Regulator rules against MTN for misleading advertising
Future MTN Shesh@ promotions must explicitly state that 300GB of the 600GB of data may be unusable without a reliable 5G connection. Picture: iStock
The Advertising Regulatory Board (ARB) has ruled against mobile giant MTN for misleading advertising in its promotion of the 'Shesh@600' data deal, finding that the campaign created 'an unqualified expectation' of 600GB of usable data per month – despite many customers being unable to access half of it due to poor 5G coverage.
The ruling follows a consumer complaint over the Shesh@5G package promoted on social media, which advertised 600GB of data for R399 per month.
The fine print revealed that the offer was split into two 300GB bundles – one at 'best 5G speeds' and the other capped at 20Mbps.
The complainant argued that because MTN's 5G coverage was unreliable or non-existent in his area, he could never access the 5G portion of the deal, effectively leaving him with only 300GB of data.
ALSO READ: WATCH: DStv's 'R100' advert deemed misleading by regulatory board
The ARB found this practice to be in breach of Clause 4.2.1 of Section II of its Code, which prohibits misleading or ambiguous advertising, and Clause 16 of Section III, which deals with the non-availability of advertised products.
It said MTN's marketing did not sufficiently warn consumers that the 300GB of 5G data would be forfeited if a stable 5G connection was unavailable.
'In modern data usage, customers reasonably expect their routers or devices to default to slower speeds rather than cancel a data allocation entirely,' it added.
'The assumption that consumers should understand the 5G data is 'all or nothing' is not reasonable especially when MTN's coverage maps suggest the service is available in the area.'
ALSO READ: FSCA fines African Bank R700 000 for misleading advertising [VIDEO]
MTN refers regulator to its Ts&Cs
MTN responded by pointing to its website's terms and conditions, which it claims made the two-bundle structure clear.
But the ARB rejected this defence, noting that the social media posts and promotional material made repeated and prominent reference to '600GB at R399', and '300GB at best 5G speeds x 12 months', without qualifying the forfeiture risk if 5G was not accessible.
It has ordered MTN to withdraw or amend the offending adverts and to ensure that future Shesh@ promotions explicitly state that 300GB of the data may be unusable without a reliable 5G connection.
ASLO READ: Everything you need to know about your rights with false advertising
Breach of consumer trust
In a further directive to the industry, the regulator has requested that all its members – including media platforms – refrain from accepting MTN advertising for Shesh@ products unless the promotional limitations are clearly spelled out.
This is the second ruling involving MTN's Shesh@600 product in less than a month. A previous complaint was dismissed after MTN confirmed the full 600GB was technically available.
However, in this latest case, the board ruled that the data may be inaccessible in practice – which amounts to a breach of consumer trust.
This article was republished from Moneyweb. Read the original here.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
12 hours ago
- The Citizen
Daily Lotto results: Sunday, 20 July 2025
Tonight's jackpot is R300 000! Here are your winning Daily Lotto results for 20 July 2025. Lottery Balls with a clipping path so you can have them with what ever background you wish. Image: iStock Get the Daily Lotto results as soon as they are drawn on The Citizen. Daily Lotto results for 20 July 2025: The winning Daily Lotto numbers will appear below after the draw. Usually within 10 minutes of the draw. You might need to refresh the page to see the updated results. 00, 00, 00, 00, 00. How to play Daily Lotto in SA? If you are buying a ticket in-store: Pick up a betslip in any lottery store. Choose five numbers between 1 and 36 or ask for a Quick Pick. Entries cost R3 each. You can play a max of R150, but you are allowed to play multiple boards. Select how many consecutive draws you wish to enter, up to a maximum of 10. Leave blank for a single draw. Take your betslip to the teller to pay for your ticket. Write your details on the back of your ticket in case you need to claim a prize. If you do not sign your ticket and you lose it, anyone can use it to claim the prize. If you are playing online: Set up a lottery account here and make a deposit to pay for tickets. Choose five numbers from 1 to 36 or select 'Quick Pick' to generate a random set. Repeat this on as many boards as you want to play. Decide whether to enter a single draw or multiple draws. Confirm and pay for your entry The Daily Lotto draws take place shortly after 9:30pm every evening, and tickets can be bought until 8:30pm. Is there a winner every day? Yes. The jackpot prize money is guaranteed to be given away even if no one matches all five numbers. When this happens, the jackpot is split between everyone who matches two or more numbers. Visit and go to the How to Play Daily Lotto section to learn more.
