
A Tale Of Two Stopbanks Hemming In Wairau River
At the time John Boswell took it in stride.
'Look, his house is threatened,' Boswell told Local Democracy Reporting after the resident left.
'You can understand the person, like, I get it.'
The resident was not alone in his dissatisfaction with council. Nearly every Spring Creek resident who spoke to LDR voiced the same grievance.
'They should have sorted it out yesterday,' one resident said, standing next to a water pump.
'We expected council would start the works when they said they would,' said another.
Each frustrated sentiment was underpinned by a single question.
Where were the promised Wairau River stopbank repairs? And why had they been delayed?
In 2024, council set aside $8.7 million in their Long Term Plan to strengthen the stopbank after it was compromised following the 2016 Kaikōura earthquake. That included $3.6m in government funding.
Work was to begin at the end of 2024, but was delayed by about a year to the start of 2026, with work to be completed by June 2027.
That delay left residents, who had already been flooded for three of the past four years, with another year at risk of flooding.
Speaking last week, Boswell said rebuilding a stopbank from scratch was no easy task, and required time to get it right.
'You can't just repair a stopbank overnight,' he said.
'It takes time, and because of the type of events that we experienced at the weekend, they're going to have to do it in the summer.'
Boswell said the delay was caused by a combination of design finalising, funding and material sourcing, and works on the northern side of the Wairau River.
'There was work done on the northern side in terms of clearing out some vegetation, and widening the river [to take] the pressure off the southern bank, which worked really well during [last weekend's] event.
'And then we went through the design process, sourcing the funding, getting the materials, and so on.
'They're working bloody hard to do it as quickly as they can.'
At least 35,000 tonnes of rock would be needed for the job, the council said last year. Most of that was expected to come from the nearby Pukaka Quarry.
Boswell said council had long communicated with the Spring Creek community about the complexities of rebuilding a stopbank.
'One of the first things I walked in on when I came to this job was a meeting in the hall at Spring Creek, where our rivers engineers team talked the community through the issue, what the potential fix looked like, and the time frame for that fix,' Boswell said.
'Since that meeting, they've worked bloody hard to get the design confirmed, to source the money from government, to think about where they're going to source the materials and how they're going to pre-position them.'
Concerns about how the stopbank would perform when put under stress caused council to issue a precautionary 24-hour evacuation for 60 households in Spring Creek on June 27.
But Boswell said that stopbank actually performed better than they thought during the rainfall.
'The bank itself held up really, really well ... it was performing exactly as we hoped it would,' Boswell said.
'Once the river level started to drop, and we could see that the integrity of it still was there, then we were able to let the residents back in.'
Boswell said he stood by the decision to evacuate residents.
'When it comes to risking someone's life versus their property, then we'll always err on the side of caution, and that's what we did on this particular occasion,' he said.
Boswell said the water that covered parts of the township was surface flooding, not due to a stopbank breach.
'The surface flooding was as a result of stormwater coming in across the paddock to the west of the Spring Creek settlement,' he said.
'On this particular occasion it resulted in a low, although incredibly annoying, level of stormwater or flooding for the local residents.
'But it certainly wasn't life threatening to the same extent as if there had been a [stop bank] breach.'
Boswell said the council was also hard at work identifying and repairing faults in the stopbank at the confluence of the Wairau and Waihopai rivers.
The council issued a 'be ready to leave' order on June 27 that led many Renwick residents to self-evacuate.
Boswell said it was a very close call for Renwick residents.
'During [a routine] check, it was found what appeared to be seepage through a stopbank on the Waihopai River, which if compromised could have impacted on lower Renwick,' Boswell said.
Boswell said that if the bank had been breached they would have had less than an hour to fully evacuate lower Renwick.
'We thought that was enough time if people have been pre-warned, to get them out if we needed to.
'We had a trigger point for when we were going to order an evacuation.
'We didn't quite get there, so we didn't have to do it.'
