Sued for R6.5 billion by Toyota insurer, KZN transport builds legal team
The floods caused Toyota to pause production for four months, resulting in a R6.5 billion loss.
The KwaZulu-Natal department of transport is assembling a legal team to navigate the R6.5 billion lawsuit filed by Toyota insurer Tokio Marine & Nichido Fire Insurance in the Durban High Court over the 2022 floods.
The floods caused significant damage at the Toyota South Africa Motors (TSAM) vehicle assembly plant in Prospecton, Durban.
Tokio Marine & Nichido Fire Insurance is claiming that the damage caused by the floods was due to negligence of the infrastructure. For this, the insurer is suing KZN transport, eThekwini municipality and Transnet SOC Limited.
ALSO READ: Toyota SA says employees won't lose jobs as operations begin after KZN floods
Toyota floods
The floods damaged the plant, forcing Toyota to pause production for four months, which allegedly resulted in the company incurring R6.5 billion in costs – R4.5 billion for repairs and R2 billion for business interruption.
MEC for transport and human settlements Siboniso Duma told journalists at a media briefing on Friday that he had engaged with Andrew Kirby, president and CEO of Toyota South Africa Motors, regarding the lawsuit and was assured that the lawsuit was not brought by Toyota, but by the insurer.
'For the record, in our engagement with Andrew Kirby, he pointed out that the litigation proceedings against the department of transport, eThekwini municipality and Transnet SOC Limited are not being facilitated and/or funded by Toyota South Africa Motors.'
Damage caused by the 2022 Durban floods at Toyota. Picture: X/Hein_The_Slayer
Toyota not to benefit
Duma said he was told that Toyota will not benefit in any way from the subrogated recovery action against the three parties being sued.
'At this stage, we wish to announce that we are assembling a strong team of legal minds to guide us on this lawsuit instituted by Tokio Marine & Nichido Fire Insurance. Therefore, we will not get into the legal technicalities and details of processes that will unfold.'
At the time of the damage, the parent company of Toyota SA called the incident 'the most comprehensive damage to one of our global production facilities as a result of a natural disaster'.
More lawsuits on the way
Craig Woolley, from Norton Rose Fulbright SA, representing the insurance company, said that more companies in the Prospecton area are taking legal action for damage caused by the floods.
The lawsuit states that by failing to maintain waterways and drainage systems that carried the floodwater, the defendants are responsible.
Damage caused by the 2022 Durban floods at Toyota. Picture: X/Hein_The_Slayer
ALSO READ: Hundreds of Toyotas destroyed, 500 survive the floods at Prospecton plant
How the parties bear responsibility
The lawsuit details how the three parties are to be blamed for the floods.
'During the April floods, the structural integrity of the Umlaas canal and the diversion berm was compromised, leading to stormwater flowing into the Prospecton industrial area where the Toyota plant is situated, causing extensive flooding and damage.
'Transnet owned the Umlaas canal and was responsible for its management, maintenance and the associated flood risk. The concrete-lined canal is intended to channel and divert the uMlazi river around the Prospecton industrial area. Together with the diversion berm, it forms an integral part of the flood control and prevention mechanism for the Prospecton industrial area.
'The Department of Transport was responsible for the management and maintenance of the diversion berm, while the municipality owned, managed, and was responsible for the maintenance and control of the stormwater management system for the Prospecton Industrial Area.'
Toyota shares its point of view
The Prospecton plant builds the Hilux bakkie, Fortuner SUV, Quest and Corolla Cross cars, as well as HiAce minibuses and Hino trucks and buses. About half of the production is exported, mainly to Europe.
NOW READ: KZN flood damage to dent auto industry's contribution to economy
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
TimesLIVE
an hour ago
- TimesLIVE
Tanak secures first win of the season for Hyundai in Greece
Estonian Ott Tanak took Hyundai's first win of the season in Greece's Acropolis Rally on Sunday despite a gearbox scare in the final stage. The victory on the rough gravel roads and in sweltering heat also ended Toyota's unbeaten run with Sebastien Ogier, winner of the previous two rounds, finishing second and 32.8 seconds behind. Hyundai's Adrien Fourmaux completed the podium. Tanak closed the gap on Toyota's championship leader Elfyn Evans, who finished fourth, to 12 points. Ogier, who is running a part-time campaign, is nine points behind his teammate. 'I was very worried, to be honest,' Tanak said of the final gearbox drama. 'In the last stage, third gear got very noisy and I understood that this one broke. 'Soon, the whole gearbox got very noisy and we didn't have much confidence that we would finish the stage and get back here. It was definitely far too much stress to win a rally.'
