Case of U.S. Citizen Jonathan Lehrer Jailed in Dominica Shows Signs of State Interference, Say Lawyers at KCT Chambers and Pilgrim & Associates
Initially, the lead investigator, ACP Jeffrey James, went on TV multiple times to assure the citizens of Dominica that the police and his investitive prowess led to the arrest of Jonathan Lehrer with ample evidence to easily close the case. As we now hit 18 months since those televised press conferences, why do we find Jonathan Lehrer still in jail and no trial date yet set? The easy answer is that the entire case has fell apart and the system has highlighted that ACP Jeffrey James has lied to the courts at almost every stage of the investigation to date (as stated by Justice Colin Williams in his official bail ruling, Sec 92-103, opens new tab).
Outline of concerning activity from official court proceedings:
The unfolding case of Jonathan Lehrer has moved far beyond questions of guilt or innocence — it now stands as a damning indictment of Dominica's justice system. From knowingly false statements under oath by lead investigator ACP Jeffrey James to deliberate withholding and misrepresentation of evidence, the record of court proceedings paints a disturbing picture of systemic misconduct. Despite repeated rulings by Justice Williams exposing these deceptions, Lehrer remains imprisoned without trial, raising urgent concerns not only about prosecutorial abuse, but about the very legitimacy of the judicial process in Dominica. As international scrutiny intensifies, the Lehrer case may well become a defining test of whether Dominica is prepared to uphold the rule of law — or continue down a path of institutional corruption and authoritarian control.
Jonathan Lehrer is represented by Pilgrim & Associates.
About KCT Chambers
KCT Chambers is a law chambers located in Bridgetown, Barbados. It was established out of a desire to help individuals and entities capitalize on opportunities, enforce rights, resolve existing challenges and preempt future ones. We believe in practical and legally grounded solutions and are guided by the core principles of accessibility, integrity and diligence. In order to achieve these objectives we apply a progressive, responsive and client-centred approach which is built upon detailed analysis of legal rights and obligations and the provision of clear, timely and consistent advice. For more information, visit kctchambers.com, opens new tab.
About Andrew O. G. Pilgrim Q.C.
Mr. Pilgrim is the founder of Pilgrim & Associates, the largest law chambers in Barbados to have a focus on criminal litigation. With over 25 years in practice, he is renowned throughout Barbados and the English-speaking Caribbean for his passionate and inspired representation of his clients. He has leveraged his wealth of knowledge and exceptional oratorical and analytical skills in a plethora of cases which have led to landmark decisions of the Court of Appeal of Barbados and the Caribbean Court of Justice.
Media Contact
Nicolia Wilesnwiles@prime-techpr.com
###
SOURCE: KCT Chambers
Copyright 2025 EZ Newswire
See release on EZ Newswire
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
7 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Ex-Army major allegedly joked about killing his wife and moving to Thailand before she drowned in a lake
A former Australian Army major accused of murdering his wife during a kayaking trip allegedly joked he would 'kill her and move to Thailand ' if she ever left him. Graeme Davidson, 56, was charged earlier this year over the 2020 death of his wife, Jacqueline Davidson, after returning to Australia from Thailand. The 54-year-old drowned while the pair were kayaking on Lake Samsonvale, near Forgan Cove in Queensland 's Moreton Bay region. Her death was initially ruled an accident but it was later deemed suspicious. Davidson began a relationship with his second wife, Thai woman Pick Pattraporn, after he moved to the Thai beachside town of Hua Hin in April 2021. Appearing in the Brisbane Supreme Court for a bail hearing, Davidson's barrister Craig Eberhardt KC argued the prosecution's case was 'fundamentally weak' and relied almost entirely on a comment made during a conversation in 2017. According to Mr Eberhardt, the remark was made while Davidson and a friend were discussing another man whose wife had left him on the day of his retirement, taken half of his pension, and then moved to Thailand. In response, Davidson allegedly said, 'Oh s*** yeah, I'd kill her and move to Thailand too.' Mr Eberhardt dismissed the comment as nothing more than 'a quip' and insisted it was 'not nearly as sinister as it sounds' with the context. Justice Tom Sullivan noted the prosecution's case did not include 'direct evidence of murder,' and Mr Eberhardt said there was no evidence Jacqueline had been 'violently assaulted' by Davidson. The court heard her body showed only minor bruising, which Davidson's defence argued was consistent with his efforts to rescue her and perform CPR. Mr Eberhardt said the couple had been about 10metres apart on the water when Davidson attempted to 'show off' by standing up on his kayak. 'Jacqueline became distressed about that and used the 'safe word'… designed to let him know that she was concerned about what he was doing,' he told the court. Davidson claimed he then saw his wife fall into the water and dived in to rescue her. But he struggled to locate her in the 'murky' and weed-filled lake. He eventually dragged her to shore where he performed CPR and called for help. Neither were wearing life jackets, with Davidson allegedly telling police the vests had been destroyed by rats while the couple were still living in Bondi, in Sydney's east. Mr Eberhardt said a witness had confirmed hearing this explanation prior to Jacqueline's death. Davidson also faces charges of fraud and attempted fraud after allegedly trying to claim more than $1million from his wife's life insurance. While the defence claims Jacqueline had no intention of leaving the marriage, the court heard she had discussed separation with friends following an affair Davidson had while posted in Papua New Guinea However, she had also expressed a desire to stay and repair the relationship. Davidson remains in custody as the matter continues.
