Butler by Salena Zito review – how Trump won America's heartland
Last November, Trump came within just three points of winning a majority of Latino voters. Such Americans walked away from their presumed political home – in droves. A Trump endorsement by Roberto Clemente Jr, son of the late Pittsburgh Pirates baseball star, was a harbinger. Likewise, Trump posted double-digit gains among Catholics and Jews, once core constituencies in the Democratic party of FDR.
To quote Bob Dylan, 'The times, they are a changin'.' Into the fray jumps Salena Zito with her latest book, Butler, and its dramatic subtitle, The Untold Story of the Near Assassination of Donald Trump and the Fight for America's Heartland.
Zito is definitely a Trump fan, living in western Pennsylvania, a place that's become part of Trumplandia. No wonder: her analysis is sharp-eyed and her anecdotes revealing – she walks among Them. Beyond that, she possesses roots and an affinity for her 'Yinzers'.
These days, she writes for the Washington Examiner and is a contributor to the Washington Post. Last time out, with The Great Revolt, co-authored with Brad Todd in 2018, she painted a portrait of Trump's base that was not standard GOP-issue and a Democratic party overly reliant on coastal elites. That take remains valid. Other than in faculty meetings, you can't win elections solely with the votes of JDs, MDs and PhDs. More voters lack four year-degrees than those who have them.
Butler, turns to Butler, Pennsylvania, the site of the failed July 2024 assassination attempt on Trump, as a serendipitously fitting backdrop and fulcrum of the events that preceded and followed. She had access to the Trump, JD Vance and the senior staff of the campaign.
Trump delivers bouquets of compliments. Zito is flattered, even enthusiastic. She enjoys the rapport, admires her subject. Trump is not a lab specimen or patient. She is not his psychologist. Rather, he talks to her, expresses concern about her grandchildren, and offers a lesson in politics 101: empathy goes far.
On the page, Trump takes Joe Biden and Kamala Harris to task for waiting a year before appearing at the village of East Palestine, Ohio, the site of a major railcar disaster, 42 miles from Butler.
'They never showed up to see them,' Trump tells Zito. 'Never. It's a shame. I did, I came, I told them I would not forget them and I won't.'
Ohio, Vance's state, went Republican by better than 10 points. All of Ohio's top elected officials are now Republicans. In polarized times, ticket-splitting grows rare.
Elon Musk talked to Zito too. There's nothing like the zeal of a 12-figure convert, the world's richest person. Given the current fallout between Musk and Trump, it is memorable stuff, a bromance before it went off the rails.
Butler unintentionally delivers a packet of receipts.
'I asked Musk if I could interview him, and he said: sure,' Zito recalls.
''Who are the ones that are trying to silence free speech? That's the Democrats,'' Musk advises.
'They're the ones trying to silence free speech,' he continues. 'You know who the bad guys are – the ones who want to stop you from speaking. Those are the bad guys. It's a no-brainer.'
To put it mildly, irony abounds. Never mind what Musk did to X, formerly Twitter, in terms of promoting one sort of view and quashing another. Since their relationship turned to dust, Trump has threatened to deport Musk and cancel his government contracts.
In hindsight, that the Trump-Musk relationship would last long would have been a bad bet.
Sign up to What's On
Get the best TV reviews, news and features in your inbox every Monday
after newsletter promotion
Musk vows to support primary challenges against Republicans who stuck with the president on his sweeping bill of cuts to taxes and spending. But whatever you think of the legislation or Musk, Trump holds a decisive advantage.
Beyond the obvious, regarding simple power, Trump is a far better showman. Startling to say it, he is way less weird. Musk is the nerd who always wanted to hang with the cool kids.
Zito devotes attention to the dichotomy between the 'placed' and the 'placeless' – 'people who are rooted in their places versus people who are essentially nomads' – and its relationship to politics and Trump. The placed are with him; the placeless, not so much.
Such demographic faultlines are global. They played an outsized role in the fight over Brexit. Populism is not restricted to the US.
In 2017, David Goodhart wrote Road to Somewhere, which examined the forces that drove Brexit. He placed a premium on describing how a sense of belonging has come to shape politics, in an uncertain world.