The Citizen
a day ago
- The Citizen
Lexus GX: Prado's fancy cousin not too larny for a street fight
The 3.5-litre V6 petrol engine from the Toyota Land Cruiser 300 gives this SUV serious oomph. As great as the latest Toyota Land Cruiser Prado is, there is no scope for greater performance in the seven-seater SUV. Only sold locally in GD-6 2.8-litre turbodiesel guise, the customary outputs of 150kW of power and 500Nm of torque it shares with the Hilux and Fortuner without 48V assistance is as good as it is going to get. The 2.4-litre turbo petrol engine that produces 207kW/430Nm, and 243kW/630Nm with mild hybrid assistance, that is offered in other markets, is off-limits to the Southern tip of Africa. Lexus GX finally in Mzansi But that gap has now been bridged by not Toyota but rather Lexus, the Japanese carmaker's premium division. In existence for over two decades but only introduced locally in April, the Lexus GX is the Prado's private school cousin in the same way the Lexus LX is to the Land Cruiser 300. The Lexus brand is operated separately from Toyota, but hardware is shared across model ranges and the GX is in essence a punchy, premium Prado at a very respectable price. There is no mistaking the Toyota Land Cruiser Prado from the Lexus GX in terms of styling. The GX features aggressive and sharp lines along with the very Lexus-like front grille which is a real head-turner. Built on the TNGA-F platform like the Prado and Land Cruiser 300, the Lexus GX drops the former's 2.8-litre diesel mill for the latter's peach of a 3.5-litre V6 twin-turbo petrol engine. It is also hooked up to 10-speed automatic like in the LC300 and produces 650Nm of torque, although power is slightly down from 305kW to 260kW. The game-changer. Picture: Jaco van der Merwe Boulevard vs bush The Citizen Motoring tested the Lexus GX 550 SE. It is the more 'boulevard' model alongside the bush-ready GX 550 Overtrail. At R1 829 000, the SE comes at a R343 700 premium over the VX-R Prado. This sticker makes it an enticing offering as buyers would have gladly forked out the difference for the V6 mill in a Prado, nevermind the additional luxury the Lexus badge brings to the table. We did not run the new Prado against the clock as both the lighter 2.8-litre Hilux and Fortuner failed to reach 100km/h from a standstill in under 12 seconds without 48V assistance. But even if we are generous and gives the Prado a sprint time of 12 seconds, it pales in comparison to the Lexus GX's impressive time of 7.68 seconds. This just 0.86 seconds slower than the LC300 fared and exactly why the engine will be such drawing card for the GX. The six-cylinder soundtrack on offer in Sport S+ driving mode under hard acceleration proves that this privately schooled cousin is up for any street fight should the opportunity arise. It might be down on power on the LC300, it has ample low-down pull which along with the generous torque makes it feel faster than it is. ALSO READ: Lexus GX shows its credentials as more than just a 'fancy' Prado Smooth ride Like the LC300, the Lexus GX can prove to be rather thirsty leaving it in Sport+ for too long, which will make you consider trying the other driving on offer; Eco, Normal, Comfort, Sport and Custom. The Lexus GX 550 SE rides on 22-inch alloys. Picture: Jaco van der Merwe The ride is every bit as refined as you'd come to expect in a Lexus, with the 10-speed box exceptionally smooth. While the SE does not feature all the hard-core off-road feature as the Overtrail, standard permanent all-wheel drive with low-range transfer case and Adaptive Variable Suspension should put you in good stead on the pavement in Sandton. ALSO READ: Butch or bling? Lexus LX gets bush alongside boulevard SUVs Superior craftsmanship While the Prado features a very plush interior, in Toyota terms anyway, the Lexus GX raises the bar even further by means of the brand's renowned Japanese craftsmanship. Our tester's cabin featured a combination of semi-aniline black leather with contrast stitching, black wood veneer, brushed aluminium touches and soft-touch rubber. The Lexus GX features a different dashboard to that of the Prado which includes a new housing for the 14-inch infotainment system and 12.3-inch digital cluster with Apple Carplay and Android Auto. The GX SE further comes standard with 22-inch alloy wheels, heated steering