Blenheim Resident Clashes With Council Over Noisy Building Site
Not just during normal operating hours, McFarlane said, but at all hours of the day.
"They were out there working until four or five o'clock on a Saturday," McFarlane said.
"And they were doing vibro-rolling. If they do vibro-rolling over there, this whole house shakes."
Vibro-rolling used a heavy duty roller to compact the ground with vibration.
McFarlane said he thought that when the Marlborough District Council approved the development of the business park opposite his Aerodrome Rd property, it would enforce the usual limits on operating hours.
But because the property was in an industrial zone, the council said there were no limits on operating hours except for land disturbance works.
Vector One Nine Ltd was developing the site into a 50-lot business park, consent documents showed.
Director Phil Robinson said the council had not been in touch with him about any complaints. They would have been dealt with by one of the three or four contractors on site, he said.
McFarlane and Lewis' property, on the west side of Aerodrome Rd, was in a rural zone.
The industrial-zoned construction site was between Omaka Aerodrome to the south, Taylor River Reserve to the east, and the Omaka Landing subdivision to the north, which was zoned urban residential.
The construction site's zoning was changed from rural to industrial in the region's major planning document, the Proposed Marlborough Environment Plan, which was finished in 2020. An appeal of the new zoning by Omaka Landing's developers was rejected.
In January, McFarlane phoned the council to complain about vibro-rolling on a Saturday afternoon.
A council staffer told him the operating hours were Monday to Friday, and until noon on a Saturday, McFarlane said.
"And I was quite happy with that because that's pretty normal."
On May 24, when workers started erecting a building outside of those hours, McFarlane contacted the council again.
"You can hear the vehicles going over there," he said.
"I could hear all that on the Saturday when they were working.
"[The council] came back and said, 'no ... there's no conditions, no hours', and I thought 'that's weird' because I know for a fact there was," he said, referring to the phone call in January.
Council compliance manager Rachel Williams said because the site had industrial zoning, the only restrictions on operating hours were for land disturbance works.
Use of the vibro-roller did not count as land disturbance works, Williams said.
"Equipment operators were spoken to on site and they decided to restrict their hours, which was done voluntarily on their part to address the complainant's concerns," Williams said.
"Under the Proposed Marlborough Environment Plan, there are no rules that restrict the hours of construction, rather the rules relate to mitigating effects such as noise through standards that limit noise levels," Williams said.
"To date no evidence of a breach has been found."
McFarlane said he thought he should have been consulted back when the resource consent was lodged with the council, particularly given there was no limit on operating hours.
"Somebody decided it wasn't notifiable because there was nobody impacted. Yeah right," he said.
"It's directly opposite all our land.
"This council is doing what the hell they feel like whenever they feel like it, and to hell with the rest of us."
McFarlane met with the council on June 10.
He said they reiterated that the site was zoned as an industrial area, but told him to call council if a vibro-roller was in use on a Saturday.
"They said everything was done by process. They seem very reluctant to admit there might be a problem."
McFarlane said he planned on writing a detailed letter to council laying out his complaint.
"So it continues," he said.
Williams said the council would continue to work with McFarlane to address his concerns.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
3 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Putting ‘soul' into every piece key to endurance
This year, Dunedin jeweller Tony Williams notches up 50 years of being in business in the city. He talks to business editor Sally Rae about his successful career. Back in 1975, Tony Williams was told the life expectancy of a small business in New Zealand was five years. Notching up a 50 year career as an artist craftsman, which has included manufacturing jewellery, employing, training, exporting, retailing and wholesaling, he has blown that timeframe out the window of his Dunedin workshop. While semi-retired, Mr Williams (76) continues to make fabulous pieces from a bench he refers to as his "world" and he has an exhibition at the Otago Art Society later this month. When it came to business success, the goldsmith and enamelist believed those that thought of it only in dollar terms had missed the point. His tenure had been successful because he had made a living, which had varied from "being appalling to quite good". He had done some great work and he had a reputation that expanded outside New Zealand. And it was a lot more than just an object that was being sold. "If you haven't dripped blood — sometimes literally — into the piece, does it really have a soul? "Being aware of that is part of how you survive." Born in England, where his father Robert (known to his family as Robin) Williams was embarking on post-graduate study at Cambridge University, he was brought up in Wellington. Robin was an influential civil servant and scientist who moved into university administration, taking the position of vice-chancellor at the University of Otago in 1967 where he oversaw a review of the struggling Otago Medical School. Describing himself as "one of those kids who didn't know what to do", the young Mr Williams dropped out of university. While there was some expectation, due to his father's standing, that he would complete his tertiary studies "and get a uni-type career", he said his father was supportive of his desire to get into jewellery making. The significant arts and crafts movement in New Zealand at that time was at its peak. While he tried to get an apprenticeship, he was too old, as, because of the economics of the time, businesses could not afford to pay adult wages, rather than a youth rate. His father made some inquiries and Mr Williams returned to England where he trained at the Birmingham School of Jewellery, receiving an honours diploma in jewellery and a diploma in gem diamonds. He later worked for Anglo-Italian jewellery designer Andrew Grima in London, the leading contemporary jeweller of the