Historian blames post-war 'chaos' for Harvard Magna Carta 'copy' confusion
Harvard Law Library bought a version of the royal charter at auction for just $27.50 in 1946, the equivalent of around $450 (£328) today.
The vellum document was described as a "copy made in 1327... somewhat rubbed and damp-stained" - but two historians last month discovered it was actually a rare original worth millions of pounds.
The document was just one of seven versions of the Magna Carta to survive from King Edward I's 1300 issue of the charter.
Professor David Carpenter, who made the discovery with Professor Nicholas Vincent, believes "post-war chaos" is to blame for the confusion.
Speaking at a meeting of the Pipe Roll Society at The National Archives in London, he said: "This was just after the war, there was still a measure of chaos, someone has misread the date on it.
"This is most likely how it happened."
Following the discovery, Prof Vincent traced the history of the document prior to Harvard buying it.
His research suggests that after it was issued by King Edward I to the former parliamentary borough of Appleby, it fell into the hands of a family before being passed to slavery abolitionist Thomas Clarkson.
Via his estate, it ended up in the hands of Forster Maynard, a World War One flying ace, who sold it to London book dealers Sweet & Maxwell for £42, which then sold it to Harvard.
Prof Carpenter, a medieval historian at King's College London, immediately realised the 'copy' looked a lot like the real Magna Carta when he spotted it in Harvard's online catalogue.
"I immediately sent the image to my colleague Nicholas Vincent asking him 'Is this what I think it is?'," he said.
Speaking at the same meeting, Prof Vincent said: "I told him immediately, you know what that is!"
The Magna Carta was originally established in 1215 under King John and outlined the rights of ordinary people under common law for the first time.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
25 minutes ago
- BBC News
Coastguard warns to fill sand holes dug at beaches
Islanders are being reminded by the Coastguard to fill any large holes they dig in the sand at the beach before Coastguard said digging holes posed "a safety risk" to others and could end in a month, the UK Coastguard said a teenager had been "extremely lucky" not to have suffocated after being buried 7ft (about 2m) deep in said: "These holes can collapse without warning, potentially trapping or injuring people. There have been tragic incidents in the UK, including fatalities, where individuals were buried under sand after holes collapsed." The Coastguard added the holes could become dangerous when left unattended or "obscured by shifting tides"."Our advice is to be respectful of other beach users and always fill in any holes you have dug before leaving the beach," it said.
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Guernsey pupils perform 'significantly better' than UK average
Guernsey pupils perform "significantly better" in literacy and English than the UK average, the head of education improvement has said. Clare Sealy said 40% of the island's key stage two pupils were exceeding benchmark expectations for their age, compared with 23% of pupils in the UK. The States said Ms Sealy and Joanne Siddall, part of Guernsey's Education Office, were also members of an expert panel which had devised a new national writing framework launched this month by the UK Department for said their contribution helped to showcase the island's "strong primary education provision". 'Real transformation' Guernsey officials said a focus on handwriting, encouraging children to express themselves in spoken language and a renewed focus on reception classrooms were part of the UK government's Siddall, Guernsey's primary education development officer, and Ms Sealy helped shape the guidance to ensure it reflected the "research and the realities of classroom practice", the States from La Houguette Primary School, which followed the approach for more than a year, were used to shape the Claire Judd said the school had seen a "real transformation" in how pupils approached writing, adding there had already been improvements in "fluency and confidence". 'Leading the way' Ms Sealy said: "It has been fantastic to contribute to this national framework, helping to share our best practice, and shape and guide classrooms nationally about how best to teach children vital writing skills."Ms Siddall said States primary schools were "leading the way in using current educational research" to hone writing skills. "The schools that have implemented a sentence knowledge curriculum have seen big improvements in writing, and we look forward to continuing to share our sector-leading work with schools locally and further afield," she added.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Couple celebrate victory after five-year row with neighbours over giant cypress tree that went to top of government and saw police called in
A couple have won a bitter row with their neighbours over a hedge they claimed were making their lives a misery. Keith Smith, 71, and his wife Julie, 68, were left frustrated by a row of cypress trees belonging to David Hunter and Niena Hunter Mistry in the Edinburgh suburb of Prestonfield. The five-year feud, which began as a mild disagreement, grew increasingly to involve Edinburgh Council, the Scottish Government and even the police, who were called to the home multiple times. The Smiths turned to the City of Edinburgh Council in a bid to have them chopped down, but were left stunned when the council rejected. However, they later successfully appealed to the government and the trees had to be cut to 8.5ft. One tree remained, which the Smiths, who have resided in their detached home for 44 years, insisted towered over their garden and left it in darkness. Mr Hunter went to the Scottish Government in a bid to save his tree, but that has been rejected and it will have to be lopped to 8.5ft. In his appeal letter, Mr Hunter insisted the tree was not part of the hedge and begged for it to be kept. He said: 'The individual tree identified in the varied notice cannot reasonably be said to be part of the boundary hedge. 'It appears as a separate individual tree and has never been trimmed. 'We would be very grateful if you would take all our points and concerns into account and request that you quash the revised high hedge notice.' In a document to the government, the Smiths said: 'The cost to the public purse must be considerable in terms of government, council and police resources. 'We, the Smiths, have suffered hugely financially, emotionally and physically by this process and sincerely hope, this will now lead to resolution.' Mrs Smith had earlier said she was constantly 'anxious, stressed and scared' to enter her garden and claimed the conflict had impacted on her marriage. Government reporter Amanda Chisholm said: 'During one period of sunshine, I observed that the disputed tree casts shadow over a significant proportion of the neighbouring property's rear garden. 'In any case, the varied high hedge notice applies to the hedge as a whole, which has already been found to adversely affect this property's reasonable enjoyment. 'In my view the part of the hedge that has not been reduced in height continues to do so.'
