World Press Photo suspends credit for 'Napalm Girl' picture
The documentary chronicles an investigation into rumours that the image, which helped change global perceptions of the US war in Vietnam, was taken by a little-known local freelancer, not the Associated Press (AP) staff photographer Nick Ut, who won a Pulitzer Prize for the photo.
World Press Photo, which awarded its own Photo of the Year prize to Ut in 1973 for the black-and-white image -- whose official title is "The Terror of War" -- said the film had "prompted deep reflection" at the organisation.
After investigating from January to May, it determined that "based on analysis of location, distance, and the camera used on that day", two other photographers "may have been better positioned to take the photograph than Nick Ut".
"World Press Photo has suspended the attribution of 'The Terror of War' to Nick Ut, from today," it said in a statement.
The organisation named the two other photographers as Nguyen Thanh Nghe and Huynh Cong Phuc, both present for the infamous scene in the southern village of Trang Bang on June 8, 1972.
In "The Stringer", which premiered at the Sundance film festival in January, Nguyen told the documentary's makers he was certain the photo was his.
AP, which said earlier this month it would continue crediting the photo to Ut, said in a statement it stood by that decision.
But it acknowledged its own investigation had raised "real questions that we may never be able to answer" about the picture's authorship.
"We have found that it is impossible to prove exactly what happened that day on the road or in the bureau over 50 years ago," it said.
Ut insisted the image was his in a February Facebook post, calling claims to the contrary "a slap in the face".
The girl in the picture, Kim Phuc, survived her injuries, and is today a Canadian citizen and outspoken advocate for child war victims.
World Press Photo emphasised that the authenticity of the image itself was not in question.
"It is without question that this photograph represents a real moment in history that continues to reverberate in Vietnam, the United States, and globally," said executive director Joumana El Zein Khoury.
© 2025 AFP
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
AFP
8 hours ago
- AFP
Hoax posts about Malaysian cash aid scheme misuse unrelated visuals
The purported news report by online news site Malaysiakini was shared on Facebook on July 19, 2025. "GOVERNMENT ASSISTANCE OF RM50,000 FOR ANYONE WHO APPLIES," reads the Malay-language chyron on the report, which features footage of Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim at various events and a voiceover that repeats the claim about the subsidy. "Please check your eligibility and the application method," the voiceover says. Image Screenshot of the false Facebook post captured on July 22, 2025, with a red X added by AFP Another version of the claim shared on July 11, 2025 includes a photo of people posing in an office with a mock cheque labelled "Disaster fund Turkey". Image Screenshot of the false Facebook post captured on July 23, 2025, with a red X added by AFP Other posts on Facebook ask users to get in touch for further details about the purported subsidy. AFP reached out to one of the Facebook accounts and was given an order form asking for personal details, including full name and delivery address. Applicants are also told to prepare a copy of their national identity card and bank statement. Scam posts demanding users' personal information regularly circulate on social media in Malaysia. AFP has previously debunked accounts impersonating government schemes that garnered tens of thousands of followers. However, the government has not announced a 50,000 ringgit cash aid scheme. A spokesperson for the finance ministry told AFP the claim is false, and pointed to a list of all genuine government assistance announced under the 2025 budget instead (archived link). Misused visuals A combination of keyword and reverse image searches on Google using keyframes from the falsely shared video led to a similar news clip published by Malaysiakini on its Instagram page on July 15, 2025 (archived link). The original report states Anwar would make a "big announcement" as a tribute to Malaysians (archived link). On July 23, he announced a host of measures to help citizens with cost of living issues, such as a 100 ringgit handout and lowered petrol prices (archived link). A Malaysiakini representative told AFP on July 22 that its logo had been misused. "This is definitely not our video. We have never edited any of our videos to promote government aid," the spokesperson said. The clip shared in the false posts has been altered, including font that does not match Malaysiakini's style and a pink chyron covering the original orange one that reads "Anwar to announce extraordinary tribute to citizens". Image Screenshot comparison between the fabricated clip (left) and a genuine Malaysiakini news video report (right) A separate reverse image search on Google found the photo of people posing with a mock cheque was first posted on the verified X account of the Ambassador of Turkey to Kuala Lumpur on March 3, 2023 (archived link). Image Screenshot comparison of the false post (left) and the original post by the Ambassador of Turkey to Kuala Lumpur (right) The ambassador was thanking the Malaysian Aeon Foundation, a charitable organisation under the Aeon Group of Companies, for donating to victims of the devastating earthquake that struck Turkey in February 2023. A similar photo of the event was also published on the Aeon Credit website (archived link).
