Ex-Peppa Pig boss ‘loses £300,000 after he was sacked for brandishing a pen at his boss' in five-year court battle
Mark Dowding, who earned up to £160,000 a year at toy giant The Character Group PLC, was given the boot and left with a hefty bill after a five-year court battle.
Advertisement
5
Mark Dowding former group finance director of Peppa Pig toy company The Character Group PLC took the company to an employment tribunal
Credit: Champion News Service
5
The Character Group PLC are makers of Peppa Pig plushies and Doctor Who toys
Credit: Champion News Service
5
Despite the ruling, the former Peppa Pig exec launched several appeals
Credit: Champion News Service
The former chief financial officer, who may be forced to sell his home and pension, was dismissed in 2017 after a breakdown in trust, following a heated row with his boss where he allegedly pointed a pen in a threatening way.
He took the company, makers of Peppa Pig plushies and Doctor Who toys, to an employment tribunal, claiming he was unfairly dismissed and that the pen incident was fabricated.
But in 2020 Employment Judge Omar Khalil said: "The tribunal concludes that the incident as described by [Mr Dowding's boss] did occur, which included the claimant pointing towards him brandishing a pen in a threatening manner."
Despite the ruling, the former Peppa Pig exec launched several appeals.
Advertisement
LEGAL BATTLE
Despite the ruling, Dowding launched several appeals and a High Court claim, running up eye-watering legal costs.
One remaining claim is still live- but he's now been told it will be struck out unless he coughs up the £288,000 he owes from his failed legal bids.
High Court judge Richard Spearman KC said the financial blow puts Dowding at risk of losing his £850,000 home and his pension, his only regular income.
The judge quoted Greek tragedy writer Sophocles, saying: "It is a painful thing to look at your own trouble and know that you yourself and no one else has made it'.
Advertisement
Most read in The Sun
He added: "That, in my view, is the predicament in which the claimant Mr Dowding now finds himself."
THE PEN INCIDENT
Mr Dowding joined The Character Group in 2012 and was earning £110,000 plus a potential 50 per cent bonus by the time of his dismissal.
The 2017 incident unfolded during a heated meeting with his boss, Mr Shah.
Judge Khalil said: "Their discussion became heated and voices were raised.
Advertisement
"The claimant accepted in evidence he raised his voice first.
"Mr Shah also alleged that the claimant had pointed a pen towards him, causing Mr Shah to retreat.
"This was set out in his email, which followed this altercation on the same day.
"In that email, Mr Shah said: 'You raised your voice towards me in a threatening manner and pointed a pen in my face whilst rolling forward towards me with your chair. I had to roll my chair back to prevent injury to my face'.'
Advertisement
THE FIGHT GOES ON
After losing at tribunal, Dowding refused to back down, instead filing a flurry of appeals and launching a High Court claim.
In December 2023, an order was made securing his legal costs against the equity in his Rotherhithe Street home in south London.
Judge Spearman said: "Essentially as a result of the way in which he chose to plead his case and to contest the efforts of TCG to restrict that case to what is properly arguable, a number of substantial orders for costs were made against Mr Dowding in July 2024.
"Mr Dowding sought, but was refused, permission to appeal against those orders to the Court of Appeal.
Advertisement
"According to the disclosure Mr Dowding has provided, his only source of income is his personal pension, and his only substantial assets are his personal pension fund and the equity in his home.
"He now faces losing that fund, and maybe also his home, to meet those costs orders.
Read more on the Irish Sun
"He is in a very unhappy position because, on the disclosure he has made, he can ill-afford to meet these costs liabilities: either his home may be forfeit or his pension may be forfeit - possibly, if things go on the way they have, both.
"That is a consequence of bringing and pursuing expensive litigation which has all been unsuccessful, resulting in the costs orders."
