Children's Ombudsman hugely concerned over use of AI 'nudify' apps on images of underage girls
Dr Niall Muldoon has warned that stronger laws are needed to tackle the scourge of so-called 'nudification' apps, which allow real photos of women and girls to be edited by artificial intelligence to produce deepfake images that make them appear naked.
Nudification apps can be downloaded via online app stores,
though some have been removed by Apple and Google
; others can be accessed via a web browser by anyone who has a URL to the relevant app.
Although sharing non-consensual sexual images is a crime in Ireland under the Harassment, Harmful Communications and Related Offences Act (also known as Coco's Law), legal experts
have said the legislation does not cover the creation of deepfakes
.
Tens of thousands of ads for these apps
have appeared on Facebook and Instagram
in recent months, and keep pushing the apps to Irish users despite Meta's repeated attempts to remove them because they breach the company's advertising rules.
'The ease of access by children to this type of technology is a huge concern to the Ombudsman for Children's Office (OCO),' Muldoon told
The Journal
.
'It is difficult to comprehend any possible need for these apps when the risk of abuse and sexual exploitation of children is so high.'
He called for Coimisiún na Meán and the European Commission to strengthen the oversight of major technology companies under the Digital Services Act, to ensure that the apps were not being recommended to children and young people online.
A spokesperson for Coimisiún na Meán said that the Online Safety Framework makes big tech platforms accountable for how they protect people, especially children, from harm online.
The European Commission's spokesperson for tech sovereignty Thomas Regnier said that the commission is aware that ads for services to create pornographic deepfakes of women were present on Facebook and Instagram.
He also said large tech companies have an obligation to ensure measures are in place that mitigate risks to users.
A spokesperson for Meta said the company prohibits the display of nudity or sexual activity in its ads and that the company removes ads that violate its policies, but that bad actors are continually evolving their tactics to avoid enforcement.
Ombudsman for Children Dr Niall Muldoon has expressed concern
RollingNews.ie
RollingNews.ie
Nudification apps have already attained notoriety in other countries, including in the United States, where
dozens of teenage girls have been targeted
in schools in California, New Jersey
and Washington
.
Earlier this week, the children's commissioner for England called for the apps to be banned after publishing a report which found that deepfake nudification apps disproportionately target women and girls.
The report contained interviews
from a number of teenage girls, some of whom said they had already changed their online behaviour as a result of nudification technology.
'This chilling effect is causing them to take steps to keep themselves safe, which often requires them to limit their behaviour in some way,' the report said.
'This pattern of behaviour is similar to girls avoiding walking home alone at night, or not going to certain public places alone.'
The Dublin Rape Crisis Centre previously said it was 'deeply concerned' about the capacity of deepfake images to 'amplify harm to women' and said they should not be available to download.
What are nudification apps and how do they work?
Nudification apps can be downloaded via app stores (if they have not already been removed), or accessed via a web browser using a URL; certain bots on the messaging app Telegram also offer nudification services.
Advertisement
The apps encourage users to upload a photo of any woman, and offer to produce a new, deepfake version of the same image in which the person appears without clothes.
The apps are thought to have been trained using open-source artificial intelligence models in which the underlying code is freely available for anyone to copy, tweak and use for whatever purpose they want if they have the skills to do so.
In the case of nudification apps, the artificial intelligence works by creating new images that are based on their attempts to replicate existing images that they have been trained on.
They are specifically thought to have been trained from vast amounts of explicit images of women, which is why they tend to only work on women and teenage girls.
The artificial intelligence is unable to tell when a person is underage or that such images are illegal.
Graphika, a US company that tracks online disinformation,
has said
that open-source AI models are 'the primary driver' behind a surge in the creation and dissemination of non-consensual images of adults, including through the use of nudification apps.
The UK-based Internet Watch Foundation
has also said that
creators of child sexual abuse material have legally used open-source AI models to create explicit deepfake images of children.
An ad for a nudification app seen on Facebook
Meta Ad Library
Meta Ad Library
Deepfake economy
Graphika has also warned that nudification services and the creation of sexually explicit deepfake images has become a 'fully-fledged online industry', which some have dubbed the 'deepfake economy'.
Nudification apps often seek payment to create deepfake images, while they can also be used as part of targeted harassment campaigns and for sextortion.
In many cases, links to nudification services can be found through Google searches.