His typology divided society between 'anywheres' and 'somewheres', with the archetypal anywhere possessing a degree or two from Oxbridge or the Ivy League, a portable skill set, and a spouse who shares similar credentials. By contrast, somewheres lack those markers, and find the world a less welcoming place.
GDP figures and personal income statistics alone do not convey the entire story. In 2016, 'fuck your feelings' was a Trumpian battle cry – though those shouting it did not take kindly to being called deplorable by Hillary Clinton or, eight years later, being called 'garbage' by Biden.
As expected, Zito calls out Clinton and Biden for their missteps. Trump or his base, not so much. Yeah, there's asymmetry. But if you're a Democrat, punching down is seldom a winning strategy.
Butler is published in the US by Hachette
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
JAMnews
20 minutes ago
- JAMnews
U.S. ambassador: 'Georgian Dream sent a ‘threatening' letter to the Trump administration'
U.S. Ambassador Robin Dunnigan on Ivanishvili U.S. Ambassador to Georgia Robin Dunnigan told the Georgian service of Radio Liberty that the ruling Georgian Dream party handed her a letter intended for the administration of Donald Trump, which she described as 'threatening, insulting, frivolous,' and said 'it was received extremely negatively in Washington.' Dunnigan also shared other details about the relationship between Georgia's current leadership and the Trump administration, including when and why she sought a meeting with Bidzina Ivanishvili – the founder of Georgian Dream and the de facto ruler of Georgia – and how he refused to meet with her. On June 5, U.S. Ambassador to Georgia Robin Dunnigan announced that she is stepping down and leaving her post. In a statement published by the embassy, Dunnigan wrote that this was her personal decision and that the government did not request her recall. U.S. Ambassador to Georgia Robin Dunnigan Robin Dunnigan: 'After Donald Trump's election, I traveled to Washington to meet with senior officials in the new administration, to discuss our policy toward Georgia and to receive guidance on what the first message from the new administration to the Georgian government should be. Upon returning from those meetings, I met with Georgia's foreign minister and very clearly explained the steps Georgian Dream could take to bring U.S.-Georgia relations back on track. Three days later – and I don't usually comment on such things, but the prime minister himself mentioned it – Georgian Dream leadership handed me a letter for the Trump administration. A personal, non-public letter which, frankly, was full of threats, insults, and reckless statements. It was extremely poorly received in Washington. Extremely poorly. That's why it took us time to prepare a response. The administration was very surprised to see such a message from the leader of one country to the leader of another. While we were working on our reply, Prime Minister Irakli Kobakhidze published an open letter to the Trump administration. On May 13, Georgian Dream Prime Minister Irakli Kobakhidze addressed U.S. President Donald Trump and Vice President J.D. Vance in an open letter, expressing surprise that there had been no top-level communication between the governments of Georgia and the U.S. so far. The letter also stated that it was 'unclear' why U.S. sanctions remain in place against Georgian government officials who, according to the letter, 'effectively suppressed a USAID-funded and planned attempt at revolution' and stood up to 'violence from the Biden administration.' According to Kobakhidze, recent political events in Georgia had created a sense among the public that Trump's statements about defeating the 'deep state' were nothing more than a rebranding effort. After that, I went to Kobakhidze and said: 'I have a response from Secretary Rubio. He asked me to deliver it personally to Bidzina Ivanishvili.' And Ivanishvili refused to meet with me.' 'I was told I had to deliver the letter from the Trump administration directly to Bidzina Ivanishvili, and he said, 'No.' They didn't ask me to give it to the prime minister. I think everyone in the world understands that it's actually Bidzina Ivanishvili who runs the government. The most absurd part is that the steps needed to restore U.S.-Georgia relations to a normal path are very simple. One of the first steps would be to stop the anti-American rhetoric – just stop making statements about the U.S. that are so far from the truth. Specifically: ● The claim that we tried to open a second front in Georgia — false. ● That my predecessor supposedly tried to organize a revolution here — false. ● That our strategic partnership exists only on paper — false. ● That my government recalled me — also false. And the list goes on,' said Robin Dunnigan. News in Georgia
Scottish Sun
40 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
