ACT leader David Seymour suggested 'bots' drove 'fake submissions' against his Regulatory Standards Bill
Regulatory Standards Bill
were created using "bots".
The Ministry for Regulation received approximately 23,000 submissions regarding a discussion document about the bill in January.
In summarising the feedback, it found 88 percent of submitters opposed the proposed regulations, and 0.33 percent supported or partially supported them.
But in an interview on this week's episode of
30 with Guyon Espiner
, the newly-appointed deputy prime minister claimed most of the opposing submissions weren't valid.
"You're smart enough to know that those 23,000 submissions, 99.5 percent of them, were because somebody figured out how to make a bot make fake submissions that inflated the numbers," Seymour said.
The figures quoted were "meaningless" and represented nothing more than somebody "running a smart campaign with a bot".
When asked what evidence Seymour had that the submissions were fake, he said it's because "we've looked at them. Because we know what the contents of them is".
In a subsequent written statement to RNZ, Seymour said he was referring to "online campaigns" that generate "non-representative samples" that don't reflect public opinion.
In a statement, Ministry for Regulation deputy chief executive policy Andrew Royle would not address Seymour's claims about bots directly.
Royle said the ministry undertook a "robust process" to analyse all of the submissions received.
"Our approach was carefully designed to reflect all submissions in the final analysis, noting there were many similar points made across most of the submissions," he said.
The ministry's summary shows its process included a "qualitative" analysis of about 1000 individual submissions. Group submissions and submissions over 10,000 words were read separately. The rest were summarised using AI.
There was nothing in the report about bots or other interference in the submissions process.
Watch the full interview with David Seymour on
30 With Guyon Espiner
.
Subscribe to the podcast feed now to get every episode of 30 on your phone when it lands:
Professor in the Faculty of Law at the University of Otago Andrew Geddis said the use of the word 'bots' was disparaging.
"I think he's using bots in that kind of colloquial sense, which is an incredibly dismissive way to refer to individual New Zealanders taking the time to actually engage with his proposal.
"If he means some sort of artificial intelligence, computer-generated filling out of the forms without any human intervention, that would have been reported to him by his officials. There was no such report."
ActionStation director Kassie Hartendorp said Seymour was trying to discredit any opposition to his views.
"If he presents some evidence that there were bots involved, and there's probably ways to be able to do that, if he presents evidence, then fine. But otherwise, it just seems like an outlandish claim that isn't matching up with reality."
Kassie Hartendorp (Ngāti Raukawa, Ngāti Tuwharetoa) is the Director of ActionStation, a community campaigning platform.
Photo:
Supplied
ActionStation and other campaigning organisations from across the political spectrum have previously created templates to help people write submissions.
Hartendorp said those tools were not bots and meant make the submissions process more accessible.
"The purpose of those submission tools is to be able to make it as clear and simple as possible, so that people, who might not ever have submitted before, or who don't have much time, can be involved with the democratic process."
Clerk of the House of Representatives Dr David Wilson said he wasn't able to respond to Seymour's claims as the consultation in January was run by the Ministry for Regulation, but said there are protections in place against 'bots' during a select committee process.
Similar claims
about the impact of automated software were made during the submissions process on the Treaty Principles Bill in January, which attracted more than 300,000 submissions, but no evidence was found to support any such interference.
