Historian blames post-war 'chaos' for Harvard Magna Carta 'copy' confusion
Harvard Law Library bought a version of the royal charter at auction for just $27.50 in 1946, the equivalent of around $450 (£328) today.
The vellum document was described as a "copy made in 1327... somewhat rubbed and damp-stained" - but two historians last month discovered it was actually a rare original worth millions of pounds.
The document was just one of seven versions of the Magna Carta to survive from King Edward I's 1300 issue of the charter.
Professor David Carpenter, who made the discovery with Professor Nicholas Vincent, believes "post-war chaos" is to blame for the confusion.
Speaking at a meeting of the Pipe Roll Society at The National Archives in London, he said: "This was just after the war, there was still a measure of chaos, someone has misread the date on it.
"This is most likely how it happened."
Following the discovery, Prof Vincent traced the history of the document prior to Harvard buying it.
His research suggests that after it was issued by King Edward I to the former parliamentary borough of Appleby, it fell into the hands of a family before being passed to slavery abolitionist Thomas Clarkson.
Via his estate, it ended up in the hands of Forster Maynard, a World War One flying ace, who sold it to London book dealers Sweet & Maxwell for £42, which then sold it to Harvard.
Prof Carpenter, a medieval historian at King's College London, immediately realised the 'copy' looked a lot like the real Magna Carta when he spotted it in Harvard's online catalogue.
"I immediately sent the image to my colleague Nicholas Vincent asking him 'Is this what I think it is?'," he said.
Speaking at the same meeting, Prof Vincent said: "I told him immediately, you know what that is!"
The Magna Carta was originally established in 1215 under King John and outlined the rights of ordinary people under common law for the first time.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
The 7 most common neighbour disputes that knock £26k off your home's value – and why all parents need to listen up
FROM nuisance noise to hedge wars and building work, neighbour niggles can be costly – unless handled carefully. 'If a dispute is affecting your quality of life, it's important to take the appropriate steps to resolve matters,' says Daniel McAfee, head of legal operations at Lawhive. 7 'But try not to go nuclear too quickly. From a legal perspective, the burden of proof is likely to be with you, as most of these issues fall under civil law, meaning you also need to fund your case. 'And it can impact on the value of your property, as you need to declare any complaints you have pursued through the courts when you come to sell.' Experts estimate it could cause a ten percent price reduction – £26,500 based on the UK average house price, or £56,700 in London. Here, Daniel explains your rights in seven common disputes and how best to resolve them… FENCE FALL-OUTS These simple structures can trigger a host of disagreements, from placement and permitted height to maintenance costs. 'The rule of thumb is, your side of the fence is your side – it should define the boundary and therefore you can paint your own side however you like,' says Daniel. 'Difficulties arise when, for example, it falls down and there is a dispute over the cost or the position of the new one. 'Maybe one person refuses to pay their share or they believe it has moved and taken more of their land.' The first step is to find out if the fence was jointly owned to start with. 'Check the title plans for both properties, which set the boundary line and whether it is a 'party wall fence' with joint ownership,' says our expert. I'm being forced to tear down my loft conversion - my neighbours call it a 'monstrosity' but I'm going to fight back If the fence is a shared responsibility and one side refuses to pay their share, you can make a civil claim to recover costs. TREE AND HEDGE WARS 7 The general rule is that branches must stay within your legal boundary. If they stray over, your neighbour is entitled to cut them back to the borderline. 'It comes down to whose property the root originates from, as that establishes ownership,' says Daniel. 'But there are environmental factors and some trees have legal protection. I'd recommend getting a tree surgeon or other expert to check before you chop.' If next door's overgrown conifer is throwing shade on your sunbathing spot, there's little you can do. 'There's no right to light outside, but there is one inside your property,' Daniel says. 'You'd need a specialist survey to prove the obstruction is resulting in a more than 50 per cent reduction into a habitable area of the home, like the living room or kitchen. 'But beware – these reports can cost between £200 and £350, maybe more. And you may need to seek a civil injunction to have the tree cut down.' Hedges can also cause headaches and action can be taken if they meet certain criteria, such as being more than 2m tall. But councils cannot order the removal or cutting of hedges to below 2m. PARKING PAINS 7 Nothing sends the local WhatsApp group into meltdown like inconsiderate parking. If you only have on-street parking, there's no rule that says you are entitled to a spot outside your front door. But you can take steps to ensure no one blocks your drive. 'Contact the council to get a stripe painted on the highway to indicate this, which also makes it subject to local enforcement policies,' says Daniel. 'My clients that do this say it has been successful – and it's free.' You must also call the council if neighbours are blocking pavements with their vehicles, but it can take effort to make them act. 'Take photos, get other residents to complain and write to your MP,' he suggests. CLASHES OVER KIDS 7 The sound of children running about outside can be divisive, with some happy to hear their laughter and others finding their high spirits intrusive. Daniel says there are two areas that govern this. The first is civil law, as defined by the council, who can deal with any infringements. 