Why the new Bonnie Blue documentary may be the worst thing I've ever seen on Channel 4
Channel 4 has a rich history of making great documentaries. Dispatches is a strand of docs they have produced since 1987 and it has won a number of Baftas over the years. It was the channel which aired the Michael Jackson documentary Leaving Neverland.
In 2022 it produced a detailed expose of the practices of The Jeremy Kyle Show. Jamie Oliver's school dinners campaign was made on Channel 4 via a documentary series in 2005.
And over the past 20 years I have written about dozens of the documentaries and their findings. It's an area of the job I love. Many have led to changes in business practice or even debates in parliament and nationwide talking points.
But the new Bonnie Blue documentary is not groundbreaking, and worse than that, it is not even a detailed film on the subject matter. I have to say it is one of the worst documentaries I have ever seen on Channel 4, and now I'll explain why I think it is so weak.
Observational documentaries are quite common at the moment and successful. You follow a celeb around, get them in their normal life, chat about their past exploits, successes and traumas and then add in archive footage. If they have home videos even better, especially if it is emotive.
David Beckham did one, Robbie Williams has filmed another, and in this genre the best doc I have seen relatively recently was with Sven Goran Eriksson filmed in the year before he died. Former England manager Sven trusted the director and I felt gave a lot of himself over to the project. It left me in tears by the end as Sven said goodbye to the world via the film.
By contrast, Bonnie Blue gives away very little. There are gaps of weeks between filming. Then the final scene shows her going off to see self-proclaimed misogynist Andrew Tate. It's controversial and the interview between the pair could produce some explosive footage, but the director chooses to end filming before the meeting and does not travel with her.
On another day Bonnie is filming her most famous film to date, sleeping with over 1000 men, but the director admits she didn't stay too long so none of the details are verified. She then fails to meet up with her again for more than a week, so there is no real time reaction to the event.
It feels like Bonnie called the shots when it came to filming, and there are only a couple of occasions throughout the whole doc when I feel she isn't putting on a front or facade.
Bonnie says at one point she earns over a million pounds a month, but we don't see any examples on screen of her earning or what she pays her team who work with her. We have to take her word for it. It's another small detail which is not really proven or probed. What does she spend her money on? Does she have investments or a property portfolio which would show another side to her in terms of business acumen.
The director on the project admitted when speaking to the media the documentary wasn't her idea and she was asked to come on board. This is another red flag for me as a lot of the best docs are passion projects for the makers which means they go that extra mile and also in some cases have a long standing relationship with the subject or the insiders.
I appreciate that the rise of OnlyFans is an interesting topic and understand that some people including young girls and lads in this documentary see it as a way of avoiding boring 9-5 jobs.
And there have been interesting documentaries made on this type of subject. Olivia Attwood looked at the phenomenon of OnlyFans in her series Getting Filthy Rich on ITV in 2022.
She spoke to a variety of content providers and they spoke of the ranges of money they earned and how they earned it in detail. They also said speaking to men on the site had made them distrust men more.
But this new Channel 4 doc doesn't feel like an in-depth exploration into that world. Bonnie is allowed to say the same things over and over and many questions are left unanswered. As a viewer I still had lots of questions and that is why I feel it is such a weak documentary. A far cry from the best documentaries Channel 4 have made over the years.
For their part, Channel 4 obviously disagree. Asked for their reasoning to commission, make and screen the documentary in its current form, they said: "Tia Billinger, via her stage name Bonnie Blue, has gained worldwide attention and millions of pounds in the last year. 1000 Men and Me: The Bonnie Blue Story is an observational documentary in which director Victoria Silver follows Tia over the course of six months.
"The film questions Tia's methods and the divisive style of her social media and hears from colleagues and collaborators in order to understand her polarising business model. Part of Channel 4's remit is to reflect modern Britain and stimulate debate amongst viewers, and a film such as this, exploring changing attitudes to sex, success, porn, and feminism in an ever-evolving online world is an important addition to those conversations."
