US Supreme Court rejects American Airlines appeal of ruling barring JetBlue alliance
June 30 (Reuters) - The U.S. Supreme Court rejected on Monday a request by American Airlines (AAL.O), opens new tab to overturn a judicial decision that found that the company's now-scrapped U.S. Northeast partnership with JetBlue Airways (JBLU.O), opens new tab violated federal antitrust law.
The justices turned away an appeal by American Airlines of a lower court's decision in a lawsuit brought by the U.S. Justice Department that led to the end of the proposed "Northeast Alliance," which would have allowed the two carriers to coordinate flights and pool revenue.
The American Airlines argued that the antitrust violation ruling by the Boston-based 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals wrongly embraced a hostility to collaboration between businesses and was contrary to the approach taken by other courts to require evidence of actual harm to consumers in the market as a whole, not just the customers of the collaborators.
The company also said the ruling invalidated a joint venture that increased market-wide competition among all airlines and "threatens to wreak havoc on productive collaborations of all shapes and sizes."
The November ruling came in a lawsuit the Justice Department filed in 2021 along with six states during Democratic President Joe Biden's administration. Under Biden, the Justice Department made boosting airline competition a top priority and aggressively enforced U.S. antitrust laws.
Despite a change in administrations, the Justice Department under Republican President Donald Trump has continued to defend the government's victory in the American Airlines-JetBlue case, saying the 1st Circuit's ruling upholding a judge's decision blocking the alliance rested on "uncontroversial antitrust principles."
The alliance was announced in July 2020 and approved by the U.S. Transportation Department just days before the end of Trump's first administration in January 2021.
Through their partnership, American, the nation's largest airline, and JetBlue, the sixth-largest, joined forces for flights in and out of New York City and Boston, coordinating schedules and pooling revenue.
The Justice Department argued that the alliance would hurt consumers by eliminating incentives for American to cut prices to lure customers from JetBlue, a historically disruptive rival with often lower fares.
U.S. District Judge Leo Sorokin in Boston in 2023 sided with the Justice Department and found the alliance violated antitrust law.
Following Sorokin's ruling, JetBlue terminated the alliance, as it unsuccessfully sought to bolster its efforts to win approval for the now-dropped $3.8-billion purchase of Spirit Airlines , which Biden's Justice Department also successfully challenged.
American Airlines, though, pressed ahead with an appeal, saying the ruling would prevent the company from entering into any similar future arrangement, including with JetBlue. But a three-judge 1st Circuit panel upheld Sorokin's decision.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
7 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
New details emerge about Trump's visit to 'Alligator Alcatraz'
President Donald Trump is leaning into the cold blooded descriptions of a new 'Alligator Alcatraz' facility to detain migrants in Florida's Everglades, with a planned presidential trip to see it Tuesday. He will be joined by former presidential primary rival Gov. Ron DeSantis and Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem, who already sparked concern about the new lock-up by posting an image of menacing alligators wearing ICE baseball hats. 'The facility is in the heart of the Everglades and will be informally known as "Alligator Alcatraz,"' White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt told reporters Monday. 'There is only one road leading in, and the result the only way out is a one way flight. It is isolated and surrounded by dangerous wildlife and unforgiving terrain,' she added. The trip will have Trump leaving Washington even as the Senate is dealing with his 'One Big, Beautiful Bill,' which faces cross tensions from Republican conservatives concerned about estimates showing it adds up to $4 trillion to the debt, and moderates who have fretted about slashing cuts to Medicaid. Pressed by the Daily Mail whether the dangerous animals were a design feature, Leavitt responded: 'When you have illegal murderers and rapists and heinous criminals in a detention facility surrounded by alligators, yes, I do think that's a deterrent for them to try to escape.' 'So of course, we want to keep the American people safe, and we want to remove these public safety threats from our streets, and we want to effectively detain them as best as we can,' she continued. 