TMC MP Mahua Moitra moves Supreme Court against EC's revision of electoral rolls in Bihar
In her plea, Ms. Moitra said she seeks setting aside of the order dated June 24 under which Special Intensive Revision (SIR) is being conducted in alleged violation of various provisions of the Constitution.
"The present writ petition has been filed in public interest under Article 32 of the Constitution seeking setting aside of order dated 24.06.2025 issued by Election Commission of India under which SIR of electoral rolls in Bihar is being conducted in violation of Articles 14, 19(1)(a), 21, 325, 328 of the Constitution and provisions of Representation of People (RP) Act, 1950 and Registration of Electors (RER) Rules, 1960 which, if not set aside, can lead to large-scale disenfranchisement of eligible voters in the country thereby undermining democracy and free and fair elections," it submitted.
Ms. Moitra further sought a direction from the apex court to restrain the Election Commission of India from issuing similar orders for SIR of electoral rolls in other states of the country.
"It is submitted that it is for the very first time in the country that such an exercise is being conducted by ECI, where electors whose names are already there in electoral rolls and who have already voted multiple times in are being asked to prove their eligibility," the plea filed through advocate Neha Rathi said.
The plea said "the impugned SIR order requires the inclusion or retention of a voter's name in the electoral roll upon production of citizenship documents, including proof of citizenship of either or both parents, failing which the voter is at risk of exclusion.This requirement is ultra vires Article 326 and introduces extraneous qualifications not contemplated by the Constitution of the RP Act 1950.' A similar plea has also been filed by NGO Association of Democratic Reforms challenging the poll panel's direction for SIR of electoral rolls in Bihar.
The ECI on June 24 issued instructions to carry out an SIR in Bihar, apparently to weed out ineligible names and ensure only eligible citizens are included in the electoral roll.
Bihar goes to polls later this year.
The NGO has also sought setting aside of the order and communication, arguing that it violates Articles 14, 19, 21, 325, and 326 of the Constitution, as well as provisions of the Representation of People's Act, 1950, and Rule 21A of the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960.
The NGO's plea filed through advocate Prashant Bhushan said the EC order "can arbitrarily and without due process" disenfranchise lakhs of voters and disrupt free and fair elections.
"That the documentation requirements of the directive, lack of due process as well as the unreasonably short timeline for the said Special Intensive Revision of Electoral Roll in Bihar further make this exercise bound to result in removal of names of lakhs of genuine voters from electoral rolls leading to their disenfranchisement," the plea said.
The last such revision in Bihar was conducted in 2003.
According to the EC, the exercise was necessitated by rapid urbanisation, frequent migration, young citizens becoming eligible to vote, non-reporting of deaths, and inclusion of the names of foreign illegal immigrants.
It said with the exercise, it wants to ensure the integrity and preparation of error-free electoral rolls.
The SIR is being conducted by booth officers, who are conducting a house-to-house survey for verification.
The EC said it will scrupulously adhere to the constitutional and legal provisions as laid down in Article 326 of the Constitution and Section 16 of the Representation of the People Act, 1950, in carrying out the revision.
Several other civil society organisations like PUCL and activists like Yogendra Yadav have approached the top court against the ECI's direction.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
35 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Bihar voter roll revision: Five of 11 documents sought do not show date or place of birth
At least five out of the 11 key documents sought by the Election Commission of India (EC) for Bihar's voters' list revision do not indicate the applicant's place or date of birth — one of the pre-requisites for inclusion in the electoral rolls. Aadhaar, voter identity cards issued by the EC or PAN cards have not been included in the list of 11 indicative documents that the applicants can produce. However, these excluded documents are often the ones submitted by people to procure any of the 11 documents required for inclusion during the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) in Bihar. Among the 11 documents sought by the EC, the Scheduled Caste/Scheduled Tribe certificate, Forest Rights Certificate and Permanent Resident Certificate (or Domicile Certificates) do not display the date of birth or place of birth of an applicant. Two other documents accepted — the National Register of Citizens (NRC) and Family Register — do not exist in Bihar. The Domicile Certificate, which can be issued by a Revenue officer or Tehsildar, is in much demand in Bihar since the SIR was announced, and is often issued on the production of an Aadhaar card. A booth-level officer (BLO) of Chapra district of Bihar told The Hindu that out of the 500 forms distributed by him in the past one week, 185 were filled and returned by the applicants. 'Just 10% of the filled forms were supported by the required documents — all submitted school leaving certificates. Those who did not have any of the 11 documents said they have applied for a domicile certificate and hoped to get it in the next 10-12 days. Applicants said they provided a copy of Aadhaar to get the domicile certificate,' the BLO said. Brajesh Munan, a local functionary of the Opposition Congress party in the State said, 'Among the documents sought only a few mention the date of birth. Usually Aadhaar is furnished as the proof of date of birth which the EC is not accepting this time'. Mr. Munan said that 25% of those expected to submit the documents are estimated to be at risk of not being able to furnish them, potentially facing deletion in the voter rolls. To be included in the electoral rolls, nearly 2.93 crore people are expected to furnish the documents. During the 2024 General Elections, Bihar had 7.9 crore voters, out of which 4.96 crore voters who were there in the 2003 revision list, need not submit the details, the EC has said. A specimen of a caste certificate application on Bihar Government's website required applicants to mention the Aadhar registration number. Mirroring the criteria mentioned in the Citizenship Act, 1955, the ongoing SIR in the poll-bound State also empowers the electoral registration officers (ERO) to report cases of suspected foreign nationals to a 'competent authority' based on the said documents. According to the 2023 Manual of Electoral Rolls, published by the EC in March the same year, 'In case of non-availability of documents, an oath or affirmation from one of the parents, or Sarpanch and even a visible examination by the BLO can work as proof of age.' The ERO can conduct local enquiries to establish proof of residence in the absence of documentary evidence. When contacted EC sources reiterated that 'the final decision has to be taken by the ERO based on field visits.' The SC/ST and OBC certificates, which are issued by officers of the rank of Tehsildars and above in the district administration, reveal only the holder's name, where they 'ordinarily reside', their community's name, their parents' names, and community name. None of them display information on the holder's place of birth or date of birth. This information is required in the application forms but not displayed in the certificates. Further, FRA titles distributed under the 2006 law reveal information on the holder's name/s, their spouse, dependants' and parents' names, the village and address, if they are ST or not, the area of land covered under it, and demarcations of the same. These titles are signed by a forest officer, a tribal welfare officer and the District Collector. In Bihar, as of May 2025, there are 191 individuals holding FRA titles in the entire State. According to the June 24 order of the Election Commission for the Bihar SIR, people can furnish pension payment order issued to regular employee/pensioner of the government, any certificate issued by local authorities, banks, post offices and such prior to July 1, 1987; birth certificate; passport; matriculation/educational certificate; Permanent Residence Certificate issued by the competent State authority; Forest Right Certificate; SC/ST certificate; National Register of Citizens (wherever it exists), Family Register or any land/house allotment certificate issued by the government for the inclusion in the voter rolls. (With inputs from Abhinay Lakshman)
Time of India
37 minutes ago
- Time of India
Pure rolls key to democracy, says CEC as Bihar revision hits 47%
Patna: Chief election commissioner Gyanesh Kumar on Tuesday said pure electoral rolls were essential for strengthening democracy as the Election Commission (EC) claimed that it had reached the halfway mark in collecting enumeration forms in Bihar during the ongoing special intensive revision (SIR) of electoral rolls. "Pure electoral rolls are inevitable for strengthening democracy," the CEC told reporters in Delhi, amid the revision drive underway in the poll-bound state. According to the EC, the SIR is progressing rapidly, with 3,70,77,077 enumeration forms collected by the end of Tuesday, amounting to 46.95% of the total 7,89,69,844 electors in Bihar,just 14 days into the exercise launched last month. "In the first two weeks of the exercise, 7.90 crore forms were printed and over 97% of forms were distributed to the electors," the EC said. It added that 82,78,617 forms were collected in the past 24 hours alone, accounting for 10.5% of the total. The collection effort has been bolstered by the addition of 20,603 booth level officers (BLOs) to the 77,895 already working on the ground. These BLOs are conducting door-to-door visits to help electors fill out and submit their forms. The EC also stated that approximately four lakh volunteers, including govt officials, NCC cadets and NSS members, are working across the state to support the elderly, persons with disabilities, the sick and other vulnerable groups in completing the process. The commission also reiterated on Tuesday that the SIR guidelines issued on June 24 stand firmly on four key pillars. First, the exercise is "all-inclusive" with enumeration forms distributed to all 7.89 crore electors in Bihar. Second, every elector who submits a form will be included in the draft electoral roll, to be published on Aug 1. Third, the eligibility of an elector is determined in accordance with Article 326 of the Constitution. And fourth, any exclusion will only be made after an inquiry and will require a reasoned or "speaking" order by the electoral registration officer (ERO), which can be appealed. "Any person aggrieved by the decision of the ERO may prefer an appeal to the district magistrate and a second appeal can be preferred before the chief electoral officer against the order of the DM, in accordance with Section 24 of the Representation of the People Act, 1950," the EC said. The poll body expressed confidence that, given the current momentum, the revision exercise will be completed well before the deadline.
Indian Express
an hour ago
- Indian Express
Maharashtra government proposes amendments to slum revamp Act to fast-track projects
The Maharashtra government Tuesday proposed amendments to the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971, allowing the Slum Rehabilitation Authority (SRA) to recover pending transit rent dues from builders and developers by attaching not only company assets but also personal properties of directors or partners if necessary. Transit rent is paid by the developer or the developing authority to the eligible people vacating their premises for redevelopment/rehabilitation purposes, till they avail permanent alternate accommodation. The amendment bill, introduced in the state Legislative Assembly, seeks to treat unpaid rent to slum dwellers as arrears of land revenue, thereby empowering the SRA to initiate recovery proceedings under the Maharashtra Land Revenue Code (MLRC). This includes the right to seize and auction movable and immovable property, and in some cases, attach bank accounts or lockers. As per the amendment, if a defaulting builder lacks sufficient company assets to clear dues, the liability can extend to the personal property of its directors or partners. Currently, SRA can issue stop-work notices or deny new permissions to a defaulting developer. However, officials said that even as stop working is issued, the slum dwellers are left in lurch with no rent and the lack of stronger punitive measures has led to widespread non-payment of rent and hence the amendment is necessary. The SRA hopes that the amendments will help fast-track the rehabilitation projects and also ensure slum dwellers are not left in the lurch without their rightful rent, the official said The bill also seeks to reduce the window for dissenting slum dwellers to join SRA schemes — from 120 days to 60 days — once a majority (over 50 per cent) has consented to a redevelopment plan. After the 60-day period, those who have not joined the scheme risk losing their claim to on-site rehabilitation and may only be considered for relocation elsewhere, subject to availability. Another provision allows land under slum redevelopment to be handed over to government agencies within 30 days of issuance of a letter of intent, enabling faster execution of public sector-led projects. The bill is expected to be taken up for discussion later this week. Meanwhile, the state government has also proposed an amendment to the Maharashtra Control of Organised Crime Act (MCOCA) aimed at bringing drug peddlers under its purview. The amendment seeks to expand the definition of 'organised crime' to include activities related to narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances. This bill is expected to be discussed in the Legislative Assembly later this week.
