Bid to increase number of homes at controversial Aberdour housing site approved
Cala Homes and Hillside School now have permission to build 186 houses, alongside a new school campus, on the corner of Main Street and Mill Farm Road.
The fresh bid follows the previous approval of 125 houses on appeal to the Scottish Government.
They were originally turned down by councillors following 350 local objections.
Members of Fife Council's west and central planning committee shared many of the residents' concerns.
They fear the development will negatively affect Aberdour, and could lead to traffic congestion.
The effect of extra traffic on a 'nasty' junction near the development site was also raised.
However, councillors were told using those reasons to refuse the application would not stand up if the developer appealed.
Approval will now allow Hillside School to move out of the B-listed Hillside House and into purpose-built accommodation.
The plans also include a mix of three, four and five-bedroom homes, 46 of them affordable.
However, they will cover a 15% smaller area than the previous proposal.
Planning officer Scott Simpson said the site has sufficient capacity to increase the number of homes.
And he added: 'It would integrate well within the existing Aberdour settlement.'
Some concerns remain, however.
Conservative councillor Dave Dempsey's attempt to force the developer to improve the concerning junction was rejected.
However, members have agreed to attach an advisory note to the planning permission saying construction traffic should not use the A921 to enter the site.
Cala Homes will also have to pay £179,000 towards the cost of temporary accommodation at Aberdour Primary School.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Record
8 hours ago
- Daily Record
Appeal lodged against Renfrewshire Council's decision to refuse plans for service station in Lochwinnoch
The proposal for a pit stop on land adjacent to the A737 and Roadhead Roundabout was rejected in March. An appeal has been lodged against Renfrewshire Council's decision to refuse plans for a roadside services next to a roundabout in Lochwinnoch. The proposal for a pit stop – consisting of a petrol station, electric vehicle charging points and a coffee shop – on land adjacent to the A737 and Roadhead Roundabout was rejected in March. Elected members agreed with a recommendation from the chief planning officer to turn down an application for planning permission at a meeting of the planning and climate change policy board. But Ferguson Planning, working on behalf of EG on the Move, has now challenged the ruling to the Scottish Government, arguing the project would comply with the relevant policies of the development plan. A statement said: "The proposal is for essential infrastructure that is required within this green belt location due to the need to be located on the strategic road network. "The proposed development is of an appropriate scale for a facility of this type and would not have a significant visual impact on the green belt. "The proposed development would primarily serve the existing traffic on the A737 and seeks to support the greater provision of electric vehicle charging facilities, supporting the transition to electric vehicles as part of a net-zero economy. "The proposed development is accessible by a range of sustainable transport modes, has safe walking, wheeling and cycling connections to and from Lochwinnoch, which can be improved through developer contributions if necessary and proportionate. "The proposal is, therefore, considered in accordance with the relevant adopted policies of the statutory development plan and supported by other material considerations. "Scottish ministers are respectfully requested to allow the appeal and grant planning permission." The council previously outlined the reasons for its decision, including that it was not demonstrated the proposal was an "acceptable green belt use" or that there were safe walking, wheeling and cycle connections to and from the site. Additionally, it was argued the location and scale of the development would increase dependency on car travel, which was deemed contrary to policy seeking to address the climate emergency through a spatial strategy that helps cut emissions. In its response to the appeal last month, the council added: "The content of the council's report of handling and the subsequent reasons for refusal as set out in both the report and decision notice remain the council's position on the application and from review, it is not considered that the information and case presented as part of this appeal (including any new and additional supporting information) changes this position in any way." A letter was also sent by Lochwinnoch councillors Andy Doig, Chris Gilmour, Gillian Graham and Emma Rodden to the Scottish Government last week, setting out their opposition to the appeal. It said: "The site under consideration is green belt and development of a filling station, with associated amenities, would increase traffic on a part of the A737 whose infrastructure is sub-standard. This would undermine steps towards a just transition. "In terms of local living, the nearby village of Lochwinnoch is a conservation village with a thriving independent retail sector that lends itself to local living. "Local people can already access a range of local services and do not need corporate branded outlets that sell ultra-processed food. "To allow a filling station and associated amenities at this site would militate against the core principle of rebalanced development. "Contrary to what the applicants say there are other petrol outlets between Johnstone and Beith and with over 60 objectors to the application there is no local demand." A reporter has been appointed to determine the appeal and the planning and environmental appeals division has confirmed a target date of August 28.
Leader Live
a day ago
- Leader Live
Preferred candidate for chairman of Climate Change Committee announced
The chairman plays a key role in the committee's work of advising ministers on climate targets and reporting to Parliament on progress made in reducing greenhouse gas emissions. The UK Government, Scottish Government, Welsh Government and Northern Ireland Executive all agreed on Mr Topping as the preferred candidate for the CCC role, Mr Miliband said on Friday. Before any formal appointment, Mr Topping will be questioned by MPs on the energy and environmental audit select committees on July 16. Mr Topping is currently a member of the Climate Change Committee and previously held the position of the UK's high-level climate action champion. Following an 18-year private sector career in emerging markets and manufacturing, he worked as executive director of the Carbon Disclosure Project and chief executive of the We Mean Business Coalition. If approved, Mr Topping will replace interim chairman Piers Forster, a leading climate scientist who succeeded former environment secretary Lord Deben in the role in 2023. Mr Miliband said: 'I am delighted to announce the preferred candidate for chair of the Climate Change Committee – Nigel Topping will bring his extensive experience to this role, having already served on the Climate Change Committee for more than two years and as a UN Climate Change High Level Champion for Cop26. 'The CCC plays a vital role advising the UK and devolved governments on our climate targets and this announcement comes at a crucial time, as we deliver our mission to make Britain a clean energy superpower with good jobs, energy security and growth for the British people. 'Net zero is the economic opportunity of the 21st century and Nigel's strong business background will help us drive growth on the transition to net zero, unlocking opportunities for Britain. 'I look forward to progressing the appointment in the coming weeks along with ministers in the devolved governments.'
South Wales Guardian
a day ago
- South Wales Guardian
Preferred candidate for chairman of Climate Change Committee announced
The chairman plays a key role in the committee's work of advising ministers on climate targets and reporting to Parliament on progress made in reducing greenhouse gas emissions. The UK Government, Scottish Government, Welsh Government and Northern Ireland Executive all agreed on Mr Topping as the preferred candidate for the CCC role, Mr Miliband said on Friday. Before any formal appointment, Mr Topping will be questioned by MPs on the energy and environmental audit select committees on July 16. Mr Topping is currently a member of the Climate Change Committee and previously held the position of the UK's high-level climate action champion. Following an 18-year private sector career in emerging markets and manufacturing, he worked as executive director of the Carbon Disclosure Project and chief executive of the We Mean Business Coalition. If approved, Mr Topping will replace interim chairman Piers Forster, a leading climate scientist who succeeded former environment secretary Lord Deben in the role in 2023. Mr Miliband said: 'I am delighted to announce the preferred candidate for chair of the Climate Change Committee – Nigel Topping will bring his extensive experience to this role, having already served on the Climate Change Committee for more than two years and as a UN Climate Change High Level Champion for Cop26. 'The CCC plays a vital role advising the UK and devolved governments on our climate targets and this announcement comes at a crucial time, as we deliver our mission to make Britain a clean energy superpower with good jobs, energy security and growth for the British people. 'Net zero is the economic opportunity of the 21st century and Nigel's strong business background will help us drive growth on the transition to net zero, unlocking opportunities for Britain. 'I look forward to progressing the appointment in the coming weeks along with ministers in the devolved governments.'