time and whose clients included members of the British Royal Family. It was a large workshop, with 20 or so staff, and Mr Williams thought he once saw the late Princess Margaret — a major customer — walk through the workshop. At lunchtime, staff were allowed to remain in the workshop and work on their own designs, but if anyone came through the workshop, they had to drop their own pieces — and their lunch — and quickly return to working on Grima designs. Returning to New Zealand, Mr Williams set up in a historic stone cottage in Port Chalmers, where the rent was the princely sum of $8 a week. The trade was very supportive, and it was also very strong; he recalled doing a headcount of retail jewellers in Dunedin and reaching 27, not counting those in South Dunedin. Dunedin jeweller John Bezett convinced him to join the local jewellers and watchmakers branch, and he also had "a foot in both camps" — which was uncommon then — as he was also on the executive of the crafts council. He attributed that to one of the reasons why his business endured, as he had always been able to cater to "both ends of the spectrum". As well as top-end pieces, he also liked to be able to find something for people who did not have much money, and the mix also provided some cashflow. In 1989, Mr Williams received an Arts Council grant for overseas study which he used to further his skills in enamelling, visiting workshops in Italy and Scotland and working for a firm in London where objet d'art were also created, some destined for the Sultan of Brunei. In 1990, he was commended in the enamelling section of the London Goldsmiths' Hall Competitions. When Mr Williams first looked at exporting, he planned to target England, but he discovered it was too far away. Diamond merchants told him he would need to be there at least twice a year, and it was too expensive and too far to go. So, in the 1990s, he started focusing on Australia, promising himself he would go at least twice a year, which he did for about 15 years. Door-knocking at first, he slowly established a few firms, and his work ended up being commissioned by some leading retailers. One reason for his success across the Tasman was the fact he did things nobody else would tackle — "fairly impossible stuff", he said. A later move into the Moray Chambers in the city coincided with changes in the Australian market but he had always ensured he had "kept things rolling" back home. When his landlord doubled the rent — "during the Global Financial Crisis, rents in Dunedin were horrendous" — he moved to the Carnegie Centre and the business became much more retail-oriented. After six years, he decided to move to a workshop next to his home where he has remained for the past 10 years. There was romance involved in working with precious stones and metals. Even as a small boy, he was a romantic and he quipped he was almost able to recite The Hobbit, long before Sir Peter Jackson adapted it to the screen. He was looking forward to his exhibition at the art society from July 18-27, his first show for about 18 months. He had some new pieces which he was very pleased with. He still also enjoyed helping anyone who was interested in learning about the jewellery trade, most recently teaching an 11-year-old girl how to make a pair of earrings.
Otago Daily Times
6 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Struggling foodbanks brace for winter surge
By Amy Williams of RNZ Foodbanks already struggling with demand are bracing for a winter surge and calling on the government for guaranteed permanent funding. The coalition was providing $15 million for the community food sector from July but ongoing funding is uncertain. Manukau Foodbank, one of the largest in the country, recently had to cap the number of people getting food parcels. Manager Joel Williams said they supported more than 200 families each week, buying staples to plug gaps in donated goods. "We've got that mixture of high quality great products, rice, milk powder... down here, tonic water and crackers. That's the tension that we sit in all the time." The foodbank, run by the Salvation Army, had operated out of a warehouse in industrial Manukau for 30 years. Williams said they had been forced to open an online booking system and cap numbers because of the constant queues of people waiting for food parcels and some missing out. "How many more need to be fed? I don't see an end to that number. We'll occasionally be closed for a public holiday and we'll select a day of the week and double the numbers for that day. "Those slots get filled up within 15 minutes. We've got an online booking system and the bookings, they're like Chili Pepper tickets." Williams said they were seeing some people who were employed, but most were without work. "There's a vast number of unemployed people in New Zealand now, and the largest number of people that we see are unemployed or partially employed, on a benefit of some type. "The two largest cohorts of people are solo mums or single older men really struggling with rent." He said over the past year there had also been an increase in migrants asking for help, as well as people who were fully employed or unemployed for the first time. The Ministry of Social Development's latest monthly update in May showed there was an 11 percent annual rise - just over 21,000 people - on the JobSeeker benefit, to 213,831. The unemployment rate was 5.1 percent. The Salvation Army ran 60 foodbanks across the country. Food security manager Sonya Cameron said another year with some government funding was a relief. "It's fantastic for us, it feels like a reprieve. We had expected that funding could have ended this July so now we've got another year. "Minister [Louise] Upston is saying very clearly that she does not expect the funding to be permanent, so we're still needing to look at how we seek ways to reduce our costs and try to become financially sustainable." Cameron said foodbanks provided vital support for people and needed ongoing funding. "People come into our centres because they need food and from there we're able to then connect them to the other support that they need." Auckland City Mission also confirmed it expected to receive approximately the same amount of government funding as last year, which meant it will not have to reduce the number of food parcels it distributes. One-off funding only It came after a collective of foodbanks wrote to Social Development Minister Louise Upston asking for ongoing sustainable funding before this year's budget announcement. Foodbanks started to receive direct