Complaints to Ombudsman rose 30% in five years to 2024
The number of complaints to the Ombudsman rose by over 30% between 2019 and 2024, according to its latest annual report.
Last year, almost 1,500 complaints out of a total of 4,478 were about local authorities. Almost 1,400 related to Government departments and offices.
The Department of Social Protection was the subject of over 600 complaints.
There were 887 complaints about public bodies in the health sector with 705 involving the HSE and 149 about the child and family agency Tusla.
The Ombudsman Ger Deering used the annual report as an opportunity to call on the Government to provide funding to support younger people in nursing homes and, where appropriate, move them to more suitable accommodation.
Following an investigation by the Ombudsman in 2021, the HSE set up an 'under-65 programme' and successfully transitioned over 100 people to more suitable accommodation.
The scheme - according to the report - also "improved the lives" of those who could not transition out of nursing homes.
'Completely unacceptable' scheme cannot be delivered - Ombudsman
However, the HSE has said that there is insufficient funding to continue to assist many of the young people to move to more appropriate accommodation or to continue the programme.
Mr Deering described as "completely unacceptable", that the programme, which brought hope and independence to people with disabilities "cannot be delivered because of a lack of funding".
When it comes to supporting disabled people to access transport, he welcomed a commitment from the Department of Transport to develop a new scheme.
The Ombudsman has noted that over the last 13 years, he and his two predecessors highlighted the lack of appropriate supports for people with disabilities since the Mobility Allowance and the Motorised Transport Grant were closed to new applicants.
He expressed cautious optimism that "a long-standing injustice" was about to be righted, adding that, progress would be closely monitored.
Department of Social Protection complaint
A number of complaints have been highlighted in the report including one where the Department of Social Protection mistakenly recalled payment from a deceased carer's account.
'Anne' contacted the Ombudsman after the department recalled a payment of over €2,700 it incorrectly believed it had paid to the bank account of her son and carer, Martin, who had recently died.
Anne and her family contacted the department several times over a 12-month period to highlight the error and get a refund, but the Department refused.
It emerged that while Anne had notified the Department of her son's death, the department had attempted to continue to pay Carer's Allowance and a Carer's Support Grant into Martin's account.
As his account had been closed, the bank automatically returned any payments to the department.
However, the department did not know that the payment had been returned and also recalled the payment which meant that the money left Martin's bank account in error.
This error arose as the Department had not updated the returned payments to its account, and therefore believed that Martin had received the payment.
The department apologised to Anne for the error and refunded the money it had incorrectly retrieved.
It also agreed to pay a Carer's Support Grant of €1,850 to Anne's family as a goodwill gesture but also as Martin would have met the conditions of that Grant before his death.
In another instance, 'Fiona' had a poor experience in the Coombe Hospital in Dublin when her child was born and was extremely upset and felt traumatised by the experience.
While she had initially raised concerns with the hospital ended up making a formal complaint to the hospital two years later.
However, the hospital refused to deal with the matter as it was outside the time limit for making complaints.
The Heath Act, 2004, includes a 12-month time limit for making complaints. However, it also provides for the extension of the time limit where special circumstances make it appropriate to do so.
The Ombudsman queried whether the hospital had considered using its discretion in this case.
In response, the hospital offered to meet Fiona who wanted a written response.
According to the report, the hospital issued a comprehensive and empathetic letter which Fiona felt resolved the issues for her.
The Ombudsman raised a similar issue to Fiona's in his annual report for 2023.
Ot has led him to call on all public bodies - particularly those in the health sector - to be mindful that some people may not be in a position to make a complaint within a specific timeframe for a variety of reasons, including feeling upset or traumatised.
In such cases he said the body should consider using its discretion to deal with the complaint.
'Andrew' contacted the Ombudsman when his mother's belongings, including her dentures and shoes, went missing during her time in St Vincent's University Hospital, Dublin.
The hospital told him that it had no record of the items being with his mother when she was admitted.
However, the Ombudsman discovered evidence that both the woman's dentures and shoes were with her when she was in the hospital.
An initial report from the hospital's speech and language therapist showed that Andrew's mother had no issues eating, while a subsequent report highlighted that she was having difficulty eating and was missing some teeth.