'There might be rules to ensure noise is kept to a minimum at certain times of day,' Daniel explains. Anything that strays into anti-social behaviour, like vandalism and violence, is potentially a criminal matter. 'Don't be deterred if the police, council or social housing landlord don't act initially,' he says. 'If you make three reports in six months, you can ask to trigger an Anti-social Behaviour Review (ABR), which is independent.' SNOOPING SUSPICIONS 7 Feeling like someone is snooping over the fence is unsettling, but privacy rules can be complicated. 'Everyone has the right to quiet enjoyment of their property,' says Daniel. 'But you'd need to have evidence of an interference with that, or a breach of privacy. For example, a telescope looking directly into your bedroom is pretty clear. But other things are not.' Increased use of CCTV and Ring doorbell cameras could mean you are unintentionally in breach too. 'It comes down to common sense and talking to people,' he says. 'You have to prove they are actively trying to do this.' It also comes down to appreciating the privacy – or lack of – that comes with your particular property. 'If you don't like being overlooked, a terraced house might not be for you.' KEEP THE NOISE DOWN 7 From rowdy parties to vacuuming at unsocial hours, noise intrusion can have a huge impact. 'Most rules around noise disturbance are set by your council, setting out unacceptable decibels or time restrictions, depending on what type of area you live in,' says Daniel. It needs to count as a statutory nuisance for councils to investigate, which means it must either unreasonably and substantially interfere with the use or enjoyment of a home or other premises, or injure health, or be likely to injure health. 'If there is a breach, the council can take action and serve an abatement notice, but you may also need to ask the courts for a civil injunction for a persistent problem. 'It sounds easy, but the evidence thresholds you need to attain are high, often requiring a reliable audio meter and well-timed council visits. 'This is when things like CCTV can be a big help to build a case.' BUILDING BOTHER 7 Home renovations can trigger all sorts of gripes, from an extension being too big to the noise and dust created. It is a good idea to forewarn neighbours about any disruption, so they can be prepared. Builders will be aware of local rules on what times construction can take place and should comply. 'If they don't, council enforcement can step in, but be aware that you can also be liable for action, as you are employing them,' Daniel warns. If you suspect a neighbour's extension is in breach of planning permission, contact the planning office in the first instance. 'Councils have a range of measures available, including ordering the construction to be taken down or altered,' says Daniel. 'But they have discretion to not act or invite a retrospective application.' FYI When one or both neighbours is a tenant, complaints need to be made to the owners of the properties involved. 'This could be a private landlord, housing association or the council,' says Daniel. 'If you are the tenant, your landlord owes you a duty of care as part of your contract with them. They are obliged to take action in your interest and if they fail to do this, you may need to take action against them. 'Likewise, if the neighbour causing the problem is renting, you should direct your dispute to their landlord, as they could be breaching the terms of their lease.'
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Rise in people living alone in UK driven entirely by over-65s
A rise in the number of people living alone in the UK in the past decade has been entirely driven by an increase in older people residing on their own. In 2024, there were an estimated 4.3 million people aged over 65 living alone, up from 3.5 million in 2014, the Office for National Statistics (ONS) said. This age group accounted for just over half (51.1%) of all people living alone last year, compared with 45.5% in 2014. The statistics body said: ' People aged 65 years or over accounted in full for the increase in people living alone in 2024 compared with 2014.' There were around 4.1 million people aged under 65 years old living alone in both 2014 and 2024, the ONS said, adding that the 'increasing proportions of people living alone in older age groups reflects an ageing population'. A higher proportion of women aged 65 or over in households lived alone (40.9%) than men of the same age (27%), which the ONS said is partly because of women having a higher life expectancy than men. The latest data from the ONS estimated there were 8.4 million people living alone in the UK in 2024, up 11% from 7.6 million in 2014. Meanwhile, the proportion of young adults in the UK living with their parents has grown by almost 10% in a decade. Young men – aged between 20 and 34 years old – were more likely to be at home with their parents than women in the same age group in 2024, according to the ONS. There were an estimated 3.6 million people in this age group in a family with their parent or parents in 2024, up 9.9% from 3.3 million in 2014, the ONS said. While a third (33.7%) of men in this age group lived with parents, this compared to less than a quarter (22.1%) of women. The ONS said more young adults living with their parents at older ages is part of a 'trend of adults reaching milestones later in life' and may be 'explained by a number of factors including increased housing costs'. The latest statistics also showed that lone-parent families were less likely to contain dependent children in 2024 – 62.5%, down from just over two thirds or 66.1% in 2014. The proportion of lone parents who are fathers has grown, from 13.1% a decade ago, to 16.7% last year. While married couples still made up the largest proportion of families in the latest estimates, this has decreased to 65.1% last year from 67.1% in 2014. The ONS said this was down to more couples living together without getting married.
