COMMENT: Sundowns fall short at Club World Cup – but is it a win for South Africa?
Mamelodi Sundowns chairman Tlhopie Motsepe pictured next to the FIFA Club World Cup trophy. | Itumeleng English / Independent Newspapers
Image: Itumeleng English / Independent Newspapers
Mamelodi Sundowns may have exited the FIFA Club World Cup at the group stages, but their campaign in the United States did more than just make up the numbers — it made a statement.
Despite falling short of the knockout rounds, their performance and presence on the global stage could be seen as a major win, not just for the club, but potentially for South African football at large.
The Betway Premiership champions ended their tournament with four points from three matches — a 1-0 win over Ulsan Hyundai, a narrow 4-3 defeat to Borussia Dortmund, and a goalless draw with Fluminense.
While that wasn't enough to book a place in the last 16, Sundowns walked away with their heads held high and their bank account significantly heavier.
The club is set to pocket an eye-watering R228 million in prize money — the biggest single payday in their history — following their participation in the expanded 32-team Club World Cup.
And for a team that has invested heavily in continental dominance, this financial return represents more than just cash — it's validation.
At the heart of their competitive showing was Miguel Cardoso, the Portuguese tactician who took over from Manqoba Mngqithi seven months ago.
In that time, Cardoso has implemented a modern, structured style of play that translated impressively onto the world stage.
His side was bold and technically sharp against Dortmund, showed composure in the win over Ulsan, and displayed tactical discipline to hold Fluminense.
While their early exit was disappointing on paper, context matters. Sundowns didn't look out of place — they looked like they belonged. And that matters in a tournament where African clubs are often seen as mere participants.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
2 hours ago
- The Star
Cape Town City may face life in NFD without talented youngsters
Cape Town City will now have to prepare for life in the Motsepe Foundation Championship after being officially ruled out of the promotion/relegation playoffs earlier this week, bringing a long and difficult season to a disappointing close. The Citizens, who ended the campaign 15th on the Premiership table, fell short when it mattered most and must now regroup for the challenges of second-tier football. The Cape side paid the price for their inconsistency throughout a campaign that only saw them get seven victories from 28 matches and their turn out in the playoffs also lacked the urgency the club has been known for in the last 10 years. Their 1-0 defeat to Orbit College handed the Rustenburg-based side a historic promotion to the top flight. The result took Orbit to an unassailable eight points in the mini-league, ending City's survival hopes with a game to spare. At the start of the season, few would have predicted this outcome for City, especially with the wealth of talent still within their squad. As the dust settles, attention now turns to three of their brightest young stars—players who could soon be on the radar of top-flight clubs. The 20-year-old forward enjoyed a landmark year, becoming one of the few South African players to lift the U-20 Africa Cup of Nations. His rise continued with nine league appearances for City this season, playing a role in their battle to retain top-flight status. Ahshene's technical ability and composure in the final third make him one of the most exciting prospects in South African football. His performances have not gone unnoticed, and with City now relegated, clubs in the Betway Premiership are likely to circle for his signature. Jaedin Rhodes In a season filled with setbacks, Jaedin Rhodes emerged as one of the few consistent performers for City. The 22-year-old midfielder featured in 23 matches, showcasing his resilience and maturity despite the team's struggles. Rhodes, who received a national team call-up to the Bafana Bafana Cosafa Cup squad last year, remains a highly valued asset. His creative spark and tactical intelligence could be central to City's hopes of bouncing back quickly. However, the lure of top-flight football may make it difficult for the club to hold onto him, especially with his stock rising. Emile Witbooi
The Star
2 hours ago
- The Star
Mokwana, Mailula, Lorch step up as Africa falls short on global stage
The 2025 FIFA Club World Cup arrived with much promise for African football, particularly for South Africa as Mamelodi Sundowns carried the hopes of the nation onto the global stage. Alongside them stood continental heavyweights Al Ahly, Wydad Athletic Club, and Esperance de Tunis — four clubs that have dominated African football over the past decade. However, the group stage brought a harsh reality. None of the four African sides progressed to the round of 16, and while there were moments of quality, the early exits laid bare the concerning gap between Africa's best and the rest of the world. It was a tournament that underlined how far African clubs still have to go to match their counterparts in Europe, South America, and parts of Asia. Yet within the overall disappointment, there were bright sparks — none more so than Sundowns. The Premiership champions stood out as the most competitive African side, finishing with four points from their three matches. A thrilling 4-3 loss against Borussia Dortmund, a hard-fought 1-0 win over HD Ulsan, and a resilient goalless stalemate against Brazilian giants Fluminense left them agonisingly short of progression. Still, their performances did more than earn respect — they proved that they have matured into a club capable of standing toe-to-toe with the game's elite. Their showing was not just about results; it was a statement of growth. Years of investment, sound football management, and a focus on developing local and continental talent have made them a standard bearer for African football. For South Africa, the tournament also offered a positive subplot. Several Bafana Bafana players gained vital experience on the global stage — something national coach Hugo Broos will be keen to build on ahead of the upcoming Africa Cup of Nations and the 2026 FIFA World Cup qualifiers. Elias Mokwana The versatile attacker featured in all three matches for Esperance de Tunis in one of the toughest groups of the tournament, facing Chelsea and Flamengo. Their 1-0 win over Los Angeles FC was a highlight, but a 3-0 defeat to Chelsea ended their hopes. Despite the early exit, Mokwana impressed with his work rate and discipline and even though he would have wanted to have a lot more impact for his side, he did just enough to open the door for a few options in the market moving ahead. Cassius Mailula The Wydad forward endured a tough campaign, with the Moroccan side finishing without a point. Still, Mailula made his presence felt, scoring one of Wydad's two goals across the group stage. His loan spell from Toronto FC has been fruitful, and the exposure he gained on the world stage could push the Moroccan side to consider making his move permanent. For a player still on the rise, this experience may prove vital to his long-term development. Thembinkosi Lorch
The South African
3 hours ago
- The South African
Orlando Pirates legend on Saleng: 'You let the club down'
Orlando Pirates legend Moeneeb Josephs has expressed his disappointment in Monnapule Saleng. The 27-year-old winger has not played for the Buccaneers in over six months, reportedly due to a contract dispute. Neither the club nor the player has publicly addressed the issue. Josephs believes that Saleng has let the club down, especially in the second half of the season when the Buccaneers needed quality players to compete for the league title and the CAF Champions League. He warns that Saleng might find himself sidelined, especially with the club having acquired new players. 'Every season, a new footballer comes along,' the former Bafana Bafana goalkeeper said on Soccer Beat . 'Yes, I know it was a contract dispute that kept him on the sidelines and obviously, the influence he's got from the side as well but look now. Now it's causing him problems because we have new signings and we are looking forward to the new signings.' The former Pirates keeper admits Saleng is a great talent, but questioned his commitment following his sabbatical. What do we remember of Saleng? It is a fact that when we needed him, he wasn't there. He was an integral part of us, and he made people who are not involved in the game influence his decision, and that is disappointing for me. 'Yes, I love Saleng, he is an amazing player but as much as I love to see Saleng, I'm tired of this thing man.' The Buccaneers have already resumed their pre-season and will jet off to Spain in the next two weeks. It remains to be seen if Saleng will be part of the Orlando Pirates team during their pre-season camp. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