BBC News
7 minutes ago
- BBC News
Seán Rooney: Mother of says 'justice was not done'
The mother of Irish soldier Seán Rooney who was killed on a UN peacekeeping mission in Lebanon has said "justice was not done" following a trial that convicted and sentenced those involved. Pte Seán Rooney was in an armoured UN vehicle which came under fire while travelling to Beirut on 14 December 24-year-old was the first Irish soldier to die while on UN peacekeeping duty in Lebanon in more than 20 years. Three others were injured in the a statement, Mr Rooney's mother Natasha Rooney said the family felt "extreme disappointment and heartbreak at the recent court proceedings in Lebanon". The main defendant in the case is Mohammad Ayyad. It is understood he did not appear in court on Monday.A number of other men were convicted in relation to the the UN peacekeeping force in Lebanon, said Lebanon's permanent military court found six individuals who were charged over Mr Rooney's killing guilty. One person was death sentence was announced at a military tribunal in Beirut, according to Irish broadcaster RTÉ."What happened in Lebanon is unreflective of what we regard as a trial process," Ms Rooney said. "The trial into the murder of my son was heard and determined in less than half a day. Not only was justice not done, it was not seen to be done, with little to no information being disclosed or challenged in open court," she said. "Instead, we are forced to believe the answers provided by a Lebanese justice system which from the outset has failed to hold those responsible to account."Ms Rooney called the process a "sham trial". She also criticised that the proceedings, originally scheduled for September 2025, were brought forward to this week, something she said caused "unforeseen pressures". In a statement on Tuesday, Tánaiste (deputy Irish prime minister) Simon Harris said he raised his "deep frustration at the slow pace of proceedings" before the Lebanese Military Tribunal. Irish government reaction "While noting the sentence handed down to the main defendant, I am disappointed and share the disappointment of Pte Rooney's family at the lighter sentences imposed on a number of those convicted today," Harris added: "I appreciate that this is an incredibly difficult day for the family of Private Rooney. None of us can fathom their unimaginable pain and grief and all my thoughts remain with them at this time."In her statement, Ms Rooney criticised the Irish government for issuing public statements before speaking to the family. Ms Rooney said that "in a country where victims' rights ought to be paramount, it would perhaps be wise for the Tánaiste to speak to me, before seeking to speak for me, in his public statements". Harris visited Beirut last March and met with the Lebanese Ministers of Foreign Affairs of News on Thursday reported that Harris said in a statement he "cannot imagine the pain and suffering experienced by the Rooney family". "I look forward to meeting Mrs Rooney and arrangements are underway to ensure this happens."Above all, I want to support her quest for justice in any way I possibly can."Unifil said it "welcomes the conclusion of the trial process and the Government of Lebanon's commitment to bring the perpetrators to justice"."Once again, we offer our deepest condolences to the family, friends, and colleagues of Private Rooney and the Government of Ireland." Ms Rooney said that she will "dedicate every bone in my body to ensure justice for Seán, and to highlight the uncomfortable truths about the systemic failings by the United Nations, the Irish Defence Forces and the Lebanese justice system". "That is the very least I owe my son Seán. It is the very least I owe Seán comrades."
