Welsh Conservatives slam Labour's council tax reform as ‘failing families'
The request, which received unanimous support during a recent meeting of the Independent Group, was formally submitted late on Friday afternoon (May 23) and acknowledged by the Council. It will be formally processed on Tuesday (May 27), the next working day. Under the Council's constitution, the Presiding Officer has five working days to respond. The Independent Group has expressed its expectation that the request will be accepted and a date set without delay.
Under fire: Cllr Paul Miller (Pic: Herald file)
The call for an EGM stems from a number of concerns, which will be fully outlined during the meeting. However, central to the motion is Councillor Miller's handling of matters related to the Welsh in Education Strategic Plan (WESP) and his comments at a Cabinet meeting on April 28.
During that meeting, Councillor Miller remarked that, in his view, parents send their children to Ysgol Caer Elen for a 'good education' rather than specifically for a Welsh-language education. This statement, the Independent Group argues, conveys a perception of bias against Welsh-medium education.
Further controversy arose when Councillor Miller publicly criticised the Welsh Language Commissioner—an independent expert appointed by the First Minister—accusing her of making an 'extraordinary political intervention' after she raised concerns about the legality and implications of his proposal to collect additional data from parents choosing Welsh-medium education. The Commissioner's concerns were grounded in the Welsh Government's Schools Admission Code, which the Commissioner argued would be breached by the proposal.
Rather than addressing these concerns or withdrawing the amendment, Councillor Miller accused others of generating negative publicity and failed to accept any personal responsibility. At the Schools Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting on May 14, the issue was further examined, yet Councillor Miller did not retract his original stance. Instead, he revised his amendment at Cabinet on May 21 to apply to both Welsh and English language education—a move viewed by the Independent Group as an attempt to save face without acknowledging fault.
Despite widespread concern from the Welsh Language Commissioner, senior council officers, the Welsh Government, and committee members, Councillor Miller has neither apologised nor shown any willingness to reflect on his actions. The Cabinet's decision to adopt his revised amendment, with only six of nine members present at a remote meeting, was also a cause for concern.
The Independent Group believes that public trust in elected representatives depends on their ability to recognise mistakes, show humility, and respect expert advice. Councillor Miller's refusal to do so—despite being an experienced politician—has led to this motion of No Confidence.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
9 hours ago
- The Guardian
Language on immigration in UK news and politics found to have ‘shaped backlash against antiracism'
A pattern of 'hostile language' in news reports and UK parliamentary debates is more likely to describe people of colour as immigrants, or with less sympathy, researchers have found. The race equality thinktank the Runnymede Trust analysed more than 63m words from 52,990 news articles and 317 House of Commons debates on immigration between 2019 and the general election in July 2024. Researchers concluded that the use of language about race and immigration by media and politicians has helped shape 'the increase in reactionary politics and backlash against antiracism which has emboldened the far right in this country'. The report, A Hostile Environment: Language, Race, Surveillance and the Media is the second in a series. The first phase of the research analysed parliamentary and media reports from 2010 to 2014. It found that 'illegal' was the most commonly linked word to migrants in parliamentary debates, which the researchers said reinforced the perception of migration as inherently unlawful. The latest report found that between 2019 and 2024 'the word 'illegal' has became an even stronger word association with the terms 'migrant' and 'immigrant' in both news and parliamentary debates than it was in the 2010–14 period', which, the authors claim, 'shows that the defining characteristic of migrants has been cemented as illegality over the past decade'. The study claims that since 2014, 'hostile environment' immigration policies have worked to 'expand and normalise the surveillance state' through legislation, reporting measures and data sharing. When the researchers filtered 'words associated with immigrants' in news data by nationality, religion, ethnicity and geographical location, they found the word 'Mexican' was most strongly associated, 'typically in the context of news reports about the USA'. Referring to the second- and third-placed terms in that category, the report added that 'Chinese' and 'Indian' were also very strongly associated with 'immigrant(s)', usually when reporting about immigration 'in the UK context'. The other most commonly used signifiers of identity associated with the word 'immigrants' in news were 'Asian', 'Irish', 'Haitian', 'Muslim', 'Jewish', 'non-white', 'Venezuelan', 'Cuban' and 'African'. 