Exclusive: Before Bhopal's 90-degree bridge came up, Railways had warned: ‘Will give a bad image to engineers'
More than a year before Bhopal's infamous '90-degree' rail overbridge came up, red flags had already been raised over its peculiar design, which is now under investigation, The Indian Express has learnt. The Indian Railways, it is learnt, had warned that the design would lead to criticism from commuters and 'give a bad image of engineers'.
The 648-metre bridge in the Aishbagh area, which cost Rs 18 crore to build, was meant to eliminate long delays at railway crossings and shorten the commute for nearly three lakh people daily. While one portion was being built by the Public Works Department, the Railways was handling the other part.
The Public Works Department has constituted a four-member committee, including two chief engineers and an executive engineer, to assess the design, evaluate accountability, and recommend corrective measures.
Documents accessed by The Indian Express show that on April 4, 2024, a team of supervisors from the Indian Railways inspected the site where the bridge was being made. At the time, the sub-structure of the bridge, built by the Railways, was ready, and the 'work on the superstructure' was in progress.
The work on the approach portions of the bridge managed by the PWD was also in progress.
At the time, Sudhanshu Nagayach, Deputy Civil Engineer at the West Central Railways Division, wrote to the PWD Executive Engineer of the Bridge Construction Division that 'during the inspection, it is noticed that towards Barkhedi, connection of bridge and approach (sic)' does not seem to be proper.
Nagayach wrote that the portions of the bridge constructed by the PWD and Railways are 'meeting almost at right angle, which is neither fulfilling the functional requirement nor safe for road users'.
'It will lead to criticism amongst road users and public and also give bad image of engineers in the public,' the letter reads.
Senior officials of the PWD have, meanwhile, blamed the Railways for the lack of coordination. A senior official from the bridge engineering department said, 'They should have scrapped the project and waited for a new design. They (the Railways) just proceeded to build their ROB and leave us to design the approach portion.'
The Railways, however, maintains they had communicated to the PWD about design flaws well in advance, but since no action was taken, they proceeded to build their portion of the bridge.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Gazette
38 minutes ago
- India Gazette
APEPDCL to provide electricity to 23000 PVTG tribal households under PM Janajati Adivasi Trijan Nyaya Maha Abhiyan
Visakhapatnam (Andhra Pradesh) [India], June 30 (ANI): The Government of India is providing free electricity connections to houses without electricity through the Pradhan Mantri Janajati Adivasi Trijan Nyaya Maha Abhiyan, whose aim is to provide infrastructure to PVTG tribal settlements living in remote areas, a press release from APEPDCL said. For this scheme, officials from Andhra Pradesh Eastern Power Distribution Company Limited (APEPDCL) have identified 23,000 PVTG houses without electricity in tribal villages and settlements under its jurisdiction. As part of the Pradhan Mantri Jan-Man Yojana program, the company officials have taken action on a war footing to provide electricity to remote areas under the Revamped Distribution Sector Scheme. The electricity staff worked hard to transport the electricity poles, transformers, conductors and other equipment required to establish the electricity network to remote tribal areas that lack roads and transportation facilities. APEPDCL CMD Prithviraj Imadi would regularly hold special meetings at the electricity substations and provide necessary instructions to the staff, and would also personally visit the tribal villages to inspect the electricity meters installed free of charge for tribal households. Although establishing a network for tribal villages was challenging, the electricity staff, through their collective efforts, provided free electricity connections to more than 22,000 houses in a remarkably short period, bringing electricity to the tribal settlements. While the government's goal is to provide electricity to every household, some tribal villages located in the hills have not been connected to electricity lines. Some tribal families who engaged in shifting cultivation and periodically changed their residences on the hills were provided with five solar-powered LED bulbs, a fan, a charging point, two switchboards, and a solar plant stand. Each family was provided with electricity by providing a free package worth Rs. 50,000. To celebrate Gandhi Jayanti, village assemblies were organised for the PVTG villages that had completed electrification under the APEPDCL area. The company officials certified that all tribal houses in the respective gram panchayat had been electrified, and certificates were given to the village sarpanches who had cooperated in this effort. As of May 17, 23,024 out of 23,087 households without electricity have been connected to the power grid. Through RDSS, 15,102 out of 15,475 households have been supplied with electricity at Rs 48 crores. Through DAJGUA, 487 out of 3,745 families have been provided with electricity, amounting to Rs14.23 crores as of May 17. As part of the Government of India's PM Janman Scheme, electrification and housing are being provided to particularly vulnerable tribal groups (PVTGs), especially those in remote and migratory habitations with less than five households. Around 1,000 such tribal households have been identified. To address their unique needs, electrification is being implemented in three ways: Individual Solar Home Lighting Systems (SHLS) - Portable kits with solar panels, batteries, lights, and fans for migratory use. Solar mini-grids - For small, isolated communities, particularly those located on hilltops. Solar-Wind Hybrid Mini-Grids - For areas with mixed renewable potential. These efforts are primarily focused on the APEPDCL jurisdiction, which covers the tribal belts from Srikakulam to the Alluri Sitharama Raju districts. About 70% of the 14,312 genuine applicants of the PM Surya Ghar (PMSG) scheme under the Visakhapatnam-based Eastern Power Distribution Company of A.P. Limited (APEPDCL) are generating electricity on their rooftops. Solar Rooftop Photovoltaic (SRTPV) systems have been installed on the roofs of 11 districts under the North Coastal Andhra Power Distribution Company (Discom). (ANI)
NDTV
2 hours ago
- NDTV
Rs 100 Crore Road Built In Bihar. Problem: Nobody Cut Trees In The Middle
Imagine driving on a wide, newly built road with zero potholes and trees lined up on both sides. As you speed through the smooth road, the fresh breeze and landscape make for a scenic and pleasant driving experience. But what if these trees shift to the middle of the road? It turns into a real-life biking game where you either evade hurdles or lose a lifeline. And, this has come true in Bihar's Jehanabad, 50km away from the capital Patna, where a Rs 100 crore road widening project went terribly wrong. In Jehanabad, on the Patna-Gaya main road, trees stand tall in the middle of the 7.48 km long road, making the commuters prone to accidents. These trees didn't grow overnight. Then what happened? When the district administration undertook a Rs 100 crore road widening project, they approached the forest department, seeking permission to remove trees. But their demand was rejected. In return, the forest department demanded compensation for 14 hectares of forest land. However, the district administration could not fulfil the request, and they made a bizarre move - they created a road around the trees. The trees aren't planted in a straight line, which a driver could avoid. One must criss-cross their way through them. It appears to be an Rs 100 crore invitation to death. Many accidents have already happened due to trees being in the middle of the road, a passerby said. The district administration, however, does not seem to be taking any concrete initiative to remove the trees. Who will be held responsible if a major accident occurs and someone dies? It is a question that remains unanswered, like the problem at hand.
Scroll.in
2 hours ago
- Scroll.in
GPSC MO recruitment 2025: Apply for 100 Medical Officer posts till July 9, details here
The Gujarat Public Service Commission (GPSC) has invited online applications from eligible candidates for the recruitment to Assistant Engineer (Electrical) posts, Class-2, Road and Building Department Class-2. Candidates can apply for the posts at till July 9, 2025. The preliminary exam will be conducted on October 12, 2025. Applicants will be shortlisted on the basis of the Preliminary exam (objective) and the interview round. The recruitment drive aims to fill a total of 100 MO vacancies. Applicants should be between the ages of 20 and 35 years as on July 9, 2025. The upper age limit is relaxed for reserved category candidates. More details in the notification below: Here's the official notice. Application Fee A fee of Rs 100 applies. Steps to apply for MO posts 2025
