'My voice box was removed after the NHS missed my throat cancer'
The 68-year-old retired engineer stares at his medical notes that, he says, expose in black and white the moment his life changed forever.
"I have somehow missed… due to my mistake," a doctor writes in one of the notes, after it became apparent that Mr Barton had not been urgently referred to specialists over what later became an aggressive form of throat cancer.
Steve now has a prosthetic voice box and is one of many British patients fighting medical negligence claims after being misdiagnosed.
NHS officials in Scotland are dealing with thousands of cases annually. Meanwhile, Westminster's Public Affairs Committee (PAC) recently disclosed England's Department of Health and Social Care has set aside £58.2bn to settle clinical lawsuits arising before 2024.
Mr Barton, who lives in Alloa near Stirling, repeatedly contacted his doctors after he began struggling with his breathing, speaking and swallowing. His concerns were recorded by the NHS as sinus issues.
As panic grew and his voice became weaker, Mr Barton paid to see a private consultant who revealed the devastating news that a massive tumour had grown on his larynx and required part of his throat to be removed immediately.
"I am angry, I am upset, I don't want anyone else to go through this," Mr Barton told Sky News.
"There were at least four, possibly five, conversations on the phone. He [the doctor] said to me that it sounds like I've got reflux."
'He was palmed off'
Mr Barton is now unable to work and cannot shower by himself because if water enters the hole in his neck, he could drown.
And a windy day can cause a debilitating coughing fit if a gust catches his prosthetic voice box.
Asked if he believes this was avoidable, Mr Barton replied: "Absolutely. 100%."
His wife, Heather, told Sky News: "He hates this. You see him crying. It breaks my heart. It's been hard emotionally."
She added: "Everybody knows their own body. He was palmed off and the consequence is a neck dissection. It [life] changed overnight."
Legal battle over compensation
The Barton family have been locked in a legal battle over their ordeal with the Medical and Dental Defence Union Scotland (MDDUS) - a body which indemnifies GPs.
It has not admitted formal liability in this case but has agreed to settle financial compensation to Mr Barton.
Izabela Wosiak, a solicitor from Irwin Mitchell who represents the Bartons, said: "Cases like Steve's are complex and usually quite difficult, but solicitors have accepted there was no defence to this case.
"They have arranged to make an interim payment; however we are still in the process of negotiating final settlement."
A MDDUS spokeswoman refused to comment while talks are being finalised.
What is the scale of medical negligence in Britain?
The NHS in Scotland is under the devolved control of the Scottish government.
Figures suggest there were almost 14,000 clinical negligence claims and incidents in 2023/24, an increase on the previous year.
It comes as PAC warned that the total liabilities in England's health service has hit £58.2bn.
PAC chair Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown MP told Sky News: "I extend my sympathies to Steve and his family. Unfortunately, he is not alone.
"Some are really heart-wrenching tales. Every single claim somebody is involved, someone has been in some way injured, so this is a terrible thing.
"We are going to be working on how we can make the whole system less litigious and get compensation paid out quickly because if the state does harm to somebody, the least they could do is to compensate them as quickly as possible."
Paul Whiteing, the chief executive of patient safety charity Action Against Medical Accidents, told Sky News: "The NHS itself last year [in England] paid out just over £5bn in compensational set aside money for compensation that it would need to pay out.