'Overwhelmingly, when the UK news media represents immigrants, the image that is invoked … is of an ethnically minoritised person,' the report added. Meanwhile, in Hansard data of parliamentary debates, the top 10 words most strongly associated with migration were 'illegal', 'net', 'committee', 'act', 'bill', 'tackle', 'level', 'reduce', 'system,' and 'mass'. The report said parliamentarians 'are more likely to use humanising terms when talking about Ukrainians' – such as 'guest', 'brave', 'community' or 'diaspora'. The report claims: 'Racist discourse from the highest levels of UK society, including politicians and the media, is used to frame immigration as an existential threat to the British way of life … this works to justify ever more hostile immigration policies.' Sign up to First Edition Our morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters after newsletter promotion The report added: 'One stark example of the partnership between parliament and the news media in framing public perceptions of immigration in the UK can be found in connection with the 'stop the boats' political slogan. 'The explicit use of this slogan by rioters in the summer of 2024 on banners and in chants demonstrates that the hostile language we have identified in our analysis has emboldened sectors of the UK public to engage in racist violence. 'Throughout the 2019-24 period, news articles and political debates disseminating this kind of narrative come out in fairly close alignment with each other, both reaching their peak in 2023 and declining slightly into 2024, but with still very high levels of usage.' The Home Office has been approached for comment. The Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government said the disorder of August 2024 – which followed the Southport attack – ''highlighted the need for a new approach to community cohesion' and that a task force was developing a strategic national approach, while £1.5bn was being invested in community services in 75 areas nationwide.
Powys County Times
15 hours ago
- Powys County Times
Opinion: Powys County Council to blame for school's woes
It's summer! School holidays, seaside day trips, harvest time and of course a local show every weekend for everyone to enjoy. Local shows do offer an affordable family day out in comparison to the Royal Welsh Show, but the Royal Welsh is like no other show, Wales at its best, and it plays a huge role in the promotion of the farming and food sector in Wales. For those that attend, they would not have been left in any doubt about the quality of food and drink produced here in Wales. Every farmer I speak to, their number one priority is to produce food for our nation, but it is getting more difficult every day, UK and Welsh governments appear to have different priorities. The long awaited 'new' sustainable farming scheme still forces farmers to plant trees; it will lead to real terms cuts in funding and there was not one mention of food security in the latest draft of this policy. Welsh Government through legislation distort priorities, it adds to red tape that will see food production fall here in Wales, we will become ever more reliant on imports at a time when the cost of feeding our families is increasing, and I haven't even mentioned UK Labour's Government Family Farm Tax. Farmers want to farm, they love their farms but are seeing their business suffocated by Welsh Government, the same is true for many small businesses across mid Wales they want the freedom to do what they do best. Small and medium sized business are the backbone to the local economy. Meanwhile, back at the ranch, in County Hall, the wheels are falling off the Liberal Democrat/Labour run Council. The Cabinet's incoherent transformation programme and refusal to properly fund education has led to one of the best schools going into special measures. However, there is a little bit of good news, the Cabinet conceded that their home to school transport policy is simply not good enough and needs to be changed, but Welsh Government legislation makes the process of change slow. Therefore, I was pleased to gain a commitment to help support parental choice through the appeals process, to over come the difficulties of the Council's newly introduced Home to School transport policy. Hopefully readers will be able to attend their local show.