wheel, front seats massagers, head-up display, heated and ventilated front seats, wireless phone charger, refrigerated centre console cooler box, electric tailgate, rear roller blind, panoramic sunroof and 21-speaker Mark Levinson sound system. The cabin features trademark Lexus craftsmanship. Picture: Jaco van der Merwe Enticing offering The latest Safety Sense system features all the advanced safety goodies to keep occupants safe along with the standard systems. The introduction of the Lexus GX is a masterstroke and it's easy to see why it instantly became the best-selling local Lexus in ages. It offers just the right amount of oomph to place it in a different league to the Prado, while bringing all the Lexus goodies to the table for less than a Land Cruiser 300. And for the same price, you can only get an entry-level Land Rover Defender 90, which is according to Lexus the GX's biggest rival. Lexus GX 550 road test data
The Citizen
3 days ago
- The Citizen
‘New' Toyota Hilux spied again as reported 2026 debuts gets closer
Based on the latest and previous images, the Hilux won't be an all-new model, but reportedly the most extensive update handed to the current generation. 'Next generation' Toyota Hilux has been spied, once again, ahead of its reported world debut in 2026. Image: Toyota With little having emerged since the uncovering of first spy images back in January, the incoming 'next generation' Toyota Hilux has made its second appearance ahead of its supposed unveiling in 2026. Not entire new Spotted undergoing testing in Thailand where principle production takes place, the series of images, posted on social media on Wednesday (25 June), shows the still heavily disguised Hilux sporting what appears to be new headlights and a restyled grille, as well as a new front bumper. ALSO READ: This is it: 'New' Toyota Hilux emerges in first spy images At the rear, new vertical taillights clusters, seemingly identical to those of the Volkswagen Amarok, feature, along with what appears to be a new bumper with an integrated step. Same same Set to adopt the Hilux Travo name in Thailand based on the discovery of a trademark submission at the beginning of the year, the latest images by the Kurdistan_Automotive_Blog on Instagram, doesn't provide any technical details of what is believed to be another facelift of the current AN110 Hilux than a completely new model. Sporting the same silhouette as the AN110 that debuted a decade ago, the apparent most extensive refresh in its prolonged lifecycle is unlikely to result in any new powertrains, meaning the retention of the venerable 2.8 GD-6 turbodiesel engine possibly with and without the 48-volt mild-hybrid system. Set to remain on the IMV platform rather than moving to the TNGA-F that underpins the Land Cruiser Prado, Land Cruiser 300, Tacoma, Tundra, Sequoia, Lexus GX and LX, reports from Australia have, however, alleged that the Hilux could possibly receive the eight-speed automatic from the former, though this remains unconfirmed at present. Possible changes Its foundation, currently also used by the Fortuner and Hilux Champ/Rangga likely to be updated, the Hilux's interior will suggestively also undergo a series of revisions to offset its age, of which the exact extent remains unclear. Current AN110 generation Hilux has been on-sale globally since 2015. Image: Toyota Speculatively, these are likely to consist of upgraded materials, a new dashboard housing a bigger infotainment display, and possibly a fully digital instrument cluster on higher-end derivatives. More before 2026? '[Hilux] is extremely important to us as a business and a company. It is the most important vehicle we manufacture and sell… it is our core model,' Toyota South Africa Motors President and CEO, Andrew Kirby, told The Citizen on the sidelines of the Land Cruiser Prado's launch in Mozambique last year. '[The next generation] will have exciting features and upgrades I think our customers will enjoy,'. Rumoured back in 2023 as being inline for unveiling in 2025, expectations are that the Hilux will possibly debut early next year before arriving in key markets throughout 2026. Despite no clear details being known at present, expect more, and additional spy images, to emerge throughout the remainder of the year. NOW READ: Longer wait: Next Toyota Hilux and Fortuner now only due in 2026
