entire world knows that the Indian economy is a dead economy."
Rahul Gandhi's colleagues feel otherwise
Congress leader Shashi Tharoor said that it is a "very serious matter" for India".
He said, "25, plus an unspecified penalty for our buying oil and gas from Russia, it could take it up to 35-45... There's even talk of a 100% penalty, which will destroy our trade with America... The trade negotiations are still going on, and there is a possibility that this may come down. If it doesn't, it will damage our exports, because America is a very big market for us."
Tharoor further added that if America's demands are completely unreasonable, then India's negotiators have every right to resist. "America has to understand our needs as well. Our tariffs on America are not that unreasonable. It's about 17 per cent average. American goods are not priced competitively enough to sell in the Indian market," he told news agency ANI.
Rajeev Shukla
Congress MP Rajeev Shukla slammed Trump and said that his 'dead' Indian economy remark "is wrong".
"The Indian economy is not dead. Economic reforms were made when PV Narasimha Rao and Manmohan Singh were there. Atal Bihari Vajpayee took those reforms forward. Manmohan Singh strengthened it in the 10 years. The current government has also worked on it," he told ANI.
Shukla further defended the country and said that India's economic condition is not at all weak. "If someone claims they can finish us economically, it's likely due to a misunderstanding," he added.
The Congress leader said that Trump was "living in a delusion", adding that imposing tariffs is wrong.
"Every nation has the right to trade with the nation it wants. Restricting them, speaking against the BRICS, speaking against trade and import from Russia, this is not right," Shukla added.
Imraan Masood
Congress MP Imraan Masood expressed solidarity with Prime Minister Narendra Modi while condemning the US President's remark on the Indian economy.
"This government is not ready to speak even a single word on Trump... Have we become slaves of America? America is threatening us every day... What he (Donald Trump) said today is very objectionable. The whole country will stand firmly with PM Modi against this. But he should answer Trump," he told ANI.
Priyanka Chaturvedi
Shiv Sena (UBT) leader Priyanka Chaturvedi hit out at Trump's "arrogance" and "ignorance" for his 'dead' Indian economy comment.
"Not that one needs to say it there's enough legitimate data available to know that Indian economy is in the top 5 of the world and one of the fastest growing economies. Calling it a dead economy can only come from a position of arrogance or ignorance. Thank you for your attention to this matter!" she said in a post on X.
RJD MP Manoj Jha said that Trump's remark was not just on the government but on the entire nation. "It has been a tradition in the Rajya Sabha to ask for clarifications, but any possibility of that was ruled out today... This was not just a comment on the government but on India," he added.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
27 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Sell only Swadeshi goods, PM Modi exhorts Indian traders amid ‘global economic uncertainty'
Asserting that India is on the path to becoming the world's third-largest economy, Prime Minister Narendra Modi said on Saturday that the country must remain alert to its own economic priorities amid the instability and uncertainty facing the world economy. PM Modi's remarks came just days after U.S. President Donald Trump called India a "dead economy" after announcing a 25% tariff on the import of Indian goods along with an unspecified "penalty" for buying Russian military equipment and crude oil. Addressing a public meeting in his parliamentary constituency Varanasi on Saturday (August 2, 2025), Mr. Modi said, "As we talk about economic progress, I want to draw your attention to the current global scenario. "The world economy is facing instability and uncertainty. In such times, countries are focusing solely on their own interests. India, too, is on the path to becoming the world's third-largest economy and must remain alert to its own economic priorities." The prime minister also made a renewed push for 'Swadeshi', stressing that every party, leader and citizen must work to promote indigenous goods if "we want India to become the third-largest economy". 