HCSTSI irked by meagre allocation for Sukkur-Hyderabad motorway
They noted that at this pace, the project may not be completed even in the next decade. Such a symbolic and insufficient allocation reflects a serious lack of commitment and is tantamount to an injustice against Sindh and its vital role in Pakistan's trade and connectivity. The business community categorically rejects this approach and demands immediate and substantial funding to expedite the project.
They said that although both governments have emphasised developmental objectives, digital reforms, and increased social sector allocations, there is a glaring lack of practical relief and structural support for small traders, manufacturers, and the broader business community.
President HCSTSI Saleem Memon stated that initiatives like the SME Policy 2024–27, digital reforms in the FBR, the introduction of an automated refund system, and faceless audits are commendable steps. However, without timely and effective implementation, these initiatives may remain merely on paper. He cautioned that the imposition of new taxes on Cash on Delivery (COD), Digital Services and Digital Presence could severely impact small and emerging online businesses that are still in their nascent stages.
Senior Vice President Ahmed Idrees Chohan pointed out the rise in withholding tax rates would further escalate the operational costs for small and medium enterprises (SMEs).
Moreover, the federal budget failed to announce any relief in industrial electricity tariffs, time-of-use rates, or subsidies for SMEs, which is a significant shortcoming considering the ongoing energy cost burden.
Vice President Shan Sehgal expressed concern over the increase in carbon levy, particularly the hike from 2.5% to 5% on furnace oil, stating that many small industries are still in transition and not yet fully equipped with renewable energy alternatives such as solar systems. This would further inflate production costs and hinder their competitiveness.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
12 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Minister visits K-IV project to review progress
LAHORE: Federal Minister for Water Resources Mian Muhammad Mueen Wattoo visited Greater Karachi Bulk Water Supply Scheme (K-IV Project) and reviewed the ongoing development works on the project. The federal minister visited in detail various key work fronts, which included intake structure and pumping stations being constructed at Keenjhar lake, water conveyance system consisting of pressurized pipeline from Keenjhar to Karachi as well as water reservoirs and filtration plants in suburbs of Karachi. During the visit, the federal minister was briefed by the project team about the site-wise progress achieved so far, remaining works and timelines for their completion. It was briefed that construction work on all components of the project is in progress at a satisfactory pace. Overall physical progress stands at 63 percent, while a sum of Rs 86.4 billion has so far been spent on construction of the project. Phase-I is planned to be completed in 2026, provided the required funds are made accordingly. Speaking on the occasion, the federal minister expressed satisfaction over the pace of work and reiterated the federal government's full support for the project. K-IV is a vital scheme for supplementing water supplies to Karachi to meet water requirements for the urban use. 'We are committed to ensuring completion of K-IV at the earliest as it is one of the priority projects of the Ministry of Water Resources,' he added. The minister emphasized the need for enhanced coordination among all stakeholders to remove bottlenecks for smooth implementation of the project. He also directed the consultants and the contractors to adhere to the quality standards stipulated for the project. The K-IV project is a critical infrastructure initiative aimed at addressing Karachi's acute water shortage by providing an additional 650 million gallons per day (MGD) water to Karachi from Keenjhar lake. The project is planned to be completed in two phases. At present, WAPDA is constructing Phase-I of to supply 260 MGD water to Karachi. Phase-II, when implemented, will also augment another 390 MGD water to the system for Karachi. Phase-I is being implemented through eight contract packages awarded to different local and international contractors. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
12 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Development 2.0: the case for PPPs in Pakistan
Over the past few years, policymakers and academics have shown renewed interest in Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs) as a way of addressing fiscal limitations and speeding up infrastructure construction and the provision of increased yet sustainable public services. Similar to other developing nations, according to Dr Shamshad Akhtar, who was former finance minister of Pakistan, Pakistan will be facing an estimated USD 124 billion infrastructure financing gap by 2040, along with public debt nearing 66.3% of GDP and is projected to rise to 71.4 percent in FY2025, making traditional government-led-financed development increasingly unsustainable. These gaps have forced government to explore other forms of financing vehicles like PPPs to facilitate funding of desirable public infrastructure development using money raised from the private sector. However, PPPs have largely been promoted only as an alternative mode of financing whereas they might actually be an enabling tool to deliver