Keeper call and the deeper questions facing Banyana Banyana
Image: Backpagepic
COMMENT
Banyana Banyana's 1-1 draw with Tanzania on Friday was more than just a frustrating result — it was a performance that peeled back the layers of tactical intent, team cohesion, and national introspection.
At the heart of the storm is coach Desiree Ellis' decision to start Kaylin Swart ahead of Andile Dlamini — a move that has opened the door to technical and political debate, just as South Africa's title defence at WAFCON demands composure and clarity.
Swart is no novice. She has worn the badge with pride and stood tall on big stages, most recently at the 2023 World Cup. Yet football, like all sport, lives in the present. And after Dlamini's brilliant showing against Ghana, many felt she had done more than enough to retain the No 1 shirt.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
Instead, Swart's selection — and the missed opportunity that led to Tanzania's equaliser — has left fans questioning not only the tactical rationale, but the consistency of Ellis' selections.
Ellis, to her credit, has backed her choice. She insists the decision was based on strategy, not sentiment. But the broader discussion refuses to remain within the lines of the pitch. It has spilled into the murky terrain of race, representation, and national identity — topics that have long haunted South African sport.
For critics, the lack of coloured and white players in the national women's squad is jarring. While South Africa is overwhelmingly black in population, sport is one of the few spaces where national teams are scrutinised not just for their talent, but for their reflection of the country's diversity.
The memory of Sports Minister Steve Tshwete calling out a 'lily-white' Proteas team in 1998 still lingers. Today, similar questions are being raised — not from the ministerial podium, but from Parliament itself.
The inquiry by Patriotic Alliance MP Marlon Daniels, asking SAFA why there are so few coloured players in national teams beyond Ronwen Williams and Swart, struck a chord. Whether such inquiries are politically motivated or genuinely reflective of public sentiment, they underline the need for transparency and accountability in the structures that shape our national teams.
For Ellis and SAFA, the issue is twofold. First, are the best players being selected based on form and ability? Second, is enough being done to ensure talent is being identified and nurtured across all communities?
The timing of this storm is unfortunate — it threatens to derail a campaign that still holds promise. Banyana Banyana are, after all, reigning African champions. They are more than just a team — they are a symbol of progress, resilience, and pride. But symbols must also reflect the nation they represent.
Ellis has built a squad with loyalty and continuity in mind, but she now faces a crucial test of leadership. The next goalkeeper selection may not only determine the outcome of a match — it may shape the public's trust in her ability to make decisions beyond favouritism or optics.
There is no doubt the players remain committed.
This is a team of fighters, built on character and conviction. But with the pressure mounting and scrutiny intensifying, Banyana Banyana must now show not just the tactical discipline to advance — but the unity and maturity to weather the storm brewing around them.
As the final group fixtures loom, South Africa will be watching — not just the scoreboard, but the symbolism stitched into every line-up.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
an hour ago
- The Citizen
Donjuan ‘DiDi' van Heerden claims ABU title in career-defining victory
South African middleweight boxer Donjuan 'DiDi' van Heerden delivered a commanding performance at Emperors Palace, capturing the vacant African Boxing Union (ABU) middleweight title in front of a packed and electrified crowd. This landmark victory marks a major milestone in DiDi's professional career, firmly establishing him as one of the continent's most promising boxing talents. Known for his relentless dedication and iron will, DiDi has forged an impressive path through South Africa's amateur boxing ranks. Having competed in over 65 amateur fights — with only two losses and seven national titles — DiDi's transition into the professional arena has been marked by discipline, determination, and fierce passion. Returning to the Golden Gloves' prestigious Titans of Africa event, where he previously faced defeat, DiDi demonstrated remarkable resilience. His devastating body shots and precision uppercuts dominated the fight, landing with such force they echoed throughout the venue, signalling the formidable power and skill he now commands. 'Donjuan has always had talent, but it's his work ethic and absolute refusal to quit that sets him apart. This win is the culmination of years of relentless dedication and the ability to rise above every setback,' said Colleen McAusland, his professional manager. Whether loved or criticised, Donjuan van Heerden's brilliance in the ring is undeniable and he is most definitely back. Expressing gratitude to his team, family, and supporters, DiDi described the ABU title as only the beginning. 'This is a stepping stone towards building a lasting legacy in boxing, not just for South Africa, but on the international stage,' he said. With this career-defining victory, DiDi has not only claimed the ABU title but has also announced himself as a force to be reckoned with in the world of middleweight boxing. Fans and critics alike will be eagerly watching his next steps on the path to greatness. Quick facts about DiDi: Age: 24 Hometown: Meyerton, Midvaal, South Africa Amateur record: Over 70 bouts, six-time South African Cchampion Professional record: 10 wins, 3 losses, 7 KOs Titles: Gauteng Middleweight champion, ABU Middleweight champion (July 2025) Awards: Prospect of the year Manager: Colleen McAusland At Caxton, we employ humans to generate daily fresh news, not AI intervention. Happy reading!