'As for why the President is going, I think his trip to this detention facility actually underscores the need to pass the one big, beautiful bill, because we need more detention facilities across the country.' DeSantis will be able to hold up to 5,000 migrants, as the Trump administration gears up its mass deportation campaign targeting people who are here illegally. DHS spokeswoman Tricia McLaughlin told Fox Business that 'at the start they likely will be individuals who are picked up under 287(g). These are not going to be high threat facilities just yet, but they have the capacity to hold the worst of the worst.' She said that included murderers, rapists, and gang members. But she agreed when pressed that it would not be just violent criminals who get placed there. 'Not likely. But we do need proper facilities especially as we're ramping up,' she said. 'We do need places to hold these individuals these bed spaces before we remove them from the country,' she said, adding it could be a 'blueprint for across the country. McLaughlin was referring to a provision of the law that according to ICE allows it to partner with local authorities for the 'arrest and removal of aliens who undermine the safety of our nation's communities and the integrity of U.S. immigration laws.' The tent facility being assembled at the Dade-Collier Training and Transition Airport features an air strip that could be used for arrivals and deportations. DeSantis called the facility inside the Everglades west of Miami it a 'one-stop shop.' Opponents who are bashing the idea on environmental and other grounds are also stressing the wildlife. The habitat hosts an estimated 200,000 alligators, along with non-indigenous predators like pythons. One activist wanting to preserve the ecosystem even mentioned that a family of panthers lives nearby.
Daily Mail
8 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Kristi Noem fires back after scrutiny of $80K 'dark money' payment to her company
Donald Trump 's Homeland Security chief Kristi Noem has fired back after it emerged her company received $80,000 from a fundraising group while she was governor of South Dakota. Noem's company was paid $80,000 by a nonprofit she had helped raise $800,000 for, according to tax records reviewed by ProPublica. Critics called the arrangement 'disturbing' and pointed to a South Dakota law that the governor should 'devote (their) full time to office' and 'compensation (be) limited to salaries.' But Noem's lawyer Trevor Stanley, In a statement to ProPublica, said she had 'fully complied with the letter and the spirit of the law.' Records for the nonprofit, American Resolve Policy Fund, an organization which backs Noem, showed the $800,000 had been taken in from 'fundraising' activities. ProPublica described the nonprofit as a 'so-called dark money group' because it was not required to disclose the identities of its donors. The records showed 10 percent of the money raised was then paid to Ashwood Strategies LLC. Noem was the managing member of Ashwood Strategies, which was incorporated in Delaware in June 2023. When she became President Trump's Homeland Security Secretary, Noem filled out a detailed financial disclosure form. On that form, reviewed by the Daily Mail, she said Ashwood Strategies LLC had taken in money for 'personal activities outside my official gubernatorial capacity.' She added that the money had not been passed on to her. Income she reported for Ashwood Strategies was 'solely received by the LLC; I did not receive any personal income or other distributions from the LLC,' Noem wrote. The form also revealed that the Ashwood Strategies received Noem's $139,750 advance for her 2024 book 'No Going Back: The Truth on What's Wrong with Politics and How We Move America Forward.' In January, in an ethics agreement ahead of taking her new job as Homeland Security Secretary , Noem said she would resign from her position as managing member of Ashwood Strategies. 'I will continue to have a financial interest in this entity, but I will not provide services material to the production of income,' Noem said. 'Instead, if I receive any income from Ashwood Strategies, LLC in the future, I will receive only passive investment income from it.' In his statement to ProPublica, Stanley, said that, after Ashwood Strategies appeared on her financial disclosure, the Office of Government Ethics had 'analyzed and cleared her financial information in regards to this entity.' According to her disclosure form Noem earned $241,519 as governor of South Dakota. The new row came after she attracted attention for wearing a $50,000 Rolex Cosmograph Daytona Rolex watch when she toured the infamous Cecot prison in El Salvador in March. The following month, when she had her bag stolen at a restaurant in Washingon DC. it emerged she was carrying $3,000 in cash
Daily Mail
8 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Joe Rogan drops blunt two-word plan to 'Make America Great Again'