greater efficiencies, innovation and value for money-normally referred in Pakistan as a game changer. The prime minister, Shehbaz Sharif, has recognised the successful implementation of PSDP under the leadership and oversight of the federal minister for planning, development and special initiatives, Professor Ahsan Iqbal. He gave this credit due to the fact that PSDP is being strategically used for ensuring development of much-needed infrastructure but also serving to provide a clear vision of development priorities and growth path of the country. It is commendable, however this should be supplemented or complemented in the PSDP with addition of new models of financing for PPP that will extend the frontiers of fiscal efficiency even more, crowd in additional private funding and lead to institutional reform. A detailed report of 2023 published by the Pakistan Institute of Development Economics (PIDE), Reforming the Federal Public Sector Development Programme, presented a strong case of an urgent reform was established. The report promoted a portfolio cleaning strategy, which advised a reduction of the size of PSDP by 20 to 25 percent and the removal of almost half of all projects underway in this regard. The study indicated that many of such projects are either not backed by institutions or have become low-priority schemes that involve subjecting of the national funds on them without receiving a corresponding reward. PSDP resources are often spread thin over too many unviable projects, thus limiting impact and leading to cost and time overruns. Now this lack of efficiency has crippled the argument in favor of seeking alternative forms of developmental financing only. Beyond financing, frame-work has to be energized and implemented quickly. The greatest of them is the Public-Private Partnership (PPP) model that provides a practical and performance-oriented system of project delivery. PPPs, by utilising the privately raised funds, technical excellence, and creativity can aid Pakistan to make important infrastructure, enhance social amenities, even bring in Foreign Direct Investment as a complement and decrease the pressure on the exchequer. The federal government, to its credit, has achieved certain success in institutionalizing the PPP model with the setting up of the Public-Private Partnership Authority (P3A) across provinces and federal government. Since its inception, P3A has developed a project pipeline of PKR 2.5 trillion. Its priorities however are limited to federal infrastructure projects such as roads, bridges and transportation corridors. To make PPPs a real pillar of the national development, the model has to develop both vertically and horizontally, expanding to provinces and sectors like education, health, and housing as well. Sindh's PPP-based Education Node where private firms operate public schools has shown success in underserved areas. The mixed model has produced the following positive results such as better administration, provision, and education achievement, especially in underdeveloped and remote regions. The Sindh experience shows that when well-designed PPPs are implemented with transparency and accountability they result in marked improvement in the quality of public service delivery. Similarly, even in Pakistan, thought leaders have been promoting a paradigm shift for public investment. One of the notable economists and Vice Chancellor of PIDE Dr Nadeem Javaid has stressed on how Pakistan should no longer focus at using public money as a crutch, but should instead reinvent PPPs as a means of managing risks, corporate efficiency, and innovation. He suggested radical reforms: such as the use of inflation-linked bonds, blended finance, and revenue-sharing arrangements so that PPPs could be scaled up and made more marketable. More importantly, he pointed out to the necessity of institutional reforms and better governance in order to have sustainable ecosystem of the collaboration of the private sector. This is what is also embedded in the URAAN Pakistan transformation plan. Around the world, countries like the UK, India, Brazil, and Chile have used PPPs to bridge public service gaps most effectively. The Private Finance Initiative in the UK has been quite revolutionary in the modernisation of hospitals and transport schemes, whereas in Chile there has been a larger access to clean water due to the water and sanitation PPPs. These success stories emphasize that PPPs are not mere financial tools, they are development tools that can transform service delivery and governance. In addition to infrastructure, the scope of PPPs to revolutionize service delivery in the sectors of human development is huge. As it has been reported in Housing Finance Pakistan Report, 2024, Pakistan requires developing 2 million housing units annually to accommodate its growth requirements, which is a situation that cannot be achieved without the involvement of the private sector. PPPs can also help expand healthcare access, digital platforms, and affordable housing. Whether these projects can succeed or not will however be based on the capacity of the government to design transparent contracts, establish accountability and earn the confidence of the people. It is also a change that needs the redefinition of the role of the state. The government should stop acting as the only financier and project implementer but an enabler-designing the rules, tracking the performance, and achieving the results. It has to develop the capacity of PPP design and management, simplify the procedures of procurement, and