Daily Mail
17 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Donald Trump says US nuclear attack submarines are now 'closer to Russia' after he re-deployed them over Kremlin's 'foolish and inflammatory' taunts
Donald Trump has revealed that a pair of US nuclear submarines 'are moving closer' to Russia after he deployed them in response to an escalating war of words with former Russian President Dmitry Medvedev. The move of the nuclear submarines to 'appropriate regions', which the US President described as a 'terrible situation', appeared to be symbolic – the U.S. already has a fleet of dozens of nuclear-powered subs that are constantly ready to strike in the event of a conflict. But tensions notched up another level as Trump admitted they were getting closer. 'They are closer to Russia yeah, it's a terrible situation,' he told Newsmax. It increases the tension once again after Trump announced he was moving up his ultimatum for Russia to agree to end the war. 'We had to do that. We just have to be careful. And a threat was made and we didn't think it was appropriate. So I have to be very careful,' Trump told reporters as he left the White House on Friday for a weekend at his New Jersey golf club. 'A threat was made by a former president of Russia, and we're going to protect our people,' he added. If Russia fails to strike a peace deal by the end of next week, Trump said he will impose punishing 'secondary sanctions' on nations who trade with Russia. Trump made the decision to deploy the submarines after 'highly provocative statements' of Russia's ex-President Dmitry Medvedev - who now serves as deputy of Russia's Security Council. The United States has a total of 14 Ohio Class nuclear-powered submarines, each capable of carrying up to 24 Trident II D5 ballistic missiles that can deliver multiple thermonuclear warheads up to 4,600 miles. Between 8 and 10 Ohio Class submarines are deployed at any one time, according to the Nuclear Threat Initiative arms control group. Medvedev had called Trump's sanctions threat a clear 'step toward war,' clearly incensing the president. 'I have ordered two nuclear submarines to be positioned in the appropriate regions, just in case these foolish and inflammatory statements are more than just that,' Trump wrote on Truth Social on Friday afternoon. 'Words are very important, and can often lead to unintended consequences, I hope this will not be one of those instances. Thank you for your attention to this matter!' Medvedev, the former president of Russia who stepped aside when Vladimir Putin took a break from the top post, drew Trump's ire with his own post this week. 'Trump's playing the ultimatum game with Russia…Each new ultimatum is a threat and a step towards war. Not between Russia and Ukraine, but with his own country. Don't go down the Sleepy Joe road!' he wrote. The United States has a total of 14 Ohio Class nuclear-powered submarines, each capable of carrying up to 24 Trident II D5 ballistic missiles Trump then tore into the Russian with angry posts around midnight Thursday. 'Tell Medvedev, the failed former President of Russia, who thinks he's still President, to watch his words. He's entering very dangerous territory,' Trump wrote. Trump's jabs at Medvedev, who is often a caustic critic of U.S. policy, allows him to steer clear of Putin – with whom Trump has shown obvious frustration in recent weeks, despite Trump often referring him to him as someone he can 'get along with.' Trump has lamented apparently positive phone conversations with Putin followed within hours by Russian attacks on Ukrainian cities and towns. Trump's threats come after Russia launched yet another devastating attack on Kyiv overnight, which killed dozens of people and a six-year-old boy. Russia has routinely been sending swarms of hundreds of drones to attack Ukraine, with houses and apartment buildings suffering regular blasts. An estimated 31 people were killed and 150 injured during Thursday's attacks. Wrote Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky in response while posting a video: 'Kyiv. Missile strike. Directly into a residential building. People under the rubble. All services are on site. Russian terrorists.' 'All disappointments come from inflated expectations,' said Russian President Vladimir Putin Friday in response to Trump's expedited deadline issued Monday In his own first public comments since Trump threw down his abbreviated ultimatum, Putin criticized 'inflated' expectations about ending a war he ordered in 2022 by launching a cross-border attack on Russia's neighbor. 'All disappointments come from inflated expectations,' Putin said. 'In order to solve the issue in a peaceful way, we need deep conversations, not in public, but in the silence of a negotiating process.' Trump's reference to nuclear subs suggests both their stealth and massive firepower. Each of the 14 Ohio-class ballistic missile subs carries up to 20 Trident II missiles, with a range of up to 7,500 miles and up to eight nuclear warheads, with 160 warheads in total. The warheads are capable of causing a 475-kiloton explosion, vastly more powerful than the bomb dropped on Hiroshima in 1945. Trump said last month at the White House while meeting with NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte that first lady Melania Trump had taken to raising the issue of the toll on civilians. 'I go home, I tell the first lady, "You know, I spoke to Vladimir today. We had a wonderful conversation." And she said, "Oh really? Another city was just hit,"' Trump told reporters. Those comments coincided with an increasingly tough verbal posture on Putin from the president, who has now threatened to slap new sanctions on Russia as well as its trading partners. Just weeks ago, the Pentagon had imposed a temporary freeze on arms transfers to Ukraine, reflecting a move in Trump's administration away from the pro-Ukraine position of President Biden's, which shoveled billions of military aid to Kyiv after Moscow's invasion. Trump and his team, meanwhile, have been fighting a rhetorical battle over a 2017 intelligence assessment that Russia preferred Trump in the 2016 elections.
