The IDF is not just Israel's army: it is a symbol of Jewish self-defence
But now Jews are fighting back. Chief Rabbi Sir Ephraim Mirvis has blasted 'toxic Jew-hatred' posing as 'edgy political commentary'. The Jewish Leadership Council declaimed an 'obscene display of extremist hatred'. The anti-Zionists, meanwhile, have argued that Vylan's chant was nothing more than criticism of Israel and its military operation in Gaza.
In fact, they say, it is Vylan's detractors who are the real anti-Semites for conflating Israel with Jews. If the Palestinians must be patronised by grandstanding Westerners, they deserve better than these faint-hearted crybullies.
Not that the feelings of the Chief Rabbi or communal organisations have any impact on anti-Zionists. Lived experience is sacrosanct for every minority apart from Jews.
For a movement that appears to glory in violent rhetoric, when consequences rear their head they fold like a Hamas command centre paid a visit by the Israeli Air Force. They embrace nuance and complexity and all those other traits of the snivelling liberals they scorn. Their anti-Zionism retreats from banner slogans to multi-page footnotes.
Yes, they cavil, the IDF is a conscript army made up almost exclusively of Jews, but that doesn't mean calling for its 'death' is a call for death to Jews. (Disparate impact is another doctrine of the Left that applies to every minority except the Jews.)
Why do they cry ' death to the IDF'? The Israeli army is civilian led. Why not death to the Israeli prime minister, or the defence minister, or the security cabinet? It is not just a matter of what rhymes. The IDF is not just Israel's army; it is the symbol and the substance of Jewish self-defence and Jewish sovereignty. Without the IDF, there would be no Israel, and this is exactly what they want.
Across 2,000 years of exile from their homeland, Jews were reviled, calumnied, excluded, expelled, pogrommed, and exterminated. As the Passover Haggadah observes: 'Not only one has risen up against us to destroy us, but in every generation they rise up to destroy us.' The restoration of Jewish sovereignty in the Land of Israel was about ensuring that future generations had a means of defending themselves. More would come to destroy them, but this time they'd be prepared.
Strong Jews, sovereign Jews, Jews you can't push around. For two millennia, these were concepts not merely revolutionary but fantastical. But now they are lived out every day in Israel. Political anti-Zionism is a project to separate the Jewish people from the theory and practice of Jewish self-determination. The Israeli army is all that stands between 'death to the IDF' and 'death to the Jews'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
7 minutes ago
- The Independent
UK accused of hypocrisy at landmark UN foreign aid conference
The UK has been accused of 'hypocrisy' over its lack of high-level participation at a key global development finance summit, on top of cuts to Britain's aid budget – while talking up its role in helping lower-income nations. The accusations have been made at the fourth Financing for Development Conference (FfD4), a once-a-decade summit happening all week in Seville, Southern Spain, where delegates are aiming to tackle the perennial problem of how to help developing countries access the money they need. Thirty-two African countries currently spend more on debt repayments than on healthcare, and 25 African countries spend more on debt payments than on education, an issue that activists say needs urgent action. Some 50 world leaders are due at FfD4, including Emmanuel Macron of France, Mark Carney of Canada, and Ursula von der Leyen, President of the European Commission. The UK, however, has only sent a government minister in the form of Baroness Chapman, the international development minister. 'A level of ambition from the UK government would have been demonstrated clearly by sending higher level participation such as the prime minister or Foreign Secretary,' Lydia Darby, a senior policy advisor at Save the Children, told The Independent. Ahead of fDf4, writing in The Independent, Baroness Chapman called for a 'new era for global aid and development', that would see developing countries helped in building their own tax systems, and greater investment in developing countries from the private sector, among other measures. Hannah Bond, Co-CEO at ActionAid UK, said that it is 'hypocritical' for the UK to talk about 'fair finance' while cutting overseas aid. 'If the UK truly cares about fair finance, it must honour its overseas aid commitments, tackle unfair debts, and pay its fair share in addressing the climate crisis,' Bond said. 'Without this, talk of fair finance is nothing more than empty PR.' Baroness Chapman's appearance comes off the back of the UK cutting its foreign aid budget from 0.5 per cent to 0.3 per cent of Gross National Income (GNI) - which is expected to reduce foreign aid by £6.2 billion by 2025. Alex Farley, from advocacy group Bond, said that it is 'impossible' to see how the UK can deliver on existing funding commitments, respond to humanitarian crisis, and tackle climate change, following he 0.5 to 0.3 per cent cut. 'Let alone undo the damage these cuts have done to our reputation and credibility with countries,' he added. 