Post Office: Press watchdog revises ruling against ex-Fujitsu CEO
Michael Keegan was chief executive of Fujitsu UK from May 2014 to June 2015
A separate part of the complaint remains upheld for which the newspaper published a correction three years ago.
It is the first time the watchdog has revisited one of its published findings on the basis of new information.
The Independent Press Standards Organisation (Ipso) now says the Sunday Times had not been misleading when it reported that Michael Keegan had been "central" to Fujitsu's dealings with the Post Office, reversing a ruling it made in 2022.
A press complaint by a former Fujitsu CEO about his role in the Post Office scandal has been partly overturned by the industry watchdog following new information uncovered by a BBC investigation.
Paula Vennells was chief executive of the Post Office from 2012 to 2019
Ipso said Mr Keegan told it, as part of its original investigation in 2022, that he had only met former Post Office chief Paula Vennells once and "that he had no ongoing relationship with her; and that he did not discuss or give her any assurances regarding Horizon's capabilities".
But last year BBC News revealed Mr Keegan had in fact had four meetings with her during his 13 months heading up Fujitsu UK from May 2014 to June 2015.
Two of these were face-to-face meetings and the other two were telephone calls, one of which concerned a BBC Panorama investigation into the scandal.
Mr Keegan now accepts the new information shows he met Ms Vennells more than once.
But he told Ipso the number of times he met or spoke to her was "immaterial" to his complaint and that he had not played a "central role", as reported by the Sunday Times.
Ipso's Complaints Committee was not persuaded and found that the newspaper had not been "inaccurate" or "misleading" when it said Mr Keegan had played a "central role" or been "central" to Fujitsu's dealings with the Post Office during his time in charge.
Part of the dispute about the Sunday Times' reporting centred around comments by Ms Vennells that the Horizon IT system used by the Post Office was like "Fort Knox", a quote she attributed to an ex-CEO of contractor Fujitsu.
The Post Office has previously tried to argue that branch accounts could only be changed by sub-postmasters. It has since emerged that they could be accessed remotely.
The Sunday Times identified Mr Keegan as the source of the quote, but acknowledged it was mistaken when IPSO first investigated in 2022.
Between 1999 and 2015, more than 900 sub-postmasters were wrongly prosecuted after the faulty Horizon software made it look like money was missing from Post Office branch accounts.
Mr Keegan told BBC News: "Any judgement about the Horizon scandal should await the findings of the inquiry.
"The fact I had one additional meeting with the CEO of the Post Office on an entirely unrelated matter, some 11 years ago, does not in my view call into question the original decision Ipso reached. I am pleased that Ipso upheld its original decision in relation to the inaccuracy of the earlier article in The Sunday Times".
Last year lawyers for Mr Keegan said he regrets that sub-postmasters were prosecuted unfairly and denied playing any part in it.
A spokesperson for Ipso declined to comment.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
26 minutes ago
- The Guardian
End to school rating system could play havoc with house prices, says Ofsted chief
House prices in England could be put in turmoil by the government's scrapping of headline school grades such as outstanding or inadequate, according to Ofsted's chief inspector. Speaking at an education conference, Martyn Oliver said parents and schools had become familiar with headline grades after 30 years of use, saying he knew of house prices shooting up by £15,000 after nearby schools were graded as outstanding. But from November schools and colleges will be given more nuanced 'report cards' with up to 11 different grades given to each institution. Oliver said: 'We're about to take that away and change it to something else that for more than three decades people were used to. I mean, here's the burning question: what's Rightmove going to do?' Rightmove and other property websites prominently display Ofsted's headline ratings for nearby schools on their listing. After laughs from the audience, Oliver said: 'It's a serious point. Ofsted is probably one of the best-known regulators and inspectors in the world, let alone in this country.' Asked what impact the new report cards would have on house prices, Oliver said: 'I don't know but I do know that where I live … we've got two special measures schools right where I live, and the house prices shot up. They were both in special measures, both went outstanding, and the house prices went up £15,000 in a week. It does make a difference. 'Parents obviously put a value on it.' Ofsted inspections and gradings were criticised after the suicide of headteacher Ruth Perry, after an Ofsted inspection downgraded her school from outstanding to inadequate. Perry's husband told her inquest that she worried local house prices would fall as a result of the downgrade. Doing away with headline school grades and bringing in report cards was a manifesto pledge by Labour at the last general election. From November, schools and colleges in England will get ratings issued on up to 11 different areas. Each area will be given one of five grades: exemplary, strong, secure, attention needed or causing concern. But there will be no overall or summary grade. So far, headteachers and teaching unions have been unimpressed by Ofsted's proposals, while Bridget Phillipson, the education secretary, is said to be monitoring the results closely. The chief inspector apologised for the rushed nature of the changes and consultations. He said: 'The system was saying Ofsted needed urgent and quick reform. And so I chose to put something out that I knew would be just the beginnings, just the foundations.' Daniel Kebede, the general secretary of the National Education Union, said: 'The mess Ofsted have got themselves into is entirely of Sir Martyn Oliver's making and it is disappointing that he has tried to pass the buck.' In the UK and Ireland, Samaritans can be contacted on freephone 116 123, or email jo@ or jo@ In the US, you can call or text the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline on 988, chat on or text HOME to 741741 to connect with a crisis counselor. In Australia, the crisis support service Lifeline is 13 11 14. Other international helplines can be found at
BBC News
29 minutes ago
- BBC News
Winter fuel: Lyons says 86% of NI pensioners to be eligible for payment
The Communities Minister Gordon Lyons has said 86% of pensioners in Northern Ireland will be eligible for the winter fuel payment this comes after the government performed a U-turn on its controversial had initially scrapped the universal payment as a cost saving now those with an income of £35,000 or below are eligible for the grant. Lyons told BBC Radio Ulster's Evening Extra programme that his officials have assessed that the change in policy will mean 288,000 pensioners are in line for the payment."For comparison, across the UK as a whole about 80% of pensioners will retain [the payment], but it's slightly higher in Northern Ireland because of our lower incomes," he said. "This has been a mess from the start. The government have a lot to answer for on this. This has been handled horrifically by the government and has put a lot of worry and concern into the minds of our older people." Lyons had secured £17m from Stormont to provide a £100 one-off payment for those affected by the cut last said the Labour government's policy was misguided."I said from the start this would not have saved the government a lot of money," he said. "What we have seen is a number of pensioners reach out for help and realise they are eligible for pension credit, which is a passport for other benefits. So in that regard it'll actually cost the government more." What are winter fuel payments? Winter fuel payments were created in 1997 to help everyone above state pension age with their winter heating Chancellor, Rachel Reeves, announced last year that winter 2024 would be the first time pensioners in England and Wales would not be eligible for the Ireland was forced to follow were then restricted to those on benefits and pension credit.
The Independent
31 minutes ago
- The Independent
Watchdog opens probe into ex-MP Geoffrey Robinson over spending rules
A parliamentary watchdog has opened an investigation into whether former Labour MP Geoffrey Robinson has breached spending rules. The probe by the Independent Parliamentary Standards Authority (Ipsa) relates to whether the former MP for Coventry North West breached rules on spending for accommodation, office costs and staffing costs. Ipsa said it would not be publishing any further information until the investigation has concluded. Mr Robinson served as a Labour MP between 1976 and 2019. He was a minister in Tony Blair's first government but resigned in 1998 after it was revealed he had lent £373,000 to Peter Mandelson, who partly bought a home with the interest-free loan. The revelation also led Lord Mandelson to resign from his role as trade secretary at the time. The ex-MP also had a long career in business, having owned the New Statesman magazine until 2008, and serving as chairman of Jaguar Cars in the 1970s.
