Musclebound trans swimmer Ana Caldas wins all 5 races at women's swim nationals
Ana Caldas
, a 47-year-old
transgender swimmer
, won all five races she entered at the us. Masters Swimming Spring National Championship last weekend in San Antonio, Texas. Competing in the women's 45-49 age group, Caldas took gold in the 50- and 100-yard breaststroke, the 100-yard freestyle, and the 100-yard individual medley. She won some events by margins rarely seen at this level, such as over four seconds in the breaststroke and three seconds in the freestyle.
Footage circulating online showed her leading far ahead of other swimmers, drawing both applause and outrage. Critics quickly drew parallels to Lia Thomas, the first openly transgender athlete to win an NCAA Division I swimming title in 2022, sparking renewed debate over fairness and inclusion in women's sports.
— hecheateddotorg (@hecheateddotorg)
A Familiar Debate Reignites
Lia Thomas's collegiate victories once marked a significant moment for trans athletes but also triggered nationwide controversy. Her 2022 NCAA win in the women's 500-yard freestyle led to a federal investigation. The us. Department of Education found that the University of Pennsylvania violated Title IX by allowing her to compete in the women's division, ordering the school to strip her records and honors from that season.
This ruling raised significant questions about how athletic bodies should balance fairness and inclusion, questions now resurfacing with Ana Caldas's dominance. Some supporters view her success as a display of determination and resilience. Others, however, see it as another example of transgender athletes potentially holding physiological advantages over cisgender women, particularly in short-distance events where milliseconds usually separate winners.
Public Backlash and Athlete Reactions
The reaction online has been swift and polarizing. Prominent women's sports advocate Riley Gaines, a former collegiate swimmer, dismissed Caldas's gender identity and tweeted, 'He won them all.' Another critic, Beth Bourne, likened the situation to a 'real-life South Park episode,' a reference that quickly went viral on social media as viewers expressed disbelief at the race footage showing Caldas outpacing competitors by multiple body lengths.
Bourne, who is an outspoken advocate for women's rights in sports, also called the results 'insanity,' noting, 'Anyone who competes in swimming at the national level knows this is unheard of in a 50-yard race where wins are often measured in a tenth or a hundredth of a second' at national-level events, not in multiple seconds.
A spokesperson for the
Independent Council on Women's Sports
(ICONS) told Reduxx, 'He's just laughing at these women,' referring to Caldas's performances. ICONS also sent a letter to us. Masters Swimming (USMS), warning that allowing her to compete might violate fair competition principles.
Governing Policies and a Complex Legacy
Under USMS policy, transgender women may compete in women's events if they meet specific
hormone-level criteria
. Caldas was allowed to compete under these rules. But critics argue those standards do not adequately offset physiological advantages carried over from male puberty. Her athletic history adds further fuel to the debate: before transitioning, Caldas, born Hugo Caldas, competed in men's sports and even made three appearances at the CrossFit Games, narrowly missing a spot in the 2012 London Olympics.
This background, combined with her recent dominance, has intensified calls for sporting bodies to revisit their policies. Supporters of transgender inclusion maintain that exclusion based on gender identity is discriminatory. However, critics insist that fairness for female athletes must remain a top priority.
As Ana Caldas becomes the latest flashpoint in a growing cultural and legal debate, sports organizations are being pushed to clarify how best to respect identity while preserving the integrity of competition.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
2 days ago
- Time of India
Exciting New Legends Arrive First on Mobile: EA Sports Unveils Icons and Heroes for EA FC Mobile
EA Sports has officially teased the introduction of new Heroes and Icons to EA FC Mobile, making it the first platform to receive these legendary cards before they land on the PC and console versions. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now The publisher revealed a total of eight football legends, comprising four Heroes and four Icons, via a recent teaser video. This marks a historic change in the EA FC (formerly FIFA) ecosystem, as for the first time, mobile players will now get exclusive early access to some of the game's most legendary names. EA FC Mobile new Icons and Heroes teased: Bierhoff, Fellaini, and more Traditionally, Icons and Heroes have made their debut on console or PC versions, but this year, EA is flipping the script. With no season reset in EA FC Mobile and regular live updates, players on the mobile platform will get to use these legends months ahead of their console counterparts, who must wait until the launch of EA FC 26 in September, 2025. Here's a closer look at the officially revealed Icons and Heroes: Icons Zlatan Ibrahimovic - Already available through the Icon Chronicles chapter. Toni Kroos - Released via the ongoing Legacies Event. - Released via the ongoing Legacies Event. Dunga - Expected to be released on July 26, 2025 as 'ICON-making Challenge as per EA FC Mobile leaks. Oliver Bierhoff - Teased, with an arrival likely in the coming 'After Daybreak' weeks. Heroes Cesc Fabregas Andrea Barzagli Marouane Fellaini Esteban Cambiasso Mario Mandzukic Among these, Cambiasso and Dunga are already confirmed to have special cards in the Mighty Winter segment of the Ragnarok event. Meanwhile, the remaining new Heroes - Fabregas, Barzagli, Fellaini, and Mandzukic are expected to arrive in the After Daybreak phase, which is the second phase of the Ragnarok campaign. While both categories represent elite footballing legends, Icon cards are designated to those retired players who have achieved the epitome of greatness, boasting remarkable achievements throughout their long, consistent careers. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Hero cards, on the other hand, pay tribute to the ex-players who may not have reached "Icon" status but still left a memorable mark on the game, particularly in specific leagues, clubs, or tournaments. According to leaks from reliable sources in the EA FC Mobile community, like @madridistaafc, and @mazenfcm, more Icons like Andrés Iniesta, Oliver Kahn, and Marcelo are rumored to be added in future events. However, since it is unconfirmed by EA, this must be considered with a grain of salt. EA Sports' decision to bring Icons and Heroes first to EA FC Mobile signals a major shift in how content is prioritized across platforms. Mobile players now enjoy a front-row seat to the legendary experience, ahead of the PC and console community. With more updates likely on the horizon and Ragnarok's second phase just around the corner, EA FC Mobile is definitely on the right track to level-up its game in 2025.