"Our cybersecurity people were not aware that any of the submissions were made that way, and they do have security in place to alert them to if that was happening," Wilson said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
3 hours ago
- RNZ News
Broken pump forces Hamilton firefighters to withdraw from house fire
The professional firefighters' union says crews are under-resourced, but their employer says they're trained to cope. Photo: RNZ / Tracy Neal A "catastrophic failure" to a fire truck responding to a Hamilton fire highlights how under-resourced firefighters are, the New Zealand Professional Firefighters Union (NZPFU) says. But Fire and Emergency New Zealand (FENZ) says issues like this can and do occur and crews are trained and highly skilled to cope. Six fire crews responded to a garage fire in Flagstaff late Thursday night. On arrival they were met with a fully involved house fire. Hamilton local secretary for the NZPFU Jay Culhane said that while in the middle of fighting the fire, Te Rapa's pumping appliance lost the ability to pump water. "There was a catastrophic failure of the pump, so they lost water pressure to the firefighters, both to the internal and external firefighting crew," Culhane said. The crew inside the house had to withdraw from the building and the external firefighters had to move away. "The biggest problem is a fire doubles in size every thirty-seconds so the delay in operations ... you are going to lose more property and suffer more damage." Pumping operations were quickly swapped over to the Chartwell pump truck which began pumping water to continue fighting the fire. There were no reports of injuries to the firefighters. However, Culhane said more incidents like this were happening and poor planning and under-resourcing were to blame. "You can service an old truck as much as you want but they are still going to have issues," he said. A FENZ spokesperson said it had a fleet of around 1300 firefighting trucks. "Our firefighting trucks are well maintained, safe, certified, and legally compliant. We have a strict schedule for regular maintenance and repairs. "We typically spend more than $20 million each financial year on new firefighting trucks and other vehicles. In 2023/24 we spent $26 million, in 2024/25 we spent $20 million, and in 2025/26 we will spend $29 million." The spokesperson said since FENZ was established in 2017, it had purchased 317 new firefighting trucks. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
5 hours ago
- RNZ News
Country Life: Harnessing the power of plants to combat vineyard threats
Michelle Thompson in her lab at Plant & Food Research in Lincoln Photo: Craig Robertson Follow Country Life on Apple Podcasts , Spotify , iHeart or wherever you get your podcasts. Are some grapevines better at naturally defending themselves from a disease-spreading pest which costs the New Zealand wine industry millions of dollars? Michelle Thompson is running trials at Plant & Food Research in Lincoln to find out. The PhD student is studying the feeding behaviour of mealybugs, tiny insects which extract sap from plants, reducing the plants' vigour and production. She wants to identify grapevine varieties which produce higher levels of defence compounds that deter the insects. Mealybug electropenetrography on grape leaves Photo: Craig Robertson Conventional vineyard practice at the moment is to use chemical insecticides, as well as removing infected plants. "It would be great to have a more natural way of managing mealybugs and protecting our vineyards, something that's more environmentally sustainable and also less costly," Thompson told Country Life . Leafroll virus damage in a Hawkes Bay vineyard Photo: Tony Corbett Leafroll virus Photo: Tony Corbett "I'm working with Citrophilus mealybugs and they are able to feed on lots of different parts of grapevines - the trunks, canes, leaves, berries and the roots." Mealybugs also transmit the Grapevine Leaf Roll Associated Virus. "This impacts the health of the vine, reduces yields and it changes the grape quality as well." Mealybug electropenetrography on grape leaves Photo: Craig Robertson In the lab, Thompson is using a technique called electropenetrography to study how the pests feed. She is working with four grapevines inside two metal cages, designed to minimise external electrical interference. The vines have differing levels of bioactive compounds in their leaves . Mealybug electropenetrography on grape leaves Photo: Craig Robertson The mealybug electropenetrography on grape leaves is conducted in faraday cages Photo: Craig Robertson "There is a plant electrode that's inserted into the potting mix of the vines and a tiny voltage is applied to the plants." A mealybug attached to an electrode is placed on the leaf of each plant. The gold conductive wire glued onto their back is light enough not to restrict their movement. Michelle brushes the dust off a mealybug before attaching the conductive wire Photo: Craig Robertson Michelle uses a microscope to attach the wire to the mealybug Photo: Craig Robertson A Mealybug moves along a grape leaf while attached to the wire Photo: Craig Robertson The technology measures electrical signals produced by insects feeding on the leaves and monitors their feeding behaviour. "I want this information on mealybug feeding behaviour to be able to inform breeding of rootstock varieties, so we can breed varieties that are resistant to mealybug feeding and therefore reduce virus transmission in our vineyards." The project, Smart Adaptive Rootstocks for a Changing World, is funded by the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment's Endeavour Fund. Mealybug electropenetrography on grape leaves Photo: Craig Robertson Learn more:
RNZ News
6 hours ago
- RNZ News
NZ in Cook Islands domestic affairs 'improper'
Pacific politics 19 minutes ago Former Cook Islands Prime Minister Henry Puna says he thinks it's "improper" for New Zealand to involve itself in the "domestic affairs" of the island nation and issues between the two countries should be resolved with leaders talking behind closed doors.
