DU panel's decision to drop proposed PG papers on Islam, Pakistan, China sparks row
A Delhi University panel's decision to drop proposed postgraduate Political Science papers on Islam, Pakistan, and China has failed to find consensus among the members. While some called it ideological censorship, those who supported the decision termed it a step towards making the syllabus 'India-centric' and free from bias.
In its meeting on Wednesday, DU's Standing Committee for Academic Matters directed the removal of four elective papers — Islam and International Relations, Pakistan and the World, China's Role in the Contemporary World, and State and Society in Pakistan. A fifth paper, Religious Nationalism and Political Violence, will be reviewed in the next meeting on July 1.
Opposing the decision, committee member Professor Monami Sinha said such changes undermine critical thinking and reflect a push to dilute controversial but academically relevant content.
'We argued that it is imperative to study Pakistan and China in detail. Ignoring these geopolitical realities would be academically short-sighted,' she said in a statement.
She also flagged the removal of references to caste, communal violence, and same-sex relationships in revised syllabi for Sociology and Geography.
However, Professor Harendra Tiwari, also a member of the committee, supported the changes, calling the syllabus 'agenda-driven' and lacking in balance.
'Why only a paper on Islam and International Relations? Why not on Hinduism or Sikhism? We want a syllabus that serves students and our nation,' he told PTI.
He added that the dropped papers will not be reinstated unless the revised syllabus aligns with an 'India-first' perspective.
The next committee meeting on July 1 is expected to see further debate on the syllabus.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
18 minutes ago
- Time of India
India, China Reach Breakthrough Border Agreement, Set Up Special Talks Mechanism: Mao Ning
'Unthinkable Trade Barriers Must Go'- Donald Trump Warns India Ahead of US Trade Deal Deadline Donald Trump amped up the pressure on India just days before the July 9 tariff deadline, stating that US businesses must be allowed to trade freely without "unthinkable" restrictions. As the US finalizes deals with China, Trump's focus has shifted to India, accusing it of trade protectionism and threatening 25% reciprocal tariffs if barriers aren't lifted. Talks have reportedly stalled over auto, steel, and agricultural duties, with India pushing for concessions while offering tariff cuts on nuts and energy access to the US. Trump also signaled he may bypass formal negotiations altogether by sending letters demanding compliance. With stakes rising, will Modi give in or stand firm? This could redefine the future of India-US economic ties.#donaldtrump #india #unitedstates #ustradedeak #trumpindia #usindiatrade #tariffdeal #trumpnews #moditrump #tradewar #uspolitics #indiaglobaltrade #toi #toibharat #bharat #breakingnews #indianews 26.5K views | 2 days ago
India Gazette
24 minutes ago
- India Gazette
Army chief visits Bhutan to bolster defence cooperation
New Delhi [India], June 30 (ANI): Chief of the Army Staff (COAS) General Upendra Dwivedi on Monday departed on an official visit to Bhutan. The Indian Army stated that the visit aimed to further bolster the enduring bilateral defence cooperation between the two nations. 'General Upendra Dwivedi, COAS proceeded on an official visit to Bhutan today. The visit aims to further bolster the enduring bilateral Defence Cooperation between the two nations. The visit reflects the deep-rooted relationship between India & Bhutan and reaffirms India's commitment to its neighbour,' the Army said in a post on X. India and Bhutan share unique and exemplary bilateral relations, which are based on mutual trust, goodwill and understanding. Formal diplomatic relations between India and Bhutan were established in 1968. The basic framework of India-Bhutan relations is the Treaty of Friendship and Cooperation signed in 1949 between the two countries, which was renewed in February 2007. Earlier, Bhutan's Prime Minister paid a state visit to India in December 2018 and again in May 2019 to participate in the swearing-in ceremony of the new government. External Affairs Minister (EAM) S. Jaishankar visited Bhutan in June 2019, marking his first overseas trip after assuming office. The Foreign Minister of Bhutan visited India from November 17 to 23, 2019. The Commerce and Industry Minister (CIM) visited Bhutan from February 28 to 29, 2020. EAM S. Jaishankar visited Bhutan from April 29 to 30, 2022. The India-Bhutan Agreement on Trade, Commerce, and Transit, which was first signed in 1972 and revised most recently in 2016, establishes a free trade regime between the two countries. The Agreement also provides for the duty-free transit of Bhutanese exports to third countries. The traditionally unique bilateral ties, characterised by mutual trust and understanding, have been advanced by regular high-level exchanges between the two countries. PM Narendra Modi visited Bhutan in August 2019. Prime Minister of Bhutan Tshering Tobgay accompanied by Lyonpo DN Dhungyel, Minister of Foreign Affairs and External Trade, Lyonpo Gem Tshering, Minister of Energy and Natural Resources, Lyonpo Namgyal Dorji, Minister for Industry, Commerce and Employment and other senior officials, paid an official visit to India during 14-18 March 2024. (ANI)
India Today
27 minutes ago
- India Today
Ordinary Indians are more mature about Israel-Iran than the pundits