* 1000 Men and Me: The Bonnie Blue Story is on Channel 4 on Tuesday night at 10pm and available to stream online.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
19 minutes ago
- Daily Mirror
Peru Two drug mule Michaella McCollum insists she's changed ahead of Celeb SAS challenge
EXCLUSIVE: Michaella McCollum is trying to move on from her Peru Two past and make her kids proud on TV this weekend If there is one women who might be equipped to take on the toughness of an SAS challenge, it is Michaella McCollum. It's been more than a decade since drug mule Michaella made headlines as one half of the so-called Peru Two. On 6 August 2013, Michaella McCollum and Melissa Reid were arrested at Jorge Chavez International Airport in Lima, Peru. Their luggage contained £1.5m worth of cocaine. Michaella had been convinced to attempt to smuggle the drugs from Peru to Spain by a man she met in Ibiza. But it was a decision that would see her go on to spend three years behind bars in one of South America's toughest prisons before being granted early release. Her interview comes after Channel 4 breaks silence after Gogglebox couple suddenly dumped from show. Looking back, Michaela admits that having messed up when she went to jail for drug smuggling left her so terrified of making another mistake she became so cautious and stuck in her ways. Signing up to Channel 4 's SAS was her way of giving her a push to take back control of her life. 'I feel like in my younger days, I made lots of mistakes, so then I was really cautious of doing things, because I didn't want to mess up again. I didn't want to mess up, I didn't want to make any more mistakes. "But we can't live life like that, because we're always going to make mistakes, we're always going to make bad choices, obviously not as bad a choice as I made previously, but it's okay to make a mistake. 'I had got to the point where I was just refusing to do a lot of things because I was scared. What if I mess it up? What if I take this job and it doesn't work out? What if I move to this place and it doesn't work out? I was just a little bit afraid of making those decisions. I felt stuck. So I guess that was the main thing for me, to try and learn to overcome that. 'I was at the point in my life where I was just stuck in my comfort zone, and I thought this is a good way to break those barriers and do the things that scare me, and maybe that will help me in the future with decisions and just different things in life.' Now 32, she is stepping back into the spotlight in the new series of Celebrity SAS: Who Dares Wins, alongside the likes of Rebecca Loos and Conor Benn. The celebs take part in the most gruelling phase of Special Forces selection, directed through by an elite team of ex-Special Forces soldiers including Chief Instructor Billy Billingham. First she had to learn to swim before heading onto the show, then face a grilling from the SAS team and even fight her co-stars and take on a range of other challenges. Michaela knows she will always be known as one half of the Peru Two but Michaela hopes being on the Channel 4 series will show people a different side to her. She told the Mirror: 'It's so easy to sit at home and judge somebody when somebody's whole life is tearing apart. So I feel like it was important, I guess, when I got there, to show that I'm not just that girl who went to prison. "I'm a mother, I'm a human, I make mistakes. This is what we are and this is what we're here to do. So I hope it does change the public's opinion, but if it doesn't, it doesn't. 'I did that show for me, I wanted to improve myself and push myself. There's gonna be people that will always have their opinion. There'll be people that will always judge me for that(smuggling). But I'm not just that. "I hope it kind of, softens the image so people get to see me in a different light.' And having spent three years in the notorious Ancon 2 jail Michaella endured horrendous living conditions, physical violence, and while battling the legal system and learning to survive in an environment that was as hostile as it was brutal. Following her release in 2015, Michaella sought to rebuild her life in Northern Ireland, earning a degree in International Business Management from Ulster University in 2023. She also found a new passion for fitness, using it as a tool to reclaim control over her life. She regularly delivers motivational talks about personal transformation, overcoming adversity, and the dangers of coercion. Her experiences, both in prison and in navigating the challenges that followed, have made her a sought-after speaker for law enforcement and community groups. Away from the show She's a single mum to two twin boys and Michaela says they are going to be shocked when they see what she did on the course. She can't wait for them to see her in action and realise that behind the glam exterior is a tough cookie. She said: 'I spoke to my kids about the show, and they didn't want me to do the show, because they were like, 'You're going to die.' 'I'm like, 'I'm not going to die' And like, 'No, because this is really bad, and you're going to break your nails.' I'm like, 'It's fine. I can break my nails. It's okay'. 