After weeks of tension and speculation in mushroom murder trial, attention returns to the three lives taken
At 2.15pm on Monday at Latrobe Valley law courts in Morwell, about a two-hour drive from Melbourne, courtroom four was packed and humming with tension.
Justice Christopher Beale, who had presided over the supreme court trial, instructed everyone to remain silent during the hearing. He didn't need to. You could hear a pin drop.
Before the judge entered, Patterson sat between two security guards. She closed her eyes. Her chest rose and fell with slow, deliberate breaths.
Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email
But when the doors opened and the judge and jury filed in, her eyes snapped open, focused, unmoving.
One by one, the charges were read aloud.
Patterson was found guilty of the attempted murder of Pastor Ian Wilkinson, who fell critically ill after a lunch at Patterson's Leongatha home on 29 July 2023. He was the only survivor.
He had eaten a beef wellington laced with deadly death cap mushrooms. He spent seven weeks in hospital recovering. He told the trial the plates his and the other three lunch guests' meals were served on were a different colour to Patterson's, testimony that the defence disputed.
Patterson was also guilty of the murder of Heather Wilkinson, Ian's wife and her estranged husband Simon's aunt.
Guilty of the murder of Gayle Patterson, Simon's mother.
Guilty of the murder of Donald Patterson, Simon's father.
With each guilty verdict – Patterson looked straight at the jury comprised of seven men and five women. She didn't flinch. Her face was unreadable.
After a week in the witness dock, where she was prone to emotional outbursts, this time, there were no tears.
There were no members of either the Wilkinson or Patterson families in the courtroom to hear the verdict. Just one friend of Erin Patterson's, quietly wiping away tears.
It was 1.38pm, when the supreme court's email hit journalists' inboxes: the jury had reached their verdicts.
It was unexpected – most reporters had stepped out for lunch at the same time the jury had done every day during the trial. They raced out of cafes across the city, leaving their meals uneaten and frantically calling their editors.
The trial was the subject of feverish media attention which only escalated once the jury retired.
Outside the automatic doors of the Latrobe Valley law courts, a circus formed – shade tents, fold-out chairs, gorilla carts filled with cables and tripods.
All told, there were close to 100 reporters, photographers, camera operators, podcasters, documentary crews and screenwriters on hand.
Only a small number of them were able to make it into court four, the room where the verdict was handed down.
Members of the public keen to be in the room got to court early, went upstairs, and left their bags and jackets in an orderly line outside the door to the court room.
Morwell coursed with an odd mix of suspense and boredom in the days since 30 June, when the jury retired to deliberate.
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
Lawyers for the defence and prosecution were seen around town, unrobed and unburdened, waiting like everyone else.
One of the two cafes within a block of the court had a record day for takings and covers on 1 July, the day after Beale finished his charge to the jury.
Towards the end of those 365-pages of directions, he stressed to the 12-member jury the importance of them reaching a unanimous verdict, though stressed they could get to that verdict however they wished.
They were sequestered, transported to court every morning, Monday to Saturday, and deliberated in the jury room, before being taken back to a hotel in the late afternoon.
As Beale half jokingly quipped, they were 'locked up.' And when they finally emerged, Patterson was guilty.
There was no outrage. No tears. No court room drama.
Just silence.
And the weight of three lives taken.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
News live: Australia reportedly in talks over Ukraine defence pact; childcare provider to install CCTV
Update: Date: 2025-07-08T20:36:47.000Z Title: G8 Education to install CCTV in its childcare centres Content: Australia's largest childcare provider, G8 Education, will install CCTV in all of its centres and allow parents to provide preferences on who conducts nappy changes and toileting after child abuse charges were laid against a former employee, Joshua Dale Brown. Dale, 26, was charged with more than 70 offences relating to eight alleged victims aged between five months and two years old. In an announcement to investors on Tuesday evening, managing director and chief executive of G8 Education Limited, Pejman Okhovat, said the team was 'horrified and appalled' by the allegations. 