High Court rules ‘vexatious litigant' son can't file new lawsuits against ex-MCA sec-gen father and 10 firms without court leave
KUALA LUMPUR, May 9 — The High Court has declared Datuk Seri Andrew Kam Tai Yeow a 'vexatious litigant' due to his multiple lawsuits against his father, Tan Sri Kam Woon Wah, and the latter's 10 companies.
The court also barred Tai Yeow from initiating any new legal proceedings in Malaysia against his father — a former MCA secretary-general — and the 10 firms unless he first obtains leave from a High Court judge.
High Court judge Roz Mawar Rozain issued the orders on Tuesday and directed that the declaration be gazetted. She also ordered Tai Yeow to pay RM20,000 in costs to his father and the 10 companies.
The father, aged 96 this year, and his 63-year-old son have been embroiled in legal disputes since 2017.
In June 2024, Woon Wah and the companies filed a High Court suit to have Tai Yeow declared a vexatious litigant. The 10 companies include Raub Mining & Development Company Sdn Bhd (RMDC), Raub Oil Mill Sdn Bhd, and eight corporate shareholders of RMDC, such as Berjaya Realty Sdn Bhd and United Raub Oil Palms Sdn Bhd.
In her 24-page written judgment dated May 6, Justice Roz Mawar highlighted a 'protracted legal drama' between father and son that has flooded Malaysian courts since 2017.
The family feud reportedly began after Woon Wah publicly disowned and disinherited Tai Yeow via a newspaper announcement on March 7, 2017.
Court proceedings initiated by Tai Yeow include a 2017 lawsuit claiming ownership of RMDC shares based on an alleged January 2017 shareholders' agreement with his father. While the Court of Appeal in 2022 ruled the suit should proceed to trial, it found no basis for action against the corporate shareholders.
Despite ongoing trials, Tai Yeow filed a fresh suit in February 2024 based on the same alleged agreement. The High Court struck out this case, and he has since filed an appeal.
Other cases initiated by Tai Yeow include nine failed applications for leave to start contempt proceedings and a December 2021 bid to assess his father's mental capacity. The latter was struck out in February 2023, with the court deeming it baseless, oppressive, and an abuse of process.
In its ruling, the High Court found that Tai Yeow's repeated litigation and collateral proceedings placed significant burdens on his father, the companies, and the judiciary.
Justice Roz Mawar emphasised that constitutional rights to liberty and equality must operate within legal bounds and respect final judicial decisions.
'Courts are empowered to act when access to justice is transformed into a tool for harassment and oppression,' she said.
The court concluded that Tai Yeow had misused the judicial system for personal grievances rather than resolving genuine legal issues. It noted that his persistent pursuit of settled matters crossed the line into harassment and abuse of process.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Malay Mail
an hour ago
- Malay Mail
Tax rule change: No more 2pc deduction for deceased agents, dealers and distributors effective August 1, says IRB
PUTRAJAYA, June 30 — The Inland Revenue Board (LHDN) will no longer accept the two per cent tax deduction involving deceased agents, dealers or distributors (Resident Individuals) (EPP), effective Aug 1. In a statement today, LHDN said the decision was made as the term 'individual' under Section 2 of the Income Tax Act (ACP) 1967 is defined as a living person or 'natural person'. 'Therefore, if an EPP has passed away, they are no longer categorised as an individual under this provision. 'In the event that income is still received after the death of the EPP, it must be managed by the executor, administrator, heir or legal representative and reported under the Deceased Person's Estate (TP) file,' said the LHDN. The statement added that the executor, administrator, heir or legal representative of the deceased must register the TP file at any LHDN office by completing the Notification of Taxpayer's Demise (CP57) form and submitting supporting documents, including a copy of the death certificate and the grant of probate or letter of administration. In this regard, LHDN advised the paying company as well as the heirs' representatives or estate administrators to take note of the ruling and act accordingly in managing the deceased's income, in line with existing tax laws and procedures. For users' convenience, LHDN said Form CP57 can be downloaded from its official portal via quick access at According to LHDN, under Section 107D of the ACP 1967, companies are required to make a two per cent tax deduction on cash payments to a deceased EPP. The deduction is applicable to resident individuals who have been appointed by the paying company as EPPs and who receive payments from sales proceeds, transactions or schemes carried out in that capacity. — Bernama