Joe Rogan gave a two-word solution to what he believes will fix all of America's problems. On a June 24 episode of The Joe Rogan Experience, he was talking to US Senator Bernie Sanders about how education, economic inequality and decades of systemic failure have stacked the deck against millions of people. 'If you wanna make America great again, less losers,' Rogan said. 'How do you make less losers? Don't stack the deck against them.' He argued that empowering people through education is key to building a stronger and smarter nation. 'We believe that there should be free public education,' Rogan added. 'And most people believe that the university system should also be funded. And it would benefit everyone. You'd have better GDP, you'd have more, more successful people.' Rogan also pointed to how many communities, especially in urban areas, have seen little change for generations, tracing current inequality back to historical injustices. 'These cities have been the exact same way for decade after decade,' he said, citing 'Jim Crow and the red line laws.' Jim Crow laws enforced racial segregation in the South until the mid-20th century, while redlining was a discriminatory practice that marked mostly Black and minority neighborhoods as high-risk, denying residents access to loans, homeownership, and investment. 'Why is nothing being done to fix that or to correct that problem? It becomes this political beach ball that they just bounce around the air at a concert,' Rogan said. Sanders agreed with Rogan's comments, saying: 'The first point you made, you wanna make America great, right? Have the best-educated workforce in the world. How's that? Yes. Radical idea. I don't think so.' The senator also pointed out that higher education is linked to longer life expectancy. His statement reflected findings from multiple studies showing that people who finish high school reduce their risk of dying early by 25 percent, while college graduates cut that risk by 34 percent. The US continues to lag behind other developed nations in educational performance, particularly in math and science. This growing gap has serious consequences for the economy and the future of American workers. According to a 2021 Education Week article, America now has 'the worst-educated workforce in the industrialized world.' Because US workers are among the highest paid globally, the report warns, this education shortfall leaves them uncompetitive, both in the global job market and against rapidly advancing machines. 'It is a formula for a grim future,' the article states. Sanders said that if America wants to have the best future possible, it needs to have the best childcare system in the world. 'What are the most important years of human development? Zero to four, how is our childcare system doing? It's a disaster,' he said. The Senator added that childcare workers are only making $15 an hour, and most families cannot afford childcare, noting Vermont starts around $20,000 a year. Shifting to education, Sanders said many young people want to pursue college or trade school, but the system makes it increasingly difficult. 'We desperately need... here's something that really drives me a little bit nuts in America today, Joe,' Sanders said, segueing into what he called a broken healthcare system 'based on greed, not on need.' 'All over the country, people have to wait sometimes months to get to a doctor's office,' he said. 'We have a massive nursing shortage. We need more dentists. Big problem in dentistry. We need more mental health counselors. We need more pharmacists.' Sanders emphasized the urgent need for medical professionals and the crushing student debt burden that prevents many from entering the field. He estimated that medical school graduates often leave with between $250,000 and $500,000 in debt, with nurses owing $100,000 to $150,000. 'You wanna go to medical school… If you don't have any money, you know how much you're gonna graduate in debt? Probably a quarter million dollars. Easy double debt. Really,' Sanders said. 'It is not unusual for people from working-class homes to come out of medical school $500,000 in debt. It's insane. We need more doctors.' Rogan then asked Sanders what he would have done differently if he had become president. 'Imagine if you hadn't gotten derailed and they hadn't conspired against you, and you actually became the Democratic candidate for president and you won. What would you have done differently?' Rogan asked. Sanders joked about needing hours to answer, but pointed to campaign finance reform as a top priority, saying he would push for publicly funded elections. 'Well, it's not just the first day in office. I would've dealt with this campaign finance reform issue,' Sanders said. 'And there are ways that you can get around that Supreme Court decision.' He laid out a model in which candidates who gather enough signatures to prove they're serious would receive a set amount of public funding. 'You wanna run against me? That's great, but you're not gonna get super PAC money. We are gonna publicly fund you,' Sanders said. When Rogan asked if that meant both of them would be funded by the government, Sanders replied, 'Yes, absolutely. Rather than someone running for president funded by the current president.' He acknowledged critics who oppose using taxpayer money for campaigns but argued it was far better than billionaires buying elections. 'That makes a lot more sense than what you've got right now,' Sanders said.
