logo
Why two justices could hand Republicans their own ‘Ginsburg moment' next year

Why two justices could hand Republicans their own ‘Ginsburg moment' next year

Independent3 days ago
Are conservatives headed for their own 'Ginsburg moment'?
That could be the outcome of the 2026 midterm elections if Democrats have any say in the matter.
With next year's congressional elections still on the horizon, the first glimpses of the political dynamics that will shape 2026 are coming into view. Even as Donald Trump and his administration remain this week consumed by an uproar among the MAGA base over the handling of the Jeffrey Epstein investigation, issues like inflation and the White House's mass deportation raids continue to retain salience quietly in the background — quietly, but not with diminished importance, as they'll likely remain the top factors driving Americans to the polls.
Then, there's the Supreme Court. It remains a sore point for liberals who watched Republicans lock Barack Obama out of the discussion over a vacant seat in 2016 and then, in 2020, watched Ruth Bader Ginsburg's death just two months before a presidential election notch a second rightward shift for the court in less than a decade.
Justice Clarence Thomas, 77, is the oldest member of the bench. Some conservatives have privately begun to fret that the right-leaning justice or his 75-year-old colleague, Samuel Alito (whose wife hung a symbol honoring the January 6 conspiracy after the attack) could cause another 'Ginsburg moment' by refusing to resign while Republicans control the Senate, allowing one or both seats to fall into liberal hands.
Legal commentators are somewhat torn over whether either will retire this term. Mike Davis, a former Senate GOP staffer on Supreme Court nominations and current 'viceroy' of Trumpworld, wrote that Alito was 'gleefully packing up his chambers' after the 2024 election.
Ed Whelan, the Antonin Scalia chair in constitutional studies at the Ethics and Public Policy Center, also predicted in 2025 that Alito would retire in 2025, and Thomas in 2026, according to the American Bar Association Journal (ABAJournal).
Others are less certain, and a source close to Alito tried to tamp down on that speculation earlier this year.
"Despite what some people may think, this is a man who has never thought about this job from a political perspective," they told the Wall Street Journal.
"The idea that he's going to retire for political considerations is not consistent with who he is," the source added.
David Lat, who founded his own blog reporting on gossip surrounding the Court and broader legal world, also noted to ABAJournal that both justices have hired full rosters of clerks for the upcoming two terms, the latter of which will end in 2027.
Under Donald Trump's first term, three Supreme Court vacancies were filled by conservative justices. Ginsberg's refusal to retire at multiple points when multiple factors were clear, including how her health challenges were affecting her work and the likelihood that Republicans would bend the rules (or shatter them) to see her seat filled with a conservative, is still looked by many as a failure of not just the justice but those liberals around her who allowed the octogenarian's desire to stay on the job conflict with political realities.
Her defenders insisted that the justice's deliberations about retiring did not factor in politics at all. Critics of the Court see the justices' shroud of apoliticism as an excuse that does not match their rhetoric or actions, either on the bench or in public.
The efforts by Alito's allies to dissuade speculation echoed those same defenses and rang especially hollow for the conservative justice who has shmoozed with a conservative billionaire with cases before the court and who reportedly authored his own blueprint for the eventual overturn of Roe vs Wade as far back as 1985.
Thomas, meanwhile, reportedly sparked fears among conservatives that he would resign from the Court on his own way back in 2000 as he complained about the job's pay. But there's been no such murmuring as of late.
If the claims are true and both justices are set on remaining on the bench, they could put Republicans in an awkward spot.
The GOP's chances of protecting their newly-acquired Senate majority remain strong but have grown noticeably weaker in the past six months. The announced retirement of Thom Tillis in North Carolina puts his purple-seat state decidedly in play. Maine's Susan Collins is up for re-election, as is John Cornyn in Texas; Cornyn faces a hyper-MAGA primary challenger whom the senator has said could give up the seat to Democrats in November of 2026 if his primary challenge is successful.
Rumors also continue to swirl about the possible retirement of Joni Ernst, the senator from Iowa, and her partner in the Senate delegation from the state, Chuck Grassley, is a staggering 91 years old himself.
Several factors could force the Senate back into Democratic hands next year, and if the party's discussions over countering GOP redistricting in Texas by 'going nuclear' and following suit across a range of blue states is any indication, the party's members have learned not to give Republicans an inch and could block any of Trump's SCOTUS nominations going forward.
In the end, the same shaky apoliticism that the justices cling to when facing any criticism from Congress or the Executive Branch could swing back to help the left, after causing so much damage at the end of the Obama era. It would be up to Democrats in the Senate to decide whether they are truly willing to take a page from the GOP's playbook.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Tulsi Gabbard scrambles to appease MAGA by declassifying MORE Obama docs showing he 'ordered' Russia 'hoax'
Tulsi Gabbard scrambles to appease MAGA by declassifying MORE Obama docs showing he 'ordered' Russia 'hoax'