'These allegations are deeply disturbing, and our hearts go out to all the children and families involved. I am deeply sorry for the unimaginable pain caused to our families and what they are going through.' Okhovat said following the trial of CCTV in several centres, it would be rolled out to all operators in light of the allegations. In addition to greater parents' choice over their children's care, G8 would also commission an independent review into the incident following the police investigation and criminal proceedings. Update: Date: 2025-07-08T20:36:47.000Z Title: RecipeTin Eats cook upset her beef wellington recipe 'entangled in a tragic situation' Content: Nagi Maehashi, the Australian cook behind RecipeTin Eats, says it is 'upsetting' to have become 'entangled in a tragic situation' after it was revealed her beef wellington recipe was used by Erin Patterson to lace a meal with death cap mushrooms. During the trial, Patterson said she made multiple changes to the RecipeTin Eats recipe she was using to prepare the fatal beef wellington two years ago. It was a dish she had never made, but she wanted to try something special for her guests, she said. The recipe is described on Maehashi's website as 'incredibly juicy, edge-to-edge rose pink beef encased in pastry boasting a flawlessly crispy base'. It is only available in her debut cookbook, Dinner. In a post to Instagram on Tuesday, Maehashi requested journalists 'please stop calling and emailing and texting and DM'ing me about the Erin Patterson case'. It is of course upsetting to learn that one of my recipes – possibly the one I've spent more hours perfecting than any other – something I created to bring joy and happiness, is entangled in a tragic situation ... Thank you for respecting my privacy. On Monday, Patterson was found guilty of murdering three relatives and attempting to murder a fourth. Update: Date: 2025-07-08T20:36:47.000Z Title: Welcome Content: Good morning and welcome to our live news blog. I'm Martin Farrer with some of the top overnight stories and then it'll be Rafqa Touma to guide you through the day. Australia is in negotiations with Ukraine about a security pact that could see the two countries firm up cooperation on intelligence sharing, according to briefing documents prepared for the foreign affairs minister, Penny Wong. More coming up. One of the childcare operators at the centre of the abuse allegations in Victoria has told shareholders it plans to install CCTV in all of its sites and allow parents to provide preferences on who conducts nappy changes and toileting. More details shortly. The health regulator has recommended sunscreen manufacturers add safeguards to products containing two ingredients amid concern about their efficacy. We have more coming up.
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
Mother ‘murdered by former fiancé she took pity on'
'At times she thought it was easier to give in to his pestering than to challenge it,' Ms Oakley said, adding that Ms Mickleburgh told friends and family that she was going to follow through with a promise to spend his 60th birthday at the hotel in Bagshot in April. 'She didn't wish him any ill, but she no longer wanted to live with him and no longer wanted to be in a relationship with him,' Ms Oakley said. 'But part of her also felt bad for him, believing that he had no one else to spend that day with.' Mr Cartwright is said to have spent the morning of his birthday with his other girlfriend in Devon before Ms Mickleburgh picked him up from the station. The pair arrived at the hotel at about 5.30pm and had arranged to have dinner in the hotel restaurant. They are said to have had champagne and cake on the terrace before returning to the room. CCTV shows Samantha changed clothes, but the prosecutor alleged that Mr Cartwright had spent nearly the entire time in the room communicating with other women, including his other girlfriend. During the meal Ms Mickleburgh reportedly started to feel unwell with staff said to have noticed her 'falling asleep at the table'. The pair left, with staff describing Mr Cartwright as 'holding the lady up' as they returned to their bedroom. The prosecution believes Ms Mickleburgh was likely dead by about 1.30am, as at 1.22am Mr Cartwright started deleting images of her from his phone. Mr Cartwright, 61, is standing trial at Guildford Crown Court accused of raping and murdering Ms Mickleburgh between April 12 and 14 last year. He also denies one count of controlling and coercive behaviour between May 1 2022 and April 14 2024. Mr Cartwright called the emergency services to hotel on the morning of April 14 last year after he 'apparently discovered the cold, lifeless body of his partner, lying on her back next to him'. The prosecutor said a post mortem examination had revealed bruising to Ms Mickleburgh's forehead, scalp, right jaw, left neck and the bursting of blood vessels under the skin. A 'blunt impact' to the forehead is said to have been so severe that it fractured her skull. Tests revealed the presence of Mr Cartwright's semen inside her body, the prosecutor said. 'You will have to consider with great care whether…. she voluntarily engaged in intercourse with him,' the prosecutor said. Cartwright denies the rape and murder of Ms Mickleburgh and controlling and coercive behaviour. The trial continues.