'Sell only Swadeshi goods' Making a special appeal to traders and shopkeepers, the prime minister said, "At a time when the world is going through uncertainty, let us take a pledge to sell only Swadeshi goods from our shops and markets. Promoting made in India goods will be the truest service to the country." He also urged people to be conscious consumers, saying, "Whatever we buy, we should ask ourselves — has an Indian toiled to make this? If it has been made by the sweat of our people, with their skills, that product is Swadeshi for us. We must adopt the mantra of 'Vocal for Local'." "The feeling of Swadeshi in every action will define our future. This will also be a true tribute to Mahatma Gandhi. Only through collective effort can we fulfil the dream of a developed India," Mr. Modi said. The prime minister, who was addressing a massive public gathering on Saturday in Banauli village, highlighted the government's farmer-centric policies in detail. He said the government is constantly working for the well-being of farmers. Calling for a national movement to support local products, the prime minister said, "This is not just about Modi saying it, every Indian should say this — if we want India to become the third-largest economy, every political party and every leader, keeping aside their hesitations, must work in the nation's interest and awaken the spirit of Swadeshi among the people." Demands made by U.S. The U.S. tariff action is being seen as a pressure tactic to get New Delhi to agree to demands made by the U.S., which has, in recent days, got favourable trade deals with major partners like Japan, the UK and the European Union. India has especially toughened its stance on extending duty concessions on agri products, dairy and GM foods in the proposed bilateral trade agreement (BTA) with the U.S. With the U.S. not able to finalise a deal with India so far, Mr. Trump on Thursday announced the imposition of an additional 25% import duty on Indian goods entering American markets from August 7. Earlier, this duty was to be imposed from August 1. The President has also not specified the penalty that he announced against India for buying crude oil and military equipment from Russia. 'Fastest growing major economy' In the backdrop of Mr. Trump's "dead economy" barb at India, Commerce Minister Piyush Goyal had told Parliament on Thursday that India is the world's fastest-growing major economy and widely expected to be the "third largest economy" in a few years. Mr. Goyal also said India will take all necessary steps to safeguard and promote national interest and that the implications of the US tariffs are being examined. In a post on Truth Social, Mr. Trump had said, "I don't care what India does with Russia. They can take their dead economies down together, for all I care. "We have done very little business with India, their Tariffs are too high, among the highest in the World." His remarks were echoed by Congress leader Rahul Gandhi who said President Trump has stated a "fact", prompting a strong condemnation from the BJP. While announcing the tariff, Trump described India's trade policies as "most strenuous and obnoxious".
Time of India
41 minutes ago
- Time of India
Air India crash: UK families await update on DNA-matched remains
LONDON: British families, waiting for the remains of relatives aboard the London-bound Air India 171 plane that crashed soon after takeoff from Ahmedabad airport, are expecting confirmation on DNA matches after high-level India-UK government talks, their legal team has said. Keystone Law, which has been working with aviation experts to assist many of the families who lost loved ones in the June 12 crash, called for urgency in the process this week. During Prime Minister Narendra Modi's UK visit last week, Downing Street had confirmed that Prime Minister Keir Starmer had discussed the Air India plane crash during their bilateral talks against the backdrop of UK media reports of mislabelling of some remains repatriated to Britain. "The UK and Indian governments have held high-level talks, as a result of the international media coverage of this problem," said James Healy-Pratt, Aviation Partner at Keystone Law. "It is believed that some matched DNA remains may now have been located in India. Confirmation is awaited," he said. The 241 passengers and crew who died in the disaster included 52 British nationals, with two out of 12 caskets repatriated to the UK for last rites found to be incorrectly identified. The ministry of external affairs (MEA) had responded to the UK reports to stress that "all mortal remains were handled with utmost professionalism and with due regard for the dignity of the deceased". "We are continuing to work with the UK authorities on addressing any concerns related to this issue," the MEA's official spokesperson said in a statement last month. Asked to estimate the scale of the issue, Keystone Law said of a sample of 12 caskets repatriated from India to the UK, two were "mislabelled, mishandled and misidentified". "Extrapolated out - with an unacceptable error rate of 15 per cent, that would suggest 40 sets of remains may have been mislabelled, mishandled and misidentified. That is a known unknown, and many of the families' loved ones have been cremated already," said Healy-Pratt. Last month, an inquest into the deaths of some of the British passengers was opened and