Council staff would be out in Renwick identifying any more weaknesses in that stopbank.
'We're going to do whatever we can to ensure the integrity of that stopbank, should there be another event,' Boswell said.
'Then we're going to look at the wider scheme just to make sure that we've got everything.'
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

1News
16-07-2025
- 1News
Māngere family say 'yes for now' to buyout after two-year wait
A Māngere family is faced with a difficult decision after learning that their home is considered an "intolerable risk to life". After waiting two years for answers, the Taufoous are now forced to choose between staying uninsured or leaving the community they have built over decades. Auckland Council claimed that the buyout was fair and voluntary but local leaders, including Councillor Alf Filipaina, said families should have access to all relevant information before making their decision. Daisy Taufoou, who has lived on Hinau Rd for 42 years, was shocked to return to her flood-damaged home only to discover that it was categorised as high-risk. Along with her husband, children, and elderly parents, the family has decided to proceed with the Auckland Council's voluntary buyout process to understand the implications of their choices. ADVERTISEMENT They must notify the council of their decision by July 17. Like their neighbours, they wished to stay, but after extensive deliberation, they felt they needed to explore all options before making a decision. Taufoou said the buyout situation felt like a "lose-lose" for many families on Hinau Rd. "It's been an emotional rollercoaster for us trying to decide what to do," she said. "We have decided to move forward in the process so that we can understand what we're saying yes or we're saying no to. Because, at any time, we can still say no and pull out. "It's a lose-lose. If we go, we lose our community. If we stay, we lose insurance and can't get cover for the next flood." Unlike some homeowners eager to receive a Category Three designation to escape flood-prone properties, Taufoou and her neighbours never wanted the buyout label. They wanted to remain in their homes. She criticised the limited timeframe they were given to decide on a buyout process after a lengthy two-year wait to learn their street was classified as Category Three. She said it had taken countless hours of unpaid effort to pursue reports and briefings. ADVERTISEMENT "Our whole street have repaired their homes or renovated their homes fully and we're all back into our homes. And then to hear, two years later, that it is an intolerable risk to life… just doesn't sit right with us. "Unlike the council staff who work on this eight hours a day, we have full-time jobs, kids and elderly parents. We're doing this in the evenings and weekends, just to figure out what's true." Workers upgrade Walmsley Road Bridge as part of flood resilience projects aimed at reducing future flooding in Māngere. (Source: Local Democracy Reporting) Nick Vigar, Auckland Council's head of Planning for Healthy Waters, said Māngere was prioritised for major flood reduction projects, but assessing how upgrades like the Walmsley Rd Bridge would affect each home's risk took time. "Hinau Rd sits very low and close to the stream, which means that, even with these major upgrades, the risk to life during another major storm would still be too high," Vigar said. "Because of this, these homes remain eligible for a voluntary buyout. We know this is incredibly difficult, so we extended their timeframe and put extra support in place to help residents make an informed choice." Vigar said the upgrade to Walmsley Rd Bridge and the wider Māngere Flood Resilience Project would reduce flooding for many homes but Hinau Rd was an exception due to its location in the more hazardous 10-year floodplain. This meant floods might occur more frequently than in surrounding areas. ADVERTISEMENT "The unfortunate thing for Hinau Rd is that, while they are part of the big floodplain, they are developed in an area which we currently call the 10-year or 10% floodplain. That means those properties can expect to get hit more frequently than everyone else," Vigar said. Taufoou said the council's data did not align with the reality residents experienced. She insisted drains and upstream ponds had not been adequately maintained and minor repairs were neglected. "They keep talking about the bridge, but what about the drains? The worst of the damage came from blocked stormwater drains. It just doesn't seem fair to decide our lives on one big flood when fixing the small things could help," she said. Vigar said the council wished it could have provided families with answers sooner, but final modelling and funding approvals required time to complete. "It would have been preferable to come to them earlier and say, hey, this is the situation, but the reality is it took time to secure funding, do the design, update the flood models and get approval. It's really unfortunate for these people," he said. Vigar admitted the technical language around flood risk could be difficult for families to understand. He said opting into the buyout process did not commit families to follow through with it or agree to a set buyout price. "We talk about flood risk, 100-year events, 10-year events. It's really technical. I always worry that people won't fully understand what that means for them. ADVERTISEMENT "Opting into the buyout process does not lock a homeowner into going through with the buyout or a specific buyout price. "But it does give homeowners access to a dedicated property adviser, plus $5000 for legal and valuation costs, to help them understand what