'Truly shocking and should never have happened': Hiqa chief on RTÉ nursing home doc
'I was shocked and appalled, and felt let down by the provider,' Fitzgerald said today, acknowledging public confidence in the Health Information and Quality Authority had been 'damaged' by the revelations.
Speaking to the Dáil's Public Accounts Committee (PAC), Fitzgerald apologised to those impacted by the abuses, and said Hiqa had 'a lot more to do as regulator'.
During the hearing, Fine Gael TD James Geoghegan had asked Fitzgerald if she had ever seen anything worse during her three years at head of the organisation. She agreed she had not, adding: 'I hadn't seen the type of behaviours, my colleagues as inspectors had never witnessed the behaviours there.'
What was broadcast, she said, 'was truly shocking and should never have happened'.
The programme, which aired in June, involved two RTÉ researchers working undercover in two different homes; one in The Residence Portlaoise, and one in Beneavin Manor in Glasnevin.
Emeis Ireland, formerly known as Orpea, operates 27 nursing homes across the country having entering the Irish market in 2022.
Advertisement
Almost 200 notifications of 'alleged, suspected or confirmed' abuse of residents at Beneavin were received by Hiqa between 2022 and June this year, according to an interim report released two weeks after the RTÉ programme aired. The Residence had 40 such notifications.
Asked at the committee how the Glasnevin home was allowed to remain open, Susan Cliffe, Deputy Chief Inspector with Hiqa, told TDs: 'We wouldn't close a nursing home unless there was absolutely no other option.'
Cliffe said Beneavin Manor has been inspected three times since the RTÉ programme aired, and nothing seen had warranted closure. She said the watchdog is taking regulatory action against both nursing homes featured in the RTÉ programme, and both now have limits on admissions.
Fine Gael TD James Geoghegan, said the 'natural consequence' of the RTÉ Investigates programmes is to question whether Hiqa is 'fit for purpose' as an inspection body.
'I find it hard to believe that after 20 years of Hiqa being active that something like this could happen', he added.
22 of the nursing homes operated by Emeis have been inspected since the RTÉ Investigates programme aired, with one inspected a second time, the committee was told today.
Seven nursing homes in Ireland were closed in 2024 due to findings of non-compliance. In the previous year, one was closed.
Hiqa said that 0ver 80% of nursing home visits are unannounced. However, several TDs noted that the treatment uncovered by the RTÉ Investigates programme was unlikely to be identified without an undercover inspection.
The Hiqa officials at the committee said they were unclear if they are permitted to carry out undercover inspections and would have to look into the legality.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
4 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
'It was a very frightening time': Cork gay activist on Aids and preparing for Pride
Arthur Leahy will never forget the 'balloon-like' figure standing in the hospital doorway as he held the hand of a man dying from Aids. The junior doctor buried beneath multiple layers of protective clothing was clearly terrified but it offered Arthur a moment of light relief during what was a very dark time for Ireland's gay community. 'He had so much protective gear on that he looked like a giant balloon,' Arthur said. 'People were so frightened they would catch the disease.' Trailblazer Arthur had founded the inclusive space in Cork City known as the Quay Co-op back in 1982. The business continues to operate to this day as a vegetarian restaurant and health food store. It opened three years after the activist made television history with an RTÉ interview as Cork's first openly gay man. He, along with his Australian partner at the time, Laurie, provided an insight into life at the time for a gay couple. At the time, the country was pockmarked by homophobia, shockingly highlighted by the death of Declan Flynn who was beaten to death by a gang of teenagers in 1982. Arthur Leahy says the onset of the Aids epidemic 'was a torturous situation for families.' Picture: Jim Coughlan News of his perpetrators walking free from court with suspended sentences rocked the country. One of the attackers was just 14 at the time and could not to be named for legal reasons. The miscarriage of justice sparked a protest 11 days later that inspired the first Dublin Pride parade that June. Nonetheless, gay people remained extremely vulnerable, with homosexuality in Ireland not decriminalised until 1993. However, the threat of homophobic abuse wasn't enough to keep Arthur from the grim task of helping Aids victims to die with dignity. He was a founding member of Gay Health Action and Cairde which were established respectively to address HIV and Aids and provide hands-on support to patients. 'During that time it took over our lives.' The six houses in Cork Arthur co-founded to support those impacted by the Aids epidemic is among his proudest achievements. Years on, as we approach Cork Pride 2025 - which takes place from July 26 to August 3 - Arthur is pleading with people not to forget what people went through. Colour and celebration at last year's Cork Pride. 'If you're part of the gay community now, you get the sense that it never happened,' said Arthur, who turns 80 in November. 'There is a kind of denial there and not a lot of awareness and recognition around what people went through. People can take a drug for it now so there is no big drama about it. However, during the time we are talking about it was terminal.' Arthur recalls supporting Aids patients in hospitals. 