'But I think I had these conversations with them, obviously they're only seven, but I had these conversations with them after. So I think when it does air, to show them that, because obviously they don't see that side of me, to show that I am capable of doing that, and that it's okay. "They'll think it's super cool to jump off a speedboat onto a helicopter. They're going to see that mum is an action hero! I'm a single mum, so it's just me in my household. They always say mum doesn't do boy stuff but I hope when they see this and what I did I'll be like, "Yeah, you see me? I can do what boys do too.' Asked if she has learned anything from the experience, on top of all the other experiences she had had in life, she added: 'I mean, they're incredibly strong, resilient people. You don't normally meet people that are faced with the challenges and the things that they have to do. "And I guess when you listen to them and you talk to them, you realise that the things that you worry about in your everyday life really don't freaking matter. The things we're stressing about every day, they don't matter when you have people like them in the Army or SAS. What they have to go through when they are in times of war, you don't really understand that.'
Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Daily Mirror
Hollyoaks tour cancelled ahead of huge anniversary over 'low ticket sales'
The upcoming Hollyoaks Live tour has been dropped by its promoters, who are said to have 'over-estimated' the appeal for the production, which is external to the TV show A huge tour for a major TV show has been dramatically axed due to low ticket sales. Hollyoaks Live, which is an external production from the Channel 4 soap opera, was expected to hit the road, giving fans an insight into the popular programme but bosses have been forced to pull the plug. But while a string of famous faces from the show had signed on the dotted line to meet with fans, the production, which was due to take place in October, will no longer be going ahead. Soap stars including Nick Pickard, Kieron Richardson, Jorgie Porter, Gary Lucy, and Ashley Taylor Dawson were set to meet fans who had splashed out a whopping £161 for meet and greet tickets, allowing them to ask burning questions about their favourite TV show. It comes after reports Meghan Markle and Prince Harry are set for new 'goldmine' offer - but could face issue. However, sources have claimed that bosses behind the production had "overestimated" the appeal for the show, which was due to take place in Manchester, Glasgow and London, had been left with no option but to cancel the entire tour. "The promoter massively over-estimated the appeal a live stage show would have to Hollyoaks' core audience," a source said. They went on to tell The Sun: "The ticket prices were incredibly high for a show that's popular with teenagers. "The decision was made to pull the tour rather than have a loss-making venture with empty theatres." But those who purchased tickets for the events will be offered refunds at their points of purchase. It's understood that the tour was organised by an external production team, with Hollyoaks and Channel 4 having very limited involvement in the planning. A spokesperson for the tour said in a statement: "Due to unforeseen circumstances, the planned theatre events with Maple Tree Entertainment featuring Hollyoaks cast are not going to take place as planned. "We are sad to disappoint those who had purchased tickets but they will be refunded via the venues." However, it's a stark contrast for ITV soap, Coronation Street, which is going ahead with a live theatre tour. Long standing cast members from the Manhcester based soap opera will appear at theatres across the nation to discuss their time on the show, in a production which has been billed An Audience with Coronation Street. Fans will pay more than £30 with the promoters promising "behind-the-scenes secrets, share hilarious stories, and relive heart-warming moments from the iconic ITV show". Hosted by This Morning's resident soap expert, Sharon Marshall, the show promises to be filled with laughter, nostalgia, and "more than a few jaw-dropping surprises!" Each event will feature five Coronation Street stars live on stage, including a surprise Corrie legend. The line-up will vary at each venue, with fan-favourite cast members including Andrew Whyment (Kirk Sutherland), Jack P Shepherd (David Platt), Samia Longchambon (Maria Connor), and Simon Gregson (Steve McDonald), with more names to be announced soon. Additionally, former show legends will also appear on stage. The tour will start in September and includes dates in London, Sheffield, Manchester and Glasgow. Promoters say in the first half, the audience will be treated to an intimate and lively interview session with some of Corrie's most beloved cast members. Ever wondered what goes on between takes? Curious about those off-screen friendships and real-life dramas? This is your chance to hear all the gossip straight from the source. The second act will feature a Corrie legend who will appear on stage and talk about their time on the ITV show.
Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Daily Mirror
Queen Victoria's 'great, great, granddaughter' seeks DNA test and approval from King Charles
American claiming to be the result of a long love affair between the monarch and her Scottish ghillie hopes that science will prove the findings put forward by social historian Dr Fern Riddell A woman who believes she could be the illegitimate great, great grand-daughter of Queen Victoria says her ultimate goal is to gain recognition from King Charles. Angela Webb - Milinkovich, from Minnesota, thinks she and her sister have lineage which stems from Victoria's long, romantic relationship with her loyal manservant John Brown. New research from historian Dr Fern Riddell suggests that while on paper Angela's great grandmother Mary Ann was the only child of John's brother Hugh, and his wife Jessie, there is evidence suggesting the baby could actually have been the result of his love affair with the monarch, during which they were secretly married. Angela, 47, is now planning to have a DNA test as the ultimate proof of her royal heritage. She says she has no interest in making money out of the story, only in ensuring that her family's place in history gets the recognition it deserves. 'My main goal is to have the story acknowledged - I want their relationship to be recognised and for the royal family to stop saying it didn't happen," she explains. "If I'm going to reach for the top, it would have to be from King Charles,' she adds, when asked who she'd most like to hear from. 'I mean, it's a great story and it has his family involved, too. So he would be interested in it.' Or Prince William perhaps? 'That'd be great. That's acceptable,'she laughs. Angela grew up believing her family was descended from the royal line stemming from baby Mary Ann. She doesn't remember precisely when she was told this, just that they were aware of a story involving 'a big boat trip… and a baby given to the family.' Dr Riddell contacted Angela during her four years of research for new book Victoria's Secret and told her she'd discovered that childless Jessie and Hugh had emigrated to New Zealand in 1865, registering Mary Ann's birth there soon after - which might explain the boat trip. Speaking on Channel 4 in the accompanying documentary, Dr Riddell argued that widowed Victoria could easily have concealed a pregnancy in the 1860s, and then had the baby - her tenth child - spirited away to the other side of the world to avoid a scandal. It is recorded that, in 1874, Victoria paid for the trio to be brought back home to Scotland, even giving them a large house to live in on the Balmoral estate. After John's death, she also moved Hugh's family to be near her at Windsor. Angela was able to provide Dr Riddell with access to a treasure trove of new evidence from the Brown family archive, containing items and documents that have been in their possession for decades. Some of it comes from a safety deposit box opened around five years ago by Angela and her sister, who wishes to remain anonymous, following the death of their father. 'We didn't know what we had, just that they were items from John Brown and Queen Victoria,' she says now. 'It was always something in the back of our heads - we should probably get these looked at.' Despite long-held family suspicious that they were related to Queen Victoria, Angela was still shocked when Dr Fern got in contact. 'I believed my family was being truthful with it, but we could never prove it. Once she sent that message, I thought 'What the heck? Is there actually validity to this?' Angela, who works as a mental health care worker, said her goal is for the love affair, which was covered-up both during and after Victoria's lifetime, to be acknowledged as the truth. 'It's something that I'm very proud of,' she said. 