logo
Bhorta is not bharta: A guide to Bengal's boldest mash; and a recipe

Bhorta is not bharta: A guide to Bengal's boldest mash; and a recipe

Indian Express13-06-2025
Many moons ago, I remember watching a Nigella Lawson show where she said she would make a fish finger bhorta. My ears perked up, because bhorta – not to be mistaken with bharta – is a uniquely East Bengal preparation. It's a simple, dry mash of vegetables (sometimes just their peels), occasionally with fish or shrimp, mixed with mustard oil, raw onions, fresh coriander, and dried red chillies roasted in mustard oil. Think of the texture as that of mashed potatoes, and it is eaten with rice.
Lawson's version (I understand fish fingers were added for their ubiquity in England) was surprisingly close to the real thing. She learnt it from a journalist's X feed and her version, too, had onions cooked till translucent, mashed with garlic, ginger and chillies, some mustard oil and crispy fried fish fingers mashed into the pan with some coriander, spinach and lime.
Bhorta is popular in Bangladesh. While bharta, especially baingan ka bharta – made of cooked and mashed brinjals – is popular across Indian cuisines, the Bengali Muslim or Baangal bhorta repertoire is more expansive. The base remains the same: mashed vegetables, fish or prawns paired with mustard oil, garlic, onions and dried red chillies. But never ginger.
The most common bhortas include brinjal, potato (Bengal's favourite vegetable), vegetable peels, prawns, hilsa, and other fresh or dried fish. It's quick, tasty, needs minimal prep, and very few utensils. It's also a vegetarian's dream, just switch out the fish for a range of vegetables or peels.
At home, we never really made bhorta. Alu maakha – a version of bhorta made with mashed potatoes with mustard oil and green chillies – yes, but nothing else. Panta bhaat, a dish of rice soaked overnight in water and eaten with fried vegetables, was also rare, made occasionally for a Punjabi school friend of mine. My grandfather, from West Bengal, considered these peasant foods – meals for those without easy access to meat or high-quality fish. I used to think this was snobbery. But bhorta is, at its heart, simple peasant food from rural Bengal.
Bhorta finds mention in the folklore of undivided Bengal as early as the 8th century, with references to jute-leaf mash. In the 17th century, Portuguese missionary Friar Sebastian Manrique recorded that the common people in Bengal ate panta bhaat, salt, shak (spinach), and mashed vegetables. The elite, meanwhile, indulged in ghee, butter, milk, chhana, and lots of mishti.
As I've grown older and started cooking and experimenting, I find bhorta preparations incredibly delicious and easy to prepare. The ingredients, like I mentioned earlier, are basic. You can steam, grill, or roast your core ingredient, and then mash it all together with your hand or a fork. While bhorta is believed to have originated with Bengali Muslims, it's now central to Baangal cuisine.
I got so distracted by a recipe I found while researching this piece that I made a masoor dal bhorta for lunch. I also came across another recipe that shows the versatility and inclusiveness of bhorta, ensuring nothing goes to waste in the kitchen – coriander bhorta. This is a mash of fresh coriander leaves, fresh green chillies instead of dried red ones, a few spices, sautéed in mustard oil and mashed together.
Where I differ from most recipes is that I rarely use raw onions. Instead, I roast sliced onions with dried red chillies until slightly brown. This sweetens the onions, takes away the pungency, and acts as a good foil to the spice of the red chillies. You can make bhorta with pumpkin, potato peel, lauki peel, bhindi or okra, roasted tomatoes, banana blossoms, and spinach. Bhorta is even made with kathal or jackfruit seeds – these are dried, boiled and then mashed. Baangals would make them with shutki (dried or fermented fish). They can even be made with a spice as the main ingredient. I've had one with nigella seeds or kalo jeera, another with mustard seeds, and another with poppyseeds or posto. You'd add these to a larger meal as the flavour can be quite strong.
Village-made bhortas are another level altogether. The ingredients are fresher, and they're mashed by hand using a sheel nora – a stone slab and roller that grinds ingredients slowly, releasing oils and flavour in a way no food processor can match.
Today, bhorta has all but become Bangladesh's national dish. An entire meal of different bhortas is not uncommon, and not at all boring.
Here's my version of masoor dal bhorta. Try it. Taste the food of my people, or at least, some of them.
Masoor Daal – 1 cup
Onions – ½ an onion, sliced fine
Garlic – 2 cloves, sliced fine
Turmeric powder – ½ tsp
Salt – 1 tsp (to taste)
Coriander Leaves – 2 tablespoons, chopped
Mustard Oil – 2-3 tbsp
Dry Red Chilli – 2 to 4
Author of The Sweet Kitchen, and chef-owner of Food For Thought Catering ... Read More
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Say No-Cheese! Eateries Rise To Allergy Challenge
Say No-Cheese! Eateries Rise To Allergy Challenge

