Japan court awards asylum seekers damages over prolonged detention
A Japanese district court has ordered the state to pay a total of 1.2 million yen ($8,260) in compensation to two asylum seekers, ruling that in some cases their repeated detentions by the country's immigration agency did not take account of their physical and mental conditions.
Deniz, a Kurdish man in his 40s with Turkish nationality, and Heydar Safari Diman, an Iranian national in his 50s, sought about 30 million yen in damages, after they were detained and released several times over the space of more than a decade. They filed the lawsuit with the Tokyo District Court in 2022 focusing on their treatment from 2016.
The ruling handed down on Tuesday said that on some occasions, they were detained despite deteriorating health conditions, such as a diagnosis of depression.
"We cannot say the necessity of detention overrode their physical and mental disadvantages," the court said, ruling that some of their detentions violated the International Covenants on Human Rights and amounted to unjust physical restraint prohibited by Japan's immigration law.
The plaintiffs also questioned the immigration law itself, which allows detention without going through a review process such as trials, saying that it infringes the human rights covenants.
But the court dismissed their claim on the grounds that their rights to a trial are guaranteed through a lawsuit seeking release.
Masako Suzuki, a lawyer representing the plaintiffs, underscored the significance of the ruling, telling a press conference that it "clearly acknowledges that there was a violation of the International Covenants on Human Rights in the detention."
The Immigration Services Agency has said it will respond "appropriately" after reviewing details of the ruling, since some of its claims were not upheld.
According to the complaint, Deniz, who declined to give his surname for fear of retaliation against his family in Turkey, and Safari Diman had both overstayed their visas and were subsequently repeatedly detained by the Immigration Services Agency.
From 2016 to 2020, they were detained several times for a total of more than three and a half years each, the complaint said. They have been on provisional releases since the spring of 2020, according to their supporters.
Seeking help from the international community, the two had notified a U.N. expert panel on arbitrary detention of their cases, leading the panel to release an opinion in 2020 that found their deprivation of liberty was "arbitrary" and contravened human rights covenants.
Related coverage:
FEATURE: Hate speech bringing unwanted focus on Japan's Kurdish community
FOCUS: Female Afghan refugees facing legal limbo, deportation in Pakistan
No. of foreign residents in Japan hits record high for 3rd year
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
2 hours ago
Ishiba to Meet with U.S. Treasury Sec. Bessent on Friday
News from Japan Politics Jul 17, 2025 22:05 (JST) Tokyo, July 17 (Jiji Press)--Japanese Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba will meet with U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent at the prime minister's office in Tokyo on Friday afternoon, the Japanese government said Thursday. With U.S. President Donald Trump's administration set to implement so-called reciprocal tariffs on Aug. 1, Ishiba apparently hopes to use the meeting to make a breakthrough in tariff negotiations with the United States. Ishiba is expected to seek the U.S. side's understanding of proposals Japan has made so far, with the aim of reaching a mutually beneficial deal. The meeting will take place at an unusual time, just before Sunday's House of Councillors election in Japan. Bessent is visiting Japan to attend the "national day" event of the United States at the ongoing World Exposition in the western city of Osaka on Saturday. [Copyright The Jiji Press, Ltd.] Jiji Press
Yomiuri Shimbun
4 hours ago
- Yomiuri Shimbun
Sentencing of Japan ‘Spy' Shows China's Line on National Security; Lack of Transparency May Set Back Japan-China Ties
A Chinese court's sentencing of a Japanese man to 3½ years in prison for allegedly engaging in espionage could deal a setback to the recently improving relationship between Japan and China. The man, an employee of drugmaker Astellas Pharma Inc., had been detained by Chinese authorities since March 2023. Japan's government plans to once again press the Chinese side to quickly release Japanese nationals still being detained there. However, concerns over the lack of transparency from Chinese authorities in cases of law enforcement where 'national security' is used a pretext to detain people will continue to smolder. According to the Japanese Embassy in China, the man appeared to listen calmly to the Japanese interpretation of the ruling read out in Chinese