'I want the vindication essentially for John Brown and just for my lineage, because they were not able to talk about it. It was something that just became that secret that we couldn't really share, but we knew.' If Dr Riddell's version of events is to be believed, and there is plenty of evidence to support it, Victoria and John enjoyed a romantic relationship lasting the best part of 20 years, until his death in 1883. As well as making reciprocated declarations of love to him on his deathbed - 'I told him no one loved him more than I did and he answered 'nor you - than me'' - she also had made a cast of his hand, just as she'd done with Albert. When her own death came in 1901, she asked to be buried with a lock of hair and photograph of the man who'd been by her side for two decades since Albert's death in 1861. Surviving letters see her calling him 'my beloved' and 'darling one'. However, on the others of her eldest son Bertie - about to be crowned Edward VII - the Palace set about erasing John from the record. Victoria's journals were copied and edited, and the originals destroyed. Bertie, who had often clashed with Brown, also ordered the statues and private memorials that Victoria had created for him to be removed. Angela's grandfather died when she was in fifth grade but she remembers him being upset about the way in which the Browns were airbrushed out of existence. 'My understanding from my Mum was that he was just really upset and bitter about it,' she explained. 'He didn't like to talk about it. Now, having both my parents and my aunt gone, we don't have those resources any more. So the bulk of the story I have been learning from Fern, which is amazing, and I'm so grateful.' Angela is optimistic about the royals eventually having to accept the validity of the claims being made about her ancestors, also shown in a Channel 4 documentary on Thursday. 'My gut says it's going to have to get acknowledged at some point,' she reasons. 'Scandals are always very exciting so I'm sure there'll be a lot of questions for them to answer. If they don't say anything, that's their choice. But I'd like them to acknowledge the truth of this love, to recognise that it wasn't cool to cover up and destroy evidence of the relationship they shared. Let's be real, Bertie was a bit of a d**k to the Browns. "That story deserves to be known, to have its own breath out there in the world. You don't get that kind of romance every day. It's what you'd hope for anybody, that you would find another chance at love. So I don't see why we should look down on that. It's like an opportunity presented itself and they embraced it, and I think that is beautiful.' Angela says she's hoping to have a DNA test to prove her ancestry, but has been warned it may take some time because of the need for perfect source material for testing across the four-generation gap. 'I'll let the scientists do the science,' she says cheerfully. 'I'm a supporting character in this journey, and so I will follow wherever the story leads me. I'm totally open to it. So far it's been so exciting, so cool. I'm just really stoked.' The tattooed American, who wears a nose-ring, insists that she's not simply trying to cash in on the royals' wealth. 'Money is the furthest thing from my goal in telling this family story. It has always been to get Queen Victoria and John Brown's story the truth it deserves.' She says she cannot think of any other reason why her family would be in possession of precious heirlooms from Victoria and John, including a brooch and lock of hair. 'Their relationship was authentic and genuine. They obviously had feelings for each other. It went well beyond a queen and man servant situation.' There was plenty of gossip at the time about the pair, played by Dame Judi Dench and Billy Connolly in the 1997 movie Mrs Brown. In 1865, after Victoria requested John's transfer to the Royal Household at Windsor, two of her daughters, Helena and Louise, openly referred to him as 'Mamma's lover'. And the following year a Swiss newspaper published a story claiming Victoria, then aged 46, had privately married John and become pregnant. Angela would be happy whether Mary Ann turns out to be John or Hugh's daughter. 'Either John Brown is my great, great uncle or he is my great, great grandpa. My family still played a key role in history with their friendship and closeness to Queen Victoria. I'm proud of their steadfastness in keeping the legacy of John Brown alive and their word to holding the secret close. It's still a beautiful romance that deserves its moment of recognition in history.' With her Scottish roots from her mother's side, Angela loves spending time in the UK whenever she can and admits she sometimes feels more British than American. 'I've always felt a little disconnected in the sense that I feel more at home over there. Scotland is my happy place. I would move there if I could, for sure.'