The Citizen
3 days ago
- The Citizen
Businesses embrace GenAI in SA – but strategy, skills lagging
This dramatic rise positions GenAI as the fastest-moving digital trend in the country. According to the findings, South African enterprises are rapidly integrating Generative AI (GenAI) into their operations. Picture: iStock A new report has revealed that the informal and unregulated usage of generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) by businesses in South Africa poses a threat to both them and their employees. The report, produced by World Wide Worx and Dell Technologies, surveyed over 100 medium and large-sized enterprises nationwide. Gen AI According to the findings released on Thursday, South African enterprises are rapidly integrating Generative AI (GenAI) into their operations, but most are doing so without formal strategies, dedicated leadership, or the infrastructure required to maximise value and minimise risk. This dramatic rise positions GenAI as the fastest-moving digital trend in the country. World Wide Worx CEO and principal analyst of the study, Arthur Goldstuck, said that in a rush to adopt the fast-growing technology, there is a need for organisations to take the foundational steps of planning and governance. 'Many organisations are simply unaware of the gaps they're leaving in their systems, said Goldstuck. 'The risk goes beyond the technical, and includes reputational, ethical, and operational vulnerability. While the first step of technology adoption is well underway, our survey demonstrates there is room for operational growth.' ALSO READ: WATCH: 'Gen AI solves problems that were too expensive to solve' – Cyborg Anthropologist Findings According to the report's findings, AI adoption has brought clear benefits to the organisations using it, with 86% of GenAI users citing increased competitiveness as a result of using AI tools. The report also showed that 83% reported improved productivity, while 66% saw enhanced customer service. On the other hand, the report raised the alarm over 'shadow AI' – the unsanctioned use of GenAI by employees without oversight. It showed that 32% of businesses correctly report informal or unregulated GenAI use, while a further 20% report a mix of official and unofficial GenAI use. 84% say oversight is an important or very important factor in the success of GenAI deployment. Caution The report cautioned that South Africa could find itself divided by the ability to use GenAI wisely and scale deployments as the technology matures. 'There's a real risk of a GenAI disconnect in South Africa between those who use GenAI deliberately, strategically and ethically, and those who use it blindly or not at all,' Goldstuck said. Goldstuck said as companies race to embed GenAI tools like Microsoft Copilot and ChatGPT into business functions, most are overlooking deeper transformation through infrastructure, skills and internal capability. He said holistic AI infrastructure, combined with people and processes, is critical to scaling AI deployments and clearly connecting them to tangible return on investment. ALSO READ: Organisations encouraged to empower employees with AI fluency
Daily Maverick
3 days ago
- Daily Maverick
After the Bell: WhatsApp — changing the world one group (too many) at a time
It's amazing how WhatsApp has changed our lives. I think I live my life on it. And the fact that companies can use it to keep teams together across borders, oceans and continents is sometimes like magic. But this doesn't mean that it's all plain sailing. I sometimes wonder if the quickest way to bring the economies of many countries to a staggering halt would be to simply switch off WhatsApp. Really, I think I live my life on it. Virtually all of my communication. To the point where I often forget to check my email. I imagine that you, like me, are on an unbelievably long list of groups. And while it's become common to complain about the number of groups that you are on (so many groups start with the admin apologising for creating 'yet another group'), the fact is that creating another group is usually the correct solution to whatever communication problem you have. It's also amazing how WhatsApp has changed our lives. In the late 1990s, I tried to phone a friend in Harare simply to wish him Merry Christmas. This was from a home landline to a home landline. It took forever to work out how much it would cost. But that was nothing compared to how long it took. Zim being Zim, and this being the only way to speak to him, I called about 17 times just to get his landline to ring. Much easier to talk to Now, that same friend has moved several time zones away — but he's so much easier to talk to. I can call him any time and have a quick chat. All on WhatsApp. It's funny because the main reason this works is that data networks have been created. More and more of us make our calls on WhatsApp because it's cheaper. MTN and Vodacom have both noticed this, as it has had quite a big impact on their bottom line. In May, MTN said its data revenue for the first quarter of the year was up by nearly 18% and described its voice revenue as 'mostly flat'. Obviously Vodacom is hugely affected by this too — they've reported the same dynamic. At some point, some of these companies might start to switch off their voice services. Last year in December, after spending much of the day phoning tyre shops (this was the same Tyre Shop Incident of 2024, where I was inspired to write about retirement), I ran out of airtime. Thankfully, I was on the phone to an old friend at the time. I called her back on WhatsApp and we could both not stop laughing at the immaturity of running out of airtime. It was so 2002. Back when we were young. Now if you run out of airtime, you probably won't notice. Running out of data, however, will ruin your day. But WhatsApp has played probably the biggest role in this transition. I think the first cellphone I got that allowed me to make a video call was a Nokia back in 2004. The first video I took was of my friend on our roof running after what was described as one of the last three chimney sweeps in Joburg. For a decade, when I tapped on a contact, my bloody phone would ask me if I wanted to make a normal call or a video call. Not once did I tap 'video call'. Then WhatsApp came along and I was making video calls all the time. I don't know what changed, but it was WhatsApp that made me do it. Not Nokia. Like magic And of course the fact that companies can use it to keep teams together across borders, oceans and continents is sometimes like magic. But this doesn't mean that it's all plain sailing. Sometimes I wonder if a lot of what happens in WhatsApp groups has become quite performative. Perhaps it's just the career I'm in, but so often people feel they have to all join in to say the same thing. Say someone wins an award or something. Everyone in the entire group now has to be seen to say 'well done'. I'm of a generation where, if you wanted to say that, you'd make a phone call. Sometimes someone will do something really exceptional and I'll phone them to congratulate them. When everyone else congratulates them on a group, I then wonder if perhaps all of the other group members think I didn't think it was that impressive. Even though I've gone further and phoned them. I realise I'm a member of the species Grumpasaurous for saying this, but I find birthdays particularly tiresome. If you have 50 people on a group, that's a birthday almost every week. And with 49 messages saying the same thing every week, that's nearly 2,500 messages a year. All saying the same thing. Being of an age where my birthdays have ceased to exist (I have children…), I often just don't see the point. I'm probably on my own here. In fact, I hope that I am. And that everyone else just gets more joy from this than I do. WhatsApp is dangerously close to becoming my entire life. I can't imagine life without it.