Daily Mail​

time19 minutes ago

  • Daily Mail​

Tulsi Gabbard scrambles to appease MAGA by declassifying MORE Obama docs showing he 'ordered' Russia 'hoax'

Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard has declassified another tranche of documents about the 2016 elections – a day after President Donald Trump accused Barack Obama of 'treason' and said he should be investigated. Gabbard ordered the release of a 2020 report by the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence on the Intelligence Community's assessment on Russia during the 2016 presidential election. That is an election Trump won, but the president has long railed against what he calls the Russia 'hoax' – and this week has been calling for investigations of top security officials at the time while referring to Obama as the leader of a 'gang.' The report by the Intelligence panel, then chaired by Trump ally Rep. Devin Nunes (R-Calif.) found the nation's spies reached 'credible' assessments that Russian President Vladimir Putin ordered 'conventional and cyber influence operations' by leaking hacked emails. But it also disputed the Intel assessment, released in 2017, that Putin 'developed a clear preference' for Trump and 'aspired to help his chances of victory.' That conclusion has long infuriated Trump. It said these conclusions did not 'adhere to the tenets' of intelligence tradecraft. The House Intel panel's report put the onus on Obama and dismissed its composition, calling it a 'high-profile product ordered by the President, directed by senior IC agency heads, and created by just five CIA analysts, using one principal drafter.' Gabbard on Friday released a report and accused Obama of overseeing a 'treasonous conspiracy' against Trump. On Tuesday night at a meeting at the White House with House Republicans, Trump called Gabbard the 'hottest' person in the room. That comes despite indications of a split over the attack Trump ordered on Iran's nuclear facilities. 'She's like, hotter than everybody. She's the hottest one in the room right now because she found out. ... I think we knew it before, in all fairness, Tulsi, but now you have certainty. She has all the documents. She has everything that you need. And she found out that Barack Hussein Obama led a group of people, and they cheated in the elections, and they cheated without question,' Trump told his allies. Gabbard, an anti-interventionist, had testified in March that the intelligence community 'continues to assess that Iran is not building a nuclear weapon' despite its big stockpiled of enriched Uranium. Gabbard appeared on the conservative Newsmax network Tuesday night, and contested a scathing statement by Obama, who had called the resurfaced allegations 'bizarre' and a 'distraction.' 'We will be releasing further documents tomorrow that will refute that statement,' Gabbard said. The backdrop for the throwback drama over the 2016 election – rather than the 2020 race Trump repeatedly calls 'rigged' – are the series of stunning disclosures about the Jeffrey Epstein case that have rocked the White House and divided the MAGA movement.

Trump again calls for Fed board to act, says Powell 'doesn't get it'
Trump again calls for Fed board to act, says Powell 'doesn't get it'

Reuters

time19 minutes ago

  • Reuters

Trump again calls for Fed board to act, says Powell 'doesn't get it'

July 23 (Reuters) - U.S. President Donald Trump on Wednesday reiterated his criticism of Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell amid his ongoing call for lower rates, and called on the central bank's board to act. "Our Rate should be three points lower than they are, saving us $1 Trillion per year (as a Country). This stubborn guy at the Fed just doesn't get it — Never did, and never will. The Board should act, but they don't have the Courage to do so!" Trump wrote on his social media platform.