Advertisement
5
After losing at tribunal, Dowding refused to back down, instead filing a flurry of appeals and launching a High Court claim
Credit: Champion News Service
5
Despite the ruling, Dowding launched several appeals and a High Court claim, running up eye-watering legal costs
Credit: PA
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sunday World
7 hours ago
- Sunday World
Former GAA player finally pays compensation for assault on reporter in Four Courts
Ex-Cavan footballer Eddie Óg O'Reilly was convicted in 2023 after attack on journalist Ray Managh, who asked that the money be given to charity A former Cavan GAA footballer who assaulted a court reporter after demanding that he not report on his debt case has finally paid the compensation ordered by a judge over two years ago. Eddie Óg O'Reilly was convicted in 2023 of assaulting journalist Ray Managh, now aged 82, in the Four Courts in 2018. The case was delayed on a number of occasions for administrative reasons and after O'Reilly's legal team said their client could not deal with the stress and anxiety caused by the case. O'Reilly, who has US citizenship, went to work in America after the attack, but was arrested by Garda Mick McGrath, of the Bridewell garda station, in Dublin Airport in 2019 when he was returning to Ireland. O'Reilly, from Kilcogy, Co Cavan, pleaded not guilty to the attack. After he was found guilty, Judge John Hughes characterised O'Reilly's evidence that he was terrified for his life due to Mr Managh and news photographers chasing him through the streets of Dublin as 'delusional'. 'The reporting of civil and criminal cases goes back hundreds of years — it is a valuable function in society and needs to be protected,' Judge Hughes said. Court reporter Ray Managh was assaulted by Eddie Óg O'Reilly in 2018. Photo: Collins Courts O'Reilly was given a nine-month suspended sentence for the offence. He was ordered to pay a fine of €2,000 and attend an anger management course. The judge also ordered him to pay Mr Managh €3,000 in compensation, which the reporter requested be paid directly to the cancer research unit at Children's Health Ireland (CHI) at Crumlin. The assault took place after O'Reilly was in court trying to prevent the repossession of a €500,000 investment apartment that he and his brother Michael had got into arrears on. After that hearing, O'Reilly followed Mr Managh out of the court and badgered him not to report on the case. When told 'no', he shouldered the journalist, then 75, into a lift and violently pinned him against a wall until he could get his notebook. The notebook was taken and never returned. Mr Managh was able to write the story despite the assault. O'Reilly refused to apologise and took an appeal that was dropped on the eve of the appeal hearing last January. Mr Managh said he had recently been told by gardaí that the children's hospital had received the €3,000 compensation he was due from the case. 'I was beginning to worry that it would never be paid, so it's a relief that it's finally over,' Mr Managh said. It is understood the compensation money was paid earlier this year after O'Reilly withdrew his appeal. Eddie Óg O'Reilly. Photo: Collins Courts Today's News in 90 Seconds - July 21st
Extra.ie
10 hours ago
- Extra.ie
Community 'safety' group includes violent offenders and killer as members
A failed far-right election candidate who ranted 'I'm going all Texas on it. I got guns' in a disturbing post about asylum seekers is a founding member of 'vigilante' group Sinne na Daoine, has learned. Another founding member of the anti-immigrant group – which claims to have 'over 1,000' members – and a fellow failed election candidate, threatened to 'storm' the Dáil this week in a series of social media posts. And can further reveal – after reporting recently that a convicted father killer was in the group – that a separate person strongly associated with the sinister group is currently before the courts for a violent crime. Sinne na Daoine leader with Ger McNamara. Pic: File The worrying remarks about having guns were made in a 2022 post by Martin Murphy, who ran in last year's local elections for the Irish Freedom Party, in Tipperary's Carrick-on-Suir constituency. He also remarked on a post about former British prime minister Liz Truss and the European Commission president, Ursula von der Leyen: 'Ask which you would shoot if you only had 1 bullet.' The previous year, the former candidate and current Ireland First 'national organiser' posted a series of tweets calling for Fine Gael TDs and senators to be sent to the 'gallows'. understands Sinne na Daoine was founded last year by approximately ten people, including Mr Murphy and the president of the Ireland First party, Anthony Casey. It has been backed by ex-MMA star and self-styled presidential candidate Conor McGregor. Mr Casey said this week the Dáil needs to be 'stormed already'. The former Kildare South candidate made the comments on a post that claimed the Dublin streets 'run red with the blood of our own'. 'Do you still think @SinneNaDaoine is too extreme? Still think I'm too militant?,' he asked. 'How many innocent Irish lives are you willing to sacrifice? 