Three Fianna Fáil MEPs to vote against motion to censure Ursula von der Leyen
The European Parliament will on Thursday vote on a motion which relates to Ms von der Leyen's blocking of a freedom of information request for text messages she exchanged with the CEO of the Pfizer pharmaceutical company during the covid-19 pandemic.
The motion, proposed by a group of mainly far-right lawmakers in the European Parliament, is destined to fall far short of the two-thirds majority needed to force out Ms von der Leyen's commission, as centrist groups that hold a majority in the parliament have said they will not support it.
The motion has been taken up by some European lawmakers as a referendum on the commission's handling of the Gaza crisis.
There had been some speculation as to how the Fianna Fáil MEPs in the parliament would vote, with Dublin's Barry Andrews confirming on Wednesday that he will abstain from the vote while colleagues Cynthia Ní Mhurchú, Barry Cowen and Billy Kelleher will vote against the censure.
Mr Andrews, who is the vice-president of the parliament's delegation on Gaza, said in a statement that "abstaining is never a good option, but is sometimes the only option".
Barry Andrews: 'While this motion has no chance of passing, I will not add my vote to the tally which could endanger the commission now, including the good work of Commissioner McGrath and others.' File photo: Sasko Lazarov/© RollingNews.ie
He added that the motion is "tabled by fascists, neo-fascists, Putin puppets and Netanyahu-supporting MEPs and cannot be supported".
"I have confidence in President von der Leyen's management of the pandemic and refuse to be associated with the anti-vaccine agenda behind the motion.
"While this motion has no chance of passing, I will not add my vote to the tally which could endanger the commission now, including the good work of Commissioner McGrath and others."
However, he said that he could not vote against the motion as "President von der Leyen has been utterly silent on the ongoing genocide in Gaza, which we all can see with our own eyes" and "not once criticised blatant Israeli war crimes".
He said that abstaining will not add to the vote numbers required for the motion to succeed or "undermine the stability of the EU at this crucial time".
Ms Ní Mhurchú said that Ms von der Leyen is "rightly facing political scrutiny and pressure due to her actions and inactions during the course of her term of office".
"Last year, I voted against her securing a second term as President of the European Commission, primarily due to, but not limited to, her actions and commentary since the barbaric October 7 Hamas attacks and Israel's illegal, inhumane and ongoing war crimes in Gaza.
President von der Leyen has failed to hold Israel to account for its war crimes in Gaza. I have continually raised the fact that our continued preferential trade terms with Israel, and continued arms sales from EU countries to Israel, are in contravention of EU legal obligations and values.
However, she said that the motion "is not solely a vote of confidence in President von der Leyen; it is about the entire College of Commissioner's stays in office".
"What is clear is that a majority vote in favour of censuring the entire commission would result in the collapse of the Union's leadership, President von der Leyen and the other 26 commissioners, at a critical moment."
Mr Cowen said that the motion would remove the entire commission, "including those finalising important work such as Trade Commissioner Šefčovič on the EU-US and EU-UK trade deals, Agriculture Commissioner Hansen on the next Common Agricultural Policy and, indeed, Commissioner Michael McGrath".
"If this were a targeted motion against von der Leyen alone, or one related directly to her handling of Gaza, I may well have voted differently – but that is not the case."
Read More
Billy Kelleher: Ursula von der Leyen does not speak for the EU on Israel and Iran
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Extra.ie
18 minutes ago
- Extra.ie
Academic Deirdre Heenan in frame for FF Áras bid
Fianna Fáil backbenchers believe Northern university professor Deirdre Heenan 'ticks a lot of Mary McAleese boxes' as she edges closer to becoming the party's presidential candidate. The party is seeking to emulate its success in the 1997 presidential election when Ms McAleese, a Belfast lawyer and academic, won the election after getting the backing of FF. spoke with several Fianna Fáil sources yesterday, with broad support for Ms Heenan despite some concern raised about 'lack of name recognition'. Professor Deirdre Heenan. Pic: Sasko Lazarov/Photocall Ireland Several of the party sources contacted by this newspaper said that they first came across Ms Heenan when she spoke at a party event in UCD to commemorate the 25th anniversary of the Good Friday Agreement. 'I wasn't surprised to hear her name as she ticks a lot of Mary McAleese boxes. She was very impressive when she spoke at the Good Friday event and would fit the mould of what Micheál [Martin] would want,' they said. At the event, Ms Heenan, a professor of social policy, was on stage alongside former Fianna Fáil leader and taoiseach Bertie Ahern, former minister Martin Mansergh, as well as Mr Martin. Professor Deirdre Heenan and Former Taoiseach Bertie Ahern in 2013. Pic: Colin Keegan, Collins Dublin. 'She was very impressive, and really challenging about the Good Friday Agreement. She spoke about how too many people sit back and applaud the GFA, when, in her view, it is not yet complete, and that we can't afford to rest on our laurels. She was the most impressive speaker that day,' the source said. A separate party source who also attended the UCD event said her selection would be a 'fresh approach' and she had the benefit of 'not having built up a lot of enemies in the political system as she hasn't been part of it'. In 2012, Ms Heenan was appointed by President Michael D Higgins to his Council of State. The Council of State advises the President when they are considering referring a bill to the Supreme Court to test its constitutionality, refusing to dissolve the Dáil on the advice from the Taoiseach or declaring a state of emergency. The sources said that presidential elections cost a lot of money and that they don't offer much return to the party. 'If you introduce a candidate, like Deirdre, from the six counties and use it not only as to put someone forward for the presidency but to also lead the conversation about what a United Ireland looks like, that could be worthwhile.' Ms Heenan is from Annaclone in Co. Down, educated at Banbridge Academy and Ulster University and lives in Derry with her husband and three sons. She did not reply to a request for comment last night.
