Poll suggests majority of Australian voters expect fair and humane approach to refugees
The polling, commissioned by the Asylum Seeker Resource Centre and conducted by Redbridge, shows more than half of those polled support granting asylum seekers work and study rights while they await the outcome of their protection visa applications.
The findings, which asked 1,508 Australian voters in January, show while many supported tough policies for those seeking asylum, many still supported compassionate responses.
However, those polled also rated refugee and asylum seekers as one of the least important issues to voters ahead of the federal election, with the cost of living, healthcare and the economy rated in the top three. Just 1% considered refugee issues as their top election priority.
It comes as the Albanese government announced on Sunday three non-citizens, whose visas had been cancelled on character grounds because of previous criminal convictions – including a convicted murderer – had been placed in immigration detention awaiting deportation to Nauru after the tiny Pacific island agreed to grant them 30-year visas.
The polling showed 35% strongly or somewhat supported the government's powers to pay other countries to take asylum seekers or non-citizens Australia wants to deport. Around 32% were strongly or somewhat against the measure, while 23% felt neutral.
Almost a third supported deporting asylum seekers to their country of origin, regardless of the risk of persecution or violence, while 42% opposed it somewhat or strongly.
Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email
More than two-thirds supported allowing those denied a protection visa through the former Coalition government's 'fast-track' system, which Labor dismantled after being elected, a chance to relodge an application through the new system.
The controversial fast-track refugee assessment process reviewed the claims of thousands of people who arrived by boat between August 2012 and January 2014. In addition to the assessment process, the former Coalition government introduced temporary protection visas for those recognised as refugees fleeing persecution – another measure Labor scrapped in place of permanent protection visas.
Jana Favero, the ASRC's deputy chief executive, said the results showed voters had 'compassion' and 'a desire for humanity' when it came to people fleeing danger and how 'out of touch some politicians are – especially in the lead up to elections'.
'People have a big heart, and they want politicians to reflect their values. This polling shows that the current toxic debate weaponising refugee policy is misreading the nation's pulse,' she said.
'It's time for our leaders to embrace policies grounded in humanity, not cruelty.'
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
The polling also showed voters felt strongly about punitive measures for those in immigration detention, with 50% backing powers to conduct more invasive searches compared to 22% against the measure.
The data showed voters with more conservative leanings, or who watched right-wing-leaning media, were more likely to agree with tougher measures, while left-leaning respondents were more likely to agree with extending rights such as study or work.
In one example, three groups were shown different political messaging on people seeking asylum, alongside a control group, to evaluate the impact on their opinions.
The groups were then asked to support or oppose the existing system, prompted by this message: 'Currently, all people seeking asylum who arrive in Australia by sea are transferred to an offshore immigration detention centre on Nauru, with no prospect of ever settling in Australia.'
The control group supported offshore detention at 51% while 24% opposed. Support dropped marginally to 49% and 50% after messages against offshore detention, while the group exposed to pro-offshore detention increased to 57% support.
Kos Samaras, a director at Redbridge and former Victorian Labor campaigner, warned federal politicians against politicising the issue for gain.
