After Villanova's exit, is the CAA still worth it for HBCUs?
When Hampton University and North Carolina A&T left the MEAC for the Coastal Athletic Association (CAA), it was presented as a significant realignment opportunity for HBCU athletics. The move promised more exposure, stronger competition, and academic alignment. But with multiple CAA schools departing, the question HBCU fans are asking: Did the move deliver?
Since 2020, five key CAA football programs have left or announced plans to leave:
James Madison (to FBS Sun Belt, 2022)Delaware (to Conference USA, 2025)Richmond (to Patriot League, 2025)William & Mary (to Patriot League, 2026)Villanova (to Patriot League, 2026)
That leaves a restructured and arguably weakened CAA, especially for football. For HBCU additions like Hampton and NC A&T, the competitive landscape and cultural relevance of the conference are now in question more than ever.
When the Aggies and Pirates joined the CAA, they carried with them the heart of HBCU football-the drumlines, community-centered tailgates, vibrant student sections, and deeply rooted rivalries. These elements are core to the HBCU game day experience, where cultural celebration meets athletic competition. The CAA, a conference consisting of predominantly white institutions (PWIs), offered little in terms of that unique ambiance. As a result, many fans have struggled to connect with the new conference environment.
For example, Hampton has seen a decline in home game attendance, averaging just over 4,000 fans. Meanwhile, NC A&T drew 23,016 fans for its 2024 Homecoming game against Hampton-an impressive turnout that underscores how deeply HBCU traditions still resonate. However, without traditional rivals and familiar pageantry week after week, the experience feels less electric. As one NC A&T alum told HBCU Gameday in 2023, "I feel like the culture has slipped away…when it comes to the football family."
This cultural disconnect has fueled ongoing debates about whether the benefits of CAA membership outweigh the intangibles lost.
Before joining the Coastal Athletic Association, both Hampton and North Carolina A&T were dominant HBCU programs in the MEAC:
NC A&T won seven MEAC football titles, four Celebration Bowl victories, and built one of the nation's top HBCU track and field programs.Hampton claimed five MEAC football championships, consistent success in men's and women's basketball, and sent athletes to NCAA tournaments in track, tennis, and other sports.
These programs helped define HBCU athletics on and off the field. Their departures left a major gap in not only MEAC competition but the overall landscape of HBCU football, especially in the Celebration Bowl, the official HBCU National Championship Game.
North Carolina A&T's move aligned with its goal of becoming an R1 research institution. In a statement to HBCU Gameday in 2022, Athletic Director Earl Hilton said, 'The CAA is consistent with our academic and athletic aspirations. The (then-maned) Colonial already has four institutions of R1 status, and we're moving in that direction.'
Hampton's then-president, Dr. William R. Harvey, echoed this in January 2022 to 13News Now: "I have always been very interested in the concept of the student-athlete, which means a focus on academics and top athletics… This is a risk, but it's not a gamble."
However, with Delaware and James Madison exiting the CAA, only Stony Brook and Albany remain as R1 institutions, undercutting the academic synergy that helped justify the move.
Hampton ended the 2024 season 5-7, including a dominant Homecoming win over NC A&T.The Aggies struggled through a rebuilding year in football and are still adjusting to the stiffer competition in the CAA basketball conference.
Off the field, A&T's track and field continues to excel nationally. Hampton's Olympic sports, while competitive, have not replicated past dominance within the CAA structure.
CAA prestige hasn't produced playoff berths or national rankings for either HBCU.
The big question buzzing around the HBCU community. Could these HBCU programs return to the MEAC? Some fans and analysts are discussing a potential new HBCU superconference that would revive cultural traditions and regional rivalries. The Celebration Bowl, ESPN coverage, and renewed investment in HBCU sports elevate this possibility.
Still, any conference shift would require planning, media deals, and strategic coordination among institutions.
This isn't just a discussion about football. It touches on identity, culture, and community. Hampton and NC A&T took a calculated step to grow their platforms. But as the CAA's foundation shifts, the question is whether they are building a new legacy or turning away from what made HBCU sports great.
Should Hampton and NC A&T double down on the CAA, return to the MEAC, or help create a new HBCU movement?
The post After Villanova's exit, is the CAA still worth it for HBCUs? appeared first on HBCU Gameday.