by the presiding judge. Only embassy officials were in attendance at the proceedings; Japanese media outlets were unable to enter the courtroom. Men who appeared to be connected to the Chinese authorities stood around the courthouse and blocked attempts to report on the proceedings. The administration of Chinese President Xi Jinping has fostered attempts to improve ties with Japan as Beijing's relations with the administration of U.S. President Donald Trump have grown increasingly adversarial. China has even recently taken steps to resolve issues that had plagued bilateral ties with Japan, such as accelerating procedures for resuming imports of Japanese marine products and beef. The Chinese Foreign Ministry had notified the Japanese side in advance that Wednesday's ruling 'would not be as harsh' as sentences handed down in previous cases, some of which had exceeded 10 years of imprisonment, according to sources familiar with Japan-China ties. Patriotism is expected to be on the rise in China as the nation nears a period that includes Aug. 15, which marks the anniversary of the end of **World War II**, and also Sept. 3, which China celebrates as the anniversary of its victory over Japan. The latest ruling was very likely timed to draw a line under a key contentious problem in Japan-China relations before this period. Amid all this, the Xi administration has continued to ramp up its hegemonistic behavior in the region, such as by having China Coast Guard vessels regularly intrude into Japanese territorial waters around the Senkaku Islands in Okinawa Prefecture and by dispatching two aircraft carriers to conduct exercises simultaneously in the Pacific Ocean. It is unlikely that Xi's administration will offer any concessions on issues that it considers to be non-negotiable, such as national security and the nation's territory. Calls for release unanswered The Japanese government has expressed serious concerns about China's detention of Japanese nationals. Foreign Minister Takeshi Iwaya even described this issue as 'one of the biggest factors impeding people-to-people exchanges and the improvement of national sentiment' between Japan and China. The government has repeatedly pressed the Chinese side to quickly release Japanese nationals it has detained, but the day of the Astellas employee's sentencing arrived without any progress being made. Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba touched on the ruling Wednesday. 'We must ensure the world is orderly,' Ishiba said during a speech in Takaoka, Toyama Prefecture. 'We want to create a more transparent, well-structured order.' That comment was apparently made with the lack of transparency in China's judicial process in mind. China is currently detaining five Japanese nationals, including the Astellas employee. They are being held in locations including Wenzhou, Zhejiang Province; Sanya, Hainan Province; and Changsha, Hunan Province. Chinese authorities have not revealed details about the reasons for and circumstances behind these detentions have not been disclosed. The Japanese government believes it is highly likely that the Chinese side will continue to crack down on what it considers to be 'espionage' activities and to strictly apply its anti-spying law. 'The only thing we can do is have the prime minister directly reach out to President Xi and lean on him to resolve the issue,' a government official told The Yomiuri Shimbun. The latest ruling will inevitably have an impact on economic and people-to-people exchanges between Tokyo and Beijing. The Japanese government is poised to bolster efforts to secure the release of Japanese detainees and strengthen messages urging travelers to China to exercise caution.
Kyodo News
4 hours ago
- Kyodo News
Japan protests South Korean military drills near disputed islets
TOKYO - Japan's government said Thursday it lodged a strong protest with South Korea over military drills conducted in waters near remote islets in the Sea of Japan that are controlled by Seoul but claimed by Tokyo. Masaaki Kanai, head of the Japanese Foreign Ministry's Asian and Oceanian Affairs Bureau, told the South Korean Embassy in Tokyo that the exercises were "totally unacceptable and extremely regrettable," the government said. The islets, called Takeshima in Japan and Dokdo in South Korea, are "clearly an integral part of Japanese territory in light of historical facts and international law," the Foreign Ministry said. Earlier in the day, the South Korean navy said it had carried out the drills, the first since President Lee Jae Myung took office last month, succeeding Yoon Suk Yeol. South Korea's Yonhap News Agency reported that troops did not land on the islets and that the biannual regular training, similar in scale to previous years, was closed to the public, as was the case under the Yoon administration.
