Trump's Medicaid cuts to Planned Parenthood blocked
More: Donald Trump's megabill could mean closure for a third of Planned Parenthood clinics
The U.S. Department of Justice argued that "the bill stops federal subsidies for Big Abortion" and urged Talwani not to let Planned Parenthood and its members "supplant duly enacted legislation with their own policy preferences."
Talwani, an appointee of Democratic President Barack Obama, said the law's text and structure made clear that it was crafted to cover every member of Planned Parenthood Federation of America, the parent organization, even if they were not named.
That specificity likely transformed the provision at issue into an unconstitutional "bill of attainder," an act of Congress that wrongly seeks to inflict punishment without a trial, the judge said.
More: Supreme Court sides with South Carolina in effort to cut Planned Parenthood funding
"Plaintiffs are likely to establish that Congress singled them out with punitive intent," Talwani wrote.
She said the law also violated Planned Parenthood members' equal protection rights under the U.S. Constitution's Fifth Amendment and burdened the right of some who do not provide abortions to associate with their parent organization in likely violation of the First Amendment.
The White House did not respond to a request for comment.
The judge last week had issued a partial injunction that only covered some Planned Parenthood members. Because an earlier temporary restraining order was expiring, Planned Parenthood said many health centers were forced to stop billing for Medicaid services ahead of Monday's ruling.
Planned Parenthood has said the law would have "catastrophic" consequences for its nearly 600 health centers, putting nearly 200 of them in 24 states at risk of closure.
"We will keep fighting this cruel law so that everyone can get birth control, STI testing and treatment, cancer screenings, and other critical health care, no matter their insurance," Alexis McGill Johnson, Planned Parenthood Federation of America's president, said in a statement.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
5 minutes ago
- BBC News
US Attorney General orders grand jury hearings on Trump-Russia probe
US Attorney General Pam Bondi has ordered prosecutors to open legal proceedings into allegations of a so-called Russiagate conspiracy that Donald Trump has long claimed was concocted by political foes to smear has ordered a federal prosecutor to seek a potential indictment, according to the BBC's US partner CBS is unclear, however, what the possible charges might be and who could be month, US Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard accused former President Barack Obama and his national security team of a "years-long coup" against Trump as she released a declassified report that Democrats branded false. Gabbard alleged that intelligence about alleged Russian meddling in the 2016 White House election had been politicised by the Obama White House to falsely tie Trump to Russia. Trump reacted by accusing Obama of "treason". An Obama spokesman later called that accusation "bizarre".Democrats said nothing in Gabbard's finding invalidated a US intelligence assessment in January 2017 concluding that Russia had sought to damage Clinton's campaign and boost Trump in the vote three months earlier.A 2020 bipartisan report by the Senate intelligence committee also found that Russia had tried to help Trump's 2016 last month the director of national intelligence referred the matter to the justice department to consider possible Monday, Bondi acted on that referral by directing an unnamed federal prosecutor to present evidence to a grand jury, according to CBS.A grand jury is a group of members of the public who determine whether there is enough evidence to file an indictment in a was not clear which former officials might be the target of any grand jury Fox News reported last month that ex-CIA Director John Brennan and ex-FBI Director James Comey were under criminal investigation relating to the Trump–Russia probe. Both have long denied any wrongdoing and accuse Trump of subverting the justice of Trump's first presidency was overshadowed by an investigation from his own justice department into whether he had conspired with Russia to sway the 2016 resulting Mueller report found no proof that Trump or his campaign had co-ordinated with the Kremlin, and no-one was charged with such crimes. The debate over Russiagate was reinvigorated last week when an appendix to another justice department investigation into the affair was 29 pages from Special Counsel John Durham's inquiry cites a March 2016 memo from a US intelligence source stating that Hillary Clinton, the Democratic White House candidate that year, had approved a plan to smear Trump as a Russian asset. Durham cites "what appear or purport to be original" emails that hackers affiliated with Russian intelligence might have obtained from an employee with a non-profit run by liberal donor George of the messages appeared to have been sent by Leonard Benardo, senior vice-president at Open Society Foundations, Soros' philanthropic arm. It apparently refers to a Clinton foreign policy adviser, Julianna email, dated 26 July 2016, reads: "Julie says it will be a long-term affair to demonize Putin and Trump. Now it is good for a post-convention bounce. Later the FBI will put more oil into the fire."There is nothing illegal about a political smear, but Trump allies suggested the email, if genuine, showed that federal investigators could have been part of the scheme. Durham, however, found no proof of such an FBI to the appendix, Benardo told Durham that "to the best of his recollection" he did not draft the email, although he noted that some of the verbiage further down sounded like something he would have special counsel also interviewed Smith, who said she did not recall receiving such an email from made no determination in his appendix whether the emails were authentic, or if they had been doctored by Russian main 306-page report, published in 2023, found the original FBI probe into Trump's campaign had lacked "analytical rigor" and relied on "raw, unanalysed and uncorroborated intelligence".US officials found the Russian meddling in 2016 included bot farms on social media and hacking of Democratic emails, but they ultimately concluded the impact was probably limited and did not actually change the election result.
