The British political class have shown themselves at their worst
The welfare reform Bill was finally passed with a majority of 75, about 100 less than Labour's notional majority. But there is something missing from ministers' and MPs' reactions to this 'victory': the cheers, such as they were, sounded forced. The smiles were wan. The congratulations looked half-hearted. Because this is a Bill whose passage means many losers and zero winners – a rare achievement in parliamentary politics.
Of course, the real losers are those future claimants of Personal Independence Payments (PIP) who, depending on the detail of the latest concessions granted by Keir Starmer, will find it much more difficult to have their claims approved. But there are many more political losers. There are the rebels themselves, at least some of whom might have hoped for personal advancement in their political careers and who must now face years of being nominated for the crummiest, dullest standing committees – the traditional punishment for those who won't take their whips' advice.
Then there are the Conservatives, who voted against a measure many of them clearly supported. There was even a shadow cabinet meeting last week at which Kemi Badenoch asked each member how the party should vote. That such a question even needs to be asked suggests there was at least some support for a more principled, less cynical stance.
Then of course there is the Government, which, before this debate and vote, was in a slightly stronger, slightly more popular position than this evening and which now has achieved the passing of a measure that even ministers can no longer see the point of. It has spent a lot of its political credibility in securing a Bill that was originally sold as a genuinely reformist measure (it is not) and which would save the Treasury billions (it will not).
Not the Commons' finest moment. A damaged legislature, a damaged government and, most importantly, a damaged prime minister. Happy anniversary, Sir Keir.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
North Wales Chronicle
16 minutes ago
- North Wales Chronicle
James Vowles ‘at home' at Williams and wants to stay for rest of career
Vowles, in his third season in charge of the team he joined from Mercedes, inherited a beleaguered outfit which had finished bottom of the constructors' championship for four of the previous five years. However, heading into Sunday's British Grand Prix, Williams are currently fifth with only the might of McLaren, Ferrari, Mercedes and Red Bull ahead of them. Williams' 16th and last combined drivers' and constructors' titles arrived 28 years ago and the impressive Vowles, still only 46, could be forgiven for seeing the Oxfordshire team – established by Sir Frank Williams in an old carpet warehouse – as a stepping stone to one of the grid's bigger beasts. But when asked in an interview with the PA news agency if he ever envisages leaving, Vowles, who recently agreed a new long-term deal with Williams, replied: 'No. I can seem myself being here for the remainder of my career. And I am very comfortable with that. 'My job is to take this shirt and give it to someone else in a number of years' time, and for the team to be in a much better place as an honour to Sir Frank and his legacy. 'Williams have a passion beyond anything I have ever felt. I have never regretted a minute I have been in the building. I don't mean a day. I mean a single minute. I feel at home, I have done since the day I joined, and I have never for a second wondered if I am good enough or if this is the right place for me.' Vowles has secured the highly-rated London-born Thai Alex Albon to a long-term deal, and also persuaded Carlos Sainz to join from Ferrari. — Atlassian Williams Racing (@WilliamsRacing) July 1, 2025 Albon and Sainz have delivered more points for Williams after the first 11 rounds than the British team managed across the previous three seasons combined. However, Vowles has long earmarked next year, and an overhaul of the sport's technical regulations, as a major chance to revive Williams' former glories. 'Do I think we can win the championship?' asks Vowles. 'No, that is unrealistic. We want to anchor ourselves in fifth and move on from there. But can we be in a situation where we are fighting for podiums every now and then? Yes. 'We didn't really put much time and investment into the 2025 car. This is just low-hanging fruit we are picking up by doing the basics right and that is why I am encouraged about our pathway into next season and beyond.' At Mercedes, Vowles played a key role in six of Lewis Hamilton's record-equalling seven world championships. The Silver Arrows are currently exploring the possibility of luring Max Verstappen from Red Bull, which some believe would leave George Russell vulnerable. Russell's deal expires at the end of the season. However, Kimi Antonelli, Russell's rookie team-mate, does not have a firm contract for 2026 either. And Vowles, who remains good friends with Mercedes team principal Toto Wolff, indicated he expects Russell to stay put. He continued: 'Different drivers respond to different pressures and some drivers respond to the pressure of waiting for a deal. It challenges them to push on more. 'I am not seeing a negative impact on George. It makes for interesting reading, and a good story, but I am not actually seeing a driver that is particularly worried or driving differently. 'He is driving his socks off so the pressure might actually be helping him.'