Trump lashes out at CNN after 'new' Epstein photos with his young kids Ivanka, Eric and ex-wife surface
Trump lashes out at CNN after 'new' Epstein photos with his young kids Ivanka, Eric and ex-wife surface

Daily Mail​

time19 minutes ago

  • Daily Mail​

Trump lashes out at CNN after 'new' Epstein photos with his young kids Ivanka, Eric and ex-wife surface

Donald Trump was enraged when CNN confronted him with newly unearthed decades-old images of him and his young kids with convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein. After just 30 seconds on a call with Andrew Kaczynski on Tuesday, the president hung up when asked about the resurfaced images showing Epstein at Trump's 1993 wedding to his second wife, Marla Maples. The photographs also show Epstein that same year socializing with Trump and his children Ivanka and Eric at the Harley Davidson Cafe opening in New York. The images are not new, but they have not been widely reported. Kaczynski said that Trump dismissed the resurfacing of the images as his administration faces a slew of criticism from his MAGA base over the Justice Department's botched Epstein files review. 'We were not on the phone very long,' he said on CNN after the article was published on Tuesday. 'I think our call was about 30 seconds or so.' 'When I asked him about the wedding photo… he sort of paused for a second and then said, 'you've got to be kidding me,' before calling CNN 'fake news' and then hanging up on me,' the journalist recalled of Trump shutting down the conversation. White House Communications Director Steven Cheung doubled down on the fake news claims and reiterated how Trump kicked Epstein out of his club for 'being a creep.' 'These are nothing more than out-of-context frame grabs of innocuous videos and pictures of widely attended events to disgustingly infer something nefarious,' he said in a statement on the resurfaced images. It's widely known that Trump socialized with Epstein and his co-conspirator Ghislaine Maxwell in the 1980s and 1990s. He is listed as one of the many famous and rich people who flew on Epstein's private plane, known as the Lolita Express. Family members of Trump are also listed on the flight log from the same period. This includes his son Eric, his second wife Marla Maples and their daughter Tiffany. Previously revealed images show Trump and his third wife and current First Lady Melania alongside Epstein and Maxwell in 1997 at Trump's Mar-a-Lago club in Palm Beach, Florida. No charges have been brought against Trump in relation to Epstein and there is no known wrongdoing by the president during his time associating with Epstein. While CNN branded the latest images as 'never been seen' before, Kaczynski admitted in his article that the photos were available on Google images and content library Shutterstock. The outlet paid to have exclusive rights to a few of the photos for a month. Kaczynski said they 'have not been widely reported and pre-date any of Epstein's known legal issues.' Trump is not pleased with how his base is still obsessing over the Epstein investigation. When Attorney General Pam Bondi released a joint memo with the FBI earlier this month concluding no one else would be charged in relation to his child sex trafficking crimes, it immediately sparked fury among the MAGA base. Many of Trump's biggest fans have stoked conspiracies that Epstein did not kill himself in prison in 2019 and that he was actually murdered to keep quiet about co-conspirators. Additionally, they were clamouring for a so-called 'client list' that would reveal those who worked with Epstein. But Bondi's review found that no such list existed. Trump was forced to give into pressure from his supporters' demanding the administration continue pushing for more answers. He directed Bondi last week to request the grand jury testimony from the court case in the Southern District of New York be unsealed. Additionally, Bondi announced that Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche is looking to speak with Maxwell 'in the coming days' to find out what she knows. Maxwell remains the only living person paying the price for Epstein's crimes. She is currently serving a 20-year prison sentence – though her lawyers tried to get the Supreme Court to take up her case arguing she shouldn't have been charged due to a 2008 plea deal Epstein struck with prosecutors. The DOJ opposed Maxwell's request for appeal earlier this month.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store