
Some health services would collapse if 'insourcing' ended overnight, HSE head says
The discussion followed publication on Tuesday of a HSE report showing almost €100m was spent in just 27 months on this funding.
It is given by the National Treatment Purchase Fund (NTPF) to hospitals for reducing waiting lists. However questions have arisen over how this is used, including at Children's Health Ireland.
HSE CEO Bernard Gloster said he now expects this funding will be eased out by June 30 next year. He told the committee he asked about the impact of ceasing these payments overnight.
'The system came back to me and said 'if we were to do that in the way you've asked right now, these are the following services that will collapse today,'' he said.
He expanded on how enmeshed the top-up funding is in the HSE in response to Senator Teresa Costello.
'There's only one way you can change the culture of dependency on insourcing and that's to end it, that's it, there's no other way to do it,' he said. "You have to end it sensibly and over time.'
Staff, he stressed, only did what they were asked as until recently there were few questions asked. He acknowledged this is a failure of governance.
Answering questions from Fianna Fáil TD Padraig O'Sullivan, he accepted extra clinics funded by the NTPF offer attractive pay rates to staff involved.
'In the level of the scale of it, I think we took our eye off the ball,' the CEO said.
It is very difficult to ask a nurse or anyone else to do ordinary overtime on a Saturday when the possibility now exists that in a different construct, they can get paid much more significantly.
The report shows the HSE is giving notice they will not renew or enter in contracts with external providers of insourcing care. Any agreements between now and June need to be approved item by item by hospital CEOs.
The report warns of potential impacts including conflicts of interest, non-compliance with HSE procurement rules and risk of abuse or fraud among other issues.
Out of 950 companies involved, the bulk is done by 50 larger companies, HSE CFO Stephen Mulvany, told Sinn Féin health spokesman David Cullinane.
Some 534 work in hospitals, other clinics mentioned included offering Assessment of Need in the disability sector.
'Perverse incentives'
Mr Cullinane asked about 'perverse incentives' and links between the HSE and these external companies.
Analysis of directors in 148 companies found 83 staff with links to the HSE or health bodies funded by the HSE under Section 38 arrangements, including some serving staff, Mr Gloster explained.
NTPF CEO Fiona Brady defended its oversight processes. She said she is not aware of problems identified by Beaumont Hospital being replicated in other hospitals. A HSE internal audit team has been examining that issue since April, she confirmed to Labour health spokeswoman Marie Sherlock.
Mr Gloster also said in the case of University Hospital Limerick (UHL), insourcing funding has helped patients.
He told Senator Maria Byrne: 'The weighted average (waiting) time in UHL is below the national average, which is a really significant achievement - because it is the time people are waiting. And you can say ok there was in-sourcing involved in that but at least there was a return.'
Regional executive director for the HSE Midwest, Sandra Broderick, said they have made funding requests to hire more specialist consultants to address these waiting lists internally.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Widow settles case against HSE over death of husband (44)
Our Lady of Lourdes hospital breached its duty of care to a 44-year-old man who died two weeks after he was allegedly wrongly discharged from the Co Louth hospital, the High Court has heard. Simon Sherry (44), late of Edenburt, Virginia, died at Cavan General Hospital in August 2019 after developing a severe urinary tract infection and subsequent heart infection, about two weeks after he was allegedly wrongly discharged from Our Lady of Lourdes, Drogheda, without a doctor's certification. Mr Justice Paul Coffey was told on Friday that Fiona Sherry, Mr Sherry's widow, had settled her case against the HSE over his death for a 'substantial' sum. Outlining Ms Sherry's case, her senior counsel Dr John O'Mahony, instructed by Hussey Fraser solicitors, said a breach of duty of care to Mr Sherry occurred at Our Lady of Lourdes, resulting in his death. READ MORE Court documents show that a letter of apology was sent to Mr Sherry's family on behalf of the Our Lady of Lourdes, acknowledging deficiencies in care that led to his death, and apologising. Dr O'Mahony said Mr Sherry was admitted to Our Lady of Lourdes on August 4th, 2019, suffering with significant back pain and fever. Mr Sherry was diagnosed with a urinary tract infection, and antibiotics were proscribed. Counsel said Mr Sherry was discharged after two days in hospital, and added that his discharge was allegedly not certified by a doctor. Dr O'Mahony said the 'flagrant breach' of duty of care was Mr Sherry's discharge from Our Lady of Lourdes when he was still unwell. It was Ms Sherry's case that it was clear her husband should not have been discharged. Following this discharge, Ms Sherry's case contended that Mr Sherry developed urosepsis, a severe urinary tract infection, which gave rise to an abscess developing on his kidney. He ultimately developed endocarditis, an inflammation of the lining of the heart, which led to his death at Cavan General Hospital on August 23rd, 2019, the case contended. Mr Justice Paul Coffey approved the division of €35,000 in statutory mental distress payment between members of Mr Sherry's family, and extended his sympathies to them.


Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Whistleblowers lodge 67 valid HSE disclosures, with a third about patient health and safety
There were 67 valid protected disclosures made to the Health Service Executive last year, of which more than a third related to the alleged 'endangerment of health and safety' of patients or service users. On Friday, the HSE published its 2024 annual report, which found there were 135 protected disclosures received by the executive last year, up 38 per cent when compared with 2023. A total of 67 disclosures were deemed to be 'valid'. Of these, 26 were closed over the 12-month period and 41 are 'still under examination'. More than 80 per cent of disclosures were made by HSE employees, with the remainder coming from Section 38/39 workers who were not HSE employees. READ MORE A total of 37 per cent of disclosures related to the endangerment of health and safety, 15 (22 per cent) related primarily to alleged unlawful or improper use of funds, with a further 15 relating to 'oppressive, discriminatory or behaviour that constitutes gross misconduct by a public body'. The responsible area that had the highest number of disclosures was HSE Dublin and Midlands with 15, followed by HSE Dublin and North East at 12 and HSE Dublin and South East at 10. According to the annual report, Ireland's population grew by approximately 100,000 people last year, reaching 5.38 million. The number of people aged 65 and over has increased by 37 per cent since 2015 and life expectancy now stands at 82.6 years – above the EU average. As a result of the ageing population, the burden of chronic disease and cancer 'remains high, particularly among older adults'. The report highlighted a number of areas in which services have improved, including a reduction in waiting times for elective procedures as well as fewer people on trolleys. However, it also acknowledged the provision of disability services as a key challenging area for the health service. 'A major priority for the HSE is to significantly improve access for children and families to services,' the report said. 'There is still much to do to significantly improve access when needed, particularly for children and young people.' [ Opinion: Nobody wants to stay in hospital longer than necessary. There's a better way to handle patient discharge Opens in new window ] Speaking about the annual report, HSE chief executive Bernard Gloster said last year marked 'real progress'. 'We reduced the number of people waiting on trolleys by over 10 per cent, expanded community services and improved access to scheduled care with an additional 24,000 patients seen within target time frames,' he said. 'Our focus in 2025 will be to build on this momentum, improve patient flow and continue to reform how care is delivered across seven days.' [ HSE aims to bring in new weekend work rosters for healthcare staff over summer Opens in new window ]


Irish Daily Mirror
5 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
HSE paid supplier €723,000 twice in 2021 and has not recovered overpayment
The HSE paid a supplier €723,000 twice and has not recovered the overpayment according to the State auditor. The double payment was made by two different areas of the HSE on separate financial systems operating in December 2021, which was not cross-checked. The Comptroller and Auditor General Seamus McCarthy said the HSE disclosed the payment and set out actions to avoid such a situation in the future. "The HSE acknowledges there were weaknesses in controls, particularly, in relation to appropriate goods receipting protocols," Mr McCarthy said in an assessment attached to the HSE's annual report and financial statements for 2024. "The statement on internal control sets out the actions taken by the Health Service Executive to avoid similar circumstances recurring in the future." He said a single integrated financial system, which was due to go live at the start of this month, would "significantly reduce the risk of this kind of overpayment occurring in the future". Mr McCarthy also highlighted that €4.1 million due to the HSE was lost last year by missing deadlines by which it could claim charges for patients covered by a health insurer. A memorandum of agreement with the health insurer in 2016 sees the HSE paid 70 per cent of its charges for a patient stay, on account, if it makes its submission and validation within a 12-month period of a fully completed claim. If it does not meet that deadline, it must pay for all of the costs. "For a sample of eight hospitals examined on audit, it was noted that losses incurred in 2024 as a result of delays in submitting completed claims amounted to €2 million," Mr McCarthy said. "The Executive estimates that losses for the remaining hospitals it manages were €2.1 million, resulting in an estimated total loss of €4.1 million for 2024." The HSE's annual report indicated there was a 10 per cent reduction in the number of people waiting on trolleys in emergency departments last year. Over 108,000 people were recorded on trolleys in emergency departments last year, amid an 8 per cent increase in the total number of people attending and a rise of 7 per cent in admissions to emergency departments. HSE chief executive Bernard Gloster said one of the most "challenging" aspects for the HSE was wait times for healthcare, and said tackling "unacceptably long" waits in emergency departments was an area of focus. HSE CEO Bernard Gloster (Image: Gareth Chaney/Collins) The HSE annual report for 2024 analyses the health service's performance and health trends among Irish people. "Addressing waiting lists for scheduled care and unacceptably long waits in emergency departments (EDs) remains a priority focus area, especially for older people and those with complex needs," Mr Gloster said in the foreword. "My plan for 2025 is to continue to bring trolley numbers down and to improve how our health and social care system works across seven days to allow consistent access to care." Requests for assessments of need for children spiked by 26 per cent last year compared to a year previous, and were 33 per cent above expected demand in 2024. There were 8,400 such requests in 2023 and more than 10,600 in 2024, in figures which had previously been shared by Children's Minister Norma Foley in the Dail. Norma Foley (Image: Gareth Chaney/Collins Photos) Although there was a slight uptake on the measles, mumps, rubella (MMR) vaccine compared to the previous year, the 89.9 per cent figure was below the target for 2024. The chairman of the HSE's board, Ciaran Devane, said in an introductory statement to the report that Ireland's population is ageing "faster than that of any other country in the EU". Since 2015, the number of people aged 65 years and over has increased by 37 per cent. Although life expectancy in Ireland, at 82.6 years, is ahead of the EU average, the burden of cancer is higher and accounts for a quarter of all deaths of those aged over 65. Mr Gloster, who is to step down from his role in March 2026, said 2024 was a year of "real progress". "We reduced the number of people waiting on trolleys by over 10 per cent, expanded community services and improved access to scheduled care with an additional 24,000 patients seen within target timeframes. "Our focus in 2025 will be to build on this momentum, improve patient flow and continue to reform how care is delivered across seven days." Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here.