Scot has becoming a mega hit with MAGA in US thanks to his ‘likeable' Trump impression
'You need to keep it light. When it gets too critical or dark then it starts to cross the line. That's something we always want to avoid. DEAD RINGER Scot has becoming a mega hit with MAGA in US thanks to his 'likeable' Trump impression MIMIC Lewis Macleod has revealed how he's become a hit with Americans thanks to making Donald Trump more 'likeable' again. The Scots copycat, who is part of Radio 4's popular long-running show Dead Ringers, saw two recent clips of him impersonating the US President receive over 22million views. 5 Lewis as Trump and his "secret service". 5 Lewis as he looks normally minus the orange tan. 5 Dead Ringers with Jan Ravens, Jon Culshaw and Lewis has been going for quarter of a century. 5 Lewis recording another episode of Dead Ringers for Radio 4. But while Hollywood stars Jamie Foxx and Alec Baldwin have become known for their brutal Trump mickey takes, US comedy legend Chevy Chase and even Make America Great Again supporters have praised Lewis's version. He says: 'Jamie does an excellent Trump as does Alec but they usually do him when he's bellowing statements out just before he steps on Air Force One. 'But I like to do him when he's talking normally, in that softer, more husky voice. That's the one people seem to really like. It's also where I believe you can get more laughs. 'I even got one message from a supporter in America saying I had made Trump more likeable again. Because when he is talking normally on the likes of Joe Rogan's podcast, he's a funny guy. 'I think his own supporters like to see more of that side of him.' In one clip Lewis says as Trump, how he's going to make, 'Elon Musk the first lady and call her Elania', adding: 'Because Melania has been malfunctioning for a while. She keeps saying things like, 'I wish I'd never met you'.' Lewis says: 'You need to keep it light like that. When it gets too critical or dark then it starts to cross the line. That's something we always want to avoid.' In 2018 National Lampoon's star Chevy Chase gave the thumbs-up to the Scots' Trump impression when they met on ITV's Good Morning. But Lewis actually quit playing The Donald after his last presidency ended in disgraceful scenes with the Capitol Hill Attacks on January 6, 2021. He says: 'I stopped doing his voice and cameos right after that tragedy. I thought, 'This isn't funny anymore.' Donald Trump stuns Glasgow punters as he dances with busker to 'Man Who Sold the World' after taking tour of Scottish Sun Christmas Shop 'He had become too divisive at the time. But when he was elected again, Dead Ringers asked me to do him again, so I was up for giving him another go.' Lewis, 55, from Torrance, near Glasgow, started doing impressions at school before landing a regular slot on BBC Scotland's Off The Ball, mimicking the great and the good of Scottish football. While in 1999 he provided the voice of pod-racing alien Sebulba in the Star Wars prequel The Phantom Menace. He also played Paul McCartney in a Beatles skit on the Harry Enfield and Paul Whitehouse BBC sketch show Harry & Paul. And he has had several serious acting roles too including in The Crown, where he played the headmaster of Prince Charles's school Gordonstoun and the 2022 movie The Lost King opposite Oscar-winner Sally Hawkins. While in 2021 he portrayed This is Your Life host Eamonn Andrews in an episode of ITV cop drama Endeavour in 2021. But it's Trump he can't escape, as he continues to be booked to appear as the US leader at corporate dos and charity events. And Lewis, who now splits his time between homes in France with his French wife Marion and the UK, believes his 6ft 3in stature also helps him fit the bill. He explains: 'Trump is officially 6ft 3in although there are rumours he actually lied about his height during his medical, so I may actually be an inch taller. 'Donald's mum Mary MacLeod is from Lewis and so is my family. So there's a good chance we could be related. 'But I'm also born on the Fourth of July – it doesn't get any more American than that.' He adds: 'But the wig is very important. My one's made by Alex Rouse who makes wigs for loads of films from Harry Potter to James Bond and TV shows like Outlander and Game Of Thrones. 'So if you've got a good voice and a good wig - and being the right size - then I reckon you're on to a winner.' The performer also became a regular on Steve Wright in the Afternoon after he was on his Radio 2 show as a guest alongside Dead Ringers co-stars including Jan Ravens, Jon Culshaw and Duncan Wisbey. Lewis would do uncanny impressions of Steve's fellow radio host and Channel Five presenter Jeremy Vine right up until Wright's show was axed in 2022. The DJ passed away last year aged 69. The dad of two says: 'I started doing these songs with Jeremy singing and Steve absolutely loved them. 'Then these 10 second jingles just got longer and longer until we were doing whole songs. 