'It would be nice to hear the government expressing regret for its cuts to the aid budget, rather than blithely claiming that they are somehow doing developing countries a favour,' Michael Jacobs, from the think tank ODI, told The Independent. Mr Jacobs added that the claim that private sector money can substitute public funds is 'silly at best, disingenuous at worst'. This is because 'the private sector wants returns, while much aid - for health, schools, sanitation, climate adaptation - doesn't make a profit, so is not investable', he said. Catherine Pettengell, executive director of NGO network Climate Action Network UK concurred that the UK had 'failed to sufficiently support developing countries' calls for fairer debt, tax, international cooperation, and climate finance ' in build-up to the conference. 'It's a crushing blow that only compounds the recent UK aid cuts,' she added. Attendees of FfD4 say, however, that it is not all doom and gloom in Seville. The final agreement of the talks - the Compromiso de Sevilla - was in fact agreed to just ahead of this week's conference. According to Save the Children's Ms Darby, there is notably positive language on matters including international tax cooperation and an agreement to initiate an intergovernmental process on debt. 'The document is an important step with plenty to build on in the months and years to come,' Darby said - though she acknowledged it has inevitably fallen short of 'the transformative ambition that civil society and vulnerable communities worldwide had called for'. While the UK, along with the EU, has been accused of watering down key priorities for low-and-middle-come countries, these countries have at least contributed much more positively than the US, which withdrew from talks ahead of the conference over the refusal from the rest of the world to delete the goal of 'sustainable development' from the text.
The Guardian
20 minutes ago
- The Guardian
First Thing: Senate Republicans pass Trump's sweeping policy bill, clearing major hurdle
Good morning. Senate Republicans passed a major tax and spending bill demanded by Donald Trump yesterday, ending weeks of negotiations over the comprehensive legislation and putting it another step closer to enactment. The bill's passage is an accomplishment for Senate Republicans, who faced divisions in getting it passed. The push to get the legislation done intensified on Saturday when the chamber voted to begin debate, then continued with amendment votes that began on Monday and stretched all night. Approval came just after noon on Tuesday, and required the vice-president, JD Vance, to break a tie after three Republicans joined all the Democrats in voting against it. What was the significant opposition to the bill? In the lead-up to its passage, several moderate Republicans indicated unease over its cuts to the social safety net. They included Thom Tillis of North Carolina. What happens next? It still has to be voted on by the House of Representatives, where it is unclear whether changes made by the Senate will be accepted. Although Republicans control both houses, factionalism in the lower chamber is particularly intense, with rightwing fiscal hardliners demanding deep spending cuts and moderates wary of dismantling safety-net programs. Trump has claimed Israel is ready to agree to a peace deal with Hamas as he seeks to broker a ceasefire to the war in Gaza that has claimed almost 60,000 lives. Hamas responded on Wednesday saying it was open to a ceasefire agreement but stopped short of accepting the proposal Trump had announced, insisting on its longstanding position that any deal bring an end to the war in Gaza. Meanwhile, 170 non-governmental organisations yesterday called for the US-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation to be dismantled, after the killing of more than 500 Palestinians seeking food since it launched operations. What's the latest in the conflict? The bombing of Gaza continues, with Israeli strikes killing at least 14 people on Wednesday at the time of writing, Gaza's civil defence agency said. This is a developing story. Follow our live coverage here. The Trump administration has raised the possibility of stripping Zohran Mamdani, the progressive Democratic mayoral candidate for New York City, of his citizenship as part of a crackdown against foreign-born citizens convicted of certain offences. Karoline Leavitt, the White House press secretary, appeared to pave the way for an investigation into Mamdani's status after Andy Ogles, a rightwing Republican congressman for Tennessee, called for his citizenship to be revoked on the grounds that he may have concealed his support for 'terrorism' during the naturalization process. Mamdani, who was born in Uganda to ethnic Indian parents, became a US citizen in 2018. He is a vocal supporter of Palestinian rights. What's the background to this suggestion? It comes after the Trump administration instructed attorneys to prioritize denaturalizing foreign-born US citizens who had committed some crimes. Why are rightwingers up in arms about Mamdani? The 33-year-old democratic socialist and member of the state assembly was virtually unknown when he launched his candidacy, but has built an energetic campaign that defeated the former governor Andrew Cuomo. Keir Starmer managed to avoid an embarrassing parliamentary defeat yesterday, after the UK prime minister was forced into significant concessions on a bill that initially planned to cut about £5bn ($7bn) from disability payments. Extreme poverty is accelerating in 39 countries affected by war and conflict, leaving more than a billion people hungry, according to the World Bank. It urged western governments to step