
Digital reform roadmap a good move but gaps remain
'Consistently publishing detailed updates will allow the public to have a better understanding of the status of ongoing reform initiatives,' says the Centre to Combat Corruption and Cronyism (C4).
The digital roadmap, Petari, which was published on May 23, would address the disconnect people feel with the lawmaking process, said C4's chief executive officer, Pushpan Murugiah.
'Over the past few years, BHEUU has shown its dedication to inclusive and participatory policymaking – which is a practice that should be followed by other ministries,' said Pushpan.
'For instance, the public would benefit from having similar transparency on the status of development of amendments to the Official Secrets Act, and Printing Presses and Publications Act, which are under the Home Ministry,' he said.
While other organisations have commended BHEUU's initiative, they also argued that the roadmap is missing key reforms that had been promised by Pakatan Harapan in its election manifesto.
Projek Stability and Accountability for Malaysia (Projek Sama) says the 'missing' initiatives include reforms to the appointment process for top figures in the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission, the Election Commission and the Inspector-General of Police.
'Reforms that are left out, such as those mentioned, should be considered for further studies and implementation before the term for the Madani government ends in 2027,' Projek Sama said.
Petari, a Malay acronym for Peta Reformasi Institusi (Institutional Reform Roadmap) was launched by Minister in the Prime Minister's Department (Law and Institutional Reforms) Datuk Seri Azalina Othman Said.
The digital roadmap lists 14 new Bills and amendments to existing laws that BHEUU is working on, as well as six legal studies and six strategic initiatives.
The new laws include one to establish the Ombudsmans office, to regulate funding and financing for political parties and to make Parliament more independent, all of which have been targeted for tabling this year.
Petari also includes amendments to the Election Offences Act, The Whistleblowers Act, the Legal Professions Act, as well as ongoing studies such as the separation of the Attorney-General and the Public Prosecutors offices and the possibility of a Human Rights Tribunal for Malaysia.
Projek Sama added that to improve Petari, the government should publish clear deadlines for when the new laws and amendments will be brought to Parliament and explain any delays.
Petari should also include white papers on reforms to enable better public consultations so that the best solutions can be reached, Projek Sama said.
Aliran, a human rights organisation, also welcomed Petari as a positive first step towards transparent governance that allows civil society to monitor the progress of reforms.
'We welcome the inclusion in the roadmap of key legislation governing freedom of information, an ombudsman's office and the creation of a parliamentary services commission. But critical gaps persist,' Aliran said.
These gaps include initiatives to remove political appointments to government-linked companies, and limits to the prime minister's power to influence the appointment of judges, Aliran said.
'All these Bills will probably be only as effective as the people appointed to lead the offices and entities established under the respective legislation.
'It is time to establish a bipartisan select committee on vetting crucial appointments. Without addressing the appointments processes, even well-designed legislation risks becoming hollow rather than providing meaningful reform,' added Aliran.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Daily Express
42 minutes ago
- Daily Express
Ministry approves new site for 188-year-old Sung Siew
Published on: Monday, July 28, 2025 Published on: Mon, Jul 28, 2025 By: Mardinah Jikur Text Size: Also present were Sandakan MP Vivian Wong Shir Yee, Sandakan District Education Officer Roslin Siabok, school principal Kwok Chee Yen, SM Sung Siew School Board Chairman Vun Soon Chong and representatives from the Sabah Education Department and alumni. SANDAKAN: The Education Ministry approved the relocation of the 118-year-old Sekolah Menengah Sung Siew here to a new 25-acre site at Batu 4 near Sekolah Rendah Kebangsaan Sung Siew. The approval letter was handed over during a ceremony at the school on Saturday, witnessed by Deputy Education Minister Wong Kah Woh during his official working visit here. Also present were Sandakan MP Vivian Wong Shir Yee, Sandakan District Education Officer Roslin Siabok, school principal Kwok Chee Yen, SM Sung Siew School Board Chairman Vun Soon Chong and representatives from the Sabah Education Department and alumni. The Ministry granted the approval on June 25, following a request submitted four years ago by the school, Sandakan District Education Office and Sabah Education Department. Kah Woh hopes the relocation approval would expedite the construction process. The current school, built on 2.24 acres owned by the Basel Christian Church Malaysia, would move to the new site at Batu 4, where Sung Siew's primary and preschool sections have already been operating for several years after relocating there. 'Over 80 per cent of students live near Batu 4 residential areas which was a key factor in the decision. Our priority is to provide the best educational access for all students here,' he said. Meanwhile, Vun Soon Chong thanked the Ministry, the Sabah Education Department and the District Education Office for the approval, adding that the school board, parents and staff had been actively fundraising for the new campus through charity events and marathons. Earlier, Kah Woh visited SK Sri Tanjung Papat I and SK Sri Tanjung Papat II in Kampung Sim-Sim, which currently share premises after the latter was destroyed by tidal waves in 2018. Following discussions with parents, the Ministry would seek a new site for SK Sri Tanjung Papat II to accommodate the growing number of students. The Deputy Minister also inspected SK St Mary Town and SK St Mary Labuk, where the Ministry has allocated RM185,000 for upgrading works, including a new canteen. He also attended a Bahasa Malaysia Oratory Competition and a Multilingual Writing Test (in Malay, Chinese and English languages) involving 144 finalists from eight districts, praising the decades-old programme for nurturing student talents. * Follow us on our official WhatsApp channel and Telegram for breaking news alerts and key updates! * Do you have access to the Daily Express e-paper and online exclusive news? Check out subscription plans available. Stay up-to-date by following Daily Express's Telegram channel. Daily Express Malaysia