Daily Maverick
5 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Siya Kolisi back to lead new-look Boks against Georgia as Rassie continues to grow depth
Springbok flank Siya Kolisi will play his first Test of 2025 when he captains the side against Georgia in Nelspruit on Saturday. It's an indication of the Springboks' depth that despite naming three uncapped players for Saturday's clash against Georgia, the squad still boasts more than 900 Test caps. Captain Siya Kolisi returns with his 92 Test caps to bolster the stats, while there is a start for Cobus Wiese at No 8, which looks like the most interesting experiment in coach Rassie Erasmus' latest lineup. In all, the Bok starting XV, which includes an entirely uncapped front row of Boan Venter at loosehead, hooker Marnus van der Merwe and Neethling Fouché at tighthead, has 484 Test caps. Venter has impressed for Edinburgh this year, and Van der Merwe was one of the best players in a competitive Scarlets team during the United Rugby Championship. Their selection also highlights the excellent decision by the South African Rugby Union to allow the Bok coach to select overseas-based players. Eight of these 23 are registered to foreign clubs. The impressive Test cap number is bolstered by the return of lock Eben Etzebeth, who will earn his 133rd cap, while centre Damian de Allende also starts after sitting out the second Test against Italy. Last week, Erasmus favoured an inexperienced bench, with three uncapped players. This week, while the starting XV, outside of Kolisi, Etzebeth, De Allende (88 caps) and Pieter-Steph du Toit (87 caps), has limited experience, he has stacked the bench with proven winners. Bongi Mbonambi, Vincent Koch and Thomas du Toit are the front row reserves. Lock RG Snyman returns, with Kwagga Smith covering the back row options in a traditional 5-3 split between forwards and backs. Faf de Klerk and Handré Pollard provide vast halfback experience while two-time World Cup-winner Damian Willemse completes a formidable bench. With the three newbies, Erasmus has now awarded seven new caps in 2025. Kolisi's return means that the Boks have used 46 players this year already. They continue to build depth while winning. 'We wanted to make sure that Siya is 100% fit before selecting him, so it's great to have him back in the squad, while Boan, Marnus, and Neethling have been training hard and deserve their chance,' said Erasmus. 'Marnus and Neethling played against the Barbarians, so they have an idea of what international rugby is about, while Boan has shown great potential at club level and with the squad in the last few weeks, and we are looking forward to seeing him play. 'Building squad depth has been one of our pillars as a squad since 2018, and they are all undoubtedly ready to make the step-up.' Wiese for Wiese Jasper Wiese, who was red-carded against Italy at the weekend for a headbutt, has been given a four-match ban by World Rugby's disciplinary tribunal. He will miss the next four Bok Tests, which include two home contests against Australia, and the 6 September clash against the All Blacks at Eden Park. He was impressive in the first Test against Italy at Loftus, gaining metres with every carry while also making himself felt in defence. But his moment of madness in the second Test has cost him and the team, and the Boks must now improvise at No 8 if they want the same ball-carrying threat. Cobus Wiese, who started his career at the Stormers as a flank, has been used at lock at the Bulls this season. But he showed enough in the last 20 minutes of the second Test against Italy to suggest a return to the back row might not be a bad move. He was prominent in the loose with some strong carries. The Wieses don't mind the physical stuff. While Cobus Wiese isn't as quick as Evan Roos or Smith, he does pack a punch in contact and can set the tone for winning the gain line battle. It's a huge opportunity for Cobus Wiese, considering everything leads to that massive showdown at Eden Park without Jasper Wiese. Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu also starts in a Test for the first time since last August, when he led the line against the All Blacks, and has a chance to shine. Manie Libbok's polished performance last week, which was a masterclass in creating opportunities for his outside backs, must give him the inside line for the big Tests later this year. With Aphelele Fassi back at fullback, the return of Kurt-Lee Arendse, and Edwill van der Merwe completing the back three, the attacking potential is salivating. Canan Moodie gets another go at outside centre as Erasmus looks for depth in a position that has belonged exclusively to Jesse Kriel and Lukhanyo Am for the better part of seven years. While the level of the opposition this week and the gulf in class, with all due respect, is below what will come later in the year, the players need to show the coaches that they can stick to the plan and stay on script. The game has the potential to devolve into an unstructured runaround, which might be fun to watch but will serve little purpose in the bigger picture. Essentially, the players have more to lose than they have to gain in this outing. 'We know how passionate and intense this Georgian side is, and they will be determined to make a strong statement,' said Erasmus. 'So we selected some experienced players who we would like to get more game time before the Rugby Championship, and give a few of the younger players who have put up their hands another run … so we are pleased with the balance we have in this group.' DM
IOL News
8 hours ago
- IOL News
‘Amakhosi for life': Yusuf Maart bids emotional farewell after Kaizer Chiefs exit
Khosi for life Former Kaizer Chiefs captain Yusuf Maart has completed his move to newly promoted Austrian side SV Ried. Photo: Alche Greeff/BackpagePix Image: Alche Greeff/BackpagePix Get your news on the go, click here to join the IOL News WhatsApp channel. 'I know that Austrian football is very intensive and physical. Ried has a great atmosphere in their stadium, and the fans are known for it.' Maart also penned an emotional letter and thanked Chiefs as well as his previous club, Sekhukhune United, for how his career had turned out. The Capetonian actually began his professional career in the colours of Orlando Pirates. However, things didn't pan out, and after a brief loan spell to Cape Umoya United, he secured a move to Sekhukhune United, where he started to make an impact. After helping Sekhukhune earn promotion to the Betway Premiership, he moved to Kaizer Chiefs and quickly became one of their key players. He was the club's captain last season and scored the winning goal in the Nedbank Cup final against Pirates. Read Maart's full letter below: Firstly, I want to express my deepest gratitude to the Chairman and CEO of Sekhukhune United for believing in my talent,' he wrote in the letter shared by his agency, P Management. Their unwavering support and the leadership opportunities they provided were pivotal in shaping not only my confidence as a player but also as a person. The lessons I've learned will stay with me forever. I would also like to thank the Chairman of Kaizer Chiefs and the entire management for entrusting me with the honor of wearing the armband. Leading one of the biggest and most prestigious teams on the continent is something I will always cherish and be proud of. To all the coaches who have guided me throughout my journey, I am beyond grateful. The knowledge and wisdom you've shared have helped me grow in ways that go beyond the game itself. Your influence has shaped me into the player I am today. To my teammates, thank you for your support and the unforgettable moments we've shared on and off the field. But most importantly, I want to thank the Amakhosi faithful – the fans. Your unwavering belief in us through both the triumphs and the challenges has been a constant source of motivation. Amakhosi for Life. IOL Sport Get your news on the go, click here to join the IOL News WhatsApp channel.
