Maharashtra schools submit letter to Minister Bhuse over clarification on 3-language policy, military education
As many as 23 educational institutions and associations have come together and submitted a letter to the Maharashtra School Education minister Dada Bhuse, urging for a written order to end the confusion. The letter dated June 8, also demands cancellation of plans to introduce basic military education from grade 1 in government-run schools, announced by Bhuse, earlier this month.
'In Maharashtra, there has been unrest over the introduction of three-languages from Class 1, particularly the decision to mandate Hindi. While the Hindi mandate was officially revoked, there is no formal order by government on whether or not the third language will be introduced in Class 1 from academic year 2025-26, as declared earlier,' stated the letter which further adds that amidst this chaos over introduction of third-language at this young age, the recent announcement to introduce basic military education from Grade 1 has caused further stress for schools.
In April, the state education department issued a government resolution (GR) mandating Hindi as a compulsory third language from Class 1 in Marathi and English medium schools under the Maharashtra State Board. Following a political backlash, with opponents questioning the imposition of Hindi on non-Hindi speaking students, the Hindi mandate was withdrawn immediately. The government, however, insisted on continuing with three-languages then.
Though Bhuse later clarified in a media interaction in late May that the implementation of the three-language policy was on hold, no official circular has been issued in this regard as yet.
Sushil Shejule, Coordinator of the Marathi School Management Association, who is leading the collective of associations which sent the letter, said, 'Introducing additional languages at such an early stage is not supported by child development experts. Furthermore, with young children not yet capable of understanding concepts like the nation, military responsibilities etc., introduction of military education from Grade 1 sparks a question if it is a step towards turning the country into a militarized regime. Educational decisions, especially those involving curriculum and values, must be taken with expert consultation.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
29 minutes ago
- Mint
‘Not Marathi vs non-Marathi': Aaditya Thackeray says Thane assault started over ‘phone charging'
Amid the language row in Maharashtra, Shiv Sena (UBT) MLA Aaditya Thackeray addressed the Thane assault case and said the incident should not be viewed as a Marathi versus non-Marathi divide. Aaditya Thackeray clarified that the issue stemmed from something as simple as not allowing someone to charge their phone. Aaditya Thackeray said, 'I talked to Rajan Vichare ji on the video, and he told me that this is neither about Marathi and non-Marathi, nor about Maharashtra and North India, nor about any community or society.' 'An official had gone into the shop to charge his phone and he wasn't allowed to do so, which led to a fight and the person was beaten... A lady saved the person... This has gone into a police complaint,' Thackeray said. He further added that 'we want that our mother tongue Marathi is not insulted and no language is forcefully imposed. We don't want anybody to take the law into their hands, but when it is the other way round and Marathi or Maharashtra is insulted, things can escalate.' The issue pertains to an assault case wherein a man was beaten up after a dispute over mobile recharge which led to a quarrel outside the Thane railway station. Also Read | 'Acting smart in Maharashtra?' UP cab driver gets thrashed despite speaking in Marathi | Watch viral video A video of the incident which took place on Tuesday night went viral. According to the reports, the complainant, a 45-year-old man, was apparently drunk when he visited the mobile recharge shop, said an official of Naupada police station. There was an altercation, and the shopkeeper and his friends allegedly beat up the man. As the situation escalated, some passersby also gathered near the shop. Traffic police personnel later rushed to the spot and prevented the situation from deteriorating further. An FIR was registered but no arrests have been made so far, the officer said. The incident comes on the heel of another case in which a member of Raj Thackeray's Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS) assaulted an elderly North Indian restaurant owner on Mumbai's Mira Road allegedly for not speaking in Marathi, reigniting the language debate. In the viral video, three men, allegedly MNS workers, slapped a restaurant owner when the latter refused to speak in Marathi but argued that 'all languages are spoken in Maharashtra'. Meanwhile, Maharashtra minister Yogesh Kadam issued a warning that laws will be imposed if anyone 'disrespects' the Marathi language. 'In Maharashtra, you have to speak Marathi. If you don't know Marathi, your attitude shouldn't be that you won't speak Marathi. If anyone disrespects Marathi in Maharashtra, we will enforce our laws,' Kadam told ANI.
Hindustan Times
33 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Aaditya Thackeray's ‘things can escalate' warning amid Marathi language controversy in Maharashtra
Aaditya Thackeray of the Shiv Sena (UBT) on Thursday issued a stern warning amid the escalating language controversy in Maharashtra, asserting that any disrespect towards Marathi or the state would not be accepted. Shiv Sena (UBT) leader Aaditya Thackeray addresses the media during the Monsoon session of Maharashtra assembly at Vidhan Bhavan in Mumbai on Thursday, (PTI) Aaditya Thackeray also dismissed media reports claiming shop owners were slapped and forced to apologise for refusing to speak Marathi at party leader Rajan Vichare's office. 'We want that our mother tongue Marathi is not insulted and no language is forcefully imposed,' Aaditya Thackeray told reporters in Mumbai. 'We don't want anybody to take the law into their hands, but when it is the other way round and Marathi or Maharashtra is insulted, things can escalate...' According to Thackeray, he spoke with Rajan Vichare about the video, and the latter confirmed that the incident had nothing to do with Marathi versus non-Marathi speakers, Maharashtra versus North India, or any community conflict. "An official had entered a shop to charge his phone and was denied permission. This led to an altercation where the individual was assaulted... A woman intervened to protect him... The matter has now been reported to the police," Thackeray said. Thackeray's clarification follows the circulation of a video allegedly showing former MP and Shiv Sena (UBT) leader Rajan Vichare summoning a group of traders to his office, where they were reportedly assaulted and made to apologise for not using Marathi. Some media reports claimed that Vichare and his associates had pressured the traders to conduct business in Marathi. The incident comes amid a string of recent episodes where individuals have been targeted over language, particularly by Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS) workers. In one such case, a restaurant owner in Mira Road was assaulted by MNS members for not speaking Marathi with customers. Amid growing outrage, several shops remained shut on Thursday in protest against what many see as increasing intimidation and violence in the name of language.
Hindustan Times
39 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
‘Marathi ko mara na': Scuffle over phone recharge turns into Marathi vs Non-Marathi row after video goes viral
A simple request for a phone recharge in Thane has sparked a Marathi vs Non-Marathi row, with a Shiv Sena (UBT) MP in the centre of the controversy. The shop staff members made to hold their ears and admit that they were wrong before the camera in the video clip.(X) The incident took place a couple of days ago, when a 43-year-old man, Kiran Tanaji Sawant, visited a local shop in Thane requesting for a phone recharge. However, Sawant allegedly lost his temper after the recharge couldn't be completed owing to a technical issue, according to the staff members of the shop. They claimed that Sawant created chaos, which led to a fight between him and four or five of the shop staff. During the scuffle, Sawant sustained injuries and filed a police complaint afterwards. A case under sections of Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) pertaining to causing hurt was filed, and four staff members were detained. They were released later after being served legal notices. Viral video of Sena (UBT) MP's office The issue received a fresh lease of life after a video of Shiv Sena UBT MP Rajan Vichare's office went viral. In the video, both parties – the staff members and Sawant are present. While a staff member tries to speak, one of Vichare's aide interrupts him, saying, 'Marathi mein bol, Marathi ko mara na? Marathi mein bol.' The clip further showed the staff members approaching Sawant – who was sitting – and apologising by folding their hands and touching their feet. Sawant then goes on to slap the staff members, who are also made to hold their ears and admit that they were wrong before the camera. The incident comes close on the heels of a another one which took place on Tuesday (July 1), wherein a group of men wearing Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS) scarves allegedly assaulted a Thane shop owner for not speaking in Marathi. The men had gone to the shop to buy food. After the owner spoke to them in Hindi, they asked him, 'Which language is spoken in the state?' When the owner responded saying 'all languages', one of the men shouted and slapped him several times, along with the others.