they would get from Council, including reimbursement for insurance repairs they have already done in good faith." Vigar said the added risk of losing insurance complicated the decision. "More and more, the insurance industry is requiring higher premiums or declining cover for flood-prone properties. It's not just about risk to life. There are real difficulties for higher-risk properties to get insurance," he said. Filipaina said the council's proposal aims to provide people with choices, but that they need all the information to make informed decisions. Hinau Rd. (Source: Local Democracy Reporting) He said Hinau Rd was one of the streets most at risk despite nearby flood mitigation works. ADVERTISEMENT "We as an Auckland Council… we cannot say that if there's another major flood or cyclone that you will end up being safe," Filipaina said. "This is why we're asking you to please consider the buyout option. If you have all the information and it says to leave, but you don't want to leave, well then you take on the burden if anything happens." Taufoou said her neighbours have rallied to push back against the proposal, organising street-wide meetings with the council and seeking support from Community Law and local board members to challenge the findings collectively. She said they still worried about the future of the land if they decided to leave. "What we did was unique. No other area has come together like this to challenge the council as a street. We're proud of that. "You can't tell me Māngere won't be developed later. If we leave, will this land really stay empty? That's hard to believe," Taufoou said. The council stated that no final decision had been made about the land, but its policy meant that most Category Three sites would remain undeveloped for flood resilience or public use. Future residential development was "highly unlikely" because of the high hazard risk. For now, Taufoou's focus was on staying informed, asking questions, and reminding families that they still had the option to walk away if the buyout does not feel right. "It's about being able to reach out and ask for help and question things if they don't make sense. I don't want any of our families to feel like they're alone in this," Taufoou said. Local Democracy Reporting is local-body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.


Scoop
11-07-2025
- Scoop
Lake Kaniere Septic Tanks Under Scrutiny As Subdivision Grows
West Coast Regional Councillors and iwi uneasy about water quality in Lake Kaniere are relieved it has so far shown no sign of pollution from increasing subdivision nearby. The deep, glacial lake south of Hokitika is the source of the town's water supply. The prospect of contamination from septic tanks was raised earlier this year by the council's Management chair Brett Cummings. And iwi rep Jackie Douglas (Ngati Maahaki; Makaawhio) asked if the council had any reports on Kaniere, given growing development in the area. Council staff who monitor the lake for invasive weeds and for E. coli in the swimming season have reported bacteria levels rising sometimes after heavy rain. But a recent survey carried out at the councillors' request has shown Lake Kaniere is in good health, Environmental Science manager Shanti Morgan told the July meeting of the council's Resource Management committee. 'We identified some areas where we want to do some more intensive sample monitoring to track the influence of increased development around certain parts of the lake. We can provide that to you in the quarterly update. ' Ms Douglas said she had gone out on Lake Kaniere with council staff when they sampled the water at key points and was happy with the results. 'We had a really good look at Hans Bay and Sunny Bight…the science team is able to follow up to ensure we don't see problems in the future or they can be easily identified.' Buller councillor Chris Coll said he was fascinated to hear that the water quality was unaffected. 'What happens if it starts to change? With the town water supply coming from there, if started showing up, how would you reverse it? ' he asked. Cr Cummings said that had been a problem at Punakaiki when run-off from an old septic tank was putting E. coli into the lagoon. 'They traced it back and found out what was going on – it's important to monitor, though Lake Kaniere is a whole lot bigger than Punakaiki lagoon,' he said. Ms Morgan said the council's compliance team could check out any issues with septic tanks but the Westland District Council was also monitoring the water independently, under the (national ) drinking water guidelines. Westland mayor Helen Lash told LDR the council was very much aware of the new subdivision activity in the hills around Lake Kaniere and was considering the potential risks. 'It's causing a bit of angst; more sections are appearing and it has been brought to our notice. Once you have an issue, how do you clean it up? ' The council might have to bring in additional testing, to be sure the water quality was beyond reproach, Mrs Lash said. 'All our water supplies are chlorinated, so there is a safeguard there, but we need to keep a close eye out for possible incremental effects and be sure the new septic systems are all top quality. Though it's more likely any problems would stem from the old ones. ' The Regional Council monitors West Coast lakes along with DOC and Manawa Energy, as part of its obligations under the National Policy Statement on freshwater, using submerged plant life as a health indicator. The surveillance programme detects invasive aquatic weeds but the report tabled this month shows mainly native vegetation in Lake Kaniere, with no signs of deterioration in its ecology.


