In deadly Texas floods, one town had what some didn't: A wailing warning siren
Comfort had recently updated its disaster alert system, installing a new siren in the volunteer fire department's headquarters and moving the old one to a low-lying area of town along Cypress Creek, a tributary of the Guadalupe that is prone to flooding. Friday was the first time the new two-siren system had been used outside of tests, providing a last-minute alarm for anyone who hadn't responded to previous warnings on their cellphones or evacuation announcements from firefighters driving around town.
'People knew that if they heard the siren, they gotta get out,' said Danny Morales, assistant chief of the Comfort Volunteer Fire Department.
Morales said that no one died in Comfort, a town of about 2,300 people in Kendall County. But in Kerr County about 20 miles away, dozens of people, including young girls staying at Camp Mystic, a riverside Christian summer camp, were washed away when the Guadalupe surged over its banks and swamped the surrounding countryside. As of Monday evening, officials said, 104 people had been confirmed dead, 84 of them in Kerr County, including dozens of children. Kerr County has no siren system despite years of debate, in part because some local officials felt it was too expensive to install.
The part of Texas Hill Country known as 'flash flood alley' has seen rising waters many times before, but the swift and punishing destruction over the Fourth of July has focused attention on whether local officials are doing enough to protect their residents as climate change causes more frequent and severe weather disasters and the federal government is slashing spending on emergency preparedness.
The swollen river has receded, leaving behind heartbreaking signs of the devastation: little girls' suitcases and clothes strewn along the wrecked cabin grounds and plush toys caked with detritus, twisted metal and gnarled vehicles. Three days after the flooding, searchers were still picking through downed trees and hunting through thick black mud for those still missing. Parents' hopes were dimming as the days dragged on with no signs of life.
It is impossible to know whether a siren system in Kerr County would have saved lives; they are meant to alert people who are outdoors, not in bed indoors, as many of Kerr County's victims were when the river rose overnight — at one point by 26 feet in just 45 minutes.
The weather service issued a flood watch for the area Thursday afternoon and an urgent flash flood warning for Kerr County at 1:14 a.m. Friday, a move that triggers the wireless emergency alerts on cellphones.
By the time flooding inundated low-lying parts of Kendall County, where Comfort is located, it was later Friday morning. The first weather service flash flood alert for Kendall came at 7:24 a.m. When the sirens went off, many residents were already awake and aware of the dangerous flooding. A Facebook video recorded by Jeff Flinn, the managing editor of The Boerne Star, shows the emergency sirens in Comfort sounding at 10:52 a.m.; he said the alert lasted for about 30 seconds.
Kerr County was relying on the emergency alerts that blare on cellphones. Those alerts may not get through, particularly in rural areas with bad service or in the night when phones are off or when there are no phones around; the girls at the summer camp weren't allowed to bring them. And some may choose to ignore them, because they're bombarded by phone alerts.
Some Texas officials have blamed the National Weather Service, arguing it didn't do a good enough job forecasting rainfall and issuing timely flood warnings. But some independent meteorologists and a former weather service official told NBC News that the agency performed as well as it could given the unpredictability of rain and flash flooding and the timing of the disaster.
Tom Moser, a former Kerr County commissioner, said he began looking into a warning system for his area after flooding in Hays County, which was overwhelmed by the Blanco River, killed 13 people over Memorial Day weekend in 2015.
Kerr County officials debated various options, including one for an alert system that included sensors and sirens, and the cost was about $1 million, Moser said.
'There were a number of people that did not like the sirens going off because they go off accidentally,' Moser said. 'They didn't want that disturbance in the Hill Country.'
At a March 2016 commissioners' meeting, Rusty Hierholzer, then the Kerr County sheriff, was adamant that the deadly flooding in the Hays County community of Wimberley was a warning for the need to install sirens in addition to a phone app notification system known as Code Red already in use.
In Wimberley, some people didn't get alerts on their phones, 'so yes, you need both,' Hierholzer said, according to a transcript of the meeting. 'You need the sirens, and you need Code Red to try and make sure we'll notify everybody as we can when it's coming up.'
During a follow-up discussion about the proposal that August, then-Commissioner H.A. 'Buster' Baldwin questioned the flood warning system they were considering, saying, 'I think this whole thing is a little extravagant for Kerr County, with sirens and such,' according to a transcript.
They estimated the system would cost $1 million, and they didn't have the money to add it to the budget.