South Wales Argus
16 minutes ago
- South Wales Argus
James Vowles ‘at home' at Williams and wants to stay for rest of career
Vowles, in his third season in charge of the team he joined from Mercedes, inherited a beleaguered outfit which had finished bottom of the constructors' championship for four of the previous five years. However, heading into Sunday's British Grand Prix, Williams are currently fifth with only the might of McLaren, Ferrari, Mercedes and Red Bull ahead of them. Williams are fifth in the constructors' championship ahead of this weekend's British Grand Prix (Bradley Collyer/PA) Williams' 16th and last combined drivers' and constructors' titles arrived 28 years ago and the impressive Vowles, still only 46, could be forgiven for seeing the Oxfordshire team – established by Sir Frank Williams in an old carpet warehouse – as a stepping stone to one of the grid's bigger beasts. But when asked in an interview with the PA news agency if he ever envisages leaving, Vowles, who recently agreed a new long-term deal with Williams, replied: 'No. I can seem myself being here for the remainder of my career. And I am very comfortable with that. 'My job is to take this shirt and give it to someone else in a number of years' time, and for the team to be in a much better place as an honour to Sir Frank and his legacy. 'Williams have a passion beyond anything I have ever felt. I have never regretted a minute I have been in the building. I don't mean a day. I mean a single minute. I feel at home, I have done since the day I joined, and I have never for a second wondered if I am good enough or if this is the right place for me.' Vowles has secured the highly-rated London-born Thai Alex Albon to a long-term deal, and also persuaded Carlos Sainz to join from Ferrari. Albon and Sainz have delivered more points for Williams after the first 11 rounds than the British team managed across the previous three seasons combined. However, Vowles has long earmarked next year, and an overhaul of the sport's technical regulations, as a major chance to revive Williams' former glories. 'Do I think we can win the championship?' asks Vowles. 'No, that is unrealistic. We want to anchor ourselves in fifth and move on from there. But can we be in a situation where we are fighting for podiums every now and then? Yes. 'We didn't really put much time and investment into the 2025 car. This is just low-hanging fruit we are picking up by doing the basics right and that is why I am encouraged about our pathway into next season and beyond.' At Mercedes, Vowles played a key role in six of Lewis Hamilton's record-equalling seven world championships. The Silver Arrows are currently exploring the possibility of luring Max Verstappen from Red Bull, which some believe would leave George Russell vulnerable. George Russell's contract with Mercedes is up for renewal at the end of the year (Bradley Collyer/PA) Russell's deal expires at the end of the season. However, Kimi Antonelli, Russell's rookie team-mate, does not have a firm contract for 2026 either. And Vowles, who remains good friends with Mercedes team principal Toto Wolff, indicated he expects Russell to stay put. He continued: 'Different drivers respond to different pressures and some drivers respond to the pressure of waiting for a deal. It challenges them to push on more. 'I am not seeing a negative impact on George. It makes for interesting reading, and a good story, but I am not actually seeing a driver that is particularly worried or driving differently. 'He is driving his socks off so the pressure might actually be helping him.'