In these deeply polarised times, it is extremely rare for people on opposing sides of political and ideological divides to agree on an issue. When even a modicum of agreement is difficult and rare, a near consensus on a contentious issue is indeed astonishing. A survey conducted by CVoter over questions raised by the de facto war between Israel and Iran reveals that ordinary Indians, who are often looked down upon by pundits and intellectuals, display far more maturity when it comes to core national look at the responses to one simple question: from the perspective of its national interests, which country should India trust more: the US or Russia? Amongst those are supporters of the Opposition, the INDIA bloc, and less than 10 per cent say the United States is more trustworthy. Amongst supporters of the ruling National Democratic Alliance, just about 15 per cent of the respondents share that contrast, seven in ten of both factions' supporters say that Russia is more trustworthy than America. To be sure, recent developments have almost certainly impacted public opinion in India. For one, repeated threats by US President Donald Trump to companies like Apple to not manufacture iPhones in India. More tellingly, how Trump 'barged' in as a mediator-cum-peacemaker during Operation Sindoor and claimed all credit for the ceasefire between India and Even more tellingly, there is the spectacle of top American military leaders praising Pakistan as a 'Phenomenal Partner' in counter-terrorism efforts, and to cap it all, Trump invited Pakistan Army chief Asim Munir to the White House for a cosy the relative levels of distrust that ordinary Indians have towards the US vis-a-vis Russia are not a sudden, newfound, or fleeting phenomenon. It goes back decades to the 1971 war between India and Pakistan that led to the creation of Bangladesh. During that conflict, the US was unrelentingly hostile towards India and openly supportive of Pakistan. The ghosts and memories of that era doesn't mean Indians are hostile towards the US. Far from it. In the aftermath of economic reforms in 1991, economic ties between India and the US have consistently flourished. Till Trump acted like a bull in a China shop on the issue of immigration, India has been sending the largest number of students to American universities. Numerous CEOs of top American multinationals are of Indian origin. There is a lot of surveys over the years have found that a big majority of Indians have a favourable opinion of the US. But an equal if not bigger majority has a favourable opinion of Russia. In many ways, the average Indian displays tremendous maturity: Engage with the US and pursue good relations because it will benefit India, but do not trust it as a reliable ally or response is better than the hysterical response of social media 'patriots' who were in love with Trump till recently and now feel betrayed. It is far better than the two-faced response of liberals and intellectuals who think America leads a malign coterie that tramples upon Third World countries. Perhaps the public persona of External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar represents the actual opinion of a majority of it comes to Israel versus Iran, the gap is not as wide as the one between the US and Russia. But a significantly larger proportion of respondents (45 per cent) think Israel is more trustworthy than Iran (26 per cent). On this issue, one can see that polarised opinion is back in the fray. While just about four in ten supporters of the INDIA bloc think Iran is more trustworthy, less than two in ten NDA supporters share that sentiment. But even here, the polarisation is not as deep as in most other cases. An equal proportion of INDIA supporters think Iran and Israel are more trustworthy. One can clearly see a national consensus on this issue, and political parties would do well to pay attention to to half of the respondents think the real worry for India if the Israel-Iran conflict intensifies, is energy security. India is heavily dependent upon oil and gas imports, and a prolonged conflict in West Asia would not only disrupt supplies but also trigger a rise in oil and gas prices. Quite rightly, Indians have identified the real area of concern for their country rather than falling for rhetoric from ideological divides about Israel being a brutal colonial apartheid state and Iran being a brutal theocratic Islamic regime. Yet another response to a question reveals the maturity of ordinary Indians. The question was: Do you think India's economic ties with Israel should continue regardless of regional tensions? While close to half said yes, another quarter was in favour of closer ties with Israel, but in a cautious manner. In effect, three-fourths of Indians want closer economic relationships between India and Israel. Only two in ten are not in favour. advertisementA final set of responses and data points concludes the argument being made by the authors about the maturity of the average Indian, even when it comes to complex geopolitical issues. The survey asked: What do you think India's official stance on the Iran-Israel conflict should be? While 28 per cent wanted India to support Israel, about 19 per cent wanted India to support Iran. Close to half wanted India to remain neutral and call for peace. The ordinary Indian, unlike ideologically blinkered intellectuals, understands that both Israel and Iran are important for India and there should be no binary options here. To cap it all, 53 per cent of respondents want India to step in as the mediator. advertisementWhen Russia invaded Ukraine in early 2022, there was an ideological divide between ardent fans of America and supporters of Russia. CVoter surveys at the time found ordinary Indians displaying the same measure of maturity that is on display now. Even better, the NDA regime's foreign policy reflects the opinion of a majority of Indians.(Yashwant Deshmukh is the Founder and Editor-in-Chief of C-Voter Research Foundation and Sutanu Guru is Executive Director)- Ends(Views expressed in this opinion piece are those of the authors)Tune InMust Watch