Moser said they also didn't get disaster relief funding they'd asked for from the Federal Emergency Management Agency. 'As a matter of fact, there were no grants available we thought we could get in a timely fashion,' Moser said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NBC News
9 minutes ago
- NBC News
Camper evacuated from Texas flood recalls harrowing hours at Camp Mystic
KERRVILLE, Texas — Lucy Kennedy said it was about midnight when she woke up to the sound of thunder. 'I couldn't go back to sleep,' Lucy, who is 10, said Tuesday in an interview, her mother sitting by her side. 'I just had a feeling that something really bad was about to happen.' Lucy had been asleep Thursday night in her bunk at Camp Mystic, a roughly 750-person summer camp in Hunt. Outside, rain had begun to pound an area known to be at severe risk of flash floods. As water began to inundate her campsite, girls from her cabin were told to grab blankets, pillows and water bottles and line up single file, Lucy said. They moved to the second floor of a rec hall for safety, where they sat in soaking wet pajamas before they migrated to a campsite on higher ground. In the light of day, survivors were airlifted Friday to safety by helicopter — a sight Lucy said was 'pretty, but also not pretty at the same time.' 'Everything looked flooded and broken, so it was also kind of sad,' she said. After the helicopter, Lucy was shuttled to an elementary school where her mother, Wynne Kennedy, waited with other parents in the gym, hoping to hear their children's names called out. 'When I saw her, she was wrapped up in a blanket, had a teddy bear,' Wynne said. 'We just held each other tight, and I held her all night.' Days after floodwaters swept through Texas' Hill Country, rescue workers continue to comb the region. More than people 100 are dead across six counties, and Gov. Greg Abbott said Tuesday that 161 people are known to be missing. Few places, if any, were hit as hard as Camp Mystic, a private Christian summer camp for girls that has been around since 1926. At least 27 attendees and counselors at Camp Mystic are either dead or missing. Kerr County Sheriff Larry Leitha said Tuesday that five campers and a counselor are still unaccounted for. On Tuesday, a sign that reads 'Jesus Wept' was propped up on debris by the riverbank next to the camp. Officials in Kerr County, where Camp Mystic is located, said over the weekend that they were caught off guard by the onslaught of floodwater, noting that parts of the Guadalupe River rose 26 feet in 45 minutes. But some crucial questions remain unanswered, particularly around whether adequate warnings were issued. At a news conference Tuesday, local authorities dodged questions about the local alert system. In a statement on its website, Camp Mystic said it had been in communication with state and local authorities in efforts to find those still missing. Wynne, who used to work at the camp, said she felt her daughter 'was in the safest place she could be because of the extensive flood evacuation plans that they trained us on.' Last week's devastation felt unprecedented, she said, saying that 'the water never got near any of those cabins, ever, before, when we would have a little flooding.'
The Independent
3 hours ago
- The Independent
FACT FOCUS: No, weather modification did not cause the deadly flash floods in Texas
As authorities search for victims of the flash floods in Texas that killed more than 100 people over the Fourth of July holiday weekend, social media users are spreading false claims that the devastation was caused by weather modification. Many pointed to one process in particular, blaming cloud seeding performed on July 2 by a California-based company for the tragedy. But officials say there is no evidence that the floods are the result of cloud seeding and experts agree that cloud seeding would not result in precipitation of this magnitude. Here's a closer look at the facts. CLAIM: A July 2 cloud seeding operation by Rainmaker Technology Corporation caused flash floods in the Texas Hill Country over the Fourth of July holiday weekend. THE FACTS: This is false. It is not possible that cloud seeding generated the floods, according to experts, as the process can only produce limited precipitation using clouds that already exist. Forecasts predicted rain for that weekend prior to July 2 in an area that was already prone to flooding. 'The claim that cloud seeding played a role in this tragic event is complete nonsense,' said Andrew Dessler, director of Texas A&M University's Texas Center for Extreme Weather. Dev Niyogi, a professor at the University of Texas at Austin who studies extreme weather, said it is 'extremely unlikely' cloud seeding played a role in the floods. He cited weather factors as the reason: 'the moisture flow coming into the area and the widespread rains the system had, as well as the forecast of very heavy rains over the wider area.' Sen. Ted Cruz of Texas said at a press briefing on Monday that 'to the best of my knowledge, there is zero evidence of anything related to anything like weather modification' when asked about such speculation. He added: 'The internet is a strange place. People can come up with all sorts of crazy theories.' Nonetheless, social media users questioned whether Rainmaker's operations could be connected to the disaster in Texas. 