up support for war-torn countries. At least 16 people have died and 400 been injured in Kenya as a nationwide demonstration to honour those killed during last year's anti-government protests turned chaotic. The third and final season of the hit Korean series Squid Game has broken records to become the biggest-ever TV launch for Netflix. Over its first three days, the series registered a record 60.1m views, with more than 368.4m hours viewed. David Fincher has been rumoured to be developing an English-language remake. Karin Kneissl made headlines around the world when she invited the Russian president to her wedding in 2018. Five years later, she moved to St Petersburg. The scandal revealed a dark truth about the ties between Vienna and Moscow. Italy has banned outdoor working during the hottest parts of the day in more than half its regions, as an extreme European heatwave that has smashed June temperature records in Spain and Portugal continues to grip swathes of the continent. The savage temperatures are believed to have killed at least three people, including a small boy who is thought to have died from heatstroke in Catalonia. Jesse Armstrong is the master of ripped-from-the-headlines drama, a writer who skewers the billionaire class. As his AI satire Mountainhead takes him into new territory, he talks about his nuanced view of the tech billionaire Elon Musk – and why his next project may be a bonnet drama. First Thing is delivered to thousands of inboxes every weekday. If you're not already signed up, subscribe now. If you have any questions or comments about any of our newsletters please email newsletters@
BBC News
23 minutes ago
- BBC News
No decision on Ipswich northern bypass until mayor elected
There will be no solution to long-running traffic issues in Suffolk until an elected mayor is in place, a transport boss Orwell Bridge on the A14 south of Ipswich is currently operating with lane closures while £6m repair works are carried have been calls for a northern bypass around Ipswich for decades, but there has been a lack of funding commitment, coupled with local opposition in villages any road would go Chambers, cabinet member for transport at Conservative-run Suffolk County Council, said no decision was likely to be made until after the elections for a new mayor-led authority for Norfolk and Suffolk in May 2026. "We're not going to build a northern bypass in a year. It will be the mayor that will deliver a northern bypass," said new post would be created as part of the government's devolution plans which would replace the two-tier county and district council set-up with unitary councils in Norfolk and Suffolk, with a directly elected mayor overseeing both comes as rush-hour drivers have faced long delays as lanes on the two-lane dual carriageway are closed on the bridge, resulting in slow eastbound carriageway was closed on Monday, 23 June, which was followed by a westbound lane on it happened: Live updates on the Orwell Bridge, Thursday, 26 JuneWhile the lanes were shut, traffic was limited to the usual 60mph on the eastbound side, but cut to 40mph for those travelling west while the contraflow system was in to replace 37-year-old joints on the bridge was expected to be completed by late including container trucks for the Port of Felixstowe, have been advised to "allow extra time" for their journeys. On the northern bypass, Chambers said: "Six years ago [in 2019] we commissioned a strategic outline business case."The only way you can access the funding is to put forward a housing growth plan. "Our business plan six years ago was that [that] required building 15,000 homes, in and above the targets they have to build homes at the moment to access that funding."He added: "The prime minister was only in Suffolk a few weeks ago green lighting Sizewell C."It was a shame while he was here he didn't agree to funding for the major road network that will actually increase capacity on the key road for Sizewell C." Jack Abbot, Labour MP for Ipswich, believed a northern bypass would solve "long-term issues", because improving the railway to increase its capacity to take more container freight for Felixstowe would not solve the road traffic issue."Things like Ely/Haughley [rail junctions] are a really important project for the region and the Port of Felixstowe, [but] this isn't a solution... he [Chris Chambers] mentioned it would take 100,000 HGVs off the road a year. "We have up to 20,000 a day crossing the Orwell Bridge."The northern bypass isn't just about traffic congestion in and around Ipswich, there's the long-term future of Felixstowe port at risk."We have thousands of jobs on the line in our local economy, millions if not billions of investment in our local economy... we have to look at the bigger picture not just for Ipswich and Felixstowe, but for our county as a whole." The BBC has contacted the Department for Transport for comment. Plans for a river crossing over Ipswich's waterfront and wet dock just south of the town centre were abandoned by the Conservative county council in 2018 as costs rose and extra funds were needed, despite the Conservative central government committing £77m. That route was meant to provide another cross-town option for traffic, easing pressure on the the time, council leader Matthew Hicks said they had "exhausted all [further] funding opportunities including the Department for Transport, HM Treasury, local businesses and other stakeholders". Follow Suffolk news on BBC Sounds, Facebook, Instagram and X.