The Journal
has also uncovered thousands of targeted ads for nudification apps, which claim that apps can 'erase' or 'see through' the clothes of any woman, that are being pushed to Irish social media users on Facebook and Instagram on an ongoing basis.
Advertisements entice users by claiming 'one click to undress', 'upload image, you can see anything about her' and 'your friends in transformed photos'.
The ads link to app stores, where AI editing apps can be downloaded, and third-party websites that can be accessed by anyone with a URL that links to the relevant website.
They often feature side-by-side images of a woman with clothes on and the same image of the woman naked or partly naked; other ads feature videos of women dancing or talking, which occasionally flash in a way that the woman appears with no clothes.
Some versions of the ads use AI-generated images of women, but others use images of real women that appear to be taken from social media.
The ads tend to feature on fake profiles that have small numbers of followers, but which appear to be somewhat co-ordinated: different pages will use the same names and images, or claim that they are based in similar locations.
Many share different links that re-direct to the same website in an apparent attempt to avoid falling foul of Meta's advertising rules.
Since the beginning of April,
The Journal
has found dozens of pages that have advertised nudification services via more than 20 unique links, which re-direct users to a single web-based app.
Meta has removed the majority of ads for these services, though some remain active; in some cases, the ads were only removed once they were flagged by
The Journal
while links to those that were not shared with Meta remained online.
If you have been affected by any of the issues mentioned in this article, you can reach out for support through the following helplines:
Dublin Rape Crisis Centre
- 1800 77 8888 (fre, 24-hour helpline)
Samaritans
- 116 123 or email jo@samaritans.org (suicide, crisis support)
Pieta
- 1800 247 247 or text HELP to 51444 – (suicide, self-harm)
Teenline
- 1800 833 634 (for ages 13 to 19)
Childline
- 1800 66 66 66 (for under 18s)
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
3 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Tariff uncertainty means 'tighter' spending for Budget 2026
Ministers will be told of the need to 'moderate' spending ahead of this year's budget as the Government unveils its financial package this week. The Government will today release the summer economic statement, which will outline the broad parameters of this year's budget. While Government sources say there will be money to spend and it will roll out a €30bn national development plan update, economic uncertainty means that current spending will need to be managed. A Government source said the ongoing uncertainty on the impacts of the Trump administration's tariffs on EU goods as well as any potential EU countermeasures means that the future of Irish finances is harder to predict and will necessitate a 'tighter' budget this year. It is expected that Tánaiste Simon Harris will tell Cabinet this year's document will be 'different' from previous years, given the continued uncertainty with tariffs, and that decisions made in the budget will 'have to focus on protecting jobs and investment during what could be an economically turbulent period ahead'. Government sources have said that the increase in protectionism, rising tariffs, and the 'fragmentation of global supply chains' pose a threat to Ireland's economic model, but that Budget 2026 will see additional spending and taxation measures delivered. Privately, some ministers have pointed to existing level of service (ELS) commitments as a concern in meeting additional demands. ELS is often referred to as 'standing still money' and covers previous commitments and demographic growth. In last year's summer statement, the projection for this year's budget was that there would be around €2bn for additional expenditure and €1.2bn for tax-related changes. Sources said that they believed these figures would be close to the final package available later this year. Sources said there will be a surplus, but that future budgets could be impacted by tariffs and their fallout. The Government will today reiterate three strands to its budget approach by committing to investment in infrastructure, as well as pledging funds for public services, and contributing to two long-term funds aimed at mitigating external shocks such as tariffs. Finance minister Paschal Donohoe is expected to tell Cabinet that increased investments in the likes of health and education will be made on a permanent basis and that the Government is also focused on 'maintaining the stability of the public finances'. The Government will continue to put money away in the infrastructure, climate, and nature fund, as well as the future Ireland fund. Sources said the focus has been on finding 'the right balance between enhancing our public infrastructure, improving public services, and maintaining the long-term sustainability of the public finances'. The summer economic statement is designed to 'form the basis for political discussions on the budgetary process and increase transparency in the Government's approach to planning for the provision of key public services' and 'outlines the broad parameters that will underpin discussions of economic and fiscal policy over the medium term'. In recent parliamentary question responses, Mr Donohoe has said that the SES 'will incorporate all available information and data including the latest developments in the trade policy landscape'. 'That said, it is clear that we are now in a fast-evolving and more challenging global environment, with elevated levels of uncertainty; this is the reality of the situation we face.'