Otago Daily Times
11-07-2025
- Otago Daily Times
Septic tanks under scrutiny as subdivision grows
West Coast Regional Councillors and iwi uneasy about water quality in Lake Kaniere are relieved it has so far shown no sign of pollution from increasing subdivision nearby. The deep, glacial lake south of Hokitika is the source of the town's water supply. The prospect of contamination from septic tanks was raised earlier this year by the council's management chair Brett Cummings. And iwi rep Jackie Douglas (Ngati Maahaki; Makaawhio) asked if the council had any reports on Kaniere, given growing development in the area. Council staff who monitor the lake for invasive weeds and for E. coli in the swimming season have reported bacteria levels rising sometimes after heavy rain. But a recent survey carried out at the councillors' request has shown Lake Kaniere is in good health, Environmental Science manager Shanti Morgan told the July meeting of the council's Resource Management committee. 'We identified some areas where we want to do some more intensive sample monitoring to track the influence of increased development around certain parts of the lake. We can provide that to you in the quarterly update. ' Ms Douglas said she had gone out on Lake Kaniere with council staff when they sampled the water at key points and was happy with the results. 'We had a really good look at Hans Bay and Sunny Bight… the science team is able to follow up to ensure we don't see problems in the future or they can be easily identified.' Buller councillor Chris Coll said he was fascinated to hear that the water quality was unaffected. 'What happens if it starts to change? With the town water supply coming from there, if started showing up, how would you reverse it? ' he asked. Cr Cummings said that had been a problem at Punakaiki when run-off from an old septic tank was putting E. coli into the lagoon. 'They traced it back and found out what was going on – it's important to monitor, though Lake Kaniere is a whole lot bigger than Punakaiki lagoon,' he said. Ms Morgan said the council's compliance team could check out any issues with septic tanks but the Westland District Council was also monitoring the water independently, under the (national) drinking water guidelines. Westland mayor Helen Lash told Local Democracy Reporting the council was very much aware of the new subdivision activity in the hills around Lake Kaniere and was considering the potential risks. 'It's causing a bit of angst; more sections are appearing and it has been brought to our notice. Once you have an issue, how do you clean it up? ' The council might have to bring in additional testing, to be sure the water quality was beyond reproach, Mrs Lash said. 'All our water supplies are chlorinated, so there is a safeguard there, but we need to keep a close eye out for possible incremental effects and be sure the new septic systems are all top quality. Though it's more likely any problems would stem from the old ones. ' The regional council monitors West Coast lakes along with the Department of Conservation and Manawa Energy, as part of its obligations under the National Policy Statement on freshwater, using submerged plant life as a health indicator. The surveillance programme detects invasive aquatic weeds but the report tabled this month shows mainly native vegetation in Lake Kaniere, with no signs of deterioration in its ecology. - By Lois Williams, Local Democracy Reporter