A tricky question on Good Morning Britain for Mary Lou McDonald
Mary Lou McDonald
's appearance on Monday's Good Morning Britain on ITV.
After calling for a united Ireland, the
Sinn Féin
president was asked by presenter Richard Madeley: 'Why do you want
Northern Ireland
still so badly? Because, economically, I think it's fair to say it's close to being a basket case at the moment. This country pays it a huge amount in terms of subsidies to Ulster, far more than we get back.'
This question was full of horror for unionists, in language and tone. Madeley's view of Northern Ireland as a different country leaching off his own is presumably widespread. A decade ago, ITV dropped a plan to change the title of Good Morning Britain to Good Morning UK. Perhaps it thought the audience would be as confused about the distinction as its presenter.
But the question was also full of traps for McDonald, even if Madeley appeared to have sprung them unwittingly.
READ MORE
Since 2013 Sinn Féin has insisted Northern Ireland requires almost no subsidy, as the £10 billion-plus subvention is a perfidious British accounting trick. In recent years it has simultaneously condemned the Irish Government for economic mismanagement while boasting that the Republic is booming and could easily afford what costs of unification remain.
The party restated this two weeks ago, following an academic report. Its subvention claim assumes Britain would continue paying State and unfunded public service pensions to Northern Ireland, without collecting any taxes. Although this is highly implausible, it is Sinn Féin's position and McDonald was put on the spot over it.
Describing Northern Ireland as a basket case might also have raised republican hackles. Sinn Féin has co-governed Stormont for almost two decades. Since the start of this decade it has increasingly claimed leadership of economic policy, taking control of the Department of Finance and adding the Department for the Economy last year, when it also took the First Minister's chair.
Sinn Féin has used these positions to develop what are supposedly flagship policies on labour market reform, an industrial strategy and fiscal devolution. It has sought credit for Northern Ireland's unique post-Brexit trading arrangements, claiming these have grown investment and cross-Border trade.
[
John FitzGerald: Irish unification would hit South harder than 2008 crash
Opens in new window
]
This seizing of the reins has been accompanied by promises of prosperity for all through Stormont, serving the goal of a united Ireland. Sinn Féin has given every impression of having resolved the conundrum, for republicans, of how to govern Northern Ireland successfully while also seeking to end its existence.
The party could claim this is beginning to work, although few of its policies have yet been implemented. Northern Ireland has been the best-performing part of the UK since Brexit by some measures and even its subvention is no longer an outlier: Scotland had a slightly larger subsidy per head in 2023.
Scottish nationalists point to this to argue for rejoining the EU through independence. Sinn Féin could do likewise.
Instead, McDonald simply echoed Madeley. 'The North is consistently in economic difficulties because it is not economically viable as a territory,' she replied.
The Sinn Féin president then headed off to her main engagement in London, alongside First Minister Michelle O'Neill, to address the UK's Foreign Press Association on a united Ireland. Both women made their case, yet again, in terms of Northern Ireland requiring almost no subvention.
Sinn Féin could say none of this is necessarily contradictory and it is delivering economic progress in Northern Ireland despite the poor hand history has dealt it. But McDonald could not bring herself to say this on ITV.
Obviously, Sinn Féin is tailoring its message to different audiences.
[
Leo Varadkar: 'All trends point towards Irish unification in the next few decades'
Opens in new window
]
The message to the British public is 'let us take this expensive burden off your hands', without revealing it expects Britain to keep paying the bills. The pensions claim is to reassure the Republic unification would be painless. Even a perfectly manageable amount of pain is seemingly too much to ask.
Constant complaining in the Dáil about the Irish economy is to be expected of an opposition party. But Sinn Féin is a party of government in Northern Ireland and people there hear its contradictory spinning elsewhere. On Tuesday DUP Deputy First Minister Emma Little-Pengelly said Sinn Féin ministers 'need to be open with the public – are they working to promote our economy or have they simply binned it as economically unviable?'
While this is unlikely to cause a serious row at Stormont, the depressing long-term implications are starting to sink in. Sinn Féin has not resolved the conundrum of making Northern Ireland work, nor is it giving serious economic thought to a united Ireland.