The Sun
17 hours ago
- The Sun
Rally sparks debate, not upheaval
PETALING JAYA: Analysts remain divided over the significance of the recent 'Turun Anwar' rally, held in the capital on Saturday to call for Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim's resignation, particularly in light of the reported turnout. Independent political analyst Dr Lim Teck Ghee questioned the organisers' claim that 500,000 people attended, describing the figure as likely overstated. 'A turnout of 500,000 seems unlikely. A more reasonable estimate might be closer to 50,000,' he told theSun. Lim noted that while the crowd size was not insignificant, it may not be sufficient to bring about major political shifts. He also pointed out that the rally appeared to draw a predominantly Malay crowd, which he said reflected limited participation from other communities. 'Roughly 95% of attendees were Malays, suggesting the event was not broadly representative of the wider population and may have primarily involved PAS or Bersatu supporters,' he said. Lim also observed that most speakers did not outline clear policy alternatives, focusing instead on calls for the prime minister to step down. 'While the slogan 'Turun Anwar' may resonate with some, there was a lack of detailed proposals or solutions presented during the rally,' he added. Senior Fellow at the Nusantara Academy of Strategic Research, Prof Dr Azmi Hassan, said the rally appeared designed to give the impression that Anwar had lost public support. 'In reality, this was not a people's rally, as it only drew one segment of society. The non-Malay presence was minimal, so it cannot be said to represent the rakyat as a whole,' he told theSun. Azmi added that while the opposition may be attempting to shape public perception, any change in leadership must follow due parliamentary process. 'Anwar retains the backing of the majority of MPs in the Dewan Rakyat. I doubt the opposition will table a no-confidence vote, as they are aware they lack the numbers,' he said. Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia (UKM) political analyst Professor Dr Kartini Aboo Talib @ Khalid offered a different perspective, describing the rally's turnout as noteworthy. 'Based on drone footage, TikTok livestreams, and television coverage, the rally brought together thousands to express their protest. Many remained despite the rain, chanting loudly for Anwar to step down,' she said. Kartini added that from a democratic standpoint, the peaceful nature of the event underscored Malaysians' right to free speech and assembly. 'The rally was symbolic — a way for citizens to voice dissatisfaction directly to their leaders. Malaysians understand that elections are the appropriate channel to choose their government. It's highly unlikely the people would seek to forcefully remove a prime minister, as has happened elsewhere,' she said. Estimates suggest more than 30,000 people, many dressed in black, gathered at Dataran Merdeka on Saturday to call for Anwar's resignation. Among those who addressed the crowd were former prime ministers Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad and Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin, opposition leader Datuk Seri Hamzah Zainudin, Perikatan Nasional information chief Datuk Seri Azmin Ali, Gerakan president Datuk Dominic Lau, and Kedah Menteri Besar Datuk Seri Muhammad Sanusi Md Nor of PAS. In a WhatsApp response to theSun, Azmin Ali said the prime minister had yet to fulfil many of his reform pledges. 'Public confidence has diminished. While many promises were made, there has been a lack of meaningful delivery. His leadership appears increasingly uncertain,' he said.


Focus Malaysia
a day ago
- Focus Malaysia
Turun Anwar: PM's position strengthened or a turning point in Malaysian politics?
THE 'Turun Anwar' rally, billed as a major show of dissatisfaction with Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim's leadership, drew mixed reactions, falling short of expectations for some, while others hailed it as a symbolic victory for PAS. With turnout estimated at under 30,000 and largely dominated by Malay-Muslim participants, the event exposed deeper undercurrents in Malaysian politics. Professor James Chin observed the lack of multiracial participation and NGO support, pointing to the rally's limited appeal beyond Perikatan Nasional and PAS's core base. 'There was minimal NGO support and virtually no traction with the non-Malay communities,' said Chin, adding that this reflected a failure to build a broad-based coalition for change. He also cited the involvement of former prime minister Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad as a liability. 'Mahathir's credibility is no longer what it once was. Many see his stance as driven more by personal animosity toward Anwar than genuine reform,' Chin said, concluding that the rally may have inadvertently strengthened Anwar's position. However, Australian academic and long-time observer of Malaysian politics Dr Murray Hunter interpreted the rally as a powerful statement by PAS. 'This wasn't just about Anwar stepping down. It was about who will rule Malaysia in the future.' Hunter noted the absence of the Reformasi-era crowd and warned that parties like PKR and Amanah may struggle to stay relevant in the future. 'Malaysia is now at a crossroads, between a reformist democracy, elite-controlled governance, or an Islamic state.' He added that the turnout suggests a growing ideological shift. 'What we're witnessing is the beginning of a political revolution, led by a generation that believes Islamic governance offers real solutions. The old Malaysia is being challenged — openly and decisively.' —July 27, 2025 Main image: Kosmo