'I would also do reworkings of Jeremy singing Dua Lipa songs, and Steve wrote all the jokes for the verbal skits. 'He always worked at high-speed and would basically direct me in the studio. But he was a genius. That's the best way to describe him.' AI IS BETTER THAN ME BUT NOT AS FUNNY LEWIS knows that AI is a threat to the voiceover industry but believes that people still prefer the human touch. A big part of the impressionists' day job is recording trailers and radio ads and promos, which he has done for three decades. But earlier this year his fellow Scots voiceover artist Gayanne Potter claimed her voice had been cloned for ScotRail's new AI-generated announcement system against her will. Lewis says: 'AI can mimic voices so perfectly now that it's indistinguishable from speech. 'More and more radio ad campaigns are using it, but I think the voices sound soulless and I'm not sure it connects with listeners. 'The difference is when I am in a studio I can make a suggestion, even just a subtle one. 'And directors still want to be able to give you instructions on exactly what they're wanting from your voiceover too.' He adds: 'I mean you can get AI versions of Trump that can do him better than I will ever be able to, but again where is the fun in that? 'People still love coming to see us recording Dead Ringers and like everything about it, including when we can't stop laughing or muck up the script. 'No one wants a robot perfectly delivering lines. They want to feel part of it and have a laugh and some fun with you too, especially when you make a mistake.' Lewis was back on Radio 2 last month (June) as a guest on Zoe Ball's new Saturday show, where he pretended to be Vine again, this time talking about the Glastonbury festival. He says: 'Zoe asked what Jeremy would talk about at the festival and I said it would have to be all about health and safety and how to find your tent. It was great. She had me on for ages.' And far from feeling ridiculed Jeremy, 60, has previously praised Lewis, saying his 'impersonation of me was so good it fooled even my own children'. But Lewis believes that even the notorious touchy Trump would find his mimicry funny. He says: 'People are always trying to do satirical sketches with Trump but how can you keep up with a man who tells the world that Israel and Iran 'don't know what the f**k they're doing?' 'Trump will continue to say things that will make everybody go, 'what the hell?'. So he owns all of that and the sketch writers can't compete.' He adds: 'But I think you can still find the laughs in the softer kind of Trump, which is why I've chosen to do him like that. 'I honestly believe It's the kind of thing that Trump would laugh at himself.' *Dead Ringers - The 25th Anniversary Tour will play Edinburgh Playhouse on August 17 then dates across the UK from September.
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Donald Trump calls Elon Musk's new political party ‘ridiculous' and says Tesla owner is ‘off the rails'
Update: Date: 2025-07-07T08:50:10.000Z Title: Trump calls Musk's new political party 'ridiculous' and says Tesla owner is 'off the rails' Content: Welcome to our live coverage of US politics and the second Trump administration. Donald Trump has hit out at Elon Musk's decision to start and bankroll a new US political party that the tech billionaire believes can offer a viable alternative to the Democrats and Republicans. Speaking to reporters before boarding Air Force One yesterday, the US president said: I think it's ridiculous to start a third party. It's always been a two-party system and I think starting a third party just adds to the confusion. Shortly after speaking about his former ally, Trump posted further comments on his Truth Social platform, writing: I am saddened to watch Elon Musk go completely 'off the rails,' essentially becoming a TRAIN WRECK over the past five weeks. Trump and Musk were formerly close allies, with the Tesla boss and X owner appointed to slash federal spending through the unofficial Department of Government Efficiency (Doge) from January through May. Musk fell out with the Republican president over his sprawling tax and spending plan, signed into law on Friday, which is expected to add at least $3 trillion (£2.2 trillion) to the US's already huge $37tn (£27tn) debt pile. Musk has argued that the bill, which he has described as 'utterly insane and destructive', would irresponsibly add to the US national debt. Musk, the world's richest person, posted on X over the weekend that he had set up the America Party to challenge the Republican and Democratic 'Uniparty'. The details of the structure of the new venture or a timeline for its creation are still unclear. But some of his social media posts suggests the new political party would focus on two or three Senate seats, and eight to 10 House districts. We will have more on this and other US politics stories throughout the day so stick with us.