It is just marking time until a Border poll – still maybe decades away – by telling everyone whatever it thinks they want to hear.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
15 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Central Bank promotes enforcement head to deputy governor post
The Central Bank of Ireland has promoted Colm Kincaid, currently its head of enforcement, to the position of deputy governor, overseeing consumer and investment protection. It follows the previous holder of that role, Derville Rowland, joining the executive team of the new Frankfurt-based EU Anti-Money Laundering Authority (AMLA) in May. The Central Bank has three deputy governors operating under governor Gabriel Makhlouf . 'Colm brings over two decades of experience in consumer-focused financial regulation, legal expertise and strategic leadership to the role,' said Mr Makhlouf, noting that Mr Kincaid will assume his new role at the start of August. READ MORE 'Colm's commitment to upholding the highest standards of consumer welfare and market integrity has been a hallmark of his work at the Central Bank of Ireland. He will continue the bank's focus on this crucial element of our mandate'. [ Central Bank's Derville Rowland to join EU anti-money laundering agency Opens in new window ] The bank disbanded its stand-alone consumer protection unit in January and dispersed its functions among various arms of the organisation that supervise different areas, from banks and insurers to investment firms. While this drew criticism from some politicians and consumer advocacy groups, the regulator said that it has more closely embedded consumer oversight into all supervisory areas rather than isolating it. He will be responsible for leading the strategic development and execution of consumer and investor protection policies, the regulator said. This includes engaging with stakeholders and representing the bank in domestic and international forums. Mr Kincaid, a solicitor by background, joined the Central Bank in 2004, having previously worked with law firms A&L Goodbody in Dublin, and Linklaters in London. He became director of enforcement in January, having previously served as director of consumer protection for more than three years.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Albert Manifold, Irish cement veteran hired to chair BP for pivot back to oil and gas
BP has chosen a new chair who built his career not in oil, gas or the City of London, but in gravel, asphalt and cement. The appointment of Albert Manifold , a 26-year veteran of Dublin building materials company CRH , caught many investors and industry insiders by surprise when it was announced on Monday morning. 'It is an underwhelming appointment,' said one executive headhunter. The market reaction was also muted, with no meaningful move in BP's share price despite widespread investor frustration with outgoing chair Helge Lund. But people familiar with Manifold's record argue that behind his low-key persona is the drive, discipline and focus on shareholder returns that BP badly needs. One person who has competed against Manifold on deals described him as a 'shrewd operator' and a 'man on a mission'. READ MORE One of BP's most important investors, activist hedge fund Elliott Management, broadly welcomed the appointment, saying it noted Manifold's 'track record of delivering shareholder value' and that it looked forward to working with him to 'urgently address BP's shortcomings'. [ BP appoints Irishman Albert Manifold as new chairman Opens in new window ] After a failed foray into renewable electricity, the energy major in February pivoted back to focus on oil and gas but has not been rewarded by investors. BP's share price has fallen more than 8 per cent since it unveiled its new strategy, after oil prices slid in the second quarter. In more than a decade in charge of CRH, now the largest building materials supplier in the US, the 62-year-old Manifold overhauled its assets, pushed through transformational acquisitions and moved its primary listing from London to New York. Total shareholder returns during his tenure were 342 per cent, equivalent to an annualised 16.5 per cent, according to Josh Stone, an analyst at UBS. In 2023, Manifold was the third-highest-paid chief executive of a FTSE 100 company, one place above BP's former chief executive Bernard Looney. CRH stated this year that the value of his unvested stock options from 2020 to 2024 was more than $70 million. On Monday, as well as being appointed BP chair from October, he became an adviser to CD&R, the private investment firm where current BP chair Lund is also an adviser. Manifold's experience in boosting CRH's market valuation, especially in the US, was a huge draw for BP, whose share price peaked almost 20 years ago and has been trying to increase the number of American investors on its shareholder register. 'What we really need is somebody that leads the board, leads a strategy and basically somebody that can help in terms of the performance management of the business,' said one person involved in the hunt for the new chair. Manifold's low profile and lack of oil and gas experience was not an issue, the person added. 'A chair is not meant to be the high-profile person. The CEO is the leader of the business. If you look at the way he has delivered at CRH, he has done it in a quiet way. He has not had a public persona as such, but he has delivered incredibly strong performance, and the CRH shareholders were not disappointed.' Manifold, whose parents ran a hardware store in the Dublin suburb of Kimmage, lives in the nearby coastal town of Wicklow and was described by one of his friends as down-to-earth and highly driven. 'There were no corporate jets at CRH, no drivers. Once he needed to see his chair on a Friday night, it was pissing with rain and he just got in his car and drove the 200 miles to get there,' the person said, adding that Manifold had played rugby as a prop forward, as did Peter Sutherland, the last Irish chair of BP. Manifold won the top job at CRH in 2014, when the company was still feeling the effects of the slump in US residential construction following the financial crisis. His first act was a sweeping review of the company's business, according to one senior investment banker close to Manifold. He then pushed through a transformational acquisition, beating private equity firms Blackstone and Cinven to a €6.5 billion deal for a package of assets that EU competition regulators forced cement groups Holcim and Lafarge to sell off when they merged. 'He just knew everything that was going on with his rival bidders,' said one person involved in the process. 'His level of intelligence of the industry and within his PE rivals was excellent. He was always one step ahead of his rivals in the process. The level of connectivity he had gave him an edge.' That deal 'gave them good scale', the banker said, adding that CRH 'only had to do a €1.6 billion equity placement, which was very well supported. The shares performed well and it's gone on from there.' Manifold also brings green credentials. He was president of the industry organisation effort to try to decarbonise cement production and CRH has a target to cut its total carbon emissions by 30 per cent by 2030 from 2021 levels. In an interview with CNBC last year, he described how he had moved CRH up the value chain. 'We don't just provide rocks and cement,' he said. 'We take the rocks and make asphalt, we pave the roads with that asphalt. We maintain the roads and provide the off-ramps, on-ramps and bridge components. We don't just make one sell, we make six sells.' Although he does not have oil and gas experience, Manifold has not had to look far for advice on the BP job. Lamar McKay, the former head of BP's business in the US, is CRH's senior independent director. Bob Dudley, the former BP chief executive, sits alongside Manifold on the board of chemicals company LyondellBasell. Egon Zehnder, the headhunter that oversaw the search for BP's chair, also handled the chief executive succession process at CRH. BP remains under pressure after a turbulent few years and is struggling under heavy debts and from a lack of investor confidence in its strategy. Bloomberg this month described Manifold's new role in an opinion piece headline as 'a thankless job no one wants'. But his supporters back him to turn around the UK energy major. 'He'll want the company to do things that generate cash and give the sort of returns that he wants,' the banker said. 'That's what shareholders will reward.' – Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2025
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
National Development Plan: Extra €4 billion for health and housing found by Government during negotiations
Jack White - 30 minutes ago Main Points: Details of the investment of some €200 billion in Ireland's infrastructure over the next decade will be unveiled by Government today. More than €165 billion had been allocated to the current National Development Plan (NDP) which runs until 2030. However, a review of the NDP was announced in April to allow for additional funding. The revised NDP will be boosted by the €14 billion windfall in Apple tax, the proceeds from the sale of the State's stake in AIB and money that had been put away in State accounts, including the Infrastructure, Climate and Nature Fund. It will cover costs out to 2035 with a particular focus on increasing investment to support housing delivery by investing in energy, water and transport. Minister for Public Expenditure Jack Chambers said it will help 'bridge the infrastructure deficit we have in the Irish economy.' The plan's unveiling comes as the Government considers a planning fast track for key national infrastructure to accelerate project delivery. Jack White - 4 minutes ago Revised NDP to provide largest ever rise in military spending The Defence Forces is to receive about €1.7 billion in new capital investment under the revised National Development Plan (NDP). The move will represent the largest ever rise in military spending, Martin Wall writes. The new funding will be focused on the introduction of new primary radar systems to identify aircraft in Irish skies as well as sonar equipment to detect objects under the sea. There will also be investment in new armoured personnel vehicles to provide force protection for troops. It is understood the Tánaiste and Minister for Defence Simon Harris has secured more than a 50 per cent increase on defence spending under the revised NDP. It is understood the Government believes the €1.7 billion capital investment will allow Ireland to reach the mid-level point of military capabilities – known as Level of Ambition 2 set out in the report of the Commission on Defence in 2022. Mr Harris has said that Ireland must get to Level of Ambition 2, which would mean that State infrastructure and capabilities on defence were at a point where it was in line with other smaller countries in Europe. It is understood the Government believes the allocation under the revised National Development Plan for Defence will mean Ireland can work towards the Level of Ambition 2 target initially before moving over subsequent years to the higher Level of Ambition 3. This would see Ireland develop more extensive defence capabilities including fighter jets and a larger Naval Service. Housing and water investment are set to receive about €40 billion from the Government's overall €100 billion expenditure on infrastructure and capital projects over the next five years. Jack White - 12 minutes ago The Government found another €4 billion for health and housing during down-to-the-wire negotiations over the National Development Plan on Monday evening, The Irish Times has learned. Jack Horgan-Jones reports: The plan will see the allocation of more than €200 billion over the coming decade – with the figure ballooning in recent days as talks between Coalition leaders and Cabinet ministers continued. Originally, some €20 billion was to be added to the National Development Plan – but Minister for Public Expenditure and Infrastructure Jack Chambers said over the weekend that figure would rise to €30 billion. Senior Government sources confirmed on Tuesday morning that an additional €3.9 billion was added for health and housing on Monday night. This means that there will be €34 billion extra when compared to the existing NDP, including €10 billion up until 2030 to pay for megaprojects in energy, water and transport. In total, there will be €102.4 billion allocated to different sectors for the period 2026-2030, and another €100 billion for the years 2030-2035. Government sources indicated that the review will take in total public investment of €275.4 billion, including exchequer and non-exchequer funding and the release of once-off payouts from the Apple tax money, the sale of AIB shares and State funds such as the Infrastructure, Climate and Nature Fund. Jack White - 15 minutes ago The plan being published today is one of the 'biggest ever investments in transforming fundamental infrastructure,' Taoiseach Micheál Martin has said. The National Development Plan being published by Government today is one of the biggest ever investments in transforming fundamental infrastructure in this country. — Micheál Martin (@MichealMartinTD)