AFP
12 hours ago
- AFP
Clip shows flood defence in northern Thailand, not border wall with Cambodia
"Thailand is building walls against Cambodia, reports a Khmer channel," reads Thai-language text on a TikTok video posted on July 15, 2025. The video, which has garnered more than 460,000 views, appears to show a wall being constructed. It shows concrete slabs being slotted into position by several men wearing camouflage trousers and green shirts adorned with the words "Royal Thai Army". According to the clip's , it shows an 800-kilometre border fence that Thailand was building along its border with Cambodia. Image Screenshot of the false TikTok post captured on July 23, 2025, with a red X added by AFP Similar posts surfaced elsewhere on TikTok, Facebook and YouTube, as well as in a Khmer-language post after longstanding tensions between the Southeast Asian neighbours escalated into cross-border clashes in late May, with one Cambodian soldier killed. Numerous border crossings have been closed as Cambodia halted certain Thai imports, and the kingdom's Prime Minister Paetongtarn Shinawatra was suspended pending an ethics probe into her conduct after a phone call trying to soothe the spat was leaked by ex-Cambodian leader Hun Sen (archived link). The neighbours' long-running border spat dramatically escalated on July 24, with Cambodia firing rockets and artillery shells into Thailand and the Thai military scrambling F-16 jets to carry out air strikes (archived link). Both sides blamed the other for starting the fighting, which erupted near two temples on the border between the Thai province of Surin and Cambodia's Oddar Meanchey. The clip circulating online, however, was not filmed at the countries' shared border. Thailand-Myanmar floodwall A reverse image search on Google using the keyframes from the falsely shared clip and additional keyword found a longer version of the video in a Facebook post shared on June 1 (archived link). Its Thai-language description reads: "Let's take a look at the army engineers from the Department of Military Engineering, Ratchaburi province, laying the piles and inserting the concrete slabs". "Each slab takes about 3-5 minutes. This spot should be done as soon as next week," it added. Image Screenshot comparison of the falsely shared clip (left) and the video posted on June 1 (right) The Facebook user regularly publishes videos on the floodwall construction in Mae Sai district of Chiangrai province in northern Thailand, which borders Myanmar (archived lin AFP geolocated the footage to an area near a river on the Thai-Myanmar border (archived here and here). Aerial footage from a July 21 report by public broadcaster Thai PBS shows the same guesthouses, where the floodwalls are reportedly almost complete (archived link). Image Screenshot comparison of the Facebook video from June 1 (left) and a Thai PBS report (right), with corresponding elements highlighted by AFP Another video published by the Facebook user shows a distinct yellow building downstream and across the river (archived here and here). The same building is visible in a June 1 report by state media NBT about the construction of riverbank barriers in communities that have been severely affected by flooding (archived link). Image Screenshot comparison of a building seen in a Facebook video posted by the user who shared the original video (left) and a report by NBT on June 1 (right), highlighted in both by AFP AFP has previously fact-checked other misinformation related to the Thailand-Cambodia border dispute.
LeMonde
12 hours ago
- LeMonde
Thailand and Cambodia exchange air strikes in escalating border dispute
Thailand launched air strikes on Cambodian military targets on Thursday, July 24, as Cambodia fired rockets and artillery, killing a civilian, in a dramatic escalation of a long-running border row between the two neighbors. The countries are locked in a bitter spat over an area known as the Emerald Triangle, where the borders of both countries and Laos meet, and which is home to several ancient temples. The squabble has dragged on for decades, flaring into bloody military clashes more than 15 years ago and again in May, when a Cambodian soldier was killed in a firefight. The conflict blazed up on Thursday, with Cambodia firing rockets and artillery shells into Thailand and the Thai military scrambling F-16 jets to carry out air strikes. Six jets were deployed from Ubon Ratchathani province, hitting two "Cambodian military targets on the ground," according to Thai military deputy spokesperson Ritcha Suksuwanon. The Thai prime minister's office said a Cambodian artillery shell hit a house over the border, killing one civilian and wounding three others, including a five-year-old child. Both sides blamed the other for starting the fighting, which erupted near two temples on the border between the Thai province of Surin and Cambodia's Oddar Meanchey. "The Thai military violated the territorial integrity of the Kingdom of Cambodia by launching an armed assault on Cambodian forces stationed to defend the nation's sovereign territory," defense ministry spokeswoman Maly Socheata said in a statement. "In response, the Cambodian armed forces exercised their legitimate right to self-defense, in full accordance with international law, to repel the Thai incursion and protect Cambodia's sovereignty and territorial integrity." The Thai military blamed Cambodian soldiers for firing first, and later accused them of a "targeted attack on civilians," saying two BM-21 rockets had hit a community in Surin's Kap Choeng district, wounding three people. According to the Thai military, the clashes began around 7:35 am when a unit guarding Ta Muen temple heard a Cambodian drone overhead. Later, six armed Cambodian soldiers, including one carrying a rocket-propelled grenade, approached a barbed-wired fence in front of the Thai post, the army said. Thai soldiers shouted to warn them, the army said, but around 8:20 am, Cambodian forces opened fire toward the eastern side of the temple, about 200 meters from the Thai base. Thailand's acting Prime Minister Phumtham Wechayachai said, "the situation requires careful handling, and we must act in accordance with international law." "We will do our best to protect our sovereignty," he said. Thailand's embassy in Phnom Penh urged its nationals to leave Cambodia "as soon as possible" unless they had urgent reasons to remain, in a Facebook post. Long-running row The violence came hours after Thailand expelled the Cambodian ambassador and recalled its own envoy in protest after five members of a Thai military patrol were wounded by a landmine. Wechayachai said an investigation by the Thai military found evidence that Cambodia had laid new landmines in the disputed border area – a claim denied by Phnom Penh. On Thursday morning, Cambodia announced it was downgrading ties to "the lowest level," pulling out all but one of its diplomats and expelling their Thai equivalents from Phnom Penh. Help us improve Le Monde in English Dear reader, We'd love to hear your thoughts on Le Monde in English! Take this quick survey to help us improve it for you. Take the survey Recent weeks have seen a series of tit-for-tat exchanges between both sides, with Thailand restricting border crossings and Cambodia halting certain imports. The border row also kicked off a domestic political crisis in Thailand, where Prime Minister Paetongtarn Shinawatra has been suspended from office pending an ethics probe over her conduct. A diplomatic call between Paetongtarn and Hun Sen, Cambodia's former longtime ruler and father of Prime Minister Hun Manet, was leaked from the Cambodian side, sparking a judicial investigation. Last week, Hun Manet announced that Cambodia would start conscripting civilians next year, activating a long-dormant mandatory draft law.