Irish Examiner
3 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Government delays introduction of alcohol warning labels until 2028
The Government is to delay the introduction of health warnings on alcoholic drinks until 2028, coming amid concerns the plan would undermine Irish trade competitiveness internationally. Cabinet will today approve the deferral of health warnings, with a memo due to be brought by health minister Jennifer Carroll MacNeill. The labels, which warn of links between alcohol and cancer, had been due to come into effect in May 2026. Last week, it was expected the delay would be until 2029. However, it will now only be until 2028. The delay comes amid concerns about the impact of such labels, with warnings from the Government's trade forum that it could undermine Irish products on international markets. Both domestic and international alcohol producers will have additional time to prepare for their introduction in 2028. The delay has already been criticised by Alcohol Action Ireland, with the advocacy group saying the decision shows both the Taoiseach and health minister 'turning their backs on public health'. 'It is bizarre that the Government should even contemplate delaying this measure, which has been in planning for years,' CEO Sheila Gilheany said. Meanwhile, Tánaiste Simon Harris is due to update Cabinet on the ongoing trade talks between the EU and US. The Fine Gael leader is set to tell Government that there is still uncertainty over a deal. Mr Harris is expected to outline that the EU will intensify negotiating efforts with the US ahead of the August 1 deadline. Elsewhere on trade, enterprise minister Peter Burke will bring forward the new action plan on market diversification. The plan aims to assist Irish companies seeking to export their goods. While the policy will be approved by the Government today, it is not expected that the plan will be published until late August. Housing minister James Browne will seek Cabinet approval for more funding to be allocated towards community water schemes. It is understood that a total of €73.9m is expected to be allocated towards 291 community water schemes. The funding is expected to benefit approximately 63,000 households in rural Ireland. Funds are being allocated through the multi-annual rural water programme, which aims to improve local water infrastructure in areas not serviced by Uisce Éireann. Meanwhile, children's minister Norma Foley is expected to receive government approval for the Office of the Director of Authorised Intervention, Tuam, to come under the remit of the State Claims Agency. This will see any potential claims taken against the office to be handled by the State Claims Agency. Read More Introduction of health labelling on alcoholic drinks to be delayed until 2029
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
McAleese was ‘extremely generous' with time she gave to British, newly released UK papers show
Former president Mary McAleese was highly regarded for her political analysis and 'extremely generous' with her time to the British, newly released UK state files have shown. The former British ambassador to Ireland, Ivor Roberts, wrote a glowing report about a meeting with McAleese in 2001 where he described her as being 'at her frank and engaging best'. 'She does not shrink from political or religious engagement in private and occasionally in public too, in a way which occasionally lands her in trouble,' he wrote. 'She has, however, captured the affection of the Irish people which makes her fairly fireproof here and her warmth and bravery are widely (and rightly) admired. I've always found her an exceptionally good analyst of the political scene North and South and I hope to continue to draw on her experience. She is also extremely generous with her time.' READ MORE During the two-hour breakfast meeting, the president criticised the then Labour leader Ruairí Quinn, with Mr Roberts reporting that he had an 'absolute disaster' on The Late Late Show in a debate with Gerry Adams . 'He had failed to land a single punch on Adams and had come over in an unsympathetic and uncharismatic way, in marked contrast to the Sinn Féin President, who had attracted round after round of applause,' wrote Mr Roberts. She said that Mr Quinn had gifted Sinn Féin a seat in north Kerry, unless Dick Spring stood. 'McAleese said that she was in despair at the way that Adams had got off scot free at Quinn's hands.' When she questioned her children about their view of the debate afterwards, Mr Adams's only 'false note' was the mention of a socialist state. 'She had found herself, in frustration, shouting questions at the television which Quinn should have been putting to Adams,' wrote Mr Roberts. There was also a discussion of a State visit of Queen Elizabeth II to Ireland, which Ms McAleese said would be warmly received. It would be another 10 years before the queen would visit Ireland. 'Beneath the antagonism to the British monarchy, the reality was that there was a keen interest in and affection for the monarchy which would be brought out during a state visit as had been shown in the enthusiastic reception of Prince Andrew at Kinsale a few weeks ago,' Mr Roberts reported her as saying.