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
I was horrified when ex attacked gran in hospital loo 11 years after he raped me… it sickens me I could have stopped it
HEARING the guilty verdict, Maggie Rastall and Ffion Pemberton felt an enormous rush of relief. The two women had been complete strangers before they were brought together in harrowing circumstances - and now share an unbreakable bond. 12 Both are victims of depraved rapist Lee Mullen, 38, who carried out sick attacks on Maggie, 62, and Ffion, 32, 11 years apart. Mullen was jailed for 11 years in 2015 for his vile assault on then-girlfriend Ffion, during which he gagged her with parcel tape and repeatedly raped her while she was recovering from a broken leg. He had been released on licence two weeks before he viciously attacked grandmother-of-10 Maggie in a hospital toilet in December last year. Ffion was horrified when she heard Mullen had struck again, and attended his hearing at Mold Crown Court in January, where he was branded a 'monster' for beating Maggie 30 times before sexually assaulting her. It was there that the two women met, and struck up an 'instant bond'. Ffion, a health support worker, told The Sun: 'I felt nothing but admiration for Maggie and how strong she had been reading her statement. 'I told her I was so sorry he'd been allowed out.' The two women - who have both bravely waived their right to anonymity to share their stories - became friends, and are united in their mission to ensure Mullen is never released again. Delivery driver and mum-of-two Maggie had been visiting a friend in Glan Clwyd Hospital, Denbighshire in north east Wales when Mullen followed her into the women's toilets. "You'd think being in a public hospital toilet you'd be really safe,' she recalled. I snared my murdered aunt's rapist as flirty Facebook honey trap when cops gave up & botched sting…then sicko told evil lie "I remember going into the cubicle and when I opened the door I found myself face to face with a 6ft man. 'I will never forget the 'dead' look in his eyes. He blocked the cubicle doorway and there was no escape. 'Instead he lunged at me. I could smell the alcohol on his breath. He told me he wanted sex and my voice was almost a whisper, I was so terrified, but I managed to say 'no'. "He became very angry and punched me full on in the face. Then one punch after another. 'There must have been 30 blows or more and I collapsed to the floor. "I remember the taste of warm blood in my mouth and my front teeth were in pieces, but he didn't stop. "He tugged at my trousers and put his hands inside my pants. I didn't move and just played dead. I thought he was going to kill me." Mullen only stopped when Maggie's husband, Karl, called out to her wondering why she was taking so long, which disturbed him and he ran off. 'Terrible nightmares' 12 12 12 Covered in blood and battered, Maggie was rushed to the hospital's A&E department and given a CT scan to find out the extent of her head injuries. Her face was so bruised and swollen she could barely speak. An hour and a half later detectives visited Maggie, having looked through hospital CCTV and found a bag left behind by her attacker. 'They knew exactly who he was," Maggie said. "I was horrified to learn he was fresh out of prison - he'd only been released for two weeks before he attacked me." Mullen was arrested at his flat the following morning, after police traced him there following CCTV footage showing him climbing over a fence between a nearby Costa Coffee and the A55. Mullen had been at the hospital visiting a relative of his own, who revealed he had been drinking wine and taking cocaine. Maggie lost 15kg in weight after the attack and didn't want her grandchildren to see her because she didn't want to frighten them with the horrific bruising from the beating she'd received from Mullen. "We are such a close family and it was awful not being able to see my family because of what he had done to me," she said. "I've suffered terrible nightmares since the attack and I'm still too traumatised to be in any confined space. I'll never be able to use a public toilet again." 'Extremely dangerous man' 12 On January 10 this year, Mullen, of Church Street, Flint pleaded guilty and on February 21 he was handed a life sentence with a minimum term of seven years for his attack on Maggie. He admitted sexual assault by penetration and inflicting grievous bodily harm. The judge called Mullen an 'extremely dangerous man' and imposed a sexual harm prevention order and a restraining order, both to run indefinitely. Maggie's courage was commended by the judge. She said in a statement: "I'm normally a strong lady but this has broken me… I tremble from head to toe at the sight of a hospital - somewhere I'm supposed to feel safe." The court heard Maggie's son paid for her replacement dentures, costing £1,300, after Mullen shattered them and left her with a "bite misalignment". Her husband also said he has 'never felt guilt like this' after he didn't stop Mullen from leaving the toilets, and has 'lost trust in the world'. Maggie added: 'I want the old (me) back... I don't think she will ever come back. She's gone.' I'm normally a strong lady but this has broken me… I tremble from head to toe at the sight of a hospital - somewhere I'm supposed to feel safe Maggie Rastall Ffion had begged the parole board not to release convicted rapist Mullen because she was certain that he would strike again, but he was deemed low risk and let out in March 2024. He was recalled once but then released again in June 2024. When Ffion heard he had struck again she was furious. "I appealed the decision but I was ignored. I was devastated but there was nothing I could do,' she said. 'I was halfway through my 12-hour shift when I got a call telling me that Lee had attacked another woman. I wasn't surprised at all. "I had warned the parole board what a dangerous man he was. I knew him on a personal level and knew what he was capable of. "I went to court to see Mullen jailed again and it was then I met Maggie and told her I was his first victim. "We had an instant bond.' 'I didn't stand a chance' Ffion first met Mullen in 2013 when she was 20. Then 26, he had served time for a car theft but appeared kind and gentle at first. "We began dating in 2014 and I'd broken my leg,' she recalled. 'Lee was wonderful as I was in lots of pain and on crutches. Soon after he moved in with me. "He'd carry me to the sofa and tuck me in under a blanket. He painted, wallpapered and even fitted a new carpet. I felt so lucky!" But as the months passed, cracks began to appear. Mullen would disappear with his friends, getting drunk and doing cocaine. "One night in June 2015 he came home drunk and threw my crutches out of my reach," Ffion recalled. "He dragged me around by my hair, pulling out my extensions. He was over 6ft and I was a tiny 5ft. I didn't stand a chance, he was too strong. "Next Lee rolled up a sock and stuffed it in my mouth. Then he gagged me with parcel tape and bound my hands. He threw me on the bed and punched me hard. "For the next few hours he violently raped me, all the time taunting me, asking me if I was enjoying it." After the brutal attack Mullen stripped the bed sheets and put them in the washing machine to destroy any forensic evidence. "He warned me that if I reported him to the police he would come for me," Ffion added. Mullen was arrested two days later. He wrote begging letters to Ffion asking her for forgiveness and pleading with her not to go to court. "I somehow mustered up all my strength to give evidence," Ffion said. Standing united 12 In October 2014 Mullen pleaded not guilty to the charges against him but was convicted of actual bodily harm, sexual assault, rape and perverting the cure of justice. He was jailed for 11 years. Now he is back behind bars and Maggie and Ffion are standing united, determined to ensure he is never released again. "In the future we will attend parole board meetings together. We will share our devastating stories to protect other women. Together we won't let him hurt anyone else," Ffion said. Maggie added: "Ffion is half my age but she has such fierce determination. We understand exactly how the other feels. 'Finding her has helped me so much. "My husband Karl and my family have been incredible and so supportive. I think now, slowly, I'm feeling more like me again." Even though Mullen is safely behind bars he may be eligible for release in 2032. "My greatest wish is that he can never, ever do this to anyone again. I said in my statement 'I will rise like the phoenix from the ashes' and I meant it," Maggie said. "Together we will do all we can to make sure that monster stays behind bars forever." Help after rape and sexual assault If you've been sexually assaulted it's important to remember that it was not your fault. Sexual violence is a crime, no matter who commits it or where it happens. Don't be afraid to get help. There are services that can help if you've been sexually assaulted, raped or abused. You don't have to report the assault to the police if you don't want to. You may need time to think about what has happened to you. But you should get medical help for any injuries and because you may be at risk of pregnancy or sexually transmitted infections (STIs). If you want the crime to be investigated, it's best to have a forensic medical examination as soon as possible. Try not to wash or change your clothes immediately after a sexual assault. This may destroy forensic evidence that could be important if you decide to report the assault to the police (although you can still go to the police even if you have washed). Where to get help Sexual assault referral centres (SARCs) offer medical, practical and emotional support to anyone who has been raped, sexually assaulted or abused. SARCs have specially trained doctors, nurses and support workers to care for you. Other places you can get help include: a doctor or practice nurse at your GP surgery a voluntary organisation, such as Rape Crisis, Women's Aid, Victim Support, The Survivors Trust or Male Survivors Partnership the 24-hour freephone National Domestic Abuse Helpline, run by Refuge, on 0808 2000 247 the rape and sexual abuse support line run by Rape Crisis England and Wales – you can call the helpline on 0808 500 2222 or use the online chat (both are free and are open 24 hours a day, every day of the year) a hospital accident and emergency (A&E) department a genitourinary medicine (GUM) or sexual health clinic a contraceptive clinic a young people's service call NHS 111 or get help from 111 online the police, or dial 101 in an emergency, dial 999.
