Fact Check: No, these aren't real photos showing mammoth skeleton's excavation
Four images shared in social media posts were authentic photographs of a well-preserved mammoth skeleton discovered at a North American archaeological site.
Rating:
Since 2024, a set of images has circulated online that allegedly shows the excavation of the complete skeleton of a mammoth. Mammoths were a type of large elephant that went extinct around 4,000 years ago, according to the Natural History Museum in London.
Two of the images appeared in multiple (archived) Facebook posts (archived) that paired them with a caption reading "Well-Preserved Mammoth Skeleton Unearthed at North America's Prominent Archaeological Site."
(Facebook user Husky Chukcha)
Other Facebook posts featured a collage that contained one of the same images alongside two different images that appeared to show the remains of mammoths emerging from the ground. The captions of these posts claimed the images showed a 15,000-year-old mammoth skeleton in North Africa.
(Facebook user DiggingInto Archaeology)
In short, none of the four images included in these posts were authentic photos of the remains of real mammoths. As a result, we've rated the images as fake.
Although we have not yet identified the original creator or creators of the images, they all showed signs of being the products of artificial intelligence software. The AI image detectors WasItAI and Illuminarty both found a high likelihood that someone created the images using AI.
Visual clues in the images also signaled that the images did not reflect reality. The skeletons in the images had multiple features that did not match the anatomy of real mammoth specimens held in the collections of the American Museum of Natural History in New York City and the Smithsonian National Museum of Natural History in Washington, D.C.
Most obviously, the alleged skeletal mammoth remains in the images investigated here included trunks and ears, which are respectively highlighted in red and yellow in the collage below. In one of the images, visible in the upper right corner of the collage, the mammoth's trunk also appeared to end in a tusklike point.
As is the case for those of modern elephants, mammoth trunks did not contain any bones, nor did they have sharp tips. Instead, real mammoth trunks consisted primarily of muscle. The external parts of mammoths' ears were likewise boneless (although, like humans, mammoths did have bones in their middle ears).
(Facebook users HuskyChukcha [left] and DiggingInto Archaeology [right])
Other anatomical features seen in the images also failed to match the real anatomy of mammoths, such as the oddly branching ribs visible in the image that appeared in all the posts linked above. The ribs in question are outlined in blue in the above collage.
In another image, which seemingly showed the mammoth skeleton from the rear, the mammoth appeared to have three separate tails emerging from its rump: one consisting of a single long, pointed bone and the other two resembling claws or talons, as can be seen surrounded by a green box in the above collage.
By contrast, real mammoths had only one tail each, and their tails were part of their vertebral columns — meaning they consisted of many smaller bones.
Finally, a real newly excavated mammoth skeleton would not stand upright on its own, as the skeletons in the images appeared to do. In order to produce the effect that a specimen is standing up, museum workers and other professionals who work with the fossils of mammoths, dinosaurs, and other animals must build and install complex mounts to support the bones and hold them in place.
Another hint that the posts about the alleged discovery did not reflect reality was the inconsistency of information included in text form in posts sharing the images. As mentioned above, some posts implied the discovery was North African, while others said the location was "North America's Prominent Archaeological Site" — without any indication of which of the North American continent's many archaeological sites was intended.
Some Facebook users also pointed out in comments that the scientists who excavate and study the fossilized remains of animals are called paleontologists, not archaeologists. That said, because mammoths and humans coexisted for tens of thousands of years, it's not unheard of for archaeological sites — that is, sites that show evidence of human activity — to also contain mammoth remains.
In the past, we investigated whether another image authentically showed the preserved remains of a baby mammoth that died about 30,000 years ago.
Clovis Mammoth Butchery: The Lange/Ferguson Site and Associated Bone Tool Technology – Center for the Study of the First Americans. https://liberalarts.tamu.edu/csfa/2018/05/04/clovis-mammoth-butchery-the-lange-ferguson-site-and-associated-bone-tool-technology/#:~:text=The%20Lange%2FFerguson%20site%20is,Clovis%2Dperiod%20mammoth%20butchering%20event. Accessed 14 Feb. 2025.
Dapcevich, Madison. "Authentic Picture of 30,000-Year-Old Baby Mammoth Remains?" Snopes, 14 Apr. 2024, https://www.snopes.com//fact-check/baby-mammoth-picture/.