Time of India

time43 minutes ago

  • Time of India

Say No-Cheese! Eateries Rise To Allergy Challenge

New Delhi: One busy afternoon at Mesa Lodhi, chef Sandeep Namboodiry faced a diner whose list of restrictions would make most chefs panic. She was vegetarian, lactose intolerant, didn't want anything raw, nothing cold, no rice, and no gluten. "In my head I wondered why she'd even want to eat out at a place like ours, where we serve all kinds of animal protein," Namboodiry recalls. Instead of turning her away, he improvised. "I took an avocado, filled it with mildly spiced marinara sauce and plant-based cheese, and baked it. I wasn't sure what to call it, but I went back and presented it, half expecting her to just politely refuse." To his surprise, she loved it. Not only did she finish it, she ordered it again on her next visit — and soon started bringing other guests who had similar dietary restrictions. "Through her, we found an audience that rarely dined out because they couldn't find places willing to accommodate them," says Namboodiry. You Can Also Check: Delhi AQI | Weather in Delhi | Bank Holidays in Delhi | Public Holidays in Delhi That single moment transformed the restaurant's approach. Mesa Lodhi invested in separate ovens for gluten-free dishes, kept oil vegetarian-only, created sugar-free and plant-based desserts, and trained staff to handle complex dietary needs. This quiet shift is slowly becoming more visible in Delhi, where newer restaurants and chef-driven brands are treating allergies and intolerances not as inconvenient exceptions, but as part of everyday service. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Top 15 Prettiest Icons In The History The Noodle Box Undo "In the Indian restaurant landscape, awareness around food allergies has grown tremendously over the last few years," says chef and consultant Megha Kohli. At her restaurant Mezze Mambo, allergen awareness starts from training and design. "Our menu includes naturally gluten-free, dairy-free and vegan options not by accident, but by design. We also use colour-coded utensils, separate boards and clear labelling to avoid cross-contamination. " At Boya at Malcha Marg, food allergy protocols are woven into daily operations. "Our menu highlights allergens clearly, and staff are trained to proactively ask guests about allergies before an order is placed," says Bhavya Sahu. "We also follow kitchen protocols — separate utensils, clear labelling and regular training — to make sure nothing is left to chance." Transparency is becoming the new standard. "All our menus feature an allergy index and a note encouraging guests to inform the team of allergies not specifically listed," says chef Noah Barnes of Miss Margarita by Arriba. At Ikk Panjab, millet-based rotis are offered as an alternative for those avoiding gluten. "We also pay close attention to our cooking processes and train staff to guide guests through the menu," explains Deepika Sethi. "The goal is a safe and inclusive dining experience." Inclusivity isn't just for premium restaurants. For brands like Wow! Momo, it has become part of their expansion strategy. "We've always seen the momo as more than just a product — it's an emotion rooted in comfort and culture," says Sagar Daryani, co-founder and CEO. "With our new gluten-free range, we are saying indulgence should be for everyone." Yet, making dining safe for everyone isn't easy — or cheap. "Many new outlets are aware, but catering to allergies in totality is challenging," notes a menu consultant. "Separate stations to avoid contamination often mean high investments and larger kitchens, which high city rentals don't allow." Even with strict protocols, says chef Namboodiry, kitchens cannot always promise meals that are 100% allergen-free. "We even source gluten-free products from specialised stores, and use separate ovens and tools, but human error always exists," he says. "It's a risk diners take whenever they eat out." Some older establishments, especially those whose menus rely heavily on dairy and gluten-rich dishes, remain resistant. "They know their butter- and cream-heavy food can never be truly lactose- or gluten-free, so they don't even try," a restaurateur says, requesting anonymity. Yet, across the city, the momentum is building. "In fine dining spaces, especially in restaurants serving seafood, the servers now routinely ask guests if they have allergies," says Sidhant Sharma of Hospitality Xperts. "Healthy concepts like Greenr Café and Whole Foods regularly offer gluten-free and vegan options, proving there is a demand." Behind this evolution is often thoughtful design and detailed training. "We train teams to be extremely careful about lactose and gluten, and make sure there is no cross-contamination," says Sid Mathur of Secret Ingredients, which has consulted for over 300 restaurant projects. "Sensitivity is growing, and chefs today know global standards and substitutes." While dining out is still daunting for anyone with allergies, these new approaches by chefs who learn to cook with better ingredient knowledge mean diners who were once left out can finally find a seat at the table — without fear. At Greenr Cafe, popular dishes such as pizza, pasta, pancakes and smoothie bowls have gluten- and lactose-free options. Made using sundried tomato sauce, oats and millet flour, coconut and almond milk, amaranth muesli, banana cashew creams, these dishes allow diners with food allergies to taste their favourites. According to Nitin Dixit, co-founder of Greenr Cafe, "Due to various lifestyle and environmental factors, we have also observed that food allergies seem to be on the rise amongst our customers. As a cafe serving plant-based foods and striving for transparency, we try to accommodate as many people with food allergies as possible through our menus." However, he regrets that given the risk of micro-allergens entering the dish preparation and the potential for a strong reaction, they now have to refuse service to anyone with severe allergies.

