Under pressure from India, Sotheby's halts auction of purported Buddha relics in Hong Kong
The Piprahwa gems, which the auction house said dated back to around 200 BC and were unearthed in 1898 by Englishman William Claxton Peppe in northern India, were scheduled to go under the hammer in Hong Kong today.
The Indian Ministry of Culture issued a legal notice on Monday calling the jewels 'inalienable religious and cultural heritage of India and the global Buddhist community' and said the sale violated Indian and international law.
It asked for the auction to be cancelled and the jewels repatriated to India, as well as an apology and full disclosure of provenance documents, according to the notice posted on X.
Sotheby's said this morning that the auction has been postponed 'in light of the matters raised by the Government of India and with the agreement of the consignors'.
'This will allow for discussions between the parties, and we look forward to sharing any updates as appropriate,' the auction house said in a statement.
Sotheby's said the night before that the auction would 'proceed as planned'.
The Indian Ministry of Culture wrote on X that it was 'pleased to inform' readers that the auction was postponed following its intervention.
The gems in the Hong Kong auction were part of a collection of close to 1,800 gems and precious metal sheets — including amethysts, pearls and gold pieces worked into small beads.
They were excavated at the Piprahwa village near the Buddha's birthplace and have been attributed to a clan linked to the religious figure.
Indian authorities said an inscription on one of the caskets confirms the contents — which include bone fragments — as 'relics of the Buddha, deposited by the Sakya clan'.
In an article written for Sotheby's, Chris Peppe said his ancestor 'gave the gems, the relics and the reliquaries to the Indian government' and that his family kept 'a small portion' of the discovery. — AFP
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Malay Mail
an hour ago
- Malay Mail
TECHKLOUD Officially Launches Exclusive Online Shopping Channel for Singapore, Making Global Goods Easily Accessible
SINGAPORE - Media OutReach Newswire - 3 July 2025 - The TECHKLOUD cross-border shopping platform brings a brand-new shopping experience to Singapore consumers, now officially launching an exclusive channel for convenient access to high-quality products from over 20 countries worldwide. From beauty products from Japan and Korea to Nordic home goods, everything you need is available to meet diverse shopping demands. With a fully compliant customs process, products are delivered directly to Singapore, making your cross-border shopping experience more secure and smooth. TECHKLOUD offers delivery services across Singapore, with core areas receiving shipments within 3-5 business days to ensure a fast experience. Additionally, the platform features a real-time package tracking system, allowing consumers to monitor their shopping progress at any time, providing peace of products on the TECHKLOUD platform are officially authorized genuine items, ensuring that every purchase is of high quality. We also offer localized customer support, with a service team proficient in English and Mandarin, ready to answer questions and provide guarantee your shopping experience, TECHKLOUD provides a flexible 15-day hassle-free return and exchange policy. If the purchased item does not meet your expectations, you can easily return or exchange it for a more reassuring shopping support various payment methods, including PayNow, GrabPay, PayPal, credit cards, and NETS, with all transactions secured and certified by the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) to ensure safety and convenience. TECHKLOUD Singapore is dedicated to providing consumers with a fast, safe, and convenient shopping experience. The platform covers multiple categories, including fashion, consumer electronics, home goods, toys, and sports equipment, leading the e-commerce development in some of the fastest-growing countries globally. TECHKLOUD always focuses on delivering exceptional service, ensuring every customer enjoys multiple payment options, free returns, and comprehensive support with warranty our website: Experience seamless shopping services and access to quality global #TECHKLOUD The issuer is solely responsible for the content of this announcement.