The Ombudsman also uncovered a therapist's report that said she had difficulty "putting on her shoes".
The hospital apologised to Andrew and his mother and reimbursed them for the value of the items lost.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
5 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Shock stats reveal 488 people sought medical attention in hospital for dog attack injuries in Ireland last year
THE number of people treated in hospitals for dog bites has increased year on year, new figures from the HSE reveal. A total of 488 people had medical attention in The The 145 increase in patients suffering dog attack injuries comes as the Government brought in No one is allowed to keep a The move to regulate the dangerous dogs came after a rise in dog attacks nationwide which culminated in READ MORE ON XL BULLY She was attacked and mauled to death by her own pit bull dogs at her Limerick home causing grave shock nationwide. In a second serious incident a 9 year old boy, The child had been out playing on the street with other kids in the Forgelands housing estate, Enniscorthy, The dog's owners Niall Byrne and Karen Millar were both subsequently jailed on various charges over the incident. Most read in Irish News The A source said: "It is very early days yet but if we get these pit bulls under control and off the streets there should be a long-term reduction in the number of attacks. Sister of dog attack victim Nicole Morey calls for stricter XL Bully laws "There will also be other dogs out there who for whatever reason just turn vicious and attack people." The HSE has no data yet for people treated for dog bites in 2025. DOG ATTACK IN MEATH However, only a fortnight ago, She had to be taken to hospital with her injuries which were not life threatening. Last year, the local authorities across Ireland said 442 people formally reported dog attack incidents to them for the whole of 2023. The data for 2024 will not be released until next October. 1 488 people sought medical attention in Irish hospitals after dog attacks last year
RTÉ News
9 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Listowel designated as a dementia-inclusive town
Listowel in Co Kerry has been designated as a dementia-inclusive town as part of a campaign to increase awareness and improve supports for people who are living with the condition. The initiative is part of a national campaign - called Dementia: Understand Together - which is being promoted by the HSE. The HSE estimates that the number of people with dementia will more than double to 150,000 by 2045. Listowel is one of several towns throughout the country which have been designated as dementia inclusive or are currently working towards that designation. Work on a dementia-inclusive strategy for Listowel has been ongoing since a dedicated dementia day care unit, Ard Chúram Fuchsia Centre, opened in the town in August, 2021. The centre currently caters for around 40 people who are drawn from the north Kerry area. "We were running a day care centre for older people and then there was a need for a day care centre for people with dementia, so we raised funds and built this dedicated centre," says Ard Chúram Chairman Finbarr Mawe. The two centres, Ard Chúram Day Care Centre and Ard Chúram Fuchsia Centre, are now operating alongside each other. The opening of the Fuchsia Centre four years ago marked the beginning of the dementia-inclusive project in the community, rather than the ending of the building project. "It was a big ambition for us to provide dementia-specific care at this facility," Mr Mawe explains. "We thought to ourselves, 'is there more we can be doing'? That is when we reached out to the Listowel Business and Community Alliance, and Dementia Inclusive Listowel was created." At the Fuchsia Centre, people with dementia enjoy gardening, arts and crafts, music and dance for five hours per day. This also affords family members and carers an opportunity for respite. Dementia Inclusive Listowel extends the work being done at the Fuchsia Centre into the community. It is building an understanding of dementia and how to support people with the condition and their families in the wider community. Support from community The first formal meeting of Dementia Inclusive Listowel took place in late 2022. Around 30 people turned up - enough to form a working group. Since then, with the help of the HSE, several workshops and information meetings have taken place. Staff at many local businesses took part in awareness and training courses. The work gathered momentum and two public information evenings attracted more than 250 people. "We've had great support from the people and businesses in Listowel and we know first-hand just what that means to the people living with dementia in our community and also their families," Mr Mawe says. "People with dementia are valued members of the Listowel community and we're delighted the campaign will celebrate all of the hard work of the committee and the town." Continuation of that work is now very much the theme. "We are on our initial journey," Mr Mawe says. "We are constantly making progress. We have done our workshops and seminars and now we will progress to the next step - maybe a cafe or something - because this isn't finished. "I feel very gratified, very fulfilled that people with dementia are acknowledged as being part of the community. "We