adjourned in London, with the process of identification overseen by the Senior Coroner under UK procedures. It came as a preliminary report by the Indian Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB) found that fuel to both engines appeared to have cut off shortly after takeoff. The engines tried to restart, but it proved too late to prevent the Boeing 787 Dreamliner aircraft from crashing into Ahmedabad's B.J. Medical College, claiming 19 lives on the ground. Keystone Law called for further clarity about the transitioning of the fuel cutoff switches, and which voice was saying what on the excerpts of the Cockpit Voice Recorder. "The Indian AAIB has this evidence, and has for unexplained reasons not shared this detail with the families of AI 171. The Indian AAIB cannot complain of further speculation when evidence in its possession is not released to the families on a transparent basis," said Healy-Pratt. The aviation lawyer also called for further details around reports of compensation being considered for impacted families by the Tata Group, owners of Air India. Healy-Pratt said: "There is talk of TATA setting up a (Rs) 500 crore fund for all the AI 171 families - which will provide ex gratia support (legally a gift and separate and apart from any Court ordered compensation against Air India, or indeed Boeing) of a minimum of (Rs) 1 crore per loved one lost. "Families deserve to get details of that support urgently, as legal proceedings take time in India, England, and the United States." The UK's Air Accidents Investigation Branch (AAIB) has "expert status" in the Indian safety investigation and has said it is reviewing the findings of the preliminary report released one month on from the crash, on July 12. The UK-based families who lost loved ones in the crash have previously also called for a mechanism of expert representation in the India-led investigatory process into the plane crash.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Dera castration case: CBI court allows witness to depose via video conferencing
Chandigarh: In a significant development in the alleged castration case against Dera Sacha Sauda chief, Gurmeet Ram Rahim Singh , and two medicos, special CBI magistrate of Panchkula allowed cross-examination of the complainant, a castrated sadhu and prime witness of the case, through video conferencing on Saturday. Special CBI magistrate Anil Kumar Yadav issued a 20-page order allowing the application moved by the prime witness through his counsel and directed the federal agency to coordinate with the ministry of external affairs about arrangements for video conferencing. As per the order, the date is to be finalised within one month. The agency was also directed to ensure safety of the prime witness by arranging the place and other particulars in consultation with the Consulate General of India in the USA. The order issued on Saturday read, "Officer of CBI is directed to approach the ministry of external affairs for taking assistance of the Indian Consulate in USA and to ensure availability of a secure place there for recording of evidence at a predetermined time in compliance of Rule 5.3, Volume-V, Chapter-I-H of our Hon'ble High Court. However, if such a facility is not available in the Embassy, any other place which can be determined/fixed by authorities of the Indian Consulate to ensure the integrity of deposition. " The court added that the investigating officer/holding investigating officer would intimate the court within one month about the date fixed by the office of the Indian Consulate in consultation with the witness concerned and IO/HIO. The prime witness and the victim/complainant is currently residing in the US. He has applied for asylum there in apprehension of a life threat due to the case and his role as complainant against the dera head and two other doctors. The cause of action dates back to the year 2014, when the Punjab and Haryana high court directed CBI to register a case against Dera head Gurmeet Ram Rahim Singh, Dr M P Singh and Dr Pankaj Garg, for allegedly castrating over 400 sadhus of the Dera. Investigation was launched and the CBI filed a chargesheet before the Special CBI magistrate, Panchkula. After recording the statement of the prime witness and complainant for three days in 2019, the case was under stay. Now, the court has resumed hearing with cross-examination of witnesses. Meanwhile, the complainant relocated to the US and moved court to get him cross-examined through video conferencing. While CBI endorsed the demand, defence counsels opposed the plea on certain grounds, including that the victim fled from the country without obtaining permission from court and was trying to strengthen his case for asylum in the USA, even though he went on a visitor visa. Get the latest lifestyle updates on Times of India, along with Friendship Day wishes , messages and quotes !