Free Malaysia Today
an hour ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Health impact assessment needed for Jelutong project, says group
The RM1 billion reclamation plan involves digging up and rehabilitating the closed Jelutong landfill and reclaiming adjacent coastal land north of the Penang Bridge to temporarily dump the unearthed rubbish from the landfill, besides carrying out mixed development. GEORGE TOWN : A Penang residents' group has urged environmental regulators to reject a developer's environmental impact assessment (EIA) for a planned reclamation project next to the old Jelutong landfill, saying it breaks the rules by leaving out a full health impact assessment (HIA). In a statement, the Protect Karpal Singh Drive Action Committee said the project's proponents ignored the need for a HIA, a new requirement under the law since January for such a project. 'The developer's failure to include a HIA is not an oversight, it's a direct violation of law. 'The environment department (DoE) has clear legal authority and constitutional obligation to reject this incomplete and non-compliant proposal,' the group's spokesman, Dr K Ganesh, said. The RM1 billion reclamation plan involves digging up and rehabilitating the closed Jelutong landfill and reclaiming adjacent coastal land north of the Penang Bridge to temporarily dump the unearthed rubbish from the landfill, besides carrying out mixed development. Ganesh said the EIA failed to consider long-term risks from dust, gas and noise, and ignored most residents in its social study. The group has demanded a full HIA, a certified landfill closure plan, and strong legal steps to protect Middle Bank — a mudflat rich in marine life and seagrass — and public health. He said the group met the Penang DoE yesterday and sent in a formal protest memo, outlining a few demands, including rejecting the developer's EIA. The group learnt that 98.6% of the public comments during the EIA public display period were against the project, Ganesh added. The Penang government signed the deal to rehabilitate the island's only sanitary landfill with PLB Engineering Bhd in 2020 to carry out the project over four to five years. However, no visible works have begun. The 65ha site includes 36ha of landfill and 29ha of new land next to the Karpal Singh Drive waterfront. Chief minister Chow Kon Yeow previously defended the project, saying it would not encroach on the Middle Bank. He had said that the reclamation was needed to create space for a safe landfill clean-up. He said once the site is cleaned up, it will be handed to the developer for mixed development, and the state would get back 20% to 30% of the reclaimed land as part of the deal. More recently, Chow said the Penang government may consider downsizing the reclaimed area following a meeting with the group. However, the residents said the developer's own report shows the landfill can be rehabilitated within its current boundary making reclamation unnecessary. FMT has contacted local government exco member Hng Mooi Lye for comment.
Malay Mail
5 hours ago
- Malay Mail
Vietnam avoids 46pc US tariff under new trade deal, but Beijing warns against targeting China
HANOI, July 3 — Vietnam's trade deal with the US averts the most punishing of Donald Trump's 'reciprocal' levies but has provoked new friction between Washington and Beijing. Vietnam has the third-biggest trade surplus with the US of any country after China and Mexico, and was targeted with one of the highest rates in the US president's 'Liberation Day' tariff blitz on April 2. The deal announced yesterday is the first full pact Trump has sealed with an Asian nation, and analysts say it may give a glimpse of the template Washington will use with other countries still scrambling for accords. The 46 per cent rate due to take effect next week has been averted, with Vietnam set to face a minimum 20 per cent tariff in return for opening its market to US products including cars. But a 40 per cent tariff will hit goods passing through the country to circumvent steeper trade barriers — a practice called 'transshipping'. Washington has accused Hanoi of relabelling Chinese goods to skirt its tariffs, but raw materials from the world's number two economy are the lifeblood of Vietnam's manufacturing industries. 'From a global perspective, perhaps the most interesting point is that this deal again seems in large part to be about China,' said Capital Economics. It said the terms on transshipment 'will be seen as a provocation in Beijing, particularly if similar conditions are included in any other deals agreed over coming days'. Beijing's foreign ministry spokeswoman Mao Ning said today 'negotiations and agreements should not target or harm the interests of third parties'. 'Wouldn't celebrate just yet' Shares in clothing companies and sport equipment manufacturers — which have a large footprint in Vietnam — rose on news of the deal in New York. But they later declined sharply as details were released. 'This is a much better outcome than a flat 46 per cent tariff, but I wouldn't celebrate just yet,' said Hanoi-based Dan Martin, from Asian business advisory firm Dezan Shira & Associates. 'Everything now depends on how the US decides to interpret and enforce the idea of transshipment,' he added. 'If the US takes a broader view and starts questioning products that use foreign parts, even when value is genuinely added in Vietnam, it could end up affecting a lot of companies that are playing by the rules.' A Vietnam foreign ministry spokesman told reporters today that negotiators were still 'in detailed discussion to concretise agreements'. But there are scant details about the transshipment arrangements in the deal, which Trump announced on his Truth Social platform. 'The announced deal gives Vietnam a level of certainty that most other US trading partners do not have,' said American Chamber of Commerce in Hanoi chief Adam Sitkoff. But, he said, 'assessing the pros and cons of the deal is difficult without seeing further details about what the tariffs actually mean'. 'The answers to these questions can be the difference between celebrating or crying.' 'The looming question' Bloomberg Economics forecast Vietnam could lose a quarter of its exports to the US in the medium term, endangering more than two per cent of its gross domestic product as a result of the agreement. 'The Vietnamese government will now find itself under pressure to ensure that country-of-origin rules are enforced,' explained Jack Sheehan, head of regional tax at Asian legal and tax firm DFDL. But uncertainty over how transshipping will be 'defined or enforced' is likely to have diplomatic repercussions, said Bloomberg Economics expert Rana Sajedi. 'The looming question now is how China will respond,' she said. 'Beijing has made clear that it would respond to deals that came at the expense of Chinese interests.' 'The decision to agree to a higher tariff on goods deemed to be 'transshipped' through Vietnam may fall in that category,' added Sajedi. 'Any retaliatory steps could have an outsized impact on Vietnam's economy.' — AFP