are on a road and it isn't a finished job by any manner of means." What is happening in Listowel isn't unique: the HSE is working with communities throughout the country to develop a greater understanding of dementia and to support those who are living with the condition, along with their families. Dementia-inclusive community groups are working with the HSE in towns like Tralee, Bantry, Clonakilty, Mallow, Midleton, Kanturk, Charleville, Wexford, Cashel, Thurles, Roscrea, Nenagh and Cahir. There are active groups in smaller communities, like Mohill in Co Leitrim, and in bigger communities in areas of Dublin. The reality is dementia is becoming a more relevant issue for everyone in the country, as the population grows and ages. Around 64,000 people living with dementia, says HSE The HSE estimates that around 64,000 people are currently living with a diagnosis of dementia in Ireland, and that that figure will grow to around 150,000 people over the next two decades. In May, the Minister for Older People, Kieran O'Donnell, announced the commencement of work on a national dementia registry for Ireland. The establishment of the registry is an acknowledgement that Ireland currently lacks a systematic approach to the collection and analysis of data on dementia. "It makes somebody with dementia feel a little bit more wanted." As the number of people diagnosed with dementia increases, the need for a national dementia registry becomes more acute. The HSE says the registry will allow it to plan the shape and scale of dementia services and supports into the future. "Dementia is not just a health issue, it's a social issue and it really does require a holistic community response," says HSE South West Community Healthcare Team Lead, Dolores McElligott. "Most people with a diagnosis of dementia are living in their communities. "It's vital that they can continue to avail of local services and be able to remain active and engaged in community life." Ms McElligott is based in Co Kerry and is providing HSE community development support in Listowel. "An important element of the work of Dementia Inclusive Listowel is that we're all in agreement that this is an on-going project and that we keep the conversation, the education and the understanding going - it's the only way to make sustainable change happen," she says. Karen Carmody, a solicitor in Listowel, can see the benefits of Dementia Inclusive Listowel on a practical level. Her father, DJ, is a retired dairy farmer from Moyvane, 10 kilometres north of Listowel. He is 84 and has been living with dementia for about five years. Karen describes Dementia Inclusive Listowel as "hugely positive and really, really helpful". "It makes somebody with dementia feel a little bit more wanted," she says.
Irish Times
2 days ago
- Irish Times
HSE launches urgent inquiry after two new ambulances catch fire
The HSE is carrying out an urgent investigation into why two new ambulances suddenly caught fire in recent days. The two vehicles were different makes, models and types, but an initial technical examination had 'identified a possible issue', the HSE said. The matter is 'now being urgently explored in further detail with vehicle suppliers', it said. It is understood the investigation will look at potential common links between the two ambulances. The HSE said a serious incident management team was established after the fires, which took place last Saturday and last Thursday. READ MORE However, it said ambulance services for the public were not affected. The HSE said a recently-commissioned emergency ambulance was destroyed by fire while parked adjacent to the ambulance station in Castlebar, Co Mayo, in the early hours of last Saturday, June 21st. On Thursday, June 26th, a new community paramedic response vehicle awaiting entry to service went on fire in a commissioning facility in Tullamore, Co Offaly. 'Neither vehicle was in use at the time, no patients were affected and no staff were injured,' the HSE said. 'In line with health and safety requirements, all staff on duty have also been alerted to the two known incidents, requested to remain vigilant and reminded of current fire safety, vehicle evacuation, and incident reporting procedures,' it said. National Ambulance Service (NAS) operations to the public are 'unaffected by the current precautionary measures, which will remain under constant review', the HSE added. The NAS has 437 patient-carrying vehicles, including emergency and critical care ambulances and intermediate care vehicles. The HSE said all NAS vehicles are subject to a crew inspection at the commencement of each shift, as well as a safety inspection every eight weeks. [ Ireland's Community First Responders: Making the difference between life and death Opens in new window ] It said all vehicles were constructed in line with the relevant national and EU standards, were serviced and maintained in line with manufacturers' guidelines and are replaced after five years or 350,000km. It said all staff receive training in fire safety and vehicle evacuation procedures. Last year a HSE internal audit of the national ambulance fleet found that the budget allocation for last year was 50 per cent less than the service requires. It identified that some emergency ambulances were being kept in service outside the recommended usage of five years, with 66 ambulances listed as five or six years old.
