Nurse at centre of trans doctor row accused of racism after suspension lifted
Charlotte Myles, a service manager at NHS Fife, said she had reviewed a decision to suspend Sandie Peggie over the row with Dr Beth Upton, who was born male but identifies as female.
Ms Myles told a tribunal in Dundee that senior figures at Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy 'expressed unhappiness' at her decision to allow Ms Peggie to return to work.
She said they claimed that the nurse was homophobic, had been 'racist towards a doctor' and that she supported Donald Trump's views on gender.
She said Dr Kate Searle, who was Dr Upton's line manager, alleged there were 'patient safety issues' with allowing Ms Peggie to resume her nursing job.
It was claimed that Ms Peggie had walked away from patients when Dr Upton arrived to treat them, including one who required resuscitation.
But none of the allegations were reported at the time they were said to have occurred or were supported by documentation, she said.
Ms Myles said they instead came from 'second, third-hand information' and the doctor who was the alleged subject of the racist comment did not recall it having been made.
She said Ms Peggie 'wasn't happy' with the homophobia claims as 'I believe she has a daughter who is gay'. Nicole Peggie tweeted on Monday that her mother was 'my best friend'.
Ms Myles said that the lack of evidence meant she did not consider the allegations when reaching her decision to end the nurse's suspension.
She said claims that the nurse shared Mr Trump's views on gender were 'tittle tattle' and Ms Peggie was entitled to her private opinions if they did not harm patients.
The Scottish Tories said: 'The scale of the witch hunt conducted against Sandie Peggie by her employers becomes ever more apparent and indefensible.'
The row centres on an encounter between Ms Peggie and Dr Upton on Dec 24, 2023. The nurse experienced a sudden and heavy period and feared that it had bled through to her scrubs.
Ms Peggie entered the female hospital changing room to find Dr Upton and challenged their presence. Within hours, a bullying complaint was lodged by Dr Upton and the nurse was suspended.
In May 2024 Ms Peggie submitted a formal claim to an employment tribunal against NHS Fife and Dr Upton for sexual harassment, belief discrimination and victimisation.
The nurse complained of being required to share a single-sex space with someone she believed to be male and being victimised for holding a gender-critical belief that biological sex is immutable.
It emerged last week that Ms Peggie had been cleared of gross misconduct by an NHS Fife disciplinary hearing. However, the tribunal is scheduled to continue for another seven days, with Dr Searle giving evidence on Tuesday.
After being asked to review the nurse's suspension on Feb 27 2024, Ms Myles said she concluded there was no risk to patients in Ms Peggie returning to work.
But she said senior staff at the hospital 'weren't particularly happy with my decision' when she informed them.
She name-checked Dr Searle and Dr Margaret Currer, who are both consultants in emergency medicine, and Esther Davidson and Louise Curran, two nurses who are Ms Peggie's line managers.
After Dr Searle made the patient safety and racism allegations, Ms Myles said she challenged her whether they had been 'escalated and reported appropriately when these events happened'.
Dr Searle said they had not and Ms Myles warned her that 'if these events had happened and there's been a failure to report' them, the doctor would be 'culpable' for any future incidents.
Supporter of Donald Trump
Ms Myles said Ms Davidson and Ms Curran had made similar allegations and she again asked them for the dates when the incidents occurred and whether they had been escalated.
But she said they 'couldn't give me an accurate response' and it was 'all hearsay', leading her to take no action. Ms Peggie had received no previous complaints from patients or staff.
Asked about Ms Curran's allegations, she said: 'Again, it was just very similar and, like you said, tittle tattle of being a supporter of Donald Trump and sharing his views on gender.
'But again, that's somebody's personal view. As long as it doesn't impact on patients and it doesn't impact on the workforce and actually doesn't cause harm to anybody within the board, then people are entitled to have their private views.'
Ms Myles said Ms Peggie was alleged to have called a consultant a 'p---' but it 'took a while' for Ms Davidson to recall the identity of the alleged victim, who 'doesn't recall the comment'.
The tribunal also heard that the nurse rejected a proposal to work at the Queen Margaret Hospital in Dunfermline so she and Dr Upton could avoid each other.
Nicole Peggie, the nurse's daughter, responded to the homophobia allegations on X, saying: 'Jeez, do I need to go back under oath to clear this up?
'My mum is my best friend, has and always will be. Her only concern is if I'm happy.'
Tess White, the Scottish Tories' shadow equalities minister, said: 'It's plain wrong that she was urged to work at a different hospital after pointing out that her right to access a single-sex space was being denied, while the lack of evidence for the racism allegation thrown at her suggests it was a crude smear.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
28 minutes ago
- The Independent
‘Failings' in care of ex-cricketer Graham Thorpe in months before he died, coroner says
There were 'failings' in the provision of care to former England cricketer Graham Thorpe in the months before he died, a coroner has said. Speaking at the inquest into Mr Thorpe's death, Jonathan Stevens then recorded a conclusion of suicide. Mr Thorpe was not perceived to be in a 'crisis situation' by healthcare professionals after they were told he had been asking his wife 'for help to end his life' weeks before he died, an inquest heard. The 55-year-old died on the morning of 4 August 2024 after being struck by a train at a railway station in Surrey. His widow, Amanda Thorpe, said he had taken his own life. An inquest at Surrey Coroner's Court in Woking heard he had 'spiralled into depression' after losing his job as a batting coach in 2022, and he had tried to take his own life on another occasion. After missing an appointment with the community mental health team on June 28 2024, care co-ordinator Katie Johnson spoke to Mr Thorpe's wife on the phone who told her he was 'constantly asking for help to end his life', the court heard. Ms Johnson then spoke to Mr Thorpe who told her he 'hadn't been out for a while' and 'didn't see the point of being here' but had no immediate plans to act on suicidal thoughts, the inquest heard. An investigation was carried out by Surrey and Borders Partnership NHS Foundation Trust after his death, which details a number of findings and recommendations. Dr Shriti Burgul, a consultant psychiatrist who reviewed the investigation's report before it was finalised, told the court on Friday that one of the findings was that 'it was noted that Graham's presentation at his appointment on 28 June 2024 was in keeping with previous presentations and not perceived by the team as a crisis situation'. Given the conversation was over the phone, the psychiatrist was asked if it would have been appropriate to arrange to see Mr Thorpe very quickly. She said: 'In the wisdom of hindsight, then yes, a home visit would have been clinically indicated,' adding: 'I think the team's view at that point was this was part of his chronic presentation.' Dr Burgul was asked if arranging an appointment for two weeks was an appropriate response and she said in the absence of Mr Thorpe expressing 'active intent' or an 'active plan', it would be appropriate to allow two weeks. She said Mr Thorpe was not at the level of requiring intervention from the home treatment team. The psychiatrist was asked if there was any evidence that if there had been an in-person assessment for Mr Thorpe, there would have been a different outcome, and she replied 'no'. The investigation noted that a letter from when Mr Thorpe was discharged from a private hospital in July 2022 said a neuropsychologist should be identified to provide further support, the inquest heard. This was never done by the private provider or the GP, and a risk panel advised it should be explored in June 2024, Dr Burgul said. Asked whether there was any neuropsychological impact that could have affected the cricketer's ability to engage in appointments, given he missed some, the psychiatrist said 'it's a possibility, yes'. Mr Thorpe's cause of death was recorded by a pathologist as multiple injuries, the coroner said. The inquest previously heard that while on tour in Australia, there was an 'incident involving a video that was taken that had adverse publicity'. Mr Thorpe shared a video with some friends which was leaked, and the incident was 'blown out of all proportion', leaving Mr Thorpe 'distraught', Ms Thorpe said. According to reports at the time, the video, filmed after a dismal Ashes series which England lost 4-0, showed Tasmanian police breaking up a drinking session involving both England and Australia players. Ms Thorpe described it as a 'horrible' time, and said the later termination of his employment with the England and Wales Cricket Board was a 'real shock to Graham', which was the 'start of the decline of his mental health'. Mr Thorpe was a mainstay in the England set-up for many years, first as a batter between 1993 and 2005 before spending 12 years in coaching roles. During a distinguished international career, he struck 16 Test hundreds for England, including a debut century against Australia at Trent Bridge in 1993, and represented his country 182 times in all formats. If you are experiencing feelings of distress, or are struggling to cope, you can speak to the Samaritans, in confidence, on 116 123 (UK and ROI), email jo@ or visit the Samaritans website to find details of your nearest branch. If you are based in the USA, and you or someone you know needs mental health assistance right now, call or text 988, or visit to access online chat from the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline. This is a free, confidential crisis hotline that is available to everyone 24 hours a day, seven days a week. If you are in another country, you can go to to find a helpline near you.