Free Malaysia Today
an hour ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Ex-investment banker jailed 2 years, fined RM1mil for securities fraud
Former investment banker Ruwan Amaresh Shaun Ponniah also pleaded guilty to carrying out fund management activities without a licence. (Pexels pic) PETALING JAYA : A former CIMB investment banker was sentenced to two years' imprisonment and fined RM1 million today for defrauding investors of RM201,000. Ruwan Amaresh Shaun Ponniah was sentenced by Kuala Lumpur sessions court judge Norma Ismail after he pleaded guilty to one charge of investment fraud under Section 179(b) of the Capital Markets and Services Act 2007 (CMSA). The Securities Commission Malaysia (SC) said the court took into consideration nine other similar charges under Section 179(b) of the CMSA. This consideration was made under Section 171A of the Criminal Procedure Code, which allows the court to bundle related or admitted offences into a single sentence, it said in a statement. Ruwan, a former associate director of debt capital markets at CIMB Investment Bank, was arrested and charged by the SC last September with 10 charges under Section 179(b) of the CMSA and an additional charge under Section 58(1) of the same Act. The SC said Ruwan also pleaded guilty today to the one charge under Section 58(1) of the CMSA for carrying out fund management activities without a licence. The court sentenced him to two years' imprisonment and ordered the jail term to run concurrently with the first offence. Ruwan will have to serve an additional six months' jail if he fails to pay the RM1 million fine. The SC said Ruwan had falsely represented to seven investors that he would invest their monies in shares listed on the Malaysian and foreign stock exchanges. However, the monies were for other purposes without the investors' knowledge. The offences took place between October 2018 and June 2020. Ruwan's guilty plea was made pursuant to his application for a plea bargain under Section 172C of the Criminal Procedure Code. He had claimed trial to all the charges and was granted bail of RM210,000 with one surety. On Feb 5, upon Ruwan's application to the High Court for a reduction in the bail amount, the sum was reduced to RM105,000. However, Ruwan was unable to post bail and has been held in remand at Sungai Buloh prison.
Malay Mail
2 hours ago
- Malay Mail
Armizan: Domestic Trade Ministry outlines three-pronged strategy as expanded SST enforcement begins tomorrow
KOTA KINABALU, June 30 — The Domestic Trade and Cost of Living Ministry (KPDN) will use three approaches to ensure the smooth running of Op Kesan 4.0, in conjunction with the implementation of the Sales Tax review and expanded scope of the Service Tax tomorrow. Its minister, Datuk Armizan Mohd Ali said it includes implementing the data collection of prices and service charge by ministry price monitoring officers. 'The data will from the basis of comparing prices and service charges before and after the Sales and Service Tax (SST) rate review,' he said at a media conference after an engagement session with a Sabah small and micro traders here today. He said the standard operating procedure for managing complaints on charges, prices and supplies was a good approach in ensuring the operation achieved its objectives, adding that the ministry would take stern action against traders who raised prices indiscriminately, including fines of up to RM100,000 or three years' jail or both for individuals and fines of RM500,000 for companies. On Op Kesan 4.0, he said that it was under the Price Control and Anti-Profiteering Act 2011 and its focus was to ensure traders do not take advantage by raising prices of items and services unreasonably, and in violation of the Price Control and Anti-Profiteering Act 2011. The enforcement scope includes goods and services involved in the SST rate review, including monitoring of goods not involved in the review, such as basic necessities, he added. — Bernama