government funding in 2020 during the pandemic, and over the following four years more than $200 million was invested in the sector. Since then it had been on a one-off basis only. Food security funding was extended with one-off grants to 13 providers last year, including the mission, which received a one-off $700,000 from the ministry for food parcels. The ministry said it was reviewing the way foodbanks were funded. Kore Hiakai / Zero Hunger Collective was a group of organisations working together to address food-related poverty. Executive director Tric Malcolm said its monthly data showed demand for food parcels had not eased since Christmas, and winter increased that pressure. "Capacity I think was passed a long time ago. What we've heard from foodbanks across the country for more than 12 months now is that they're trying to find ways to make everything stretch." She said ongoing government funding would help foodbanks pay for the staples they had to buy. "The level of resource available in the community has decreased, there's less people able to donate from their generous pockets because everybody's struggling with the cost of living... and there seems to be less philanthropic money that's available as well." The collective met with Upston after the recent Budget and expected to have another meeting in coming months. "When we came out of the global financial crisis we knew that food parcelling had increased exponentially, and if we kept food parcelling we're sticking a band aid on the problem." The latest Health Survey found one in four children, 27 percent, live in households that run out of food often or sometimes. "We've been inviting government to help us, help community, help business, help philanthropy find more long lasting solutions and at the same time make sure no-one in this moment goes hungry long term," she said. 'More people than ever are falling off the cliff' Looking ahead, Williams would like to see the causes of poverty addressed. "Foodbanks are not an appropriate response to food poverty. Poverty exists for one simple reason - people don't have enough money. There's a lot of things the government can do to change that. "There's a desire in our sector, in the food rescue and foodbank sector, to put ourselves out of a job, to not be needed. That would be nice. "We're the ambulance at the bottom of the cliff, and it just seems that more people than ever are falling off the cliff. Sure would be nice if somebody built a fence."
Scoop
30-06-2025
- Scoop
Marlborough Council Passes Reduced Rates Increase Of 8.61%
Marlborough District Council unanimously approved a rates increase of 8.61% along with its 2025/26 annual plan at today's [Monday] extraordinary council meeting. The vote was delayed from last Thursday's scheduled council meeting due to last-minute savings discovered in the council's insurance premiums. Chief financial officer Geoff Blake told council that after taking the weekend, council finalised a 0.76% reduction on Thursday's rates figure. 'We have received a significant reduction on last year's premium,' Blake said. '[That] had the effect of reducing the rates increase by a further 0.76%...which is about $750,000 to $760,000. 'With that we've eliminated any cost of the influence of the insurance cost on our rates increase.' Mayor Nadine Taylor welcomed this news, bringing the rates rise down 2.01% from the figure projected in the 2024 Long-Term Plan. Taylor acknowledged that while the increase was higher than ratepayers would like, most of the costs were outside of council's control. 'The increase is made up of a number of elements outside council's control - depreciation at 3.23% and local government inflationary adjustments at 3.3%, which adds up to 6.53%. 'We are also still paying for the Covid Rates Relief Fund applied during the pandemic to help ratepayers, the cost of which is spread over three years, with 1.5% every year.' The Sounds Roads recovery added another 0.23%, and additional government levies added 0.25%. Taylor said that council's inflationary figures were different, and in this case higher, than that of consumers. 'It's different than the cost index that the residents face of eggs and bread and fuel. 'Ours is concrete and bitumen, it is pipes in the ground, and so those things have to be covered.' Councillor Gerald Hope asked if the spending laid out in the annual plan got the greatest value for money for ratepayers, focusing on the must-haves rather than the nice-to-haves. 'This is one of the most important decisions we make each year,' Hope said. 'We are going to be challenged this year, as you always are in an election year, [about] frivolous spending [and] unnecessary expenditure. 'People look at us cynically and say you're spending your money in the wrong place. 'So I'm asking the obvious question on behalf of the public, are we spending money well strategically for the greater good of our community?' Blake told Hope council staff had worked to ensure the annual plan and rates rise were restricted to fundamental services. 'There were three or four items where we had considered and deferred or cancelled expenditure,' Blake said. 'I believe... we have applied appropriate due diligence in order to minimise the cost and maximise the opportunity in getting value from it.' Taylor said council had kept the pressure on staff to focus on core infrastructure. 'As a council we prioritise, and the province is seeing the benefit of that prioritisation. Because those services are being delivered and we're not chasing our tail as some other councils are.' Council claimed that of the 8.61% rates increase, 0.58% was going towards service costs, such as replacing the air-conditioning system in the Marlborough Events centre. Councillor Croad said that 'ugly hump' of rates rises might be over, but he thought council may need to have a public conversation about where more savings could be found. 'I want the public to know that we don't treat budgeting on an annual basis frivolously and lightly. We do not indulge in the nice-to-haves,' Croad said. 'We have a very, very small number that's supplied to those things, and those are things that our community have asked us for. 'We've proudly held the line wherever possible with those things, because they are of high value to the community. 'I think that moving forward... [while] we are struggling to get [rates] back down to a number that we're really happy with ... we will need to have a conversation with our community about what they're prepared to forego.' LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.
