Is Canada now free of internal trade barriers? Not yet, says expert
But anyone expecting all of them to be gone by tomorrow should read the fine print, experts say.
Throughout the spring federal election campaign, Mark Carney as Liberal leader repeatedly vowed to "eliminate" interprovincial trade barriers and create "free trade by Canada Day."
The rhetoric has been at times confusing and the political scorecard on this one is hard to track.
With July 1 just a day away, Carney's government has passed its planned changes into law — but it's more like the start of a conversation than the final word, says internal trade expert Ryan Manucha.
"It's a starting gun and it's starting a lot more activity and work, which is honestly the really exciting part," said Manucha. "If any of this was easy, it would have been done."
Manucha writes on the topic for the Macdonald-Laurier Institute think-tank and authored the book Booze, Cigarettes, and Constitutional Dust-Ups: Canada's Quest for Interprovincial Trade.
"When I'm advising governments, I say, 'Don't think of this as a light switch,"' he said. "We are changing the way that everyone approaches the concept of regulation and risk here, and so it's going to take some time."
The rush to break down internal barriers to trade comes in response to U.S. President Donald Trump's tariff war with Canada. One study estimates that existing internal trade hurdles cost the economy some $200 billion a year.
Manucha said Canada has talked about this problem for decades but is only addressing it seriously now — and it would "never have happened had we not had Trump."
He said the introduction of the Carney government's bill on internal trade was "incredible to see" because the idea was just "an academic theory maybe even as little as eight months ago."
Bill C-5, the omnibus bill that reduces federal restrictions on interprovincial trade and also speeds up permitting for large infrastructure projects, became law on June 26.
An analysis of the law by McMillan Vantage says that "this legislation would not achieve" the elimination of all internal trade barriers.
Provinces hold power
When Carney made his campaign promise, he was talking about cutting red tape put up by the federal government — not the rules set by the provinces, which have the most authority in this area.
The prime minister described this effort as a sort of quid pro quo with the provinces.
"We're getting rid of a bunch of duplicative federal regulations. We're going to have a principle of one project, one review — and in exchange, they're going to agree to eliminate all the barriers to trade and labour mobility," Carney said at a rally in Kitchener, Ont., on March 26.
"The federal government committed that we will sweep away all of our impediments by Canada Day. Free trade by Canada Day."
WATCH | Why are provincial trade barriers still a thing?
Why are provincial trade barriers still a thing?
5 months ago
Duration 7:10
More interprovincial trade is being touted as one potential countermeasure to U.S. President Donald Trump's tariff threats, but complicated barriers stand in the way. CBC's Ellen Mauro breaks down why free trade within Canada is so difficult and what needs to happen to get more goods flowing across the country.
But Canada's internal trade barriers won't all be eliminated by then — not even all the federal ones.
Canada's supply management system for dairy products, which sets provincial production quotas, will remain in place. Quebec also retains language requirements that will stay in place.
Credit unions have complained that the new law does not break down barriers to their expansion into multiple provinces.
But just how many federal barriers does the bill eliminate? That's hard to sort out. A lot of the details will have to wait until regulations are drafted — a process that will involve consultations with affected industries.
"I don't really know what this legislation could end up doing because a lot of veto power, a lot of discretion still rests with the regulatory authorities," Manucha said.
"According to the text of that legislation, it would seem like meat inspection would come off. Is [the Canadian Food Inspection Agency] really going to allow for interprovincial trade and inspection of meat coming from non-federally licensed abattoirs? I don't know."
Lack of consensus
There is no comprehensive list of existing internal trade barriers. Even some lobby groups have told parliamentarians they don't know how many barriers their own industries face.
There isn't even consensus on what all counts as a trade barrier.
"In the provincial legislation in Ontario, they're talking, for many occupations, [of] having a 30-day service standard for how long it'll take for credentials to be recognized," Manucha said. "Nova Scotia, meanwhile, is on the 10-day turnaround time. That's less than a third. Can you call the 30-day versus 10-day a trade barrier?"
Internal Trade Minister Chrystia Freeland, who has repeatedly stated that most of the barriers are at the provincial level, testified to the Senate that she will meet with her provincial counterparts on July 8 to discuss next steps.