Reuters
5 minutes ago
- Reuters
US DOJ to open grand jury to investigate Obama officials, source says
WASHINGTON, Aug 4 (Reuters) - U.S. Attorney General Pam Bondi has directed federal prosecutors to launch a grand jury investigation into allegations that members of Democratic former President Barack Obama's administration manufactured intelligence on Russia's interference in the 2016 elections, a source familiar with the matter said on Monday. The Justice Department said late last month it was forming a strike force to assess claims made by Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard about "alleged weaponization of the U.S. intelligence community." Republican U.S. President Donald Trump has leaped on comments from Gabbard in which she threatened to refer Obama administration officials to the Justice Department for prosecution over an intelligence assessment of Russian interference. Fox News first reported that Bondi personally ordered an unnamed federal prosecutor to initiate legal proceedings and the prosecutor is expected to present department evidence to a grand jury, which could consider an indictment if the Justice Department pursued a criminal case. The report cited a letter from Bondi and a source. A DOJ spokesperson declined to comment. Referring to the probe in a post on Truth Social, Trump said: "The TRUTH always wins out. This is great news." Last month, Trump accused Obama of treason, alleging, without providing evidence, that the Democrat led an effort to falsely tie him to Russia and undermine his 2016 presidential campaign. Trump won the 2016 election against Democrat Hillary Clinton. A spokesperson for Obama had denounced Trump's claims, saying "these bizarre allegations are ridiculous and a weak attempt at distraction." Gabbard had declassified documents and said the information she released showed a "treasonous conspiracy" in 2016 by top Obama officials to undermine Trump, claims that Democrats called false and politically motivated. An assessment by the U.S. intelligence community published in January 2017 concluded that Russia, using social media disinformation, hacking, and Russian bot farms, sought to damage Clinton's 2016 presidential campaign and bolster Trump, who won that election. The assessment determined the actual impact was likely limited and showed no evidence that Moscow's efforts actually changed voting outcomes. Russia has denied it attempted to interfere in U.S. elections.
The Guardian
35 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Texas House pushes forward on redistricting as Democrats vow to fight
Texas Democrats in the state legislature denied Republicans a legislative quorum on Monday by leaving the state, preventing, at least for now, plans proposed by the White House to aggressively redistrict Texas's congressional lines in their favor. When the legislature gaveled in at 3pm local time on Monday, Republicans fell short of a quorum by eight votes after Democrats fled to Illinois, a legislative conference in Boston, New York and elsewhere. In an extraordinary escalation, the state's Republican governor, Greg Abbott, said he he had ordered the Texas department of public safety to 'locate, arrest and return to the House chamber any member who has abandoned their duty to Texans'. 'There are consequences for dereliction of duty,' Abbott said in a statement on Monday, after the Republican-dominated House issued civil arrest warrants in an attempt to compel the return of the members who fled. 'This order will remain in effect until all missing Democrat House members are accounted for and brought to the Texas Capitol.' Enforcing Abbott's order will be difficult, however, because Democrats who left the state are beyond the jurisdiction of Texas authorities. Democrats hold 62 of the 150 seats in the legislature's lower chamber, so as long as at least 51 members remain out of Austin, the Texas legislature cannot move forward with any votes, including a plan sought by Donald Trump to redraw the state's congressional maps to give Republicans five more seats in Congress. The Texas speaker, Representative Dustin Burrows, adjourned the house until 1pm on Tuesday after issuing a call for absent lawmakers and threatening their arrest. He cited pending legislation on flood relief and human trafficking – and not the contentious redistricting proposal before the chamber – in his call for Democrats to return. 'Instead of confronting those challenges, some of our colleagues have fled the state in their duty,' Burrows said. 