North Wales Chronicle
17 minutes ago
- North Wales Chronicle
Keir's first year: Starmer under pressure after a rocky start for Labour
Labour swept back into Downing Street with more than 400 MPs on July 4 last year – clinching a majority just short of Tony Blair's landslide in 1997. A year later, polling expert Professor Sir John Curtice is calling it 'the worst start for any newly elected prime minister'. Sir Keir was accused of setting a gloomy tone at the outset, telling the public that 'things will get worse before they get better' and warning of 'tough choices' and a 'black hole' left in the finances by his predecessors. Soon after, a plan was unveiled to cut back winter fuel payments for pensioners, only for an enduring backlash to see the Government U-turn and widen eligibility months later. This and the recent climbdown over plans for welfare cuts to stave off a backbench rebellion have raised the prospect of further tax rises in the autumn budget as the Chancellor seeks to balance the books. It has also raised the prospect of rebellious MPs being emboldened to continue pushing back on future policy, putting Sir Keir's plans at risk. When it comes to whether voters like him, Sir John has argued that the Government has a 'lack of direction' and that the Prime Minister was 'never especially popular' and that 'the public still don't know what he stands for.' 'The only vision he's really presented is: 'We'll fix the problems the Conservatives left us.' But it's not clear how he wants to change the country,' he told Times Radio. Sir Keir has acknowledged the 'challenge' of 'getting our story across'. 'If I was to list to you all the things we've done, it's a big long list of things. [But] how do we tell the story of what we've done? How do we make sure it's actually felt by working people?' he said in an interview with The Times. He also said he took 'ownership' of all decisions made by his Government, and that he did not get to grips with the growing rebellion over welfare reforms earlier as he was focused on international affairs. Although that rebellion was eventually reduced from 126 MPs to just 49, it required extensive concessions and marked the biggest revolt of his premiership so far, just days before he celebrated his first year in office. He has played a balancing act on the world stage, strengthening ties with the EU while courting US President Donald Trump, who he wooed with an invitation for a second state visit to the UK when they met in the White House. The football-loving Prime Minister lists a 'hat-trick' of deals – an EU 'reset', a deal with India, and an agreement for relief from Mr Trump's tariffs which has been partially implemented – among his key achievements. He also touts his commitment to get defence spending up to 2.5% of GDP by 2027 – and the new Nato defence and security spending pledge of 5% of GDP by 2035. At home, he is battling the rise of Reform UK. A YouGov megapoll released last week said a general election now could see Reform UK taking more seats than Labour, while the latest Ipsos poll puts Nigel Farage's party at 34% with Labour behind at 25%. Sir Keir framed Reform UK as Labour's main opposition at a press conference in May, saying the Conservative Party has 'run out of road'. It came after Reform UK hoovered up council seats across England in local elections, as well as gaining a seat previously held by Labour in the Runcorn and Helsby by-election. An immigration speech in which the Prime Minister said the UK could become an 'island of strangers' drew criticism and comparisons with Enoch Powell's infamous 'rivers of blood' address that was blamed for inflaming racial tensions in the 1960s. Sir Keir has since expressed regret at the phrasing. But he reportedly plans to target 'authoritarian-leaning' voters with a focus on tackling migration and crime. In recent polling by LabourList of members, 64% said they wanted the party to shift to the left, with only around 2% favouring a move to the right. The next test at the polls will be Welsh and Scottish elections in May, at which Reform UK hopes to end Labour's 26-year domination in the Senedd next year. Sir Keir again took aim at the party in a speech to the Welsh Labour conference last weekend, saying Mr Farage has 'no plan at all' for the nation. Political historian Sir Anthony Seldon has praised Sir Keir's ability to react to crises in foreign policy and during the riots last summer, but urged him to counter Reform UK by communicating 'growth' and 'optimism'. 'Show people that you're Prime Minister, show people you've got a story, show people things are getting better across the whole country with growth and then, you know, that will deal with Reform,' he told Sky News. Sir Keir has pledged to lead a 'decade of national renewal' and said that the first year of that has been 'cleaning up that mess' his Government inherited. In a signal he is seeking to put a positive spin on the future, he told business leaders last week: 'We've wiped the state clean, we've stabilised the economy, and now we can go on to the next phase of government, building on that foundation.'