Copyright HBCU Gameday 2012-2025
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
14 hours ago
- Yahoo
Chris Paul Returns To Los Angeles Clippers For His Final NBA Season
Chris Paul Returns To Los Angeles Clippers For His Final NBA Season originally appeared on Fadeaway World. One of the greatest point guards in NBA history is coming full circle. Chris Paul has officially agreed to join the Los Angeles Clippers on a one-year, $3.6 million deal for what he has declared will likely be his final NBA season, his 21st overall. The deal, brokered by agents Steven Heumann, Ty Sullivan, and Jessica Holtz of CAA, was first reported by ESPN's Shams Charania. Despite interest from several playoff contenders, Paul has chosen to return to the Clippers, a franchise where he once helped redefine relevance and identity during the "Lob City" era. For Paul, this isn't just about basketball. It's about coming home. The 39-year-old has expressed a desire to play his final year close to his family in Los Angeles, and the Clippers offer the perfect blend of comfort, nostalgia, and contention. It's a poetic end for a player who spent six of his prime seasons with the franchise, earning five All-Star nods during that stretch and solidifying the Clippers as a perennial Western Conference powerhouse throughout the 2010s. Paul's return also marks a significant piece of what has become an unexpectedly bold offseason for the Clippers. They traded for John Collins on an expiring deal to bolster their frontcourt, stole Bradley Beal in a surprise buyout sweepstakes following his exit from Phoenix, and signed Brook Lopez from the Bucks to shore up the center position behind Ivica Zubac. Now, with Paul locked in, the Clippers have found their ideal backup point guard, a critical role that was left unfilled. Paul isn't expected to be the engine of the offense anymore, but his leadership, IQ, and ability to control tempo will be invaluable, especially during tight playoff moments. Whether it's stabilizing bench units, mentoring younger guards, or managing the game late in the fourth, Paul's presence checks every box for a team that still believes it can contend. The Clippers' core of Kawhi Leonard, James Harden, and now Beal, if healthy, will benefit from having a floor general like Paul to direct traffic and ease ball-handling duties. This might be the best situation for Paul to chase the elusive championship that has eluded him for two decades. And while he's no longer the All-NBA guard of old, CP3 has shown in recent seasons with the Thunder, Suns, Warriors, and Spurs that his basketball mind remains elite. For Clippers fans, it's a nostalgic reunion. For Paul, it's a legacy moment, a final ride in the city where he once captivated crowds with lobs to Blake Griffin and surgical pick-and-rolls. As the Clippers prepare to enter their new arena, Intuit Dome, later this year, it feels fitting that one of the franchise's defining stars will be there for the opening act and for his final story was originally reported by Fadeaway World on Jul 21, 2025, where it first appeared.
Miami Herald
3 days ago
- Miami Herald
HBCU stars react to viral ‘Step Brothers' photo
BALTIMORE - Max U'Ren and Walker Harris have helped shape one of the most consistent programs in HBCU football this decade. The two North Carolina Central University (NCCU) veterans-U'Ren at linebacker and Harris at quarterback-have played key roles in a program that's lost just four conference games over the last four seasons. But their recent viral moment had nothing to do with football. Step Brothers Moment Goes Viral In anticipation of MEAC Football Media Day, NCCU posted a promotional photo featuring U'Ren and Harris striking a pose inspired by the cult comedy Step Brothers. The image quickly gained traction online. "I'll say that photo wasn't even supposed to-it wasn't supposed to come out the camera," U'Ren said. "We didn't know it was coming off the camera. I was just scrolling on Instagram on Friday, and it popped up on my timeline. As soon as I saw it, it spread like wildfire." Harris, entering his second year as a starter, explained that the photo was actually his idea. "We took those probably back in February or March at the end of a photo session," Harris said. "I told Max, 'Let's go take a Step Brothers picture.' I definitely didn't think it would be posted like that-especially not for media day. But I thought it was awesome." He added, "I thought the comments were hilarious. We're honored to represent North Carolina Central University." Both players-white student-athletes from nearby Winston-Salem and Wake Forest-joined NCCU in 2021. At the time, the program was rebuilding from a 3-8 campaign in 2019 and a pandemic-induced shutdown in 2020. Under head coach Trei Oliver, the program surged, culminating in a 2022 HBCU national championship win over Jackson State, led by Deion Sanders, Travis Hunter, and Shedeur