The Hindu
3 days ago
- The Hindu
US Olympic & Paralympic Committee bars transgender women from competing in women's sports
The United States Olympic & Paralympic Committee (USOPC) has updated its policy to align with an executive order signed earlier this year by U.S. President Donald Trump barring transgender women from competing in women's sports. 'The USOPC will continue to collaborate with various stakeholders with oversight responsibilities, e.g., IOC, IPC, NGBs, to ensure that women have a fair and safe competition environment consistent with Executive Order 14201 and the Ted Stevens Olympic & Amateur Sports Act,' the USOPC said in an update to its Athlete Safety Policy. The USOPC did not respond to a request for comment on the change. USOPC President Gene Sykes and CEO Sarah Hirshland referenced Trump's executive order in a memo to the Team USA community sent out this week, ABC News reported, which said, 'As a federally chartered organisation, we have an obligation to comply with federal expectations.' ALSO READ: Janeth Chepngetich books World Athletics Championships spot after winning women's 10,000m at Kenya trials Trump signed the 'Keeping Men Out of Women's Sports' order in February in a bid to exclude transgender girls and women from female sports, a directive that supporters said will restore fairness, but critics argue it infringes on the rights of a tiny minority of athletes. The order directs the Department of Justice to make sure all government agencies enforce a ban on transgender girls and women from participating in female school sports under Trump's interpretation of Title IX, a law against sex discrimination in education. Trump's order goes beyond high school and college sports, calling for the U.S. government to deny visas for transgender females seeking to compete in the United States. Trump also said he would not allow transgender athletes to compete in the Los Angeles Olympics in 2028. The executive order instructed the State Department to pressure the International Olympic Committee (IOC) to change its policy, which allows trans athletes to compete under general guidance, preventing any athlete from gaining an unfair advantage. The order is expected to affect only a small number of athletes. The president of the National Collegiate Athletics Association told a Senate panel in December he was aware of fewer than 10 transgender athletes among the 530,000 competing at 1,100 member schools.
Time of India
5 days ago
- Time of India
Jake Retzlaff transfers to Tulane after BYU exit amid Honor Code controversy over premarital s*x
Jake Retzlaff lands at Tulane after controversial BYU exit (Image via: Getty Images) Former BYU quarterback Jake Retzlaff has committed to Tulane for the upcoming season after leaving BYU earlier this month. His departure followed an Honor Code suspension related to premarital sex and a civil lawsuit that was later withdrawn. Jake Retzlaff gets fresh start at Tulane after BYU suspension Retzlaff started at quarterback for BYU last season, throwing for 2,947 yards, 20 touchdowns, and 12 interceptions while leading the Cougars to an 11-2 record. He was viewed as one of the team's top offensive leaders and even landed an NIL deal with Jewish food brand Manischewitz due to his 'BYJew' nickname. However, his future at BYU came to a halt after a civil lawsuit accused him of sexual assault and battery. Retzlaff denied the claims, saying the encounter was consensual. Both parties later agreed to withdraw the suit. Still, BYU suspended him for violating the school's strict Honor Code, which forbids premarital sex. Former BYU QB Jake Retzlaff commits to transfer to Tulane Tulane welcomes Jake Retzlaff as walk-on amid roster shakeup and Title IX vetting Following the suspension, Retzlaff officially withdrew from BYU and announced his departure via Instagram, thanking fans, teammates, and coaches for their support. Sources told The Athletic that Tulane's Title IX office vetted Retzlaff before allowing him to join the program. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Villas For Sale in Dubai Might Surprise You Villas in Dubai | Search Ads Undo Due to his late move outside the transfer portal, he will enroll as a walk-on. Tulane, coming off a 9-5 season, needed to rebuild its quarterback room after losing starter Darian Mensah to Duke and running back Makhi Hughes to Oregon. Head coach Jon Sumrall, who had recruited Retzlaff during his time at Troy, already has connections with the quarterback. FAQs Why did Jake Retzlaff leave BYU? Jake Retzlaff left BYU after receiving a suspension for violating the school's Honor Code, which forbids premarital sex. His exit also followed a civil lawsuit that was later withdrawn. Is Jake Retzlaff eligible to play immediately at Tulane? Yes, Jake Retzlaff is expected to enroll at Tulane as a walk-on. Although he moved outside the transfer portal window, Tulane's Title IX office vetted him, allowing him to join the team. Who will replace Jake Retzlaff at BYU? With Retzlaff gone, BYU's quarterback competition is likely between Treyson Bourguet, McCae Hillstead, and incoming freshman Bear Bachmeier. Tulane rebuilds QB room with transfers as BYU looks ahead without Retzlaff Retzlaff becomes the fifth transfer quarterback added by Tulane this offseason, joining Brendan Sullivan (Iowa), Kadin Semonza (Ball State), and Donovan Leary (Illinois). TJ Finley (Western Kentucky) was also added but left the team following a spring arrest. Also Read: Dallas Cowboys delay Micah Parsons extension — But why? Inside the growing tension At BYU, the quarterback competition will likely be between Treyson Bourguet, McCae Hillstead, and freshman Bear Bachmeier. Jake Retzlaff's move to Tulane offers a fresh start and a chance to revive his football journey after a dramatic BYU exit. Catch Rani Rampal's inspiring story on Game On, Episode 4. Watch Here!