'Well … this is weird … A company called Rainmaker, conducted a cloud seeding mission on July 2 over Texas Hill Country,' reads one X post. '2 days later, the worst flood in their history occurred … in the exact same area that the Rainmaker flights were. The entire goal of Rainmaker is to increase the precipitation of existing clouds. Why do we let these corporations f — k with the weather?' Many posts also noted Rainmaker's connection to Silicon Valley billionaire Peter Thiel, who cofounded the data-mining outfit Palantir Technologies, a secretive company that has long relied on spies, police, and the military as its customers. The Thiel Foundation awarded Rainmaker founder and CEO Augustus Doricko $100,000 in 2024 as part of its fellowship program. Cloud seeding utilizes an artificial material — typically silver iodide — to induce precipitation or clear fog. The practice is an imprecise undertaking with mixed results. Dessler explained that 'cloud seeding can work in certain limited situations and produce very modest increases in precipitation,' but often delivers nothing.' Regardless, the process cannot create storms out of thin air. Ken Leppert, an associate professor of atmospheric science at the University of Louisiana Monroe, said it 'had absolutely nothing' to do with the flash floods in Texas. 'Cloud seeding works by adding aerosols to existing clouds,' he said. 'It doesn't work by helping to create a cloud/storm that doesn't already exist. The storms that produced the rainfall and flooding in Texas were not in existence two days before the event.' The Texas Hill Country, in the central part of the state, is naturally prone to flash flooding due to the dry, dirt-packed areas where the soil lets rain skid along the surface of the landscape instead of soaking it up. After a flood watch notice was issued midday on July 3, the National Weather Service issued an urgent warning overnight for at least 30,000 people. The July 4 flash floods started with a particularly bad storm that dropped most of its 12 inches (30 centimeters) of rain in the dark early morning hours. There was so much rain that the Guadalupe River rose higher than it has in 93 years by almost a foot, according to local reports. 'The natural disaster in the Texan Hill Country is a tragedy. My prayers are with Texas,' Doricko, the Rainmaker CEO, wrote as part of a series of X posts. 'Rainmaker did not operate in the affected area on the 3rd or 4th or contribute to the floods that occurred over the region.' He said Rainmaker's last cloud seeding operation prior to the floods occurred in the early afternoon on July 2 over eastern portions of south-central Texas. Two clouds were seeded and remained in the sky for about two hours before dissipating. Rainmaker suspended its cloud seeding operations indefinitely the same day in response to 'unusually high moisture content.' ___
Scottish Sun
4 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Tragic newlywed wife struck by lightning and killed as her husband prepared to take a photo of her on paradise honeymoon
Witnesses said the newlywed bride collapsed after the thunderbolt flashed across the sky TAKEN TOO SOON TAKEN TOO SOON Tragic newlywed wife struck by lightning and killed as her husband prepared to take a photo of her on paradise honeymoon Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) A NEWLYWED wife was tragically killed by lightning on honeymoon as her husband prepared to take a photo. Stephany Lucero Elvir, 23, was on the beach with her partner when the fatal bolt struck. 3 A newlywed bride was struck by lightning and killed Credit: Jam Press 3 The couple had just been married in late June Credit: Jam Press 3 Their friends and family were left devastated following the horror Credit: Jam Press Her husband Cristhian Samir Álvarez Molina was also injured when the lightning hit them. Witnesses said the newlywed bride collapsed after the thunderbolt flashed across the sky on July 5. They were rushed to get medical attention, but Stephany was sadly pronounced dead. Cristhian sustained injuries in the tragic incident but is understood to have survived. read more in world news DON'S FURY Trump slams Putin's 'bulls***' and 'meaningless' promises in savage attack The pair had just got married a few days earlier on June 28. Their friends and family were left devastated following the horror, which took place in Omoa, Honduras. Stephany worked as a pharmacist and was from Tegucigalpa, NeedToKnow has reported. She had degrees from National Autonomous University of Honduras and the Central American Technological University. Tributes have described her as "intelligent", "kind" and a "helpful girl with a big heart". A spokesperson for the Honduran Air Force said: "We pray to the Divine Creator of the Universe for her eternal rest, and that the Almighty grants Christian comfort and strength to her family and friends." Cristhian's condition at present is not yet known. It comes as authorities have issued warnings over volatile weather conditions across the country. Members of the public are advised to take additional precautions in beaches and open spaces. It comes after a 29-year-old newlywed on his honeymoon was killed by a freak weather strike while standing in ankle-deep water. The incident occurred on Florida's east coast while the man was visiting New Smyrna Beach with his wife. Jake Rosencranz had been on a delayed honeymoon when lightning hit him around 12:30 pm on Friday, officials confirmed.