"How Are Skeletal Mounts of Dinosaurs in Museum Exhibits Built?" American Museum of Natural History, July 2012, https://www.amnh.org/explore/videos/dinosaurs-and-fossils/how-are-skeletal-mounts-of-dinosaurs-in-museum-exhibits-built.
Mammuthus Primigenius (Blumbach) | 3D Digitization. https://3d.si.edu/object/3d/mammuthus-primigenius-blumbach%3A341c96cd-f967-4540-8ed1-d3fc56d31f12. Accessed 14 Feb. 2025.
published, Cameron Duke. "Woolly Mammoths Survived on Mainland North America until 5,000 Years Ago, DNA Reveals." Livescience.Com, 22 Dec. 2021, https://www.livescience.com/woolly-mammoths-in-north-america-longer.
The Intersecting Crossroads of Paleontology and Archeology: When Are Fossils Considered Artifacts? (U.S. National Park Service). https://www.nps.gov/articles/000/the-intersecting-crossroads-of-paleontology-and-archeology-when-are-fossils-considered-artifacts.htm. Accessed 14 Feb. 2025.
The Last of the Mammoths | Natural History Museum. https://www.nhm.ac.uk/discover/last-mammoths.html. Accessed 14 Feb. 2025.
TRUTH OR TAIL: An Elephant's Trunk Has over 40,000 Muscles| Cleveland Zoological Society | June 26, 2023. https://www.clevelandzoosociety.org/z/2023/06/26/truth-or-tail-an-elephants-trunk-has-over-40000-muscles. Accessed 14 Feb. 2025.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
USA Today
13 hours ago
- USA Today
Volcanoes in multiple states have been rumbling. What's going on?
Volcanoes in Alaska, Washington state, Oregon and Hawaii have recently been rumbling and even spewing lava, enough to spark a swarm of news stories. But despite the jolts and temblors, geologists say there's no cause for alarm. "Volcanoes can be unpredictable and there's always chance that something bad will happen, but these recent seismic events along the Pacific Ring of Fire from Alaska to Washington to offshore Oregon are probably not directly related to each other," said Natalia Ruppert, a seismologist with the U.S. Geological Survey's Earthquake Science Center in Seattle. "This is what volcanoes do," she said. "They come to life for a while, sometimes the earthquake activity leads to an eruption and sometimes it doesn't." Most of the U.S. volcanoes that have been making themselves known since spring woke up a bit, shook themselves off and then fell back into slumber. Two, one in Hawaii and one in Alaska, are in the midst of active and ongoing – but relatively small and non-threatening – eruptions. While it all might seem ominous, it isn't. It's simply part of life on a dynamic, seismically active planet. There's no direct connection between any of these, said Ruppert. "The distance between these (seismic) activity centers is thousands of miles." Recent US volcanic activity While volcanoes have always been a part of the West Coast's geography, it might seem that this is an especially busy time for these mountains caused by fissures in the Earth's crust that go down to the mantle below. But seismologists and volcanologists are keeping a careful eye on them, said Ruppert. "This is why the federal government funds earthquake and volcano monitoring efforts through the Department of the Interior and USGS." Consider these recent events: The volcanoes are located along what's known as the Ring of Fire, a 25,000-mile long, horseshoe-shaped string of volcanoes and seismically active areas that stretches from the southern tip of South America, up along the West coast of the United States, across the coast of Alaska, down through Japan all the way to New Zealand. It's created by the Pacific plate sinking below the North American plate and is the most seismically and volcanically active zone in the world, according to the U.S. Geological Survey. Eruptions in Hawaii Far to the west in Hawaii, Mt. Kilauea continues to erupt, though as of July 11 it has not been exhibiting the massive fountains of lava that had been taking place earlier in the month. On July 9, USGS said the most recent eruption had ended. Hawaii's volcanoes are not part of the Ring of Fire. The island chain was (and is still being) formed by a volcanic hot spot that has so far created 15 different volcanoes that stretch 3,800 miles across the Pacific. In Hawaii's case, the volcanoes are the result of a heat source deep within the Earth's mantle. The plume of magma coming from that hot spot in the ocean floor remains stationary as the Pacific Plate slowly – 2 to 4 inches a year – moves over top of it. This is why Hawaii's oldest volcanoes, on Kauai, are 5.5 million years old while the newest, on the Big Island, are only 700,000 years old and still growing.