'I remember being in the hospital with one person who was actually dying at the time. I was sitting by his bed and holding his hand. The junior doctor came in but we couldn't see him. His clothes looked like they had been blown up like a balloon because he had so many protective coverings on. "That was just the way it was. It was a very frightening time for people. It took me by surprise how I dealt with it, because I was able to transcend the horrors of it all. I dealt with it in such way that I didn't have to live with the trauma.' Mr Leahy recalled why some members of the gay community had little faith in medical professionals. 'In those days, on the medical front at least, it was the predominant view that gay people were mentally ill. It was something you just kind of accepted at the time. "There was one man named Jack Coughlan who dealt with venereal diseases in Cork and he was very progressive but a lot of others were very repressive and conservative.' He said that families were often in denial about the cause of a loved one's death. 'It was a torturous situation for families. In the beginning they didn't want to know but love usually took over towards the end. Sometimes, the control of families was very negative. It was at that point that we were pushed out of the situation. "They wanted to deal with it in a conventional way. That's where you're kind of pushed out of this situation. The Irish solution was denial at all costs.' He recalls how a number of Irish people impacted by Aids had returned from the UK to die. 'The great majority of Irish people with Aids were in London. If you looked in any hospital about half of the people there with Aids were Irish. "The houses we had in Cork were paid for by the Health Board. They helped with funding but the situation wasn't acknowledged. There were some people from the Health Board who were outstanding but they weren't supported by the establishment.' The same, Arthur recalled, could be said for the Church. There were individuals within the Catholic community who were enormously supportive and very courageous but the establishment of the Church was very negative. It was, and still is, to a great extent, in terms of all these issues. The trailblazer said he has lived a very privileged life in comparison to many others. 'I've been very lucky in life. My life is very privileged. I don't feel like I've suffered or done anything particularly brave. I think about the challenges that people are facing around the world right now. They are really enormous. "We all know what is happening. I've spent a lot of time in Gaza and in the Middle East in the last number of years so I think about their struggles all the time.' (Left to right) Cork Drag Queens Liam Bee and Lucina Schynning at Cork Pride 2024. Arthur said that while Ireland has progressed beyond recognition, other parts of the world remain in a time warp. 'The change in Ireland is remarkable. It's hard to believe the extent of the change that has taken place. However, if you look around the world there is very little change. On the contrary, we are seeing things go backwards. "We tend not to recognise in a sense how lucky we are. So many changes have taken place, not just with the gay issue but with regard to other issues too.'
Irish Examiner
15 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Israel announces humanitarian pause in parts of Gaza
The Israeli military announced on Sunday a daily pause of its operations in parts of Gaza and the establishment of new aid corridors, after months of international pressure over a worsening hunger crisis spreading in the Palestinian enclave. The military said it would cease activity in Al-Mawasi, Deir al-Balah and Gaza City from 10am to 8pm (7am to 5pm Irish time) until further notice, areas where it had not renewed ground operations since March, when it resumed its Gaza offensive. Designated secure routes for convoys delivering food and medicine will also be in place permanently from 6am until 11pm, the military said. The Egyptian state-affiliated Al Qahera News TV said on Sunday that aid started moving towards Gaza from Egypt. Hours earlier Israel began aid airdrops in what it described as an effort to ease the humanitarian conditions in the enclave. On Thursday, the UN said humanitarian pauses in Gaza would allow "the scale up of humanitarian assistance" and said Israel had not been providing enough route alternatives for its convoys, hindering aid access. International alarm over the humanitarian crisis in Gaza has increased and as Israel and the US appeared on Friday to abandon ceasefire negotiations with Hamas, saying it had become clear that the militants did not want a deal. Aid organisations said last week there was mass hunger among Gaza's 2.2 million people, with food running out after Israel cut off all supplies to the territory in March, before resuming it in May with new restrictions. Dozens of Gazans have died of malnutrition in the past few weeks, according to the Gaza Health Ministry in the Hamas-run enclave. A total of 127 people have died due to malnutrition, including 85 children, since the start of the war, the ministry said. Israel says there is no starvation in Gaza and that the aid halt was meant to pressure Hamas into giving up dozens of hostages it is still holding in Gaza. After letting in aid in May, Israel said there was enough food in Gaza but that the United Nations was failing to distribute it. The UN said it was operating as effectively as possible under Israeli restrictions. The war began on October 7, 2023, when Hamas-led fighters stormed southern Israel, killing some 1,200 people, mostly civilians, and taking 251 hostages back to Gaza. Since then, Israel's offensive against Hamas has killed nearly 60,000 people in Gaza, mostly civilians, according to Gaza health officials, reduced much of the enclave to ruins and displaced nearly the entire population. Reuters Read More The latest child to starve to death in Gaza weighed less than when she was born
Irish Independent
17 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Women who suffer miscarriages speak of ‘inhumane' conditions in Irish hospitals
Irish women have spoken about the trauma of experiencing multiple miscarriages in a new study.