One major obstacle is in Freeland's crosshairs: Canada's patchwork of interprovincial trucking regulations.
"One of three areas that I will be putting on the agenda at that meeting is trucking," she said on June 16. "It should be a lot easier than it is to drive a truck from Halifax to Vancouver. We need to get rid of conflicting requirements."
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


CBC
28 minutes ago
- CBC
American behind pro-Canada rallies says 'most Canadian thing ever'... 'we're sorry' about Trump
Kate Powers "felt shame" when she first heard U.S. President Donald Trump talking about annexing Canada. Powers said she was born and raised in western New York in the Buffalo-Niagara Falls area. "Growing up, Canada was the backyard [with] trips to Toronto, trips to the Shaw Festival, trips to Stratford, family vacations in cottage country up on Georgian Bay," Powers told CBC Hamilton. "So, the idea to me that the president of the United States would get to a place where he would say we're going to annex Canada as the 51st state, to me is appalling. And I felt shame when I heard him first start talking this way." Powers is a co-organizer of a series of rallies from the Pacific to the Atlantic, from Alaska to Vermont to London, England, celebrating the longstanding friendship between the United States and Canada. Known as the 'Elbows Up for Canada' movement, the rally organizers represent a coalition of American and Canadian advocacy groups. Rallies are planned for July 5, including in Buffalo, N.Y. and Detroit, Mich. Powers said people with some small "grassroots groups" in Windsor, Ont., and in Ottawa will be participating in the rallies. One of the rallies is actually going to be sort of in the middle of the St. Lawrence River … so, folks in Canoes and kayaks and paddle boards from the United States and Canada are going to meet up just in the river across from Prescott, Ont.," she said. "They'll be at the great Canadian flag right down by the water in Windsor, and then there will be an event in Detroit directly across from them." 'Citizens on both sides want to build bridges, not walls' "In an era when division seems to dominate headlines, we want to show that the spirit of friendship and cooperation is alive and well along our shared border," Detroit-based co-organizer Audrey Bourriaud said. "These rallies prove that ordinary citizens on both sides want to build bridges, not walls." Powers gave credit to "the women in Quebec who made the human chain in February to oppose fascism," for the initial inspiration for the rallies. "I turned to my husband and I said we should do that across one of the bridges in Niagara Falls," she said. On Trump's so-called 'Liberation Day,' on April 2, when "he was announcing all of these arbitrary and capricious tariffs," Powers said the first "counter programming" rally was held in the shadow of the Peace Bridge in Buffalo. She said dozens of people turned out in "freezing rain [and] howling wind" to stand in solidarity with Canada. "We waved our flags and we sang the Canadian National anthem as loud as we could for them, although I'm sure they couldn't hear it across the river," Powers said. We want our Canadian friends to know that we're still friends, that regardless of the vitriol coming out of the White House, the predatory threats, that we love and respect Canada as a sovereign nation. Powers said the upcoming rallies have several goals. "The first one is to say to you … to everybody in Canada, the most Canadian thing ever — to say we're sorry," she said. "I know a lot of Canadians are hurt, are angry, are frustrated, are scared, and I don't blame them. It's important to me that folks understand that there's more than 300 million people in the United States and only 70 million people voted for Donald Trump … and a lot of us are just appalled and we are doing everything we can, but we do feel like we're dancing in quicksand right now around a lot of issues. "We want our Canadian friends to know that we're still friends, that regardless of the vitriol coming out of the White House, the predatory threats, that we love and respect Canada as a sovereign nation," Powers added. Additionally, Powers said Americans in general have not forgotten the numerous times that Canada has shown up for the U.S. as a good neighbour. "We are grateful to Canada for the ways that it has shown up for us at Normandy during the Civil War, after [the] September 11 [terrorist attacks], to fight the fires in California earlier this year," she said. "We respect your sovereignty, we respect the long-standing relationship and we understand that the trust has been broken and we're going to work to repair it. "We really want to counter the narrative that it's the most natural thing ever that the United States should annex Canada or, like he said earlier this week, that Canada is a nasty country to negotiate with. We know that that's not true, so we want to counter that narrative, and if we cannot reach him, we want to at least reach all of the governors on the northern border of the United States to say we might need to make our own arrangements with Canada," added Powers. In June, five Canadian premiers, including Ontario's Doug Ford, visited Boston at the invitation of some northeastern U.S. governors to try to forge alliances against Trump's tariffs. Ford was joined by fellow premiers Tim Houston of Nova Scotia, Susan Holt of New Brunswick, Rob Lantz of P.E.I. and John Hogan of Newfoundland and Labrador for a day of meetings at Massachusetts State House with the governors of seven states or their delegates. Speaking to reporters while in the U.S., Ford said he'd spoken to leaders from around the world who are "dumbfounded" by Trump's rhetoric. "We're in disbelief too, but now we're going to build forward," he said. Earlier this year, Canadians across the country were boycotting American products and cancelling vacations plans to the U.S. Those sentiments may not be as potent now, but for many the sentiment lingers. Yao Ameyaw told CBC News he's still avoiding spending money south of the border.