integrate transparency throughout the project cycle. Procurement procedures need to be sanitized and made corruption free. This matter is most important, particularly after Pakistan has been ranked 135th out of 180 countries by the Transparency International Corruption Perceptions Index One of the priorities, in this case, should be to decentralize the PPP system into the provinces and local governments. Local governments are in a position to determine contextual demands and have a project that deals with shortages of public services at the community level. The establishment of facilitating legal and regulatory framework of subnational PPPs, coupled with technical assistance and even financial de-risking, will do a lot to stimulating development at the grassroots. The government of Pakistan needs to wade through its development problems with insufficient resources and a huge scope of the problem. Although the PSDP is important, it cannot be used as the single point through which infrastructure and service delivery aspiration is realized in the country. A gap, where vision and performance split, can be narrowed with the help of Public-Private Partnerships provided that they were well thought of and clearly performed. The time to institutionalize PPPs is now — anything less risks repeating past inefficiencies. (Dr Ahmad Fraz is Assistant Professor and Dr Mahmood Khalid is Senior Research Economist at the Pakistan Institute of Development Economics (PIDE)) Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Express Tribune
13 hours ago
- Express Tribune
10,000 import declarations tampered due to WeBOC 'glitch'
Listen to article The Chief Executive Officer of Pakistan Single Window (PSW), a government-owned trade network integration entity, revealed on Wednesday that large-scale tampering of Goods Declaration (GD) forms was made possible due to a technical glitch in the WeBOC (Web-Based One Customs) system, dating back to 2015. In a briefing with journalists, PSW CEO Syed Aftab Haider said the flaw allowed changes in GD forms without backend validation, enabling importers to alter declared quantities and descriptions of goods. He said that he had recommended the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) to register First Information Reports (FIRs) against those involved. "There was no backend validation of GD changes in WeBOC since 2015," said Haider. He added that this loophole was exploited by unscrupulous users to manipulate imports data. Haider said PSW took over WeBOC management in 2022 but cannot make system changes without Pakistan Customs' approval. In March, The Express Tribune reported that more than 10,000 GD forms were tampered with, helping evade billions in taxes. While the PSW CEO claimed that no revenue was lost, there is no rationale behind changing forms without importers at least gaining financial benefits given that they are exposing themselves to criminal cases. The scam raised serious concerns about the credibility of GD forms, which are supposed to be secure records detailing importers, agents, goods, and duties. "This alteration, effected through changes in the browser script, did not need any help from WeBOC, PSW, or Information Technology staff," stated the PSW earlier this year. Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif had directed the PM's Inspection Commission (PMIC) to investigate the scam. Though the PMIC report has not been made public, Haider said the PMIC accepted the PSW's stance that the issue was a technical glitch. The Express Tribune had reported that to remain undetected, the corrupt network did not alter the Harmonised System (HS) code, a unique numerical identifier for traded goods, they manipulated the descriptions and quantities of goods. The CEO said WeBOC has not undergone a technical audit for years. PSW is now hiring external auditors to evaluate the system. "There's a clear demarcation between the PSW and Customs. PSW only manages the WeBOC system, but Customs controls the design," said Haider. Commenting on a separate scam involving smuggled vehicles cleared as duty-paid, Haider said this resulted from the misuse of user codes, and there was no evidence of system failure. FBR has suspended the officers whose codes were used to clear the smuggled vehicles. The CEO also announced the launch of a new pilot project, the Port Community System (PCS), which is to be inaugurated by PM Shehbaz Sharif in the first week of August in Karachi. The PCS is designed to streamline port operations and fulfil International Maritime Organisation (IMO) requirements. "It will serve as a one-stop platform for all port transactions, providing real-time updates on cargo, vessels, and berthing to ensure seamless coordination between port stakeholders," said Haider. He said the system was developed in-house and PSW resisted pressure to adopt foreign-developed systems. However, he clarified that the new PCS will not directly reduce container clearance times but will make the process paperless and more efficient. "Globally, container grounding time is not more than three hours, but in Pakistan it goes as high as 26 hours," said the CEO, urging reforms to reduce cargo examination delays to reduce the dwell time of containers. He also stressed the need to integrate scanners installed at various ports. Scanners at Karachi Port and the Torkham border are not electronically linked, which creates lots of problems. Haider added that the FBR is working on scanner integration and installing new equipment to improve imported goods monitoring.