'They've left the state, abandoned their posts and turned their backs on the constituents they swore to represent. They've shirked their responsibilities under the direction and pressure of out-of-state politicians and activists who don't know the first thing about what's right for Texas.' Democrats pushed back forcefully, accusing Abbott of calling a special session at Trump's behest rather than prioritizing disaster relief in the aftermath of the catastrophic floods that killed 135 people in central Texas last month. 'I never thought as a Texan, as an elected member of the Texas House of Representatives, and now as an elected member from Texas to the United States House of Representatives, that I would see the governor of the proud state of Texas bend a knee to a felon from New York,' Texas congresswoman Julie Johnson taunted Abbott during a press conference in Illinois. 'Never thought I'd see the day, but here we are.' Johnson, whose district would be radically reshaped if Texas Republicans succeed, spoke alongside members of the Illinois congressional delegation as well as several of the state representatives who left Texas on Sunday. 'Texas House Democrats know how to fight,' said Texas state representative Jessica González. 'Our sleeves are rolled up, and we're ready to take this fight wherever it's going to take us, because our communities, our state and our nation is definitely worth fighting for.' Texas attorney general Ken Paxton, who fled his own impeachment hearings and refused a court order to release his travel records after speaking at the rally in Washington that preceded the January 6 insurrection, has described wayward Democratic legislators as 'cowards'. Speaker Burrows said the house would not sit quietly. 'While you obstruct the work of the people, the people of Texas are watching and so is the nation, and if you choose to continue down this road, you should know there will be consequences.' The Texas House Democratic Caucus said in response: 'Come and take it.' 'We are not fighting for the Democratic party,' state representative James Talarico said in a video message recorded at an airport. 'We are fighting for the democratic process, and the stakes could not be higher. We have to take a stand.' A few dozen protesters gathered in front of the governor's mansion in Austin on Monday to protest the Republicans' hasty rewriting of the state's congressional districts. Led by Democratic congressmen Greg Casar and Lloyd Doggett, protesters marched back and forth across the parking lot in front of the gates of the governor's mansion. Speaking into a bullhorn, Casar, a leading progressive, praised state Democrats for fleeing the state to deny Republicans the quorum they need to pass a new congressional map that would sharply dilute Democratic voting strength in an effort to preserve a Republican majority in next year's congressional midterms. President Lyndon B Johnson signed the Voting Rights Act in 1965 to 'prevent maps like this', Casar said. 'We're going to fight like hell to stop it,' he said. 'We're not going back to pre-1965.' 'I see him basically as an errand boy for President Trump,' Doggett said of the Texas governor, Greg Abbott. 'He didn't ask for this map, he's just following orders.' 'Governor Abbott could have easily passed flood relief on day one of this special session,' Casar added. 'Instead he's holding flood relief hostage … It's all about himself and Donald Trump.' Every Republican member of the Texas congressional delegation that Casar has discussed the map with has told him privately that they oppose the redistricting effort, he said. Republicans have worried since Trump first floated the redistricting plan that any attempt to redraw the state's congressional districts could backfire, since creating new right-leaning districts is hard to do without making existing red districts less conservative. Most of the Democratic caucus absconded to Chicago, a city with a Democratic mayor and city council in a state with a Democratic governor and legislature. Illinois governor JB Pritzker, who owns the Chicago Hyatt hotel, announced on Monday he would provide free rooms to the Texas Democrats for as long as they are out of state. A special session of the Texas legislature lasts for 30 days, but Abbott can renew the call for a special session at will. Under new rules the Texas house adopted in 2021, each lawmaker will be fined $500 a day for each day they abscond from the state. Democratic-led states have vowed to respond in kind if Texas moves ahead with its plans. Earlier on Monday, New York governor Kathy Hochul said that she was exploring 'every option' to redraw state congressional lines. 'I'm tired [of] fighting this fight with my hand tied behind my back,' Hochul said at a news conference with six Texas Democrats who fled to her state. 'We are at war,' she added. 'And that's why the gloves are off – and I say bring it on.'