Global News
29 minutes ago
- Global News
Carney meets with auto sector as Trump's trade war stretches on
Prime Minister Mark Carney is meeting with the heads of the Canadian auto industry as concerns mount over the ongoing impact of tariffs imposed by the U.S. The industry has been facing a 25 per cent tariff from the U.S. on the sector itself, as well as a 50 per cent duty on steel and aluminum, materials used in the manufacturing of vehicles. However, there are exceptions for components produced in the U.S. Carney will be meeting with representatives from the Canadian Vehicle Manufacturing Association, Ford Canada, Stellantis Canada and GM Canada during the talks on Wednesday. 5:31 Steel and aluminum measures announced to counter U.S. tariffs Brian Kingston, president and CEO of the Canadian Vehicle Manufacturing Association, told reporters in brief comments while heading into the meeting that electric vehicle mandates under current targets, as well as a range of other policies, are 'not sustainable.' Story continues below advertisement U.S. President Donald Trump has claimed for months that the U.S. does not need any Canadian-made vehicles, and called on automakers to shift all production to the U.S. Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy Canada has imposed retaliatory duties on the U.S. Trump and Carney are currently negotiating a trade deal with a July 21 target date. It's not known at this time how wide a scope a potential deal could cover. What's the impact of the tariffs so far? The impact has been felt in Canada, with a report released in April by Ontario's financial accountability officer stating the province — which houses a large part of Canada's auto industry — could enter a 'modest' recession due to the tariffs. The report found the impact of those tariffs would slow Ontario's growth in 2025 and could lead to a modest recession this year, while remaining slow in 2026, though growth would return to just over one per cent. Story continues below advertisement Rising unemployment numbers in April also indicated the impact tariffs were having on the economy. Ontario saw the biggest loss in April, with 35,000 jobs lost, mostly in the manufacturing sector. Global News reached out to various automakers and organizations that represent them, as well as Unifor, which represents autoworkers, to inquire how many jobs have been lost as a result of tariffs. In statements to Global News, both Stellantis and General Motors said no job losses have occurred due to tariffs. The Global Automakers of Canada, which represents Toyota and Honda, also said there have been no job losses at this time. Ford, the Canadian Vehicle Manufacturers Association and Unifor did not respond by publication. — with files from The Canadian Press


Winnipeg Free Press
29 minutes ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Ottawa must pass a law revoking digital service tax before refunds are issued: CRA
OTTAWA – The Canada Revenue Agency says taxpayers who already paid the now-defunct digital services tax will have to wait for Ottawa to pass new legislation before they can get their refund. Prime Minister Mark Carney announced late Sunday that, in a bid to restart trade negotiations with the United States, Canada was dropping the tax on global tech giants. The first payment was due Monday and could have cost American companies like Amazon and Uber billions of dollars. A CRA spokesperson says the agency already collected some revenue from the digital services tax before Ottawa's reversal but didn't cite an amount. MPs are now on their summer break and the spokesperson says they'll need to pass legislation formally revoking the tax when Parliament returns in order for taxpayers to get their money back. The CRA waived the requirement for taxpayers to file a DST return ahead of the June 30 deadline and will not ask for any related payments in the meantime. Monday Mornings The latest local business news and a lookahead to the coming week. — With files from Anja Karadeglija This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 2, 2025.