Breakingviews - Couche-Tard should have gone hostile on Seven & i
Couche-Tard's bid for the 7-Eleven owner was compelling at a 47% premium to the undisturbed share price nearly a year ago, but the soft approach allowed its reluctant target to drag its feet. In Tokyo, it was no secret that the company did not want to be bought; its founding family even tried its own white knight buyout before abandoning it. So it is unsurprising that Alain Bouchard, Couche-Tard's founder and executive chair concluded "there has been no sincere or constructive engagement" after the suitor raised its offer and signed a non-disclosure agreement.
Seven & i calls these barbs "mischaracterizations", but the saga evokes Japan's past bad M&A, like Toshiba's long-drawn-out sale, which activists effectively kicked off in 2017. It also confirms that subsequently introduced guidelines for fair M&A and corporate takeovers aren't worth much. These were designed to revive the $4 trillion economy after decades of deflation. Companies are not on board, however.
They make a show of acting in good faith but clutch to poison pill defences, opens new tab. Even Japan's largest publicly traded firm, Toyota Motor (7203.T), opens new tab, in June emerged as a leader of a highly controversial $33 billion deal that, as the Asian Corporate Governance Association puts it, opens new tab, "exposes the persistent frailties of Japan's corporate governance regime and the enduring power of entrenched interests".
Couche-Tard's decision not to go hostile no doubt stemmed from worrying doing otherwise would scare off the Japanese management team. It also faced antitrust hurdles in the United States and clamouring about the national interest in Japan. Yet there is a growing contingent of bankers and lawyers in the Asian country who view cultural issues as outdated hurdles to transformative inbound deals; they are advising their clients to take a firmer and, if necessary, hostile approach from the beginning.
True, Couche-Tard succeeded in forcing Seven & i to replace its CEO with a foreigner, Stephen Dacus, and revise its standalone value creation plan. But without a suitor applying pressure, some commitments could fade over time. One of these is a 2 trillion yen ($13.5 billion) buyback over the next five years funded in part by the agreed 815 billion yen sale of the group's supermarket business to Bain Capital; another is a future stock market listing of its North American convenience store unit that targets an equity value of at least 1 trillion yen.
Shareholders have concluded that Seven & i was better off with a buyer too. The stock only fell 6% on Thursday, putting it 18% above its pre-deal level. But it is languishing one-fifth below Couche-Tard's offer. The Canadians did not get what they wanted, and arguably nor did Tokyo. Neither tried hard enough.
Follow Una Galani on Linkedin, opens new tab and X, opens new tab.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
18 minutes ago
- Daily Mirror
M&S handed mobile ad ban after using 'unhealthily thin' model
An advert by Marks & Spencer has been banned because of the model's appearance (Image: PA) A Marks and Spencer advert has been banned after the featured model was judged to be "unhealthily thin". The UK's advertising watchdog has ruled that it was "irresponsible" for M&S to use the image in question to promote its clothing on its mobile app. The Advertising Standards Authority criticised the ad, stating that the model, dressed in slim-fit trousers and a white top, "appeared thin and she wore large pointed shoes which emphasised the slenderness of her legs". The ASA's decision also noted that the camera angles made the model's head seem disproportionate and "highlighted her small frame". The ASA concluded: "Therefore, we considered that the pose of the model and the choice of clothing meant the ad gave the impression that the model was unhealthily thin". The company is still recovering from a damaging cyber attack (Image: PA) In response to the ban, Marks and Spencer expressed regret for any upset caused and promptly withdrew the image. A spokesperson for the company commented: "Our womenswear sizing ranges from size 8 to 24 and we always want to reflect that in our advertising." They continued: "The product images on our website feature models of varying sizes so we can appeal to all our customers, however following the ASA guidance, we have removed this particular image from our website and apologise for any offence caused." While three additional images were brought to the attention of the ASA by concerned consumers, the authority did not find these to be in violation, thus no further action against the retailer was taken. It comes as four people have been arrested by police investigating the M&S, Co-op and Harrods cyber attacks. The arrests include three teenagers - a 17-year-old British man from the West Midlands, a 19-year-old Latvian man from the West Midlands, a 19-year-old British man from London - and a 20-year-old British woman from Staffordshire. The individuals were detained on suspicion of blackmail, money laundering, offences linked to the Computer Misuse Act and participating in the activities of an organised crime group. All four people remain in custody. Paul Foster, head of the NCA's National Cyber Crime Unit, said: 'Since these attacks took place, specialist NCA cybercrime investigators have been working at pace and the investigation remains one of the agency's highest priorities. 'Today's arrests are a significant step in that investigation but our work continues, alongside partners in the UK and overseas, to ensure those responsible are identified and brought to justice.' M&S was forced to shut down its online store following the cyber attack, which happened during Easter weekend and affected contactless payments in stores, as well as click and collect orders. It was later confirmed that customer data, including names, email addresses, addresses and dates of birth - but it does not include card or payment details, was stolen. The boss of M&S last week issued an update, and said the rest of its online operations will reopen by next month. The supermarket started resuming online orders in June but some services are still not back to normal. For example, you still cannot place an order for click and collect or next day delivery. M&S is also still is not delivering to Northern Ireland. Stuart Machin, CEO of M&S, expects these services to be fully restored from August. Speaking to shareholders at the retailer's annual general meeting, he said: "Since these attacks took place, specialist NCA cybercrime investigators have been working at pace and the investigation remains one of the Agency's highest priorities.
The Independent
20 minutes ago
- The Independent
EU and Japan agree to work together to promote free trade and economic security
Leaders of the European Union and Japan launched an alliance Wednesday aimed at boosting economic cooperation, defending free trade and countering unfair trade practices as the two sides face growing challenges from the United States and China. The agreement followed a meeting among European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, European Council President António Costa and Japanese Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba. It comes just as Tokyo and Washington reached a new trade deal, which places 15% tariffs on Japanese cars and other goods imported into the U.S., down from an initial 25%. The leaders agreed to launch 'competitiveness alliance" aimed at stepping up trade, economic security and cooperation in innovation, energy and other areas, according to a joint statement released by the EU. The leaders also supported 'a stable and predictable rules-based free and fair economic order,' and reaffirmed the importance of Japan-EU cooperation to uphold multilateral trading system with the World Trade Organization at its core, as well as with other multilateral cooperation efforts. The EU and Japan also agreed to strengthen defense industry cooperation and to start talks on an information security agreement. Japan and the EU have been stepping up their security and defense cooperation amid growing global tensions and conflicts, including Russia's war on Ukraine, conflicts in the Middle East and increasingly assertive China's military activity in Asia, recognizing that challenges in Europe and Indo-Pacific are inseparable.
Reuters
20 minutes ago
- Reuters
India's Force Motors logs quarterly profit jump on strong demand for vans
July 23 (Reuters) - India's Force Motors ( opens new tab clocked a 52% jump in first-quarter profit, on the back of strong demand for its multi-seater vans. The 'Traveller' van manufacturer reported a profit of 1.85 billion rupees ($21.4 million) for the April-June period, up from 1.2 billion rupees in the year-ago period. Quarterly revenue jumped about 22% to 22.97 billion rupees, helped by a roughly 19% growth in its sales volume. Force Motors' vehicles are also used as school buses and ambulances. It is also a contract manufacturer of engines for BMW ( opens new tab and Mercedes Benz ( opens new tab cars in India. ($1 = 86.3510 Indian rupees)