The Guardian
2 hours ago
- The Guardian
‘Nowhere for them to hide any more': Zelda Perkins' fight against NDAs after Harvey Weinstein
Zelda Perkins was 24 when – exhausted, broken and surrounded by lawyers – she finally agreed to sign the non-disclosure agreement (NDA) that would legally gag her from talking about Harvey Weinstein's sexually predatory and abusive behaviour. The suffocating power of that document haunted her for decades, casting a long shadow over her life and making her ill. 'If I go back to that room, I did not ever imagine that it would be possible to reach any form of justice,' she says. Now, eight years since she first broke her NDA and inadvertently became the world's leading campaigner against them, Perkins feels justice may finally be within her grasp. On Monday, in a move that surprised even the most committed campaigners, the UK government announced sweeping measures that will prohibit bosses from using NDAs to silence abused employees. The following day, Perkins is still digesting the news, but her delight is palpable. 'This is huge,' she says. 'It's the beginning of abusers having to change their behaviour – not because somebody's wagging a finger at them, not because they are told to, but because they have to. There's nowhere for them to hide any more, they just have to effing behave themselves.' The government's stance has, she happily admits, gone beyond her expectations. If unchanged, the new measures will protect gig-economy workers as well as staff, requests for NDAs will be able to come only from complainants, not employers, and workers will be given access to legal advice. Crucially, 'non-disparagement clauses' (widely used since non-disclosure became a 'dirty word', says Perkins) will be off the table in cases of abuse. 'It's really, really ambitious; if they actually do what they say they're going to do, it is totally world-leading,' says Perkins, who set up the Can't Buy My Silence campaign in the UK to lead the fight against abusive NDAs in 2021. The campaign argued that while NDAs may be necessary for intellectual property or commercially sensitive information, they have become a routinely used weapon to silence victims of bullying, sexual harassment or abuse, especially in lower-income sectors like retail and hospitality. 'I'm super excited in a way I haven't felt before, because I feel like I can almost smell freedom,' she says. 'But the reality is this is the first step in quite a long parliamentary process. Tomorrow it is absolutely back to the grindstone, because this isn't done yet.' With inclusion and diversity under attack by Donald Trump's administration, the move is also globally significant, Perkins argues. Legislation has changed in more than 27 US states, a Canadian province and the Republic of Ireland – but companies are feeling nervous. Recently, two global corporations who signed up to Can't Buy My Silence's pledge not to use NDAs in cases of abuse, did not want to publicise the fact, for fear of it is being reversed. 'With DEI being rolled back, Britain leading the way here is pretty bloody huge,' she says. 'There's part of me that is scared of highlighting that because I don't want to scare the horses. But essentially, this is actually now much more important than it ever has been.' It is also a moment of huge personal significance. Perkins never wanted to be a campaigner – she just felt, finally, as if she had no other choice. 'I'm the most accidental activist that ever walked the earth,' she says. 'I've literally spent my whole time trying not to do it. 'At 24 when I went to the lawyers, I thought: if I tell the grownups, then they'll sort it out.' She felt the same when she spoke to the New York Times' Jodi Kantor about Weinstein eight years ago, breaking her NDA and sparking a chain reaction that would eventually lead to his incarceration. 'But what I didn't realise in 2017, when I was 45, was that I was a grownup,' she says. 'Because I'd been silent for 23 years, I thought nobody could hear me or see me, and I was stupid. I did not believe that I had any right or power to make any change.' When the change she wanted – even expected – to see didn't happen, she kept going. She enlisted a 'ferocious team of female allies' across the campaigning and political sphere – including, but not limited to, the former Conservative minister Maria Miller, Labour's Jess Phillips and Louise Haigh, and the Liberal Democrats' Layla Moran in the House of Commons, Helena Morrissey and Helena Kennedy in the Lords, the former TUC boss Frances O'Grady in the unions and Joeli Brearley, founder of Pregnant Then Screwed, on the campaign front. She kept going. 'It's funny because everyone goes: 'Oh you're so brave for breaking your NDA' – none of that was brave,' she says. 'I tell you what's brave: every single campaigner getting up every morning when you're on your own and continuing to fight the system with no remuneration, no encouragement, and nobody really there to hold your hand. That's brave.' But there is a reason she, and others, fight on. 'Being able to make change is the biggest, most fulfilling thing any of us can do. We're all looking to be part of a bigger thing,' she says. 'I'm very lucky to have been able to turn something so negative into a positive, because 90% of women who've been in these situations don't get to do that and that's really why this win is much more for them than me.' Still, the fight – and the exposure – took its toll. At the start of the year a series of false dawns had left her disheartened and demoralised. The support of Haigh and a group of high-profile baronesses in the Lords changed the dynamic, but when she got a call from government aides about the amendments on Friday, before a meeting with the business minister Justin Madders on Monday, she expected the worst. 'I was like: 'Oh God, here we go. They want to break it to me softly to make sure that I don't cry in the meeting.'' The news, they assured her, was definitely positive. On Monday she travelled to Westminster and found herself back in a room of power, but this time she was part of it. 'Without sounding woo woo, that has been the healing part,' she says. 'As corny as it sounds, this has made me acknowledge the privilege of living in a democracy. It's tough, and yes, the buttons are sticky and the levers are rusty, but they do actually work.' So what is next for the woman – part of a vanishingly rare breed – who took on power across multiple fronts and actually won? She will, she promises, continue to buzz around the government like a committed gnat, determined to see this through. Then, maybe, a rest. 'Since the story broke in 2017 it's been a maelstrom,' she says. 'Like I was attached to a surfboard but sort of under the water most of the time. I'm now on the surfboard, but really knackered – and I'd just like to get off and go and lie on the beach.'