The Herald Scotland
an hour ago
- The Herald Scotland
Painting of Scotland's oldest wild Scots pine to be unveiled
Proceeds from the sale of the painting, and limited edition prints of it, will go towards conservation charity Trees for Life's work to restore the globally unique pinewoods and save them from being lost forever. The exhibition marks the 800th anniversary of the issuing of the definitive versions of the Magna Carta and the Charter of the Forest in 1225. The Charter drew together the forest-related rules established by the Magna Carta and is widely regarded as the UK's first environmental legislation. The Caledonian pinewoods – home of iconic Scottish wildlife such as red squirrel, golden eagle, capercaillie and wildcat -– have been reduced to less than 2% of their original area across just 84 officially recognised remnants, scattered across the Highlands and often in poor condition. READ MORE: 'Masterful' painting by Scottish colourist sells for £380,000 at auction Paintings by two Scottish Colourists to go under the hammer Some of the surviving remnants consist of a few ancient trees, known as Granny pines, that are hundreds of years old but have no young trees growing around them to replace them when they die. According to Trees for Life, Dan Llywelyn Hall's painting of the 567-year-old Glen Loyne Pine "brings this situation into stark reality". Steve Micklewright, chief executive of Trees for Life, said: 'Dan's atmospheric painting of the Glen Loyne Pine – standing alone in the dramatic Highland landscape – shows the desperate plight of many of our native pinewoods. His brush strokes say more about the situation than words ever can. 'Scotland's native pinewoods should be playing a key role in the fightback against the nature and climate emergencies, but most are on their last legs. We need urgent landscape-scale restoration and rewilding – backed by the Scottish Government – to save, expand and connect up these precious woodlands before it's too late.' Artist Dan Llywelyn Hall with Glen Lloyne Pine painting at the Society of Antiquaries, London (Image: Malcolm Park)The woodlands once covered 1.5 million hectares of the Highlands, but over time were felled for timber or to create land for grazing. Overgrazing by deer, which browse on young pine saplings, is now the main reason for their continued decline. A detailed analysis by Trees for Life into the condition of most of the known pinewood remnants recently concluded that high impacts from artificially large deer populations are the main barrier to the pinewoods' recovery, and that many of the remnants will be lost without urgent measures to help them recover. At a major conference last autumn, 25 organisations – including charities Trees for Life and Woodland Trust Scotland, and [[pub]]lic agencies Forestry and Land Scotland and NatureScot – agreed to form the Caledonian Pinewood Partnership to boost restoration efforts. Cardiff-born Dan Llywelyn Hall is a painter known for vivid paintings, including landscape and portraiture. His portrait commissions include Her Majesty The Queen in 2013, when Dan became the youngest artist to portray the monarch. He said: 'The Glen Loyne pine has lived through major historical events, including the execution of Mary Queen of Scots, Jacobite Rebellions, creation of the United Kingdom, and Second World War. We must ensure that a new generation of Scots pine can grow that can bear witness to the events of the next 500 years. 'I hope the new Caledonian Pinewood Partnership will be inspired by the Charter of the Forest and develop a new charter for Scotland's pinewoods, one where harmony between nature and human needs is paramount.' The 'Magna Carta 1225: 800th Anniversary Exhibition' at the Society of Antiquaries runs until 19 September, and also features three other newly commissioned paintings by the artist. All depict ancient forests or specific trees alive when the Charter of the Forest was drawn up by representatives of King Henry III in 1217. Following the exhibition, the different paintings will then be sold to raise funds for Trees for Life, the Society of Antiquaries Library and Collection, and other beneficiaries. Many of the surviving Caledonian pinewoods are in ancient forests – land once reserved for the monarch and aristocracy for hunting. The Glen Loyne Pine has been dated to at least 1458 by St Andrews Tree-Ring Laboratory, and is believed to be even older. It is located in a remote ancient woodland of some 57 pines, all several centuries old, scattered through Glen Lloyne in the northwest Highlands.