'Don't be concerned about my 'electability'.' He added, the 'Dáil needs to be stormed already!!' When it was put to him by a follower that he should 'stop pontificating' and 'storm it', Mr Casey replied he will be there 'front and centre'. 'There are over 1000 in Sinne na Daoine now,' he said. 'Trust me, I am working on it, and I will be there front and centre. There's a reason I'm adopting a multi-pronged approach as I've said from the get go.' He continued: 'There are strong patriots around the movement that I need to sit down with first in order to achieve this effectively.' The revelations about its founding members come as can report that a man connected to Sinne na Daoine is currently charged with a serious violent crime. The man can't be named for legal reasons but has previously attended a Sinne na Daoine meeting at which he spoke. recently revealed another man, who bludgeoned his own father to death, is also a central figure in Sinne na Daoine. Ger McNamara. Pic: File Killer Gerard McNamara – who kicked and beat his own father to death – is part of the group that previously revealed has begun staging street patrols and has members in almost every county in the country. A photo from the group's first patrol in Limerick city shows McNamara, 37, posing beside Anthony Casey. The group were dressed in orange vests featuring the Sinne na Daoine logo. An informed source described the group as 'vigilantes' who 'put up stickers on the streets they patrol'. 'They are organised and anyone who wants to join is screened,' said the source. 'One of the women does the screening, and you have to do a FaceTime call or 30-second video [before being allowed onto their online forums].' Killer McNamara was sentenced to eight years in prison, with the final two years suspended, in 2012, for killing his father in a drink-fuelled row. He pleaded not guilty to murder but guilty to the manslaughter of Joseph 'Joey' O'Donnell, 48 at Hyde Road, Prospect, in Limerick, on October 1, 2010. Joseph O'Donnell died in hospital from blunt force trauma to the head, hours after his son had kicked and beaten him with a number of household items and a full can of beer. Last week, revealed how a Muslim man was hospitalised with a broken jaw after convicted killer McNamara, who is involved in the far-right 'community watchdog' group, wrongly accused him of inappropriately approaching children in a park. The footage, which went viral on social media before it was labelled 'misinformation' by gardaí, was filmed by McNamara and posted to his TikTok account. McNamara has also addressed his criminal past in a video he posted to his TikTok account. In the video, he claimed he had no idea why people are commenting under his posts that he was a murderer and that he didn't want to have to 'lower himself' by explaining to people what actually happened. He said: 'Who never had a drink with someone, got in a row and hit him in the head?' He added: 'He died three days later. I got charged with manslaughter. He's my dad. I love him. I miss him.' He also doubled down on the video he posted about the man in the park, saying there is 'evidence' of 'this Muslim foreign fella' approaching children – but without providing any proof or evidence to back up his claim. Sinne na Daoine publicised their first and second 'patrols' in Limerick city and Clonmel, in Co. Tipperary, on social media earlier in the year. They have also listed the names of companies or people they label 'plantation enablers' on their website. Meanwhile, Martin Murphy previously attempted to downplay his threatening posts when contacted by us. He said the tweets were posted before he declared his intention to run in the local election and described them as 'gallows humour'.
The Irish Sun
a day ago
- The Irish Sun
‘Daleks' brought in to beef up security at Donald Trump's Scottish golf courses ahead of his visit
IT looks like Daleks have been brought in to beef up security at Donald Trump's Scottish golf courses ahead of his visit next week. The US President is due at Turnberry and Aberdeen from Friday to Tuesday. 5 US President Donald Trump is due at Turnberry and Aberdeen Credit: Tom Farmer 5 What look like Daleks have appeared to help beef up security at Donald Trump's Scottish golf courses Credit: John Kirkby 5 The security devices resemble Doctor Who's croaky-voiced enemies Credit: Stuart Patterson The 'Daleks' — security devices that resemble Doctor Who's croaky-voiced enemies — have been set up to deter intruders. Once their motion sensors detect intruders, they record video and alert cops. The security boost has been put in place months after activists from Palestine Action Eight people have been charged in relation to the incident on March 8 after A source said: 'Trump could arrive any day so the staff need to be constantly on their toes. "There has to be a state of readiness.' It comes as Trump filed a lawsuit after denying a report in the Wall Street Journal linking him to a lewd message sent for the 50th birthday of paedo financier Jeffrey Epstein. Most read in The Sun Donald Trump swings club in frustration as he misses putt at Turnberry 5 An actual Dalek from hit show Doctor Who Credit: Getty - Contributor 5 Trump is opening a links course in Menie Credit: PA