BBC News
29 minutes ago
- BBC News
Warning over fake vodka containing harmful chemical
The public are being warned to stay alert when purchasing or consuming Glen's vodka after counterfeit bottles containing a harmful chemical were discovered. Food Standards Scotland (FSS) said it had found 35cl bottles, or a half bottle, disguised to look like genuine Glen's vodka. A chemical known as isopropyl was found in the illegally labelled vodka, seized by the agency, which can be dangerous if consumed. Vodka containing isopropyl will taste and smell "very different" in comparison to normal alcohol and will be very strong, the FSS have said. Symptoms of isopropyl alcohol poisoning include stomach pain, vomiting, dizziness, sore head, confusion, slow breathing. In some severe cases, FSS have warned it could lead to a coma or death. Genuine Glen's vodka has a laser etched code imprinted on the back and base of the glass bottle. A legitimate product can also be identified by size, fill height and a bottle ID - FSS said these markings would not vary in position or Scotland reported last year that similar counterfeit bottles had been discovered by The Food Standards Agency (FSA).In a statement Food Standards Scotland said: "The scale of distribution of counterfeit product is still unknown."If you believe you may have consumed alcohol that has a strong smell and a very different taste to normal and are showing any of the symptoms described, please contact the NHS 24 on 111 immediately."If you have severe symptoms, call 999."
BBC News
29 minutes ago
- BBC News
Taunton GP who put bodily fluids in coffee struck off
A doctor who put his semen into a cup of coffee he made for a woman has been permanently struck off. Former Taunton GP Nicholas Chapman, 57, was found guilty in June 2023 of attempting to engage in sexual activity without consent. He was sentenced to a 12-month community order. Two years on, a medical tribunal panel has ruled he should be erased from the medical register. In a judgement published online, the tribunal panel said "reasonable" members of the public would find Chapman's conviction "deplorable", adding they would be "appalled" if he were not struck off. The Medical Practitioners Tribunal document detailed how Chapman had targeted a second woman – referred to only as Ms A – over a number of said he had shown her photos of naked women without her consent and suggested she should look for him on an unnamed dating app. The victim also said he had kissed her and, on a separate occasion, had pinched her bottom during a hug – allegations that Chapman denied. The tribunal panel ruled that these actions were "unwanted", constituted sexual harassment and created "a degrading environment" for the victim. During the 2023 trial at Gloucester Crown Court, the first woman, known to the tribunal as Ms B, described the coffee semen incident as "devious and cowardly". She said she hoped to move on but would "have to accept that the mental and emotional trauma I have suffered throughout this will always remain with me in some way". At the time, Chapman was made subject to a 10-year restraining order preventing him from contacting the victim and was placed on the sex offenders' list for five years. 'No evidence of apology' The medical tribunal heard evidence from a doctor who worked at the same practice as Chapman. The doctor said the impact of Chapman's actions on the reputation of the practice and trust in doctors was "still huge". "There continue to be comments inside and outside of the practice on a regular basis like, 'Oh we don't talk about Dr Chapman'," they added. "Some patients are put off coming to the practice and some have a mistrust of seeking help when they need it, or whether things would remain confidential," the doctor continued. Handing down their judgement, the tribunal panel said Chapman had shown a "lack of insight" about the impact of his actions. They highlighted that they had "received no evidence of apology, reflection, insight or remediation from Dr Chapman in respect of his conviction". While Chapman told the tribunal panel he accepted his conviction, he continued to maintain his innocence."Dr Chapman had undermined and breached the trust and confidence of patients and the public in the medical profession," the tribunal report said, adding he had brought the profession into "disrepute".