'They don't want their government punishing marginalised people. This is a clear message to both major parties – voters are watching, and they expect a fair and humane approach to refugees,' he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
12 hours ago
- The Guardian
Anthony Albanese faces diplomatic tightrope in China as spectre of Trump and Aukus review looms large
Anthony Albanese departs for his second trip to China with the spectre of Donald Trump looming large over meetings with Xi Jinping. While the prime minister flies to Beijing to strengthen economic and diplomatic ties with Australia's largest trading partner, a nervous eye must stay on the US's promised Aukus nuclear submarines: military commitments of hundreds of billions of dollars, spending spurred by China's own military buildup, now under review by the US defence department. According to some reports, they are a potential bargaining chip from a Trump administration seeking guarantees of support in any conflict over Taiwan. Albanese will take a business delegation to the cities of Shanghai, Beijing and Chengdu for a six-day trip from Saturday. His official itinerary is about meeting business, tourism and sport representatives 'to continue building on Australia's strong economic and trade links with China'. That includes the Australia-China annual leaders' meeting, attending a Shanghai soccer club with strong ties to Australia, a visit to the headquarters of and likely a photo op with pandas. President Xi and Premier Li Qiang are on Albanese's meeting list – whether Li repeats his warm praise from 2023 of Albanese as 'a handsome boy coming from Australia' remains to be seen. Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email Australia's two-way trade with China amounted to almost $312bn in 2024 – by far our biggest partner, the government has been keen to stress, noting Albanese's success in overseeing the removal of $20bn in trade barriers and boosting exports of barley, lobster and beef. Efforts to 'advance Australia's security and economic interests' are the flavour of the trip, government sources say, and for the business delegation, led by the Business Council of Australia (BCA), that will be top of their list. Executives from banks, including ANZ and Macquarie, miners Rio Tinto and Fortescue, manufacturers BHP and BlueScope, and universities Monash and UNSW will join the prime minister's trip. Heading their agenda is a CEO roundtable in Beijing, hosted by the China Development Bank, with an emphasis on green metals, research and development, education, finance, and clean energy. BCA CEO Bran Black said businesses were keen to find new opportunities with China, seeking 'an even stronger relationship with our largest economic partner'. But advancing Australia's security interests, as the government has also put at the top of its priority list, will call for a fine balancing act. The Coalition has urged Albanese to raise the circumnavigation of Australia by a Chinese naval taskforce and advocate further for the release of detained academic Yang Hengjun. Human Rights Watch, noting human rights were not listed on Albanese's list of trip priorities, called on the prime minister to raise abuses in Hong Kong, Xinjiang, and Tibet. Sign up to Breaking News Australia Get the most important news as it breaks after newsletter promotion But broader strategic concerns may prove the pivotal part of Albanese's visit. The foreign minister, Penny Wong, in an important speech in Malaysia on Thursday, while attending the Asean (Association of Southeast Asian Nations) summit, spoke of the 'worrying pace of China's nuclear and conventional military buildup, without the transparency that the region expects'. In the same breath, she praised China's strength, saying its 'size and weight makes it central to solving global challenges'. That Wong, intensely deliberate and the closest of Albanese's confidantes, would make such remarks on the eve of his visit to China was no mistake. Albanese, asked about her statement on Friday, said Wong was doing 'a fantastic job'. Wong's speech, referencing the tensions between China and the United States, said, 'Two countries can be the strongest of allies without agreeing on every single element of policy.' She said Canberra and Washington were 'in complete agreement on the importance of the peace, stability and prosperity for the Indo-Pacific and for our peoples'. Albanese's Beijing visit will not go unnoticed in the White House. Conservative criticism of the absence of a meeting with Trump has been overblown, and is unlikely to abate after a second meeting with Xi. But Albanese will toe a fine line as he pursues closer ties with China while continuing to strongly maintain to the US that Australia needs the Aukus submarines. Labor senator Raff Ciccone, chair of the parliament's security committee, said on Friday that the two issues could coexist. 'When there's trade, when there's dialogue, when there's economic interests at play, what you do find is countries are less likely to engage in the worst case scenario, which is war, and we're trying really [to] have those frank conversations,' he told the ABC.