"It's a huge cost and of course that doesn't speak to the cost to every individual, every family, every person who is impacted by the consequences of some form of medical accident and the trauma that can go with that."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
2 hours ago
- Telegraph
Labour-led council to ban baby formula adverts
A Labour-led council is set to ban baby formula companies from advertising its products on sites it owns. Knowsley council in Merseyside made the move as part of its wider plans to prevent the marketing of what it described as 'health harming' products. Last year, the local authority announced it would restrict adverts for unhealthy food on its sites as part of a strategy to tackle obesity rates. A report commissioned by the council has said baby formula should also be included because it is often marketed in a way that suggests it is a better alternative to breastfeeding, BBC News reported. The Advertising Standards Authority, the UK's advertising regulator, prohibits the marketing of baby formula for children under six months – but companies are able to advertise follow-on milks. This proposed ban would go even further by extending it to all baby formula – not just products for children up to a specific age. The World Health Organisation recommends mothers breastfeed their children for the first six months and continue to do so alongside solid foods until a child is at least two years old as best practice. The council's report said: 'Infant formula is often marketed in such a way it suggests its benefits outweigh breastfeeding or simply using cows' milk after the age of one. 'The marketing and packaging of these products can be misleading and undermines public health messaging for breastfeeding, widening health inequalities particularly for those on lower incomes.' The report also proposed similar restrictions on baby foods – typically sold in pouches – because they too, it claimed, are made out to be healthier alternatives to food prepared at home in raw form. It said the food was 'often less nutritious' than prepared foods at home. More than two-thirds of UK babies are given at least some formula milk within two months of birth, official statistics show. However, prices have surged in recent years due to rapid growth in demand and issues with global supply chains. In February 2024, the Competition and Markets Authority launched an investigation into the baby formula market as it sought to address why prices had risen by 25 per cent in just two years. Demand has risen even more acutely for special types of baby formula – including lactose-free versions – but experts have warned against babies without the particular allergies from consuming the product. Dr Vicky Sibson, head of charity First Steps Nutrition, wrote in a paper published in August 2024 that without a cow's milk allergy, babies who consume lactose-free formulas are more likely to gain too much weight or have tooth decay, as the natural milk sugar lactose is replaced with more unhealthy sugars.
Telegraph
2 hours ago
- Telegraph
Women standing up for their rights have been punished, claims UN expert
The United Nations' expert for women and girls has said organisations 'punished' those who stand up for sex-based rights. Reem Alsalem said public bodies that do not support women's right to single-sex spaces are going 'against what is now the law of the land', in reference to Sandie Peggie, the nurse at the centre of an employment tribunal against NHS Fife. Ms Peggie was suspended by NHS Fife from her role at the Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy in 2024 after she complained about having to share changing facilities with Dr Beth Upton, who is male but identifies as a woman. Ms Alsalem, who has been re-appointed as the UN Special Rapporteur for Women and Girls, urged the Scottish government to speed up the release of its guidance following the recent Supreme Court judgment that 'sex' in equality law refers to biological sex and not gender identity. 'Particularly since the Supreme Court ruling, punishing women because they indicate their support for their sex-based right at work seems to me to be very problematic and goes against what is now the law of the land,' she said. 'No ambiguity' Guidance clarifying how the Supreme Court judgment is to be implemented in practice is expected from the Scottish government, but no publication date has been given. It said that it was waiting for advice from the Equalities and Human Rights Commission. Consultation on the guidance closed on July 1. Ms Alsalem said: 'I do not think we should pause or put on hold any action awaiting this guidance, and I don't think the Supreme Court said that either. 'While it is good you will have guidance, I do agree with those who say that there is a lot that can and should be implemented. 'It is not that there is ambiguity about all aspects of what the supreme court says.' Ms Alsalem has been a vocal critic of the Scottish government's reforms to gender recognition legislation, warning in 2022 that proposals for self-identification could 'open the door for violent males who identify as men to abuse the process of acquiring a gender certificate and the rights that are associated with it'. Ministers had pushed back on this suggestion with Shona Robison, the then-social justice secretary, saying there was no body of evidence pointing to 'bad faith actors' trying to use statutory processes to abuse women and girls. 'Exploitation and abuse' In June, Ms Alsalem presented a report to the UN Human Rights Council in which she assesses gender-based violence in the UK. 'Women and girls, as well as their male allies, who wish to reassert their needs and rights based on their sex and have asserted the immutable nature of sex, have been ostracised, attacked and punished by State and non-State actors, including political parties, universities, private employers and the media, for their beliefs and opinions,' she wrote. She also called for Police Scotland to clarify its approach to data collection and end its current practice of conflating biological sex with gender identity. 'The conflation of sex and gender data in particular prioritising self-identified gender – erases biological sex records, distorting the male-driven nature of violence against women and girls and hindering root-cause analysis,' she said. 'This approach undermines crime statistics and policy effectiveness in relation to violence against women and girls.' In her report, Ms Alsalem backed proposed legislation, by Ash Regan, the Alba MSP, that criminalised men for paying for sex and decriminalised women working in prostitution. 'The data emanating from countries that apply the Nordic model shows very clearly that it works,' she said. 'And data that comes from countries that legalise all aspects of prostitution, I don't use the term sex work, because you are not doing work, and you are not selling sex. 'It is exploitation and abuse, and it's not a regular job.' However, she said the Bill did not go far enough and should be extended, as in Sweden, to cover websites such as Only Fans.