Sanders. Despite that high, the Eagles have fallen short of returning to the Celebration Bowl, missing out in the last two seasons due to losses to Howard and South Carolina State. According to U'Ren, the coaching staff emphasized how close the team came to its goal. "It was preached in the offseason-just how close we were the past two years," he said. "All our workouts have been focused on getting that extra half-yard, that first down, that final quarter we needed. It's been a theme all offseason." Harris echoed that mindset. "It's about the process," he said. "What are you doing daily to reach the goal of winning every game and making the Celebration Bowl? It's a grind, but it starts with being intentional." That journey continues Aug. 24, when NCCU faces Southern University in the MEAC/SWAC Challenge on ABC. It's a return to where it all started for both players. "It's really cool for me personally," Harris said. "My first-ever college football game was the MEAC/SWAC Challenge back in 2021. To end my career with the same game feels awesome. I'm very excited about that. It's going to be a great game. We plan to put on a show." The post HBCU stars react to viral 'Step Brothers' photo appeared first on HBCU Gameday. Copyright HBCU Gameday 2012-2025
Miami Herald
3 days ago
- Miami Herald
HBCU HC Ready to Defy Preseason Polls and Restore Glory
Shawn Gibbs isn't backing down. The first-year head coach of North Carolina A&T football may be inheriting a program picked dead last in the 2025 Coastal Athletic Association (CAA) preseason poll, but don't expect any excuses from the man now at the helm of one of HBCU football's proudest traditions. "This is home," Gibbs said after being introduced as head coach in December. "We're not afraid to say it: we want to be the best. And we believe the CAA gives us a chance to show the world what HBCU football is really about." That quiet confidence isn't just coach-speak-it's rooted in the legacy he helped build. From 2015 to 2019, A&T dominated the HBCU football landscape. Under head coach Rod Broadway and later Sam Washington, the Aggies won four MEAC championships and took home four Celebration Bowl trophies in five years. Their ground game, powered by stars like Tarik Cohen, was elite-and Gibbs, as the team's running backs coach, helped engineer it. However, after leaving the MEAC for the Big South in 2021 and then the CAA in 2023, A&T's golden era faded. In a controversial move, the university parted ways with Washington. Choosing to go in a 'different direction' from the Rod Broadway coaching tree by hiring former NFL linebacker Vincent Brown. In two years under Brown, the Aggies won just two games and failed to notch a single CAA conference win-a far cry from their dominance just a few years prior. With Gibbs returning to Greensboro, the program is doubling back to the foundation that brought national success. Shawn Gibbs knows the CAA isn't the MEAC. But he also doesn't buy into the doom-and-gloom. "We get to play great teams week in and week out," he said at media day. "And we get to show ourselves in a region of the country that probably doesn't know much about HBCU football. So let's go do that." While the CAA was once considered an FCS juggernaut, recent exits by James Madison, Delaware, Richmond, William & Mary, and Villanova (in 2026) have thinned its ranks. Some now question whether A&T's move from the MEAC-where they were a dynasty-to a CAA that's losing prestige was worth it. That debate flared again after HBCU Gameday reported on the 2025 CAA preseason poll, where A&T landed at last at No. 14. The Facebook comments? Brutal, with some blaming HBCU Gameday articles for stoking a flame of discourse that they want extinguished. While many fans are still asking: Should A&T come home to the MEAC? Others want to move forward and make peace with their place in the CAA. But for now, Gibbs is focused on building-not debating. Shawn Gibbs made it clear that his mission isn't just to win games. It's to restore Aggie Pride as a way of life. "Aggie Pride is what's going to help these guys graduate, be great fathers and husbands, and leaders in the community," he said. "That is my purpose. My job is to win football games." Despite being underfunded compared to their CAA peers, Gibbs isn't fazed. "We've always had to find a way to be great with less," he said. "We're going to do the most with what we have-and we're going to get players who believe in what we're building." North Carolina A&T opens its season on August 30 at Tennessee State, another HBCU with a proud tradition, that plays football in a non-HBCU conference. It's a fitting place for this new era to begin. A&T might be at the bottom of the preseason poll-but with Gibbs back on Benbow road, you shouldn't bet on them staying there for long. The post HBCU HC Ready to Defy Preseason Polls and Restore Glory appeared first on HBCU Gameday. Copyright HBCU Gameday 2012-2025