Reuters
16 hours ago
- Reuters
EU population hits record 450 million on another migration boost
July 11 (Reuters) - Migration into the European Union pushed its population to a record 450.4 million people last year, offsetting a natural population decline for the fourth straight year, EU data released on Friday showed. Since 2012, the EU has recorded more deaths than births annually, making migration the sole driver of population growth. The trend highlights Europe's demographic challenge as an aging population and low fertility rates strain welfare systems and create labor shortages. The bloc added 1.07 million inhabitants in 2024, with positive net migration of 2.3 million people compensating for a natural population decline of 1.3 million as deaths (4.82 million) continued to outweigh births (3.56 million). Germany, France and Italy remain the bloc's most populous countries, accounting for almost half of the total EU population with 47%. While 19 EU countries recorded population increases in 2024, eight saw declines. Malta recorded the highest growth rate at 19.0 per 1,000 people, followed by Ireland (16.3) and Luxembourg (14.7). Among countries with declining populations, Latvia was the steepest (-9.9), followed by Hungary (-4.7), Poland and Estonia (both -3.4). The bloc's population has grown from 354.5 million in 1960, though growth rates have slowed significantly from 3 million annually in the 1960s to 0.9 million during 2005-2024. "The observed population growth can be largely attributed to the increased migratory movements post-COVID-19," EU statistics arm Eurostat said. Population in the 27 member states had declined during the COVID-19 pandemic. Some European governments have also tightened border controls amid public concerns over migration even as irregular border crossings dropped 38% in 2024 to their lowest level since 2021. Belgium, Poland, Germany and the Netherlands have all introduced temporary border checks over the past year and a half, straining the EU's passport-free Schengen zone. The EU also rolled out a revamped migration system, opens new tab last year aimed at reducing irregular arrivals and speeding up asylum procedures.
The Guardian
18 hours ago
- The Guardian
Barnaby Joyce vows to wind back ‘lunatic crusade' of net zero with private member's bill
Barnaby Joyce has vowed to wind back the 'lunatic crusade' of net zero by 2050 in a private member's bill once parliament resumes later this month. The former deputy prime minister and Nationals backbencher's clarion call on Friday afternoon laid bare the Coalition's decades-long brawl over climate change and energy policy. The New England MP, who has long been sceptical of the impacts of climate change, described the policy to reduce carbon emissions by 2050 to net zero as 'treacherous' to Australia's security in a post on Facebook on Friday afternoon. Joyce also claimed Australia's commitment to reducing carbon emissions to net zero by 2050 was akin to self-immolation without the 'authentic' participation of other countries. 'There is no more time to assess, to ponder, to nuance or to amend. Net zero must be repealed and as such, I will, at my first opportunity bring forward a bill to do that,' he said. 'The idea that, at this stage, we have put the focus of our nation on a lunatic crusade of Net Zero is treacherous to the very security of Australia.' There's no guarantee Joyce's private members' bill will be considered for debate if it's introduced in the upcoming sitting fortnight. The opposition is undertaking an internal review of its election policies with climate change and energy expected to take centre-stage in an ideological tussle. Joyce, along with his Queensland colleague Matt Canavan, have long campaigned for the climate targets to be ditched, while some Liberals, such as the shadow home affairs minister, Andrew Hastie, have expressed fresh scepticism about the goal. Joyce has previously labelled the estimated cost of net zero 'utterly untenable' and urged the Coalition to walk away from the Paris agreement and its associated climate targets. The shadow energy minister, Dan Tehan, told Guardian Australia in June the financial cost to reach net zero by 2050 may shape the Coalition's decision on whether or not it keeps the target. 'The cost will be one of the most significant factors that will drive our decision,' Tehan said, accusing the government of obscuring the cost of signature climate policies, including the capacity investment scheme. Within the Nationals, Canavan is also conducting a review of the party's policy on net zero, which is expected to take months. The Coalition has walked back its plan to introduce government-owned nuclear power plants into Australia's energy mix as part of its approach to reducing emissions over the next three decades following the federal election. The Coalition adopted its net zero by 2050 policy in 2021 following tense, protracted discussions between Joyce, then the deputy prime minister, and Scott Morrison ahead of the United Nations climate summit in Glasgow. Morrison told ABC News in June he still believed the opposition should retain its net zero targets. 'I wanted to ensure that Australia could continue to attract investment capital, particularly out of so many other countries for which this was potentially becoming quite a stumbling block,' he said. 'I didn't want us to become an island when it came to investment of capital, which was becoming a pretty serious problem, so I thought we took the right approach.' The former NSW energy minister Matt Kean, who is now the Climate Change Authority chair, said the Liberal party needed to 'get back to making rational decisions when it comes to energy policy based on engineering, economics and science'. 'That is the path forward for the Liberal party. Anything else is a road to ruin,' he said.