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Woman who had size 34H breasts reveals she needed help showering and had to spend hundreds on special bras
A woman who had size 34H breasts has revealed that her chest was so big she needed help showering and had to spend hundreds of dollars on special bras. Amy Hills, 24, first started developing a large chest at age 14 but things spiraled in her late teens. At just four-foot-seven-inches, the weight of her breasts left her in constant agony and barely able to function. She said the pain got so bad she struggled to eat, sleep, and even breathe. 'My back and neck pain became debilitating,' she told What's The Jam recently. 'I lived with constant neck, back and shoulder pain and my posture suffered. Exercise was painful and felt embarrassing. 'I couldn't eat because I was so nauseous from constant pain. I had to supplement my intake with protein powders. 'I couldn't get out of bed without help. I felt like I was losing my mind – I was so stuck and in so much pain. At just four-foot-seven-inches, Amy Hills, 24, said the weight of her breasts left her in constant agony and barely able to function 'Even sleeping was difficult – I'd wake up sore and uncomfortable and it reached the point where I couldn't get a full breath in due to the weight on my chest.' What was even worse than the physical pain was the 'emotional toll' that it had on her. She recalled getting stares from strangers in public, and struggled to feel comfortable with her appearance. 'It was the emotional toll that hit hardest,' she continued. 'I felt hyper-visible in public, even when I was just wearing a hoodie. 'Strangers would make comments or stare. I dreaded photos and avoided certain clothes entirely – tight tops, swimsuits, anything with buttons. 'I often cried while getting dressed and found it hard to recognize myself in the mirror. It obliterated my confidence, my relationships, my mental health – everything.' Unable to purchase normal bras, Amy would be forced to spend roughly $100 each on specially sized ones – even then being left with little to no support. Buying clothes was often just as miserable as she had to size up and pay for tailoring or settle for oversized styles that didn't feel like her. She said: 'I couldn't wear standard bras – they didn't make my size in most stores. 'I was spending $100 to $150 per bra and I'd still end up with red marks and shoulder grooves. 'Every time I tried on clothes, I felt ashamed and ended up crying in the change rooms.' The business support officer, who lives in Australia, even stopped looking in mirrors and avoided going out – and she didn't even feel at ease in her own home. She needed assistance with basic activities like getting dressed, putting on shoes, and showering. 'I couldn't get out of bed without help and I could hardly use my arms as every slight movement triggered instant pain,' she explained. 'Due to this, my partner Charlie helped me dress, put on shoes and at times even helped me to walk. 'He also supported me in the shower because I would get dizzy and couldn't bend or twist. 'It made me feel so vulnerable – like I wasn't in control of my own body. I felt like an empty shell of the person I once was and I couldn't find a way out.' It got so bad that she contemplated ending her life. Amy (seen left before and right after the surgery) gushed: 'I felt relieved, emotional, and weirdly light [after my surgery] – physically and emotionally' 'It reached the point where I struggled with suicidal ideation, I struggled in darkness trying to cling to anything that would take away the constant debilitating pain and the mental anguish and grief of the life I couldn't live,' Amy shared. For years, the Australian native wanted to get breast reduction surgery but private clinics quoted her up to $13,500 for the procedure. She applied to have it done through Australia's public healthcare system but was rejected four times. But the young woman kept pushing, documenting her physical and emotional symptoms with her GP until she was finally referred to a surgeon who agreed it was medically necessary. After a long wait, Amy's operation finally went ahead free of charge in April this year. Surgeons removed around three pounds of breast tissue and performed a nipple lift to reshape her chest. The breast reduction surgery took her chest size down to a 12D, and she couldn't be happier. She has been documenting her journey on social media, where is has gone viral, and she has now created a free FAQ guide for anyone considering having breast reduction surgery. Amy concluded: 'I felt relieved, emotional, and weirdly light [after my surgery] – physically and emotionally. 'I cried the first time I looked down. I felt like I could breathe again and I finally saw a version of myself that felt right. 'I can now sleep on my side, wear cute tops, exercise freely, go for walks without pain, run and hold my body with pride. 'I even went to a concert in a crop top recently – something I never thought I'd do. Even just relaxing at home, I feel so much more comfortable and at ease. 'I feel free. The weight is gone – literally and emotionally. My confidence has skyrocketed. 'I don't cry getting dressed anymore. I feel connected to my body for the first time in years. And I feel proud, not just of how I look, but of how far I've come.'