Extra.ie
18 minutes ago
- Extra.ie
Cutting costs: Vasectomies could soon be free across Ireland as men urged to 'step up'
Vasectomies may soon be offered for free across the country, the Health Minister has confirmed. Jennifer Carroll MacNeill was responding to a question by Labour's Marie Sherlock TD, who told the Dáil that it was time for men to 'step up' and stop relying on women to use contraceptives. Responding to a parliamentary question from Ms Sherlock, Ms Carroll MacNeill agreed that there was 'significant inequity of access' to vasectomy, both geographically and based on ability to pay, and that the Government is now considering free access to vasectomies across the country. Jennifer Carroll MacNeill. Pic: Stephen Collins/ Collins Photos She said that the Department of Health's National Sexual Health Strategy is 'committed to scoping the potential for expanding access to male and female sterilisation', including vasectomies for men. The Minister also said that a strategy will be created 'as soon as possible in 2025.' Vasectomies are currently available without cost to some medical cardholders. Ms Sherlock told the Dáil: 'The responsibility for family planning shouldn't just fall on the woman's shoulders. There's a simple, relatively pain-free procedure that a man recovers from within a very few short hours, but obviously it has a transformative impact on the family. Marie Sherlock. Photo: RTÉ. 'We have to make sure in the whole family planning conversation that men step up and take their responsibility seriously. There's a real inequality of access to the service, and particularly outside of the main urban areas,' she said. 'There's a crucial issue here about how we encourage and incentivise doctors to take on the service, and crucially, then from the department of health perspective, that there is a decent geographical spread of these services across the country.' However, Aontú leader, Peadar Tóibín, last night questioned whether the Government should be offering free vasectomies while Ireland's fertility rates continue to plunge. Peadar Tóibín. Pic: Fran Veale Mr Tóibín said: 'There are major questions in relation to where the Government is going in relation to this. So what we've seen in the last decade is a collapse in the fertility levels. They're lower now than the replacement rate, which means there's going to be significantly fewer children in future than there were in the past.' The fertility rate for 2024 stood at 1.5, a decrease of 0.5 from the 2014 fertility rate of 2.0. This is still higher than the European average, which stands at 1.38 births per woman in the EU. In Malta, the fertility rate stands at 1.06, compared to 1.81 in Bulgaria. Mr Tóibín warned that Ireland will create 'lopsided demographics, which means there will be fewer young people to be able to work, to provide the taxes to pay the pensions for people into the future. 'Good governance means a balanced demographics, and actually, at this moment in time, that means encouraging families to have more children. 'There's no doubt that the housing crisis is hammering families. They're delaying having children, and they're living, oftentimes, young couples in their parents' box room, which means that they can't have children and it's later and later until people are getting mortgages.' He went on: 'The cost of childcare is prohibitive for many, many people, and also the abortion rates have increased from about 3,000 abortions a year in 2018 to spiking well over 10,000 now.' 'All of these issues are pushing down the number of children that have been born. We should be giving families the economic confidence to be able to raise their children, to be able to have children, and so that we have a vibrant society and economy into the future.' Ryan Murphy, the operations manager at Sandyford, Dublin-based clinic said that vasectomies could not be accessed in multiple areas of the country, creating a 'two-tier system'.
RTÉ News
2 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Iran 'cannot give up' on nuclear enrichment, says Foreign Minister
Iran has no plans to abandon its nuclear programme, including uranium enrichment, despite "severe" damage to its facilities after US strikes last month, Iran's Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi said. For now, enrichment "is stopped because, yes, damages are serious and severe," Mr Araghchi told Fox News' Special Report with Bret Baier. "But obviously we cannot give up enrichment because it is an achievement of our own scientists," he continued, calling it a source of "national pride." He stressed that any future nuclear deal would have to contain the right to enrichment. When asked whether any enriched uranium had been saved from the strikes, Mr Araghchi said he had "no detailed information," but that Iran's Atomic Energy Organisation is "trying to evaluate what has exactly happened to our nuclear material, to our enriched material." The US bombed three nuclear facilities in Iran on 22 June to support Israel's 12-day military offensive, including the Fordow underground uranium enrichment site located south of Tehran. US President Donald Trump has repeatedly called the strikes a success, reaffirming on Saturday that all three sites were "completely destroyed". Mr Trump welcomed Mr Araghchi's comments in a post on his Truth Social platform. "Just like I said, and we will do it again, if necessary!" he posted. Mr Araghchi's remarks come as Tehran is set to hold new talks on its nuclear programme with Germany, France and the UK on Friday in Istanbul. Regarding negotiations with the United States to de-escalate regional tension, Mr Araghchi said "we are open to talks" but "not direct for the time being." "We are ready to do any confidence-building measure needed to prove that Iran's nuclear program is peaceful" in exchange for lifted US sanctions, he added. The foreign minister also confirmed that Iran would continue to develop and manufacture missiles. Despite multiple barrages of missiles launched at Israel and waves of Israeli attacks on its bases and launchers, Mr Araghchi said "we still have a good number of missiles to defend ourselves". Mr Baier also asked about the health of Iran's Supreme Leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, who has rarely been seen since the start of Israel's attack. "I met him today, he is in a very good shape and in a very good health," Mr Araghchi said.