From Chitar Oli to America: Nagpur's Ganpati crossing oceans for 15 years
From Chitar Oli to America: Nagpur's Ganpati crossing oceans for 15 years

Time of India

time2 hours ago

  • Time of India

From Chitar Oli to America: Nagpur's Ganpati crossing oceans for 15 years

Nagpur: In the heritage-rich lanes of Chitar Oli, where idol-making is a sacred family art, 31-year-old Nikhil Juratkar continues a three-generation legacy. As a sculptor deeply rooted in tradition, Juratkar has made a name for himself, crafting eco-friendly Ganpati idols — not only for Nagpur but also for devotees as far as the United States. For over 15 years, his idols have reached Indian families abroad, including that of Dr Shraddha Gawankar, who earlier lived in Vermillion City, South Dakota, and now resides in Baltimore, Maryland. Each year, she places an order for two idols — one for her society pandal and one for her home — crafted in Nagpur and shipped overseas. "For over 15 years, I have been ordering eco-friendly Ganpati idols from Nikhil Dada — a truly gifted artist. Even after moving to the USA, we continue celebrating Ganesh Chaturthi with our Marathi Mandal, and every year, Nikhil dada ensures our beautiful Bappa arrives on time, all the way across the globe," she said. What makes his idols special is not just their intricate design but also the choice of materials. Juratkar uses a blend of five different types of shadu mitti — a type of natural, eco-friendly clay that is more expensive than regular soil. But the cost, he says, is worth it for both tradition and the environment. "It dissolves easily in water, leaving no harmful residue. That's what makes it sacred," he says. Once an idol is complete, the packaging process begins — just as carefully. Grass is first placed inside the base of the box to cushion the idol, which is then carefully wrapped, covered, and placed inside a specially made wooden box. Only then is it ready for export. The entire shipment, including customs and delivery, can cost the customer up to Rs10,000. While Juratkar also ships to cities like Pune and Varanasi, the overseas orders hold deeper emotional value. "For families abroad, it's not just about an idol. It's about bringing home with them," he says. Box Preserve sanctity, avoid fads: Bajrang Dal As newer design trends flood social media, Bajrang Dal has reminded artisans to respect tradition. Niranjan Risaldar, media and publicity head of Bajrang Dal (Vidarbha region), said, "Ganpati Bappa is not just a festival icon — he represents our faith and pride. We only ask that idols be made with devotion and in a traditional, respectful manner. This is not the time for trends or experiments, but for preserving the sanctity of our religion. "

Pangolin caught in trap, mouse deer hit in mishap, rescued and released
Pangolin caught in trap, mouse deer hit in mishap, rescued and released

Time of India

time5 hours ago

  • Time of India

Pangolin caught in trap, mouse deer hit in mishap, rescued and released

Navi Mumbai: In two separate rescue operations, an Indian pangolin and a mouse deer injured in a mishap were rescued in Ratnagiri by the forest department. The pangolin was rescued from a trap in Ratnagiri taluka while the mouse deer in Chiplun taluka by a forester and a forest guard on . The pangolin trapped in a nylon net was found inside a mango garden. Both the wild animals were releasedin their natural habitats. An animal lover, Rohan Borkar, had informed the forest department about the Pangolin trapped in the mango garden of Samir Bhatde. The forester Nahnu Gawade and forest guard Sarvari Kadam joined by animal lover Mahesh Dhotre cut the net to get the pangolin released from the trap. However, the forest team did not find any suspicious motive behind the net trap and also the animal had no injury signs. A Pachad resident, Nitin Narvekar had informed the forest guard about the mishap. Gunthe joined with his forester SS Sawant rushed the mouse deer to the veterinary medical officer- Chiplun, Dr. Shreyash Pise for treatment. The animal was kept in the forest custody for a day for observation and care. Gunthe said, "After the swelling subsided we released the 4 year old mouse deer into its natural habitat. Nothing can be confirmed as of yet on which type of vehicle had hit the animal. It seems to be crossing the road but found lying on it." The forest department has appealed to the citizens to keep them informed on distressed wildlife through the department toll free number 1926 or 9421741335. You Can Also Check: Mumbai AQI | Weather in Mumbai | Bank Holidays in Mumbai | Public Holidays in Mumbai

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store