Miami Herald
2 days ago
- Miami Herald
‘Splash in the water' turns out to be ‘species of mystery' in Malaysia. See it
As darkness settled over a nature reserve of Malaysia, a 'rare' creature emerged and moved along the riverbank. A nearby trail camera captured its presence in the country's first such sighting 'in over a decade.' But no one realized the significance of the photos — until now. Conservationists and forestry officials set up trail cameras at Tangkulap Forest Reserve last year as part of a project to survey flat-headed cats, an endangered species of wildcats, the organization Panthera said in a July 1 blog post. During the survey, the trail cameras photographed whatever animals wandered past. Later, researchers sifted through these images and found some 'unidentified otter photos,' which they labeled 'by-catch' and put in the 'general archives,' Thye Lim, Panthera's Malaysia project coordinator, told McClatchy News. The otter photos sat around, largely untouched, until earlier this year, when Panthera researchers revisited the data as part of a 'collaboration with the Malaysian Otter Network,' Lim said. To their surprise and excitement, the otter experts noticed a set of photos from February 2024 showing a Eurasian otter — the country's first sighting of the species in 11 years, the organization told McClatchy News via email. Eurasian otters are widespread from Asia to Europe, but 'its presence in Southeast Asia is largely unknown and extremely rare, and it's considered highly endangered' in Malaysia, Panthera said. 'The Eurasian otter has long been a species of mystery in Sabah,' Lim said. Photos show the otter moving along a riverbank at night. Panthera praised the Eurasian otter sighting, saying its 'splash in the water has made waves in the conservation world.' 'It is exciting to hear about this recent discovery of the Eurasian otter in Sabah,' Mohd Azlan Jayasilan bin Abdul Gulam Azad, a specialist with Malaysian Otter Network, said in the blog post. 'Studying otters is challenging and often underrepresented in many natural history-related research efforts in Malaysia.' 'This rare discovery marks a historic moment,' Panthera wrote in a July 2 Facebook post. Tangkulap Forest Reserve is now 'the only location in Malaysia where all four of the country's otter species coexist,' Panthera said. Still, 'pollution, habitat fragmentation and overfishing remain significant threats to their survival.' Tangkulap Forest Reserve is in the Malaysian state of Sabah on the island of Borneo, which is shared between Malaysia, Brunei and Indonesia.
USA Today
2 days ago
- USA Today
Catch NYC's last Manhattanhenge of 2025. How to see sunset spectacle.
If you missed the Manhattanhenge earlier this year, you can catch it one more time this weekend. The solar spectacle occurs when "the setting Sun aligns precisely with the Manhattan street grid, creating a radiant glow of light across Manhattan's brick and steel canyons, simultaneously illuminating both the north and south sides of every cross street of the borough's grid," according to the American Museum of Natural History (AMNH). Hundreds, if not thousands, gather along the streets of Manhattan to witness the solar phenomenon, which the museum describes as "a rare and beautiful sight." Here's what to know about the final Manhattanhenge of 2025 and when to see it. Need a break? Play the USA TODAY Daily Crossword Puzzle. When is Manhattanhenge? Dates, time The Manhattanhenge phenomenon occurs twice a year, two days in May and two days in July, according to AMNH. While the first Manhattanhenge occurred in May, the next Manhattanhenge with the full sun in the frame of New York City skyscrapers is expected to take place on Friday, July 11, at 8:20 p.m. ET. A half-Manhattanhenge with half the sun will also take place on Saturday, July 12, at 8:22 p.m. ET. While July 11 will see a full sun in the frame of New York City skyscrapers, Saturday's Manhattanhenge will have the top half of the sun on the grid of the city, according to the museum. What are the best spots to see the Manhattanhenge? For the best views of the Manhattanhenge, NYC Parks and the museum recommend the following streets and spots: NYC Parks also recommends arriving early at the suggested spots to get a good view because the spectacle lasts for only a few minutes. Manhattanhenge history Jackie Faherty, an astronomer at the American Museum of Natural History, who determines the dates for the Manhattanhenge each year, told the New York Times (NYT) last year that the earliest mention of the phenomenon he was able to find was a 1997 comic strip published in the Natural History magazine. However, Faherty reckons that people may have noticed the Manhattanhenge even before that, given the grid-like layout of the city. The term "Manhattanhenge" was coined by Neil deGrasse Tyson, director of the Hayden Planetarium, in 2002, who was inspired by the ancient Stonehenge monument in England, according to the NYT. Saman Shafiq is a trending news reporter for USA TODAY. Reach her at sshafiq@ and follow her on X and Instagram @saman_shafiq7.
