Calls By Jewish Council For Censorship Will Backfire
"Objectively, the last 18 months have witnessed an intense rise in antisemitic actions around the world, not least of all in Australia and New Zealand. Some of these actions have been unlawful and unacceptable. However, conflating such actions with the speech and opinions of individuals (such as students on university campuses) will not make a single Jew (or any Kiwi) safer.
'Calls by the New Zealand Jewish Council for our Government to implement similar recommendations such as stricter enforcement of 'hate speech' laws and removing funding from universities for failing to act against certain perspectives, is overreach and risks setting a terrifying precedent. It will affirm many conspiracies in certain people's minds that will inevitably result in greater antagonism against our (Jewish) community.
'As we've seen abroad, anyone who defies such bans can become a martyr or even cult hero. Censorship is a gift that can elevate the once obscure. Free speech is still our best tool with which to combat bigotry. There are no shortcuts here. We need to change the conversation, not crush it.
'A better response to any incredibly fraught issue is to facilitate wider conversations, encourage greater engagement between communities, and increase a focus on education. There are some terrible ideas out there, spread by very questionable people, but silencing them will only push this grievance underground, where it festers, and where it becomes much harder for people to diagnose and respond appropriately.
'Expose it to sunlight. Allow them their voice and ensure that those who wish to respond also have theirs. Bad (and hateful and vile) ideas are beaten by better ideas, not threats of funding removal and censorship.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
22 minutes ago
- NZ Herald
Letters: A new model for our power market is needed
Bryan Leyland, Pt Chevalier. The nuclear option As always during the winter months, our energy shortage issues are again brought up. But surely we have our head in the sand to some degree, by which I mean why can't New Zealand bury the past and re-evaluate the potential of nuclear energy. The technology has come a long way and is very efficient, so why not? It would be a game-changer but would call for some very definitive and brave decision-making from our politicians, which, unfortunately, is a rare event. Paul Beck, West Harbour. Indigenous people's rights Guy Body's cartoon (July 14) depicting our Deputy Prime Minister defending New Zealand's sovereignty with a toy sword and a trash-can lid while trampling on a Māori sovereignty flag against the United Nations headquarters adds a little humour to this important issue. Twice recently a UN Special Rapporteur has expressed their concern to our Government about the erosion of indigenous people's rights. The Government has responded with indignation, so this raises the issue of the role of the UN and what powers it should have to influence decisions of all nations. We live in global society, so if we wish to carry forward an ever-advancing civilisation, then we must solve the problem of just global governance. Consultation on this issue is the need of the age we live in as the problems of anthropogenic climate change and justice for indigenous peoples must be solved at a global level. The UN Security Council has the responsibility to ensure peace with justice and, as most people agree, needs the power of veto to be removed to function effectively. So why couldn't we, through our Government, lead efforts to ensure this happens? Consultation on UN reform is not as simple or sexy as ending bottom trawling but one can suggest it is far more important! Dennis Worley, Birkenhead. Anger at actions Antisemitism is not an appropriate term to describe many of today's protests. People are furious with Israel for what it is doing in Gaza. Israel is killing mothers and children. Protests, legal or not, are against what is being done to Gaza and its people. It has nothing to do with antisemitism. Christine Henare, Miranda. All we are saying is ... President Trump has warned nations that the United States will withhold miltary aid in future conflicts unless nations ramp up their defence spending. Nations across the globe have rushed to order weapons. Including Denmark, a peace-loving nation that will increase spending by about US$7 billion ($11.7b) over the next two years. The main beneficiary will be the US arms industry. Business has never been so good. The massive increase in defence spending is a colossal waste. Nations will have no money left to spend on infrastructure or hospitals or schools. When will this madness stop? Now is the time for people to insist that their leaders give peace a chance. Now is the time to negotiate. If peace is not given a chance, it will only take one person to press the button which will light a massive bonfire that could wipe out billions of lives. Johann Nordberg, Paeroa. Health system concerns Having listened to two highly respected doctors on the TV programme Q&A, it is very concerning to see the direction in which our health minister is driving. Basically, the doctors are saying that health will become Americanised with the private system taking control. It was obvious from the interview that both doctors were strongly in favour of a tax system that directly supported health and quoted several European countries that did exactly this. Conservative governments support a vision of less public service and more private enterprise but health is, or should be, one of their core responsibilities. Reg Dempster, Albany.
RNZ News
29 minutes ago
- RNZ News
NZ PM to be a no-show at the Cook Islands 60th celebrations
It's been confirmed New Zealand's prime minister Christopher Luxon will not be travelling to the Cook Islands for its 60th Constitution celebrations next month.
Newsroom
an hour ago
- Newsroom
Influential China course for public servants overhauled
A flagship China programme for the country's public servants is being overhauled to fit the Government's foreign policy priorities, with Southeast Asia and India being added into the mix. The changes come at a difficult time not just for New Zealand's relations with the Asian superpower, but also for China expertise within our country, with a new report warning of a dramatic decline in the ability of universities to teach